Modem Hacker Charged With ‘Aiding Computer Intrusion’

so what about the people that are stealing the internet I have comcast and I will be mad if I know someone have my MAC and info to get free internet how are they gonna get those people?:mad:

I believe your modem will stop working, this is the issue with metered bandwidth billing model, the networks just arn't secure.
 
so what about the people that are stealing the internet I have comcast and I will be mad if I know someone have my MAC and info to get free internet how are they gonna get those people?:mad:

in my other posts, i refer to DoS, DoS = Denial of Service.

Unless the CableCo's network is setup EXTREMELY poorly, only one MAC address may be on the network at the same time.

And that's the rub, CableCo's have to spend significant time/effort/money to determine who's a real user, and who's a clone.

My understand is, they either allow cloned MACs to exist on the network because disrupting service is worse, than allowing theft or service, or they kick people off in waves, and wait for ppl to call in and complain about it.

If all the theif has is your MAC address, he won't be able to verify your account information, and you'll get back on until he DoS's your cable modem agian. If the theif has all of your information, i.e. identity theft, there's no way for the CableCo to tell one from the other.


It would be one thing if the CabelCo/DOCSIS had set up a secure system that was difficult to clone/penetrate like the digital cellphone network(not impossible, difficult), right now it's not difficult, it's trivial. Arresting DerEngel didn't make it any less trivial, all of the "black-hat" cable modem hacking sites are still up. He ran a strictly White-hat/Grey-hat site.

My only hope is that the FBI is using this as a pretense to tap him for their own purposes like the Melissa virus/worm author http://www.securityfocus.com/news/6986 otherwise it makes 0 sense.
 
Frankly, this is no different, than them sending someone to jail for selling modded 360's that circumvent copyright protection. He should have known this would happen. Idiot. Don't fuck with the FCC.
 
I'll put it to you guys this way. If someone or myself have the ability to use the full potential of whatever it is that I buy or use, so long as it doesn't physically harm someone else, well, most likely I'll do it. Legality is a fine line however.
 
You go to the store to get iodine salt. When you get there you find there is only one kind of iodine salt, and although it says 10% iodine, it only has 1%. Your only option is to buy that Iodine salt, and consume 10x more salt to get the proper amount of Iodine.

A Vigilante outside the store says "pssh, comeere, i figured out a way to always get the amount of iodine they're advertising, you're paying for, and they're not providing."

Do you pay the Vigilante once, for a solution that works now, because without the Iodine you'll develop a goiter, or do you continue purchase the 1% iodized salt, and contact a lawyer about starting a class action lawsuit?

Or more precisely, the other salts are 1% iodine at one-tenth the expense, but require more to be consumed before you get your iodine requirements.

So instead of buying it you walk out of the store and meet a guy who tells you for twenty bucks he has a way with something that “could” be used to get the iodine for free. His information is to wait for someone else to buy the iodine salt and follow them home, go in and take theirs and the receipt, maybe even cudgel them if you have to so you can get to the salt freely. BUT you have to swear you won’t use the “cudgel” for that!

Saying the company has a monopoly does not excuse your theft. If you feel they have not kept to their end discontinue payment, boycott, sue, etc. Buying a product is endorsement. There's a relatively useful system of governing present to help. Stealing cable is stealing cable. There are no if's, and's, or but's. It’s not righteous or noble, it’s low. And if the company is robbing you, deal with it legally and respectably.

It won't matter how many examples I give, you and others want to justify theft because it’s an excuse for “free”. Go rob a Gas Station because oil traders are creating false markets of demand by reselling barrels.

If a person creates a chemical lab set for the creation of methamphetamines and sells it with all the instruments and chemicals required claiming that it's for show and shouldn't be used on pain of death, how is he not responsible at the very least morally when it is used to dope up a neighborhood?

Just because you can take the Cable furtively and well below the radar with a modicum of anonymity, you shouldn’t. If you’re so righteous, call the company and tell them you are using this device because they are not keeping to their end of the bargain and so you have to make this adjustment to obtain what you’ve justly paid for…
 
Arguably, this guy is one of the most knowledgable people around when it comes to DOCSIS and networks. He's been doing this for a while and nobody bothered him. I remember even reading an article how he just gave a lecture about all of his work not too long ago.

