Simple question regarding hard drive duplicating and True Crypt.

JaYp146

Supreme [H]ardness
Joined
Apr 24, 2005
Messages
5,546
Hey guys,

I have a 500GB Samsung SATA drive that I want to "dupe" to my new Seagate 1.5 TB drive.

It's currently set up with two TrueCrypt'ed "hidden" partitions, each is 100GB each. I'd like to keep both intact and have them carry over to the Seagate.

Is there anything special I need to do before copying the data from the Samsung to the Seagate? Will the hidden partitions stay intact after duplication?

Also, I'm planning on using Acronis True Image Home.



Thanks in advance!
 
I would recommend that you undo any disk encryption, making the partitions full visible. uninstall truecrypt. then do your imaging. then re-install and reconfig truecrypt on the new drive.
 
I would recommend that you undo any disk encryption, making the partitions full visible. uninstall truecrypt. then do your imaging. then re-install and reconfig truecrypt on the new drive.

I was hoping to avoid that (grr).

Anyone else? I haven't been able to find anything definitive on TrueCrypt forums, and right now I don't have access to a non-free email to sign up for their forums (irony alert) ...
 
The best thing to do is probably just to do a byte-for-byte clone of the disc. I don't know how Acronis does this if it can, but a simple dd under a Linux CD would work too. If you try Acronis it won't be able to read the encrypted partitions and might not copy them at all.

Resizing things after to fill the new drive might be more challenging.
 
You're just asking for trouble by cloning a drive with full disk encryption enabled - especially since the drives are dissimilar size. You could end up corrupting your data.
 
I think there is a TrueCrypt forum that would be a better place for this question.
 
I think there is a TrueCrypt forum that would be a better place for this question.

As I said in one of my previous posts:
I was hoping to avoid that (grr).

Anyone else? I haven't been able to find anything definitive on TrueCrypt forums, and right now I don't have access to a non-free email to sign up for their forums ...


Regardless, I'm going with sabregen's suggestion.
 
Download the TrueCrypt Q&A file and you will find the answer. It states that they fully recommend that you re-create with a new encryption and not transfer or clone any existing encryption.
 
Hey there, I'm in a similar situation. I've got multiple operating system drives encrypted with TrueCrypt, and I am still on the hunt for a utility that will clone the drives bit-for-bit (forensically, essentially). Stuff like Ghost, Acronis, etc. -- none of those will work, period. I've gone down that road with the vendors, and while they refer to their services as "cloning," they are far from it -- they are built to work with specific file systems (FAT, NTFS, etc.). They are not true cloning utilities by a long shot. If they can't "recognize" the file system or partition data, they won't function. (I used Acronis years ago before I started encrypting, and it worked great. But now it's useless.)

(These programs are built around such "helpful" features because they're targeted at the mass audience -- most people wouldn't know a partition from a hole in the ground, much less the principles of whole-drive encryption.)

Basic rule of thumb so far -- run and hide from anything that runs in Windows. To do what we need, we need a self-booting solution (especially for what I need, see below).

It sounds like my situation is a little bit different from yours, in that my encrypted drives are the O/S drives (boot drives), as opposed to just encrypted partitions. (These drives are encrypted right down to the byte -- no partitions are even recognizable until the drives are unlocked.)

I've gone through TrueCrypt's site with a fine tooth comb, and while Rembrandt is correct about their recommendation, that refers only to the use of encrypted file containers.

The notion that anyone should first unencrypt a drive is idiotic and completely defeats the purpose of encryption. Who has time to wait 9-10 hours to unencrypt a (500gb+) drive, then back it up, then re-encrypt it? Especially every time you run a backup?

I do agree that using dissimilar drive sizes could be a problem. Theoretically, I don't see that it should matter -- once there are no more bytes left to read on the source drive, the process just stops, but without knowing the innermost nuts and bolts of how TC is working, I can't be sure.

I've lost a ridiculous amount of time searching for a solution to this, and so far the Linux / DD option appears to be the best. I'm going to try this and see if it works.
 
Last edited:
Whoa

Why dont you just try it with the encryption.
Even if it doesnt work, you still have the 500GB drive intact so it doesnt matter.

And if it doesnt work undo the encryption and try again.
 
Why do you use encryption on the OS itself? Why not just encrypt the data drives. Then you can just copy/move the data directly to the new disc that you already encrypted? I think i would do it like that so I’m curious what the benefit of encrypting the entire OS is?
 
Why do you use encryption on the OS itself? Why not just encrypt the data drives. Then you can just copy/move the data directly to the new disc that you already encrypted? I think i would do it like that so I’m curious what the benefit of encrypting the entire OS is?

Lots of service companies such as law firms and accounting firms encrypting users laptops is a standard practice and the clients demand such items due to the proprietary and confidential information that they may have on their clients.
 
Purpose of a image?

Are you making a image for quick restoration of computers?

Why don't you just make a standard install first with out any important data and image that first before you encrypt?

This is what my last job use to do.
 
Why do you use encryption on the OS itself? Why not just encrypt the data drives. Then you can just copy/move the data directly to the new disc that you already encrypted? I think i would do it like that so I’m curious what the benefit of encrypting the entire OS is?

If you don't encrypt everything, information about what's in the encrypted container will 'leak'. For example, files linked through the most recently used lists, log files, other random registry entries. It's basically impossible to prevent this leakage since every application would have to be audited and modified to not do this. Much simpler to just encrypt everything.

The disadvantage is that you can't just unmount the container to secure the machine, you need to shut it down completely.
 
Back
Top