Larrabee Doing Real-Time Ray Tracing

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Intel sent us a link to this video from IDF 2009 showing Bill Mark demonstrating real-time ray tracing on the Larrabee. While all the attention is on the Radeon HD 5870 today, this ray tracing demo is impressive in its own right.
 
now...that is very impressive...

looking forward to what it will bring in future :)
 
Watching the video, it looks like it's running at about 5 fps. I remember that it was just a few years ago that a cluster of Opterons was barely rendering Quake (1) with shadows at about the same framerate. It's certainly still a long way away from catching up with traditional graphics a la ATi and nVidia, but it shows some significant progress.
 
very cool. it's amazing that they're able to run this in realtime at all, they're making some good headway. it doesn't seem like they're casting a whole lot of rays (or atleast not very accurately) but that will no doubt be refined over time
 
No user interaction, less than half a dozen on screen moving objects, most objects/textures far off into the distance. They may have pulled the resources from Quake Wars, but it looks like they pulled the low/medium quality stuff - it doesn't really look graphically any better than, say, HL2...

Can't say I'm really impressed or even convinced that it was running smooth at all. The water reflections looked cool, I guess, but nothing amazing compared to what other games can do.
 
Impressive for the technology they have now. The big thing will be how well the technology will play games. At least for me. :D
 
Considering that would look more like a glacier moving than waves on a more conventional GPU trying to do those reflections I think it is pretty impressive.
 
Pretty damn impressive. I'm curious if it will be possible for nVidia and ATI to make adjustments to their GPGPU capabilities to make this possible, and how performance would stack up.

Needless to say, Larrabee is pretty exciting technology from Intel, I'm really interested to see where this goes. It's a supercomputer on a chip! With the x86 ASA (WTF Intel...).
 
Awesome stuff, don't count intel out yet. The SSD's are proof intel can work it's magic.
 
You can really tell the difference in rendering knowledge and the wide range of users HardOcp has just by reading this article :D
 
umm they were showing this off last year if not the year before.

and all they have now is a nearly static scene with a few flying ships moving around ?

i was expecting far more like a another engine or maybe some actual live in game play.

all we get is another tech demo showing feasibility but still no real practicality.

maybe next year we will see something really interesting.
 
Raytracking is cool, but very very "old hat". Crysis looks much better, and runs much better, without Ray Tracing.
 
So the advantage here is that because its Ray Tracing, you could zoom in nearly infinintly to any part of that scene and there would be no anti-aliasing or anything being limited by texture size right?
 
To all of you saying this is unimpressive, do you have any idea WHAT RTRT (real-time ray tracing) is, or how intense it is?
 
If you want 60fps+ of realtime raytracing, give the tech to the porn industry and they'll get it there a hojillion times faster than it would take normally.
 
I think the goal here is that we all expect the future of graphics to be ray tracing, particularly if we ever wish to get to trully three dimensional graphics and displays. The objects to need to be rendered as true 3 dimensional objects in real time that can be scaled and manipulated at will. Raster graphics will never allow us to get to that point because everything has to be thought of ahead of time.

So while raster may be "as good or better" right now, its only because the technology is limited. This may show a slow start, but its progression none-the-less and thats the signifigance. If we ever wish for graphics to be as real as what we see with out eyes, then we have to learn to create the images using the same technique that our eyes (or nature) uses to draw images, and thats where Ray Tracing comes in.
 
To all of you saying this is unimpressive, do you have any idea WHAT RTRT (real-time ray tracing) is, or how intense it is?

Yes, I do, but what is the point of RTRT if it looks like ass? Seriously, I don't care HOW its rendered, I really only care what it LOOKS like, and this demo looks worse than the Source engine for gods sake.

So the advantage here is that because its Ray Tracing, you could zoom in nearly infinintly to any part of that scene and there would be no anti-aliasing or anything being limited by texture size right?

Uh, no. Ray tracing doesn't avoid aliasing, still would need AA. Ray tracing has nothing to do with texture sizes, still would be limited in texture sizes. What ray tracing does allow for is a much, much better and far more accurate simulation of light. It also can handle more polygons far more easily.

But its also dreadfully slow and a huge waste of resources.
 
The problem: Intel has zero track record with GPUs. Zero. Year after year they produce shit IGP solutions. But wait! Next year! It will be AWESOME! Really!
 
The problem: Intel has zero track record with GPUs. Zero. Year after year they produce shit IGP solutions. But wait! Next year! It will be AWESOME! Really!

Those IGP solutions don't target the high end market. They're purpose built to provide the best performance in the most efficient way possible at the lowest price point possible. It's really easy to throw money to make things perform better, but it takes skill to produce efficiency.

That being said. It's things like this that moves the industry, not just saying "we've improved 'x' feature by 'Y' times"
 
Awesome stuff, don't count intel out yet. The SSD's are proof intel can work it's magic.

After they held affordable gaming in their hand with the i740, and proceeded to screw the pooch, I'd say wait for the other shoe to drop. You know, like Intel releasing nothing because their focus shifts or it proceeds to suck.
 
Yes, I do, but what is the point of RTRT if it looks like ass? Seriously, I don't care HOW its rendered, I really only care what it LOOKS like, and this demo looks worse than the Source engine for gods sake.

Nobody said this will be a commercial game engine or anything like that. This just shows the advancement in real time ray tracing rendering.

You can't immediately start off with quality that exceed rasterized graphics capabilities. Not in real time rendering anyway

In CGI movie, its already been proven that ray tracing can achieve qualities that are beyond rasterized graphics, its just not practical to be rendered in real time yet. This is where they are making advancement.

Eventually, rasterized graphic will run out of room for improvement, and will be replaced by ray tracing.
 
To all of you saying this is unimpressive, do you have any idea WHAT RTRT (real-time ray tracing) is, or how intense it is?

I do have an idea and for that, it's impressive... but Intel is showing it off as if it'll revolutionize the whole graphics industry and cause everyone to veer away from nVidia and ATi/AMD... unless it can get a decent framerate, it won't.

On top of that, nVidia has Optix which does the same EXACT thing that Larrabee does using a GPU (RTRT with C code... CUDA in this case) and has better performance. Optix is said to be ready to ship by autumn 2009 aka any time now. Larrabee? 2010.

ATi has a similar API to CUDA and already has some neat RTRT stuff implemented in their current hardware architecture. They're just not promoting it as much.

Bottom Line: I'm a little disappointed in the state of Larrabee right now since I've seen what the other two big graphics firms have.
 
It's nice that ray tracing is a more realistic approach to lighting and shading, but the "tricks" that developers have come up with are way better looking. When ray tracing can do a water scene like this http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NAsoXHHCqWM or better with better frame rates, I'll be convinced.
 
Not impressed. Needs more tech specs and information on the demo.

Also, Ray-Tracing is a buzzword (tm)(c). No sensible developer would solely use RT to render a scene with as it has a lot of limitations, including an inability to do lighting/shadows properly. What one needs is Photon Mapping, which is what happens in Real Life (tm) too. What we call ray tracing is just the inverse of photon mapping, an ugly shortcut with a lot of limitations.

Most modern engines including my company's use a simplified version of photon mapping to get realistic lighting (global illumination) and shadows (dynamic, soft shadows). Ray-tracing can't do any of this. Please stop the hype :)
 
Back
Top