With all that's going on lately (US getting cyberattacked and all), I wouldn't be surprised if the government is just trying to get free labor. I mean...think about it. Instead of paying this guy $400k/yr or whatever, they just charge him with a bunch of federal crimes and give him a plea bargain instead having him work off his debt. It's not like the Air Force is doing that great of a job securing our national networks.
 
Or more precisely, the other salts are 1% iodine at one-tenth the expense, but require more to be consumed before you get your iodine requirements.

So instead of buying it you walk out of the store and meet a guy who tells you for twenty bucks he has a way with something that “could” be used to get the iodine for free. His information is to wait for someone else to buy the iodine salt and follow them home, go in and take theirs and the receipt, maybe even cudgel them if you have to so you can get to the salt freely. BUT you have to swear you won’t use the “cudgel” for that!

Saying the company has a monopoly does not excuse your theft. If you feel they have not kept to their end discontinue payment, boycott, sue, etc. Buying a product is endorsement. There's a relatively useful system of governing present to help. Stealing cable is stealing cable. There are no if's, and's, or but's. It’s not righteous or noble, it’s low. And if the company is robbing you, deal with it legally and respectably.

It won't matter how many examples I give, you and others want to justify theft because it’s an excuse for “free”. Go rob a Gas Station because oil traders are creating false markets of demand by reselling barrels.

If a person creates a chemical lab set for the creation of methamphetamines and sells it with all the instruments and chemicals required claiming that it's for show and shouldn't be used on pain of death, how is he not responsible at the very least morally when it is used to dope up a neighborhood?

Just because you can take the Cable furtively and well below the radar with a modicum of anonymity, you shouldn’t. If you’re so righteous, call the company and tell them you are using this device because they are not keeping to their end of the bargain and so you have to make this adjustment to obtain what you’ve justly paid for…

my initial post was a reply to illuminate the potential motivations of those who i attempt to understand to better perform my job. regardless of disclaiming myself several times, you have cast that shadow upon me, and it is neither fair nor correct. i'm not someone who advocates stealing cable, vigilante justice, or theft of any kind. I assumed incorrectly i was merely putting my understanding down within the context of your metaphor. Clearly things have gotten confused.

i do however believe it's improper to arrest someone because they're sharing information that isn't illegal to share, performing modifications that aren't illegal to perform, and pinning the crimes of others onto the distributor of knowledge.

It strikes a cord with me in particular, as someone who looks at insecure networks all day long.

Because i know of the vulnerabilities in devices that makes them insecure, it would make me a criminal for having that knowledge or sharing it with my peer group. My peer group could be the firewall user group on USENET that was created by the inventor of the firewall, marcus ranum; since there's no vetting process to being added to that list it's just as likely thats it's composed of 50% security researchers and 50% bank robbers.

Am i to be held accountable for posting information about the vulnerability in linksys routers, or reposting the article i posted earlier detailing the STILL unfixed vulnerability in 65000 time warner cable modems; realize that vulnerability makes it possible for someone to steal your banking information without you ever knowing how or why it happened.?

The point of unlocking the cable modem was to enable the peer review of the security features locked out be the CableCo, and give that power back to those who own the hardware. He ADDED features to the original firmware that increased the overall efficiency and and reliability and security of the original cable modem. If you wanted to go violate the law and download a config file you didn't have a right to, use your advanced networking skills to sniff the cable modem network for the relevant information to steal service, that was your prerogative, and THAT is no different that connecting to a wireless network with no encryption, or using any of the MANY security tools to decrypt a WEP/WPA/WPA2 wireless password.

This was not a you buy and unlocked cable modem from him, and Poof free internet, or Poof free faster internet solution. You had to know what you were doing, and be good at it. You had to be able to sniff, decode and read raw tcp/ip packets as they flowed over the network, and if you wanted a faster config file you had to hack the password to your isp's tftp server and steal it, or sniff another person's faster cable modem connection, wait for them to reboot it, and reassemble the raw tcp/ip packets into a config file. This was far from a simple process, much farther than clicking "okay i'll connect" when stealing someone else's wireless internet access.

