@netbook owners

tybert7

2[H]4U
Joined
Aug 23, 2007
Messages
2,763
For your next mobile computer, assuming the only one used is a netbook, would you get another netbook or would you get a regular notebook instead (in whatever form factor wanted)?



I ask because I was initially thrilled with my netbook, but it DOES lag on certain web pages because there is so much stuff to load and the atom just can't keep up.


Curious to know how many people who tried out a netbook planned to step up a bit higher the next go round.
 
I'd step up.

Using a Samsung NC10. Wish it had a dual core Atom in it. 2GB of RAM is plenty though.
 
I currently have an HP 8510w mobile workstation (15.4"). It's a wonderful laptop. Powerful, fantastic resolution, solidly-built, but I've taken stock of what I use my laptop for and it basically comes down to:

1) Web surfing
2) Remote Desktop (5 - 10 at a time)
3) Serial Console stuff (Cisco, etc.)
4) Email via Outlook
5) The occasional Popcap game (downloaded, not flash)

I hate lugging this thing around.. It's heavy..

I've been waiting for the HP Mini 311 with the ION, but I just saw Acer announced the new 11.6" Timeline (1810). For now, there is only a single core ULV, but they are going to release a dual core unit sometime after. I think that's the perfect balance between a Netbook and full-blown laptop.

Riley
 
I am sold on netbooks, I have a dell mini 9 right now, next time I upgrade it will be to another netbook.

I have a XPS laptop as well for programming classes at school.
 
Step up.

My NC10 was great, but the small screen resolution and weak power means it could never be my only system.


A Thinkpad X200(s) with a 12" 1440x900 screen, on the other hand, would suit my needs perfectly.
 
I would get another netbook. With 2gigs ram, I'm actually pretty happy with the Atom for web browsing. Granted I heavily tweaked the system and run adblock, flashblock, etc.

Key points are size and battery life. Maintain those and improve the other specs, and I'm all for it. I wont be getting a larger laptop unless someone else is paying.

Laptops for me are a secondary system, I dont travel often and its more of a convenience. If I didnt have an uber gaming desktop then I would get a beefy laptop instead.
 
I would get another netbook. With 2gigs ram, I'm actually pretty happy with the Atom for web browsing. Granted I heavily tweaked the system and run adblock, flashblock, etc.

Key points are size and battery life. Maintain those and improve the other specs, and I'm all for it. I wont be getting a larger laptop unless someone else is paying.

Laptops for me are a secondary system, I dont travel often and its more of a convenience. If I didnt have an uber gaming desktop then I would get a beefy laptop instead.

I still use my desktop as my main machine, but I use the netbook quite a bit as well when not home (I REALLY like getting on the net). But I am pretty sure the next go round I would just get a smaller notebook for my mobile machine that has a more powerful cpu. When I load this page on my netbook

http://www.engadget.com/

it takes awhile because there is so much stuff to load. I want things more snappy for the sites I visit.

Good news is that alot of the manufacturers are coming out with some inexpensive but VERY nice portable notebooks. Though I am not a size person, I would not mind something larger.
 
Definitely step up from my AAO. It was really cool at first but now its just to small and slow. Full notebooks with 14" 1280x800 screens can be had for only a little more money.
 
I refuse to go above the 13" range so "stepping up" would cost nearly 1000 dollars more than a netbook. I'll live with the slowness of atom.
 
I refuse to go above the 13" range so "stepping up" would cost nearly 1000 dollars more than a netbook. I'll live with the slowness of atom.


Once the 22nd hits, I think you may be pleasantly surprised. I have my eye on one that starts from 550-650 that is hitting VERY soon in best buy stores or online, with options for one of those up to 10 hour batteries on a 13"


I'll post a review when they are actually released.
 
Depends on the use. I have both, laptop and netbook.

Both are good for different things. I think the fail is that many try to group them together as one, but I have no issue deciding which one is better to grab when running out the door to different things.
 
I have both as well.
Considering it's size and power, I am quite pleased with my netbook. If I had to purchase it again, I would pursue the dual core Atom. Never had much problem with internet issues with the current setup.. It has been the perfect solution for me for being a mobile system.

Altho the Acer Aspire One is a mongrel for upgrading, Yet a consistant perfomer for my day to day use for me in the feild.
 
I like my NC10. For my use, I'd get another. Great battery life, good keyboard, easy to take almost anywhere. Enough CPU power for most anything I need it for. I wish I had more screen resolution at times, though. If money was no issue, I might be looking at some 12" Thinkpads.
 
Depends on the use. I have both, laptop and netbook.

