AOC-SASLP-MV8 verdict?

fleggett

Gawd
Joined
Nov 30, 2004
Messages
546
I was just about to buy a motherboard which has 2 PCI-E x4 slots when I remembered there was some controversy about this card. When it was first announced, it was greeted with open arms, but since then I recall reading a lot of complaints. I actually have one and it's been fine, but I'm not doing anything special with it (no RAID'ing, for instance).

If this is now a discredited card, what do people now recommend at a similar price point and configuration? SFF8087 connectors are a must. This'll be going into a Norco 4020. I'm not concerned about the actual bus interface, since I'm willing to buy a replacement motherboard.
 
Last edited:
Ockie

What did you ever figure out with the boot drive?

I know you tried the LSI version, are those significantly different than the SM version?
 
I've only got two drives on the system controller, and only a single SASLP card... but I love mine - zero problems.
 
Ockie

What did you ever figure out with the boot drive?

I know you tried the LSI version, are those significantly different than the SM version?

Not sure what you mean with the boot drive. I hated the LSI garbage, I will never use an LSI controller again for my enthusiast needs.
 
So I disabled INT13, still did not work. Then I entered the bios again and noticed that the motherboard will keep selecting drives as boot drives. After going into the bios 4 times to disable the other boot drives, it finally kept it at the one drive to boot from... works great now.

Every time I plug in another drive, the system makes it the priority boot drive for some or other reason and I will have to go into the bios and disable it.

This is what I was reffering to.
 
This is what I was reffering to.

Oh yeah that was a wrestle, but the main issue with that card was that you were not able to set pass through drives, you had to assign them as arrays... which is ok, until you have green drives or any drive which will time out for the controller, secondly... you couldn't just add drives and then use them as is, you had to create each one to be an array and then you could only add those arrays. The controllers interface sucked and the documentation sucked, not to mention the lack of features... all I wanted was a pass through controller and that LSI couldn't even provide that.

I know unhappy mage had the same issues with that LSI... I don't know if he gave up on it. Last I heard was that you can dumb flash them, but I wasn't going to go through all the trouble for that.
 
So, this is still the card to get, then? If so, I'm putting an order in with Wiredzone today.
 
So, this is still the card to get, then? If so, I'm putting an order in with Wiredzone today.

I thought all the stores were sold out (heads on over to wiredzone). These cards are pretty popular, I would highly recommend them.
 
Provantage also sells them for quite a bit cheaper, but they drop-ship and admit to a pretty long wait time. However, I don't know if I entirely trust Wiredzone's "in stock" status, as the first one I ordered was, I'm 95% certain, drop-shipped, but it still came in about a week if memory serves (from CA to FL).

Second one on its way! BTW, I'm pairing the two with this motherboard:

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16813128343&Tpk=GIGABYTE%20GA-EP45-DQ6

It was one of the few motherboards I spotted with two PCI-E x4 slots.
 
Provantage also sells them for quite a bit cheaper, but they drop-ship and admit to a pretty long wait time. However, I don't know if I entirely trust Wiredzone's "in stock" status, as the first one I ordered was, I'm 95% certain, drop-shipped, but it still came in about a week if memory serves (from CA to FL).

Second one on its way! BTW, I'm pairing the two with this motherboard:

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16813128343&Tpk=GIGABYTE%20GA-EP45-DQ6

It was one of the few motherboards I spotted with two PCI-E x4 slots.

You can just use the x16 slots also.
 
That's what I'm doing now with my GA-EP45-UD3P (it's in the x8 slot), but I wanted dedicated x4 slots should I ever plan on using the x8 slot for something crazy. In hindsight, I should never have bought the UD3P for use with those Supermicro cards.
 
That's what I'm doing now with my GA-EP45-UD3P (it's in the x8 slot), but I wanted dedicated x4 slots should I ever plan on using the x8 slot for something crazy. In hindsight, I should never have bought the UD3P for use with those Supermicro cards.

Why, whats wrong with the UD3P?
 
You can only use the remaining x8 slot for a card like the AOC-SASLP-MV8. The x16 will, presumably, be for video, the x1 slots are, from what I can see, virtually useless, and the other slots are regular PCI, one of which I'm using for my wireless NIC. Unless you plan to use the one or two x1 video cards out there (none of which are powerful enough for HD content) or an old PCI videocard, you literally cannot use more than one AOC-SASLP-MV8 in a GA-EP45-UD3P.

The UD3P itself is a very nice motherboard, just not suited for this task.
 
You can only use the remaining x8 slot for a card like the AOC-SASLP-MV8. The x16 will, presumably, be for video, the x1 slots are, from what I can see, virtually useless, and the other slots are regular PCI, one of which I'm using for my wireless NIC. Unless you plan to use the one or two x1 video cards out there (none of which are powerful enough for HD content) or an old PCI videocard, you literally cannot use more than one AOC-SASLP-MV8 in a GA-EP45-UD3P.

The UD3P itself is a very nice motherboard, just not suited for this task.

Oh well I dedicate the server use so I don't care much for video card performance. I was just wondering :)
 
I can't speak for the UD3P, but most boards will work with a non-video board in the PCI x16 slot. Having an Intel chipset makes this more likely.

The x1 slots are useful to add a decent NIC so you can get good performance out of your storage server.
 
Oh well I dedicate the server use so I don't care much for video card performance. I was just wondering :)
That's what I wanted to do in the beginning, but realized too late that, no matter how fast, a wireless connection cannot reliably stream HD content. And running the necessary wires just wasn't an option at the time.

I'd like to stick the Norco in a closet somewhere and turn the whole thing into a dedicated server one day. One day...
 
I have typically used desktop motherboards for building NAS servers, but have come tol realize it's a better idea to use a server board for the task. By the time you add a decent PCI-E intel NIC, and futz around learning the ins and outs of the PCI-E configurations on these boards, it's generally better and more cost effective to use a server board that usually has dual intel Gbe nic's on board and PCI-E slots that are designed for RAID controllers etc...

On one of my Intel Gigabyte desktop boards, the x4 PCIE slot only works if the x1 slots are not in use. Prior to the P55 or X58 series, there wern't enough PCIE lanes to go around, and most of the BIOS's didn't reassign x16 lanes the way a server board can.
 
I've had a horrible time finding a server board with the specs I need (supported cpu, ram, expansion slots, etc...).
 
I'm using two of these in my Norco 4220 WHS. They generally work fine except for some trouble with startup after the machine has been turned off. I get a timeout when the board is initializing the disks connected to the 2nd contoller on each card. I've had to pull the drives and boot the machine, then insert the drives hot and restart the machine. Upon the first restart, WHS boots up without my user settings, so I restart again (2nd restart), and the machine boots up correctly with all drives initialized and recognized. This only happens on initial startup after the machine has been turned off and happens every time the machine is turned on after being turned off. I haven't been able to figured out if I've got some setting wrong in the board's bios or just what is going on.
 
I'm using two of these in my Norco 4220 WHS. They generally work fine except for some trouble with startup after the machine has been turned off. I get a timeout when the board is initializing the disks connected to the 2nd contoller on each card. I've had to pull the drives and boot the machine, then insert the drives hot and restart the machine. Upon the first restart, WHS boots up without my user settings, so I restart again (2nd restart), and the machine boots up correctly with all drives initialized and recognized. This only happens on initial startup after the machine has been turned off and happens every time the machine is turned on after being turned off. I haven't been able to figured out if I've got some setting wrong in the board's bios or just what is going on.

You should not have that issue. Try going into your controller bios and turn down the detection timeout and then enable the controller to skip the boot sequence and just mount.
 
I have typically used desktop motherboards for building NAS servers, but have come tol realize it's a better idea to use a server board for the task. By the time you add a decent PCI-E intel NIC, and futz around learning the ins and outs of the PCI-E configurations on these boards, it's generally better and more cost effective to use a server board that usually has dual intel Gbe nic's on board and PCI-E slots that are designed for RAID controllers etc...
That alone sounds like a dizzying prospect. I can barely wrap my head around consumer-grade boards. Server boards are beasts unto themselves. I had played around with the idea once, but then saw messages about this ram not POST'ing with that board and this CPU stepping not liking that chipset and decided to just stick with the "basics".

On one of my Intel Gigabyte desktop boards, the x4 PCIE slot only works if the x1 slots are not in use. Prior to the P55 or X58 series, there wern't enough PCIE lanes to go around, and most of the BIOS's didn't reassign x16 lanes the way a server board can.
Yuck! Which Gigabyte board was this? What about the P45 chipset?
 
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16833127218

It's the only one I could find on Newegg. Are there any advantages to switching to a PCI-E NIC over a PCI version?

Wireless sucks to begin with, so it doesn't really matter, use the interface that's convenient - but I certainly wouldn't want a server connected with wireless. I'm talking about adding an Intel GigE NIC to replace the shit Realtek or Marvell onboard that every consumer motherboard bar Intel's own ships with. GigE can saturate the PCI bus, you don't want it there.

That alone sounds like a dizzying prospect. I can barely wrap my head around consumer-grade boards. Server boards are beasts unto themselves. I had played around with the idea once, but then saw messages about this ram not POST'ing with that board and this CPU stepping not liking that chipset and decided to just stick with the "basics".
Just read the CPU compatibility list and make sure you buy the right type of memory. There aren't really any bigger compatibility issues than with desktop boards IME. And things like using x8 RAID cards 'just work'. Something like the Supermicro X7SBL is perfect for a NAS.
 
I like supermicro motherboards. They make some stuff that just works right the very first time.
 
Wireless sucks to begin with, so it doesn't really matter, use the interface that's convenient - but I certainly wouldn't want a server connected with wireless.
I agree that wireless is less than ideal, but in my case it was the only option at the time. At some point, hopefully in the not-too-distant future, I am going to run the necessary wires and make the Norco a true server.

BTW, I received the Supermicro card today, just a day after ordering. I completely forgot Wiredzone has a warehouse in Miami. For those curious, the card revision hasn't changed, nor has the driver on the included CD.
 
Did they ship your card yet? I'm hoping I can find someone that has them in stock or are able to get them... For the most part they seem to be backordered :( I need one more of these.
 
NVM, I found a seller on ebay who has them in stock (buy.com)
 
Did they ship your card yet? I'm hoping I can find someone that has them in stock or are able to get them... For the most part they seem to be backordered :( I need one more of these.
Yes, I received it today. Why not order from Wiredzone? According to their website, they still have stock.
 
You should not have that issue. Try going into your controller bios and turn down the detection timeout and then enable the controller to skip the boot sequence and just mount.

Thanks for the info. I went into the cards' bios (Control-M), and changed the detection timeout to 0. I'm not sure how to enable the controller to skip the boot sequence and just mount like you suggest? Under Control-S, the only options I see are: Network Boot Protocol (PXE Preboot execution environment), Boot order (use bios setup boot order), Show Setup Prompt (enabled), and Setup Menu wait time ( 2 seconds). Network Boot Protocol and Boot Order could not be changed. After changing the timeout to 0, I'm still having the same problem with the card not initializing the drives on the second cable and just stopping the initialization process. If I pull the drives and let the cards initialize first, then insert the drives before WHS boots up, then everything works fine and upon re-boot, all of the drives initialize and work. The problem occurs only on a cold start.
 
Yes, I received it today. Why not order from Wiredzone? According to their website, they still have stock.

Mine has been ordered, so it's all good :)

Thanks for the info. I went into the cards' bios (Control-M), and changed the detection timeout to 0. I'm not sure how to enable the controller to skip the boot sequence and just mount like you suggest? Under Control-S, the only options I see are: Network Boot Protocol (PXE Preboot execution environment), Boot order (use bios setup boot order), Show Setup Prompt (enabled), and Setup Menu wait time ( 2 seconds). Network Boot Protocol and Boot Order could not be changed. After changing the timeout to 0, I'm still having the same problem with the card not initializing the drives on the second cable and just stopping the initialization process. If I pull the drives and let the cards initialize first, then insert the drives before WHS boots up, then everything works fine and upon re-boot, all of the drives initialize and work. The problem occurs only on a cold start.

This should not be happening. Try playing with the settings some more, but that is just weird.

What type of drives are you using?
 
This should not be happening. Try playing with the settings some more, but that is just weird.

What type of drives are you using?

I've been through all available settings on both the SASLP cards and the mobo and can't find anything else to change. The only setting I'm not sure about is the "Silent Mode" setting. I don't know what that is, so I've just left it set at the default setting which is "Disabled". The drives are: 1-WD Green 1TB (attached to mobo sata port), 4-Seagate 1.5TB LP, 2-WD Green 2 TB (1 attached to mobo sata port), and 2-Seagate 2TB LP.
 
I ordered two of these for my Norco 4220 build:

Supermicro AOC-Saslp-MV8

What part number for the SAS cables do I need?

Thanks!
 
I ordered two of these for my Norco 4220 build:

Supermicro AOC-Saslp-MV8

What part number for the SAS cables do I need?

Thanks!

The part number will depend on the cable mfg. But it is an SFF-8087 to SFF-8087 cable.
 
The part number will depend on the cable mfg. But it is an SFF-8087 to SFF-8087 cable.

Oh. I get it. I thought you guys were ordering super micro brand cables for some reason.

:)
 
Oh. I get it. I thought you guys were ordering super micro brand cables for some reason.

:)

I haven't seen any Supermicro SFF-8087 to SFF-8087 cables. I used Startech cables from Provantage, which were pretty expensive. Since I ordered mine, I've seen them elsewhere for a lot less than I paid.
 
Okay, I think I see what I need.

What do you think of this:

Norco brand $14 at New Egg

I guess I would need two of these for one Super Micro card, right?

And this Norco reverser breakout cable to utilize the regular SATA ports directly off the motherboard, right?

$13 Norco reverse SATA

This reverse breakout cable is good for 4 SATA ports, right?

.
.

p.s. Thanks for your patience! This stuff is all new to me!
 
Last edited:
Okay, I think I see what I need.

What do you think of this:

Norco brand $14 at New Egg

I guess I would need two of these for one Super Micro card, right?

And this Norco reverser breakout cable to utilize the regular SATA ports directly off the motherboard, right?

$13 Norco reverse SATA

This reverser breakout cable is good for 4 SATA ports, right?

.
.

p.s. Thanks for your patience! This stuff is all new to me!

Yes, yes and yes. It's great to see Norco selling the cables for a good price.
 
Back
Top