This isn't an argument for or against piracy or theft. This is an unjust arrest of a man who dedicated 6+ years of his life to knowing and understanding cable modem technology better than anyone else in the country.

He was arrested for sharing that knowledge.
 
my initial post was a reply to illuminate the potential motivations of those who i attempt to understand to better perform my job. regardless of disclaiming myself several times, you have cast that shadow upon me, and it is neither fair nor correct. i'm not someone who advocates stealing cable, vigilante justice, or theft of any kind. I assumed incorrectly i was merely putting my understanding down within the context of your metaphor. Clearly things have gotten confused.

i do however believe it's improper to arrest someone because they're sharing information that isn't illegal to share, performing modifications that aren't illegal to perform, and pinning the crimes of others onto the distributor of knowledge.

It strikes a cord with me in particular, as someone who looks at insecure networks all day long.

Because i know of the vulnerabilities in devices that makes them insecure, it would make me a criminal for having that knowledge or sharing it with my peer group. My peer group could be the firewall user group on USENET that was created by the inventor of the firewall, marcus ranum; since there's no vetting process to being added to that list it's just as likely thats it's composed of 50% security researchers and 50% bank robbers.

Am i to be held accountable for posting information about the vulnerability in linksys routers, or reposting the article i posted earlier detailing the STILL unfixed vulnerability in 65000 time warner cable modems; realize that vulnerability makes it possible for someone to steal your banking information without you ever knowing how or why it happened.?

The point of unlocking the cable modem was to enable the peer review of the security features locked out be the CableCo, and give that power back to those who own the hardware. He ADDED features to the original firmware that increased the overall efficiency and and reliability and security of the original cable modem. If you wanted to go violate the law and download a config file you didn't have a right to, use your advanced networking skills to sniff the cable modem network for the relevant information to steal service, that was your prerogative, and THAT is no different that connecting to a wireless network with no encryption, or using any of the MANY security tools to decrypt a WEP/WPA/WPA2 wireless password.

This was not a you buy and unlocked cable modem from him, and Poof free internet, or Poof free faster internet solution. You had to know what you were doing, and be good at it. You had to be able to sniff, decode and read raw tcp/ip packets as they flowed over the network, and if you wanted a faster config file you had to hack the password to your isp's tftp server and steal it, or sniff another person's faster cable modem connection, wait for them to reboot it, and reassemble the raw tcp/ip packets into a config file. This was far from a simple process, much farther than clicking "okay i'll connect" when stealing someone else's wireless internet access.

This isn't an argument for or against piracy or theft. This is an unjust arrest of a man who dedicated 6+ years of his life to knowing and understanding cable modem technology better than anyone else in the country.

He was arrested for sharing that knowledge.

If I can read one post like this each day after one yeal I will be freaking smart

Good Post
 
Oh yes. I totally agree that you shouldn't be able to buy a piece of technology and mess around with it to make it better and more useful. In fact, it should be illegal to open a PC case after purchasing unless you get a certified technician to do it, because if you modify it, you'll be getting speeds and services you didn't pay for.

What's that? You've found a wired NIC in the garbage? Sorry, can't install that in your Dell.

Oh, you've handbuilt an engine? Wait, how much money did you give Ford? NONE!? You must pay now! You're escaping this bullshit economy if you don't pay for a bunch of crap that you can get yourself for little to no cost!

Yes, I understand that he was making modems that could somehow "steal" internet. Well, it's not illegal to steal wifi, because air waves are public property, or something of the sort. So, how is it illegal to "steal" something Comcast is literally pumping into your house, but they just don't want you to use it?

Sounds like Comcast needs to step their security up.
 
this is all total bullshit. yes you can use what he is selling to steal internet and uncap your modem, but thats not how they are being sold. the "hacked" firmware being used is meant for diagnostic proposes as its built from the FATSH written for and used by ISPs. all the "hacked" firmware does is give it a friendly web GUI so you don't need a serial cable to change stuff.
 
let's go arrest everyone selling guns in gun shops, because guns can be used to kill people.
 