Both are good for different things. I think the fail is that many try to group them together as one, but I have no issue deciding which one is better to grab when running out the door to different things.

Agreed completely.
 
If you've ever experienced a netbook w/ a 9 cell / >10 hour battery you would know the answer to this question....indeed, this type of netbook is its own kind of animal. You generally can't do that w/ a notebook.....surely not @ less than 3 lbs anyway.

.
 
I sold my dell mini 9 a while back, but I'd get another in a heart beat if I was looking for a laptop :) Between my home rig and my iphone, I have no practical use for anything else at the moment but I found the mini a very capable machine. It couldn't really run any games (or anything modern at least), but it did everything else just fine :)

It ran solidworks 2004, zbrush and photoshop great

edit: forgot to mention, the biggest drawback that I had with it was the insane temps it would hit on occasion. Since it was using a passive heat sink (no fan), if I was doing something fairly intensive like watching movies on Hulu, temps would often hit close to 90* which didn't leave me feeling very comfortable using it like that for prolonged periods of time. It never locked up or anything, but it got pretty damn hot to the touch
 
Last edited:
I dont care about it running games I dont even like gaming on a laptop. If I am going to game it will be on my desktop.
 
i went and got a CULV aspire with the SU3500
it is the perfect middle ground between netbook and laptop
 
I have a big desktop for c0r3-type tasks.

I have a big laptop for mobile necessity.

My netbook serves the purpose I require of it: to let me screw around on the 'net on the couch, or in bed.

If the option was there, and it was still low-cost, I would of course take more horsepower to watch HD vids online. But, everything has a 'normal' option, so I just avoid the "HD" button while watching video on the 10v.
 
Honestly I wanted a NetBook, so I could look something up on the net without powering up my main rig or if I'm in the living room. But now that I have my G1 phone... that kinda suites my needs for that cause. I really want a laptop though, so if I go with one something like the Acer Timeline or something similar is what I'd pick. My mom has a Dell Mini 9 and FOR ME, at least I can't stand it. I can't type on it and I had a hard time seeing the screen good with it on my lap. Again, personal experience. My mom loves it and will never go back.
 
I'm contemplating stepping up to the Nokia Booklet 3g, from my Lenovo s10.

However, 60 dollars per month for the data plan is too much (2 year contract). 600 bucks unlocked...still on the fence.
 
I'd step up if someone gave me the money to. ;)

Hard to find a C2D in a 10-11" formfactor for $400.
 
I had an Asus 900, I now have a HP/Compaq Mini 311c. They've got much better and I think the 11/12" form factor is perfect.
 
I'm contemplating stepping up to the Nokia Booklet 3g, from my Lenovo s10.

However, 60 dollars per month for the data plan is too much (2 year contract). 600 bucks unlocked...still on the fence.

bad decision if made imo.


the 60 bucks a month is par for the course for "unlimited" (5GB) per month, but the machne still costs more than competing models, and for what exactly? saying the word nokia?
 
I had an Asus 900, I now have a HP/Compaq Mini 311c. They've got much better and I think the 11/12" form factor is perfect.

I do think the 311 is much better than the standard fare because of the graphics, especially when gpu accelerated flash is implemented. Flash seems to be one of the biggest bottlenecks for the atom on my netbook... and ALOT of the web has flash so that is an annoyance.


In any event, this netbook has shown me that at my core, I am a performance whore. I don't need to top speed out there, but I do need things to respond on command, near instantly with little delay.

character issue?
 
I've got a Gateway ec1803h (11.6" screen, Core2Solo SU3500, 3GB, 250GB HDD, 6 cell, Win7) and it seems to do pretty much everything I need while on the go. I love the portability of it, as I use it mainly for photo & video editing while I'm travelling.

I wish I'd hunted around for an ATI or Nvidia Ion powered one as the Intel GMA 4500MHD is only barely passable. It handles low bitrate 720p MKV and DivX files, but completely chokes on Quicktime 720p or Flash HD.
 
I do think the 311 is much better than the standard fare because of the graphics, especially when gpu accelerated flash is implemented. Flash seems to be one of the biggest bottlenecks for the atom on my netbook... and ALOT of the web has flash so that is an annoyance.


In any event, this netbook has shown me that at my core, I am a performance whore. I don't need to top speed out there, but I do need things to respond on command, near instantly with little delay.

character issue?

Well, a quicker CPU would definitely be nicer (maybe a nice new BIOS with some FSB control could fix that :p).

However, for the price/performance/portability/battery life it offered it was perfect for me. £296, faster than most netbooks, lighter than most cheap notebooks and a 5-6 hour battery life.
 
bad decision if made imo.


the 60 bucks a month is par for the course for "unlimited" (5GB) per month, but the machne still costs more than competing models, and for what exactly? saying the word nokia?

