Microsoft’s Mouse 2.0 Demonstration

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Microsoft has posted a short video on its YouTube channel demonstrating five different prototype multi-touch mice. Thanks to [H] forum member Ocean for the link.
 
Saw this a little bit earlier. They got some interesting ideas, but not sure about the useability beyond a view applications for each one. They could also let me try them and I'll see if they work out :D
 
The first and third examples are much more logical then fingerbanging your monitor. The rest of the examples are too awkward to use all day long.
 
Seems like they are one step away from that Ancient Stargate mouse in the control chair.:D
 
I bet they also have a nintendo power glove multi-touch mouse and are just too afraid to admit it. :D
 
I saw this a while ago too and thought that the FIRST thing to come out of this would be a mouse with a touch scroll wheel. That would be pretty cool.
 
I like the first one. I'd use a mouse like that which replaces the buttons for multi-touch functionality.
 
I like the second to last one, the side mouse. That one seems to allow the most Independence from the device. You could "draw" on the table next to the side mouse without using the palm rest or be hampered from your lack of finger length.
 
Interesting stuff for sure, but like concept vehicles, most of it seem too forward thinking for the current market.
 
Any demo vid featuring "Multi-finger 3-D Manipulation" is OK in my book.

On the other hand, and I'm usually all for new fangled stuff, I just don't see the point.

The only thing I saw that was neat was the one where you could lean in game by leaning your hand. That could be useful. The zooming stuff however looks like it would still be better with a good ole scroll wheel.

In some usage models the Surface stuff is really neat. With a touch screen it lets you do some nice things. But most of it is more for presentations or artistic/engineering work, then everyday office/internet/browsing stuff.

The way you see it used on news/weathercasts, how I've seen it demo'd as a teaching aid or design tool, or even some ways I could see it used in a CnC center on a ship all make sense. Most of the stuff you see in this MS demo though, kinda make it look like a solution for a problem that has not only already been solved, but in a more efficient manner as well. You'd just be better off using a 5 button mouse and a touch screen.

The idea above about a touch scroll pad could be pretty sweet though. Even just a big touch pad in front of you would be better in that you would have a much larger touch surface and it would be a lot more intuitive. Would be a nice way to use Surface without a "I hereby bequeath my left nut..." priced touchscreen.

Eh, just my take. To each their own.
 
they should put something like a mouse nub on the center of the second one, that responds to movement and pressure (like pinching)
 
I think they locked these guys and gals in the closet tooooo long. I like the ideas of the mice but some are just out there. My comment for the orb mouse is this, the thing looks like a large breast. Maybe it's just because I am a guy but damn.

KM
 
honestly i thought the first one was crap. it looks too easy for it to mistake a button push. i rest my fingers on my mouse buttons as i'm sure you all do....seems like it would be way too easy to accidentally hit the button.

the rest i didn't mind. the last one though, that was awesome:) but then i'm a CAD designer so yeah anything like that is good for me.
 
Hah. Apple had MS beat for innovative mice!

image28.jpg


Wait... No. That was just a shitty uncomfortable mouse nobody liked.
 
Tye concept of mouse is antiquated. Trying to improve into an antiquated technology as so often happens, example: car industry. Is not taking you nowhere. I want something similar to Nathal.
 
i'm a CAD designer

I hate that moniker. I do. I'm a mechanical engineer that uses CAD as a tool. No different than a hammer or a screwdriver. You shouldn't degrade yourself in that way. Either you are a mechanical drafter, a mechanical designer, or a mechanical engineer. Not a CAD designer. That simply devalues you.
 
Hah. Apple had MS beat for innovative mice!

image28.jpg


Wait... No. That was just a shitty uncomfortable mouse nobody liked.

Dude, its bizarre. They make the absolute best notebook trackpad on the market and among the best keyboards out there, but their mice SUCK.

So.

Bad.
 
[Apple makes] the absolute best notebook trackpad on the market and among the best keyboards out there, but their mice SUCK.
I think the only way they could have made the Mighty Mouse any worse is if it were somehow designed to be used upside down or if they had decided that the foot was a more appropriate appendage for manipulating such an input device (a.k.a. the Apple Footy Mouse).
 
If this was 2002, I'd be impressed, but this is the beginning of the multi touch era. For the next 10 years or so, true multi touch will be the interface of choice. At least until good voice command and good AI do most of the work for you..
 
stupid ideas, seems like they have gone over board with the apple multitouch ideas which imo is pretty crappy. Can you imagine the new mouse-hand problems that people will complain over :)

Touch screen multitouch or hand movement screen controls might work but these prototypes are kinda crap. Correction: remove kinda. Frankly humans might have 5 fingers on each hand but how easy is it to control and use each one independently?

Would be cooler with multi pointer ideas, ie. two hands two pointers, pinch to press etc. Much simpler and way more natural.

/Q
 
yeah and the mouse wheel is way easier to use then I imagine doing what they kept doing to zoom. I mean, it looked uncomfortable, like it would cause serious finger cramps after a while
 
Frankly humans might have 5 fingers on each hand but how easy is it to control and use each one independently?

I use all 5 fingers on my keyboard when playing FPS games pretty well. Pinky is usually my crouch, my Ring, Middle, and Pointer fingers are A, S/W, D respectively. Then my thumb hits the spacebar.
 
I use all 5 fingers on my keyboard when playing FPS games pretty well. Pinky is usually my crouch, my Ring, Middle, and Pointer fingers are A, S/W, D respectively. Then my thumb hits the spacebar.

I've tried several times to use WASD for controls but I could never get it down pat. I'm an arrow key user, which makes the INS (0) key on the numeric keypad my jump key instead of spacebar.

When I use WASD my fingers will stray and get lost while I'm watching the screen. In about 20-25 years of computers, I've never broke the habit of not looking at my keyboard when typing despite being a speed-typist.

That's why those gamer keys never worked for me. It's more keys to look at instead of the screen. Those mouse 2.0 accessories might give me problems too. I would prefer a sort of desktop projection that allows me the freedom of using my desktop as a touch surface.
 
I've tried several times to use WASD for controls but I could never get it down pat. I'm an arrow key user, which makes the INS (0) key on the numeric keypad my jump key instead of spacebar.

When I use WASD my fingers will stray and get lost while I'm watching the screen. In about 20-25 years of computers, I've never broke the habit of not looking at my keyboard when typing despite being a speed-typist.

That's why those gamer keys never worked for me. It's more keys to look at instead of the screen. Those mouse 2.0 accessories might give me problems too. I would prefer a sort of desktop projection that allows me the freedom of using my desktop as a touch surface.

+1 to that WASD sucks. I use arrows with Crtl, Shift, Enter, Del, Pg Dn, and INS (0) for other controls that don't get assigned to the mouse. I never have to look at the KB. I just feel it, which is great since I usually have the lights down.
 
Is it just me or is the basic function: "Look, I can zoom in and out and make windows larger / smaller with this crazy new mouse".

I definitely couldn't do that with my current mouse.
 
Well its great to see that some are still trying to rethink the mouse. Even though they are interesting concepts, I doubt that I would personally enjoy using any of them for more than a few minutes. The cap version looked the best IMO, but still it doesnt seem very attractive to have to "draw" with your fingers on the mouse or any surface for that matter. Its funny how they keep on showcasing the scaling of images, or translating the camera, as the most amazing multi touch application. My guess is that these mice are doomed already.
 
+1 to that WASD sucks. I use arrows with Crtl, Shift, Enter, Del, Pg Dn, and INS (0) for other controls that don't get assigned to the mouse. I never have to look at the KB. I just feel it, which is great since I usually have the lights down.

Let me guess, you're right-handed as opposed to left-handed. Left-handed players don't tend to have problem with WASD since, afterall, those keys are controlled by the hand they use the most.
 
Some cool ideas, but looks to me that so far all they've been able to come up with is different ways to zoom in and out with the tech lol...
 
The video is cool, if you need 17 different ways to zoom in on things.

I assume that mouse took off because it was easy to use. Slide and click. My grandfather can do that. These mice look much harder to use, to me at least. Having no tactile response seems like a step down. The lack of tactile response is getting more common (waving a Wii remote around or typing on an iPhone virtual keyboard), but for accuracy and speed I think buttons are here to stay.
 
As someone else said above, it's good that someone is at least trying to improve mice, but I wouldn't use any of those. I like tactile feedback when I hit a button, and more feedback in general as to what I'm doing than just moving fingers around. Besides, I haven't used a mouse in 10 years, mainly because they take up too much space to be able to use effectively. I'm a trackball user, and I can't understand why they aren't more popular. On the one I use, the Logitech Cordless Optical Trackman, I have 8 programmable buttons and a trackwheel that are spaced out enough to be usable and comfortable (I have big hands) and only takes up 12 square inches of space, versus the comparable mouse, which has all those buttons crammed into half the space and requires at least 64 square inches or more of desktop to move around in, depending on how you set up the cursor motion.

Having said all that, we recently got touch screen monitors at work, and I can't wait until they are move viable for home use.
 
Tye concept of mouse is antiquated. Trying to improve into an antiquated technology as so often happens, example: car industry. Is not taking you nowhere. I want something similar to Nathal.

This.

I mean, I'm a HUGE fan of Razer mice - and I don't see my Boomslang CE 2007 going away any time soon. Especially not with technology like this.

BUT!

...or...maybe...especially...

When seeing the 'Project Natal' videos, it seemed blatantly obvious that this was where things were going. I mean, it is - or would allow - the 'Minority Report' UI. And, certainly, Windows 7 has a lot of functionality built-in with multitouch to definitely benefit from it (although I kind of hope Windows 8 is built ASSUMING the presence of a multi-touch UI, rather than just having a few features to support it).

These 'multitouch mouse' interfaces...I dunno. I guess I don't see the need for the interim step. Go from the Razer/Logitech/Microsoft/etc "gaming mice" we have today straight to a 'Natal'-based UI (IE., keep what we have and don't waste time on interim solutions, instead spending those resources to bring us the ACTUAL 'next step' sooner).
 
i don't see any practical applications for this junk.

yeah it's fun to doodle with your fingers. But i'm not paying $99 for that.

Even if i were bored to death, i wouldn't sit on my computer flicking jpg's around. What's the point?
 
As someone else said above, it's good that someone is at least trying to improve mice, but I wouldn't use any of those. I like tactile feedback when I hit a button, and more feedback in general as to what I'm doing than just moving fingers around. Besides, I haven't used a mouse in 10 years, mainly because they take up too much space to be able to use effectively. I'm a trackball user, and I can't understand why they aren't more popular. On the one I use, the Logitech Cordless Optical Trackman, I have 8 programmable buttons and a trackwheel that are spaced out enough to be usable and comfortable (I have big hands) and only takes up 12 square inches of space, versus the comparable mouse, which has all those buttons crammed into half the space and requires at least 64 square inches or more of desktop to move around in, depending on how you set up the cursor motion.

Having said all that, we recently got touch screen monitors at work, and I can't wait until they are move viable for home use.


jesus, increase your mouse sensitivity and get a laser, i dont move any mouse more than an inch to the left/right/up/down with that i can get from one side of the screen to the other...



anyway, i tend to agree i like tacttile feedback, however ive been playing with the tablets here at work and once you get used to touch screen its hard to go back i find my self pressing on normal screens expecting the computer to load up something even though its just a normal lcd... The only thing with them is i hate fingerprints, and its the biggest factor for me that puts me off, so having a mouse that i can touch instead, would be better than the touch screen.
 
Tye concept of mouse is antiquated. Trying to improve into an antiquated technology as so often happens, example: car industry. Is not taking you nowhere. I want something similar to Nathal.
The car industry is crippled by their customer base more than anything. They've been innovating for years but people just don't want it.
 
Back
Top