Frankly, this is no different, than them sending someone to jail for selling modded 360's that circumvent copyright protection. He should have known this would happen. Idiot. Don't fuck with the FCC.

you have a jailbroken iphone...
 

As other people in this thread mentioned, you make a very good point. If I may add to it:


I'm a sys admin at a good size bank, right now I'm using a bunch of custom scripts to deploy/check/repair/control a program as part of a large project. Some of those scrips make heavy use of tools - to name just two - "psexec" and"setacl", they are immensely useful to what I do.

Anyone that used tools like this knows how easily they can be used for nefarious means, on the pstools site is even mentioned:

http://technet.microsoft.com/en-us/sysinternals/bb897553.aspx
"Note: some anti-virus scanners report that one or more of the tools are infected with a "remote admin" virus. None of the PsTools contain viruses, but they have been used by viruses, which is why they trigger virus notifications."

So what now? Should people like Mark Russinovich be afraid of being arrested? For crying out loud the guy even works for Microsoft.

I also remember a post (on /. I believe) by nmap's creator that he is afraid of going to Germany anymore since they passed a law making tools with hacking potential illegal.
 
what he sells is an open modem thats all, it cant be used unless some one modifies the cable modem for illegal use
like cable tv boxs if there is no firmware on it or firmware that does not give free TV on them not illegal to sell them in the UK its not any way,
i am guessing he should win this case due to both facts (as long as the judge has not been payed of by the TV company he should win this first day)


DOSCI 1.0 and 2.0 norm are easy to use for cable mode cloning (most use 1.1 i think) and the ISP cant do much about it apart from changing the modem for the affected users and blocking that mac or update every ones modem to support basic security (tune off 1.0/1.1 and only use dosci 2.0 with the security turned on) as most are in an fall back mode to make sure every modem works, finding the cloned modem can be hard on most cable networks when using dosci 1.0 or 2.0

DOSCI 3.0 has encrypted keys that is different to each modem and onyl the ISP has (its an encrypted network link), not been possible to clone an 3.0 modem and most likely may not be ever done (you most likely need direct access to the modem to clone it) if it can be the network can find out where that modem is with in an street block and they know right away if 2 modems are using same MAC

above is mostly info i know my self from reading around (need to Nag my virgin Media as my 50mb DOSCI 3.0 connection is not always 50mb drops to 10-3mb and massive packet loss if i download at full speed for 10 mins goes back up after 5-15 mins but Internet is unsaleable )
 
the encryption in 3.0 is moot since the cable companies will be supporting 1.1 for another 5+ years. it's possible to get 100mbit+ speeds on Comcast without paying for anything service. I've seen it.
 
I hope he finds federal prison accommodating, and worth doing this little stunt for.
 
So if I go 100 mph in my mustang, on a road with no cars, then thats ok?

ethically yes... (as you only risk your own life and car)
Legally, only if you're on a part of the autobahn that is unlimited, or only limited when there is high traffic. (from a german point of view 100mph isn't exactly what you'd call "fast")

It's a bad comparison, as even when the local connections are unused, the ISP might have to pay for traffic generated at a different line, and will have to pay for used energy, wear, ect.. ... in which case it would be closer to freely filling up at an unused gas station.
(assuming someone uses a higher speed than what what payed/advertised for)
 
the encryption in 3.0 is moot since the cable companies will be supporting 1.1 for another 5+ years. it's possible to get 100mbit+ speeds on Comcast without paying for anything service. I've seen it.

DOCSIS 1.1 only support 1 bond link in the US thats max 44mb you would need 2 modems, unless you can copy 3.0 modems but that should not be as easy or safe as you should be able to be found within an shorter time
 
my initial post was a reply to illuminate the potential motivations of those who i attempt to understand to better perform my job. regardless of disclaiming myself several times, you have cast that shadow upon me, and it is neither fair nor correct. i'm not someone who advocates stealing cable, vigilante justice, or theft of any kind. I assumed incorrectly i was merely putting my understanding down within the context of your metaphor. Clearly things have gotten confused.

i do however believe it's improper to arrest someone because they're sharing information that isn't illegal to share, performing modifications that aren't illegal to perform, and pinning the crimes of others onto the distributor of knowledge.

It strikes a cord with me in particular, as someone who looks at insecure networks all day long.

Because i know of the vulnerabilities in devices that makes them insecure, it would make me a criminal for having that knowledge or sharing it with my peer group. My peer group could be the firewall user group on USENET that was created by the inventor of the firewall, marcus ranum; since there's no vetting process to being added to that list it's just as likely thats it's composed of 50% security researchers and 50% bank robbers.

Am i to be held accountable for posting information about the vulnerability in linksys routers, or reposting the article i posted earlier detailing the STILL unfixed vulnerability in 65000 time warner cable modems; realize that vulnerability makes it possible for someone to steal your banking information without you ever knowing how or why it happened.?

The point of unlocking the cable modem was to enable the peer review of the security features locked out be the CableCo, and give that power back to those who own the hardware. He ADDED features to the original firmware that increased the overall efficiency and and reliability and security of the original cable modem. If you wanted to go violate the law and download a config file you didn't have a right to, use your advanced networking skills to sniff the cable modem network for the relevant information to steal service, that was your prerogative, and THAT is no different that connecting to a wireless network with no encryption, or using any of the MANY security tools to decrypt a WEP/WPA/WPA2 wireless password.

This was not a you buy and unlocked cable modem from him, and Poof free internet, or Poof free faster internet solution. You had to know what you were doing, and be good at it. You had to be able to sniff, decode and read raw tcp/ip packets as they flowed over the network, and if you wanted a faster config file you had to hack the password to your isp's tftp server and steal it, or sniff another person's faster cable modem connection, wait for them to reboot it, and reassemble the raw tcp/ip packets into a config file. This was far from a simple process, much farther than clicking "okay i'll connect" when stealing someone else's wireless internet access.

This isn't an argument for or against piracy or theft. This is an unjust arrest of a man who dedicated 6+ years of his life to knowing and understanding cable modem technology better than anyone else in the country.

He was arrested for sharing that knowledge.

Let me apologies. I did become confused concerning your motives. I was sleep deprived yesterday and missed some pertinent details as the conversation progressed that led me to feel you were defending theft rather than explaining other points of view.

I also reread the article and also noticed the linked files and read those as well. I've gone back over the conversation we've all had here and come to this understanding, it looks as if Mr. Harris may have discussed methods of hacking with Dshock. I guess it's up to whether he every confided in private discussion a "positive" view on using the devices to steal internet cable. Given the document I'm going to say it is most likely that they discussed more than the transactions. As they claim UC1, UC2, and Mr. Harris having talked to Dshock over three years. So they better hope Dshock didn't save and give the FBI incriminating discussions, if they did have them.

Yet, I'm concerned as discussing hacking and how to do so does not mean you are liable if you believe the conversation is purely asthetic. So the FBI will certainly be trying to prove he, at any time, meant or understood that someone he sold items to intended mal results.
 
My younger brother about 10+ years ago started selling pirated discs. movies, games, anything and everything and ... he got caught and since he had already served time in prison prior to that for selling drugs and being in possession of a firearm, he went back to prison.

I tried to tell him, his buddies that ... whatever money they made illegally was never going to be more than what he could make at a normal job earning a fair wage over a short period of 2 - 3 years. Maybe even less. Steady legit incomes always beat anything a small time crook can make.

What does this have to do with this guy and this story? Same difference, it's just not worth doing something illegal or borderline illegal to make a few extra dollars. The funny thing is, in the end, whatever speed his modem was set from the home office of isp, in the end would have provided him with more data than anything illegal he was doing. Kinda like the turtle and the hare story.

In the end, your really not getting over on the system.

Do some people REALLY beat the system, sure they do, but those guys are few and far between and their stories usually end up having a movie made about them.

Some people used to sell the "fixed" cards for satellite. I don't hear about that much any more so maybe DirecTV came up with a way that it can't be done. But people who did this probably had a lot of people come to them. $100 or whatever they charged for a fixed box * however many people they had coming to them probably gave them a nice side income. You couldn't do it as an every day "job", but I'm sure it gave them "extra". I'm not saying it's right, but it's not like they were trying to sell $5 movies or something.
 
Back
Top