For what? Because it has a battery life that last 12 hours without looking like a netbook that has a cancerous outgrowth sticking out that is the battery pack. It also has the look, feel, and build quality of a Macbook Pro, weighs 2.6 pounds, and is less than 3/4 inches thick.

Find me a netbook or laptop that lasts 12 hours, weighs 2.6 pounds or less, has a unibody aluminum chassis, a screen covered in glass, and 1280 x 720 resolution in that size, for 600 bucks or less (with hot swappable 3g capability, not that I would use that, but it's nice to have for when data plans drop in price).

I'm definitely not buying the data plan. I know what the costs are. I would just use the wifi connection since I'm around campus most of the time if not at home.

EDIT: It has nothing to do with brand. I'd sooner by a Walmart branded netbook if it came with those premium materials and lasted that long in terms of battery life.
 
For what? Because it has a battery life that last 12 hours without looking like a netbook that has a cancerous outgrowth sticking out that is the battery pack. It also has the look, feel, and build quality of a Macbook Pro, weighs 2.6 pounds, and is less than 3/4 inches thick.

Find me a netbook or laptop that lasts 12 hours, weighs 2.6 pounds or less, has a unibody aluminum chassis, a screen covered in glass, and 1280 x 720 resolution in that size, for 600 bucks or less (with hot swappable 3g capability, not that I would use that, but it's nice to have for when data plans drop in price).

I'm definitely not buying the data plan. I know what the costs are. I would just use the wifi connection since I'm around campus most of the time if not at home.

EDIT: It has nothing to do with brand. I'd sooner by a Walmart branded netbook if it came with those premium materials and lasted that long in terms of battery life.


Fair enough, it has a bit more going for it than I realized, most importantly the battery life. As to the materials, the metal chasis is a nice touch.

Weight is nice, but honestly, if the same machine weighed 3.6 pounds in the same form factor would that really make a difference?

At what point does the weight of a machine get to diminishing returns? to me anything around 4 pounds or less is damn light.

I'd go with one of the new 13" models coming out though.

The trade off would be battery life, but even there, you are said to get up to 10 hours with the standard 6 cell battery, is it "up to" 12? no but is that a deal breaker?

that model for the intel variant starts at 650.

matches chasis build with a combination of aluminum and magnesium, gives much more system memory, contains a faster processor, and a dual core at that.


And the trade offs are that you get something slightly larger, slightly heavier, and slightly less battery life. Emphasis on slightly.

Seems like a very fair trade to me.

http://www.logichp.com/2009/09/17/details-specs-on-new-hp-pavilion-dm3-probook-5310m-notebooks/
 
One of the things that appealed to me most was the smallness of a netbook. I have my limits to small, however. For example, I will not go below a 10 inch screen. Having said that, the Nokia Booklet 3g does have a thick bezel, which they could use to fill out an 11 inch screen nicely. It's been confirmed that the 10 inch on the Booklet 3g is actually custom for Nokia. They have said that Nokia will move up to an 11 inch screen but still have the same size netbook, which would save them money because 11 inch lcds are more readily available than custom 10 inch screens with 1280 x 720 (most are 1280 x 768; which the 11 inch will also be).

I guess to me, I like the idea of cramming as much as possible in a form factor as small as possible. I have seen the HP line and they are more robust. Prior to the Booklet 3g, I was looking at HP's offering that was the HP 2140 (it is the aluminum version of their netbook).

In terms of battery life for netbooks, the highest prior to the BOoklet 3g was something like 9.something hours with Wifi on and continuous surfing (that's the most common of benchmarks for netbook longevity).

Although, I'm not gaming on a netbook, nor do I plan to as battery life is the single most important factor in my purchasing decisions for a netbook, I question why Nokia doesn't use the ION in the Booklet 3g. I suspect the second iteration will have an ION (along with the 11 inch screen).
 
I have a Dell Mini 9 and I'd definitely would buy a netbook again. I mainly a desktop user, so the netbook fits in perfectly when I need a PC away from home. It feels good to be on a plane with my netbook open on the tray with room to spare while everyone else around me struggles with their 15"-17" laptops. :D

I'm waiting to see what Pinetrail brings. I thought about an Ion netbook, but it has come too late and doesn't provide what I want. I don't want graphics horsepower, I want small size + lots of battery life. Supposedly Pinetrail will allow for smaller mobos, so it will be interesting to see how much more battery manufacturers can cram into a 10-11" form factor.
 
Back
Top