Blu-ray Sings the PC Blues

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Apparently Blu-ray isn’t doing so hot when it comes to the number of PCs with Blu-ray drives and, if this report is to be believed, that won’t change until at least 2013.

Despite a rapid rise in the sales of consumer Blu-ray players, a fall in their prices and an increase in the number of high-definition movie titles, Blu-ray Drives (BDs) in PC systems have been left singing the blues, according to iSuppli Corp. By 2013, BDs will be found in only 16.3 percent of PCs shipped, up from 3.6 percent in 2009.
 
There's no reason to have BD players in most PCs anyway. The only exception to it being are HTPCs. This is only going to change when software requires the space of BD for installation. Which honestly, would be ridiculous to require in the forseeable future.
 
Considering most big games run off the HDD, there really no point in Blu-ray for PC.(unless you just want to watch movies all day)
 
Yeah I don't see a reason to have a Blu-ray player in my PC. I have a PS3 and a 46" LG-50 1080p television a few feet away from the computer. What do I want to watch Blu-ray on my PC for?

As for burners, I would love to have one at work for database backup. It's a pain in the ass backing up 50gb per week on DVD. But at home, I rarely burn CD, nevermind DVD. What do I need with a Blu-ray burner?
 
I was very close to buying a blu-ray burner for my PC. $160 is not a bad price for one and I found it for $144. I would buy it. In fact, i was going too until I researched the price of the media. Its cheaper to burn 5 DVDs than it is to burn 1 Blu-ray.

I still dont have a blu-ray drive....
 
I bit on an LG GGC-H20L awhile ago for $95 to rip my movie collection 'cause I'm tired of messing with discs. If BD media wasn't so expensive, maybe it would take off a bit more, at least as far as burners.
 
Back in the day, CDs couldn't hold the enough data, the leap from CDs to DVDs was logical. Today DVDs are still large enough. I don't know of any software vendors making programs so large that they require a BD. Software vendors aren't likely to make the jump to BD anytime soon as well because adoption rate is low.
 
Most people have no problem using one or dvd's to install software. And with software that you download and install now i can see that being cheaper than a blu ray disk. We have a couple enterprise programs at work that take a couple dvd's but better than getting a slim blu ray player for the server. I usually just like loading the iso over the network and calling it a day.
 
That report might as well have come from the Obvious News Network LOL. Short of a HTPC (which usually also entails using it to "backup" Blu-Ray movies), the need for Blu-Ray in a PC is very limited right now. Yes, some people use a Blu-Ray burner to backup data files (like ouch expensive).
 
I bought one but only because my gaming computer serves as an HTPC and also because it was external (needed a drive for the Wind too)... and only 20 bucks more than a normal external dvd burning drive ($99).
 
There's no reason to have BD players in most PCs anyway. The only exception to it being are HTPCs.
Which is a moot point considering that the best HTPC setup (IMO of course) is XBMC on Linux which doesn't support Blu-ray. I have two LG HD/BD/DVD combo drives but don't use them an awful lot. If I didn't have a good size HighDef movie library I probably wouldn't have bought them.
 
As soon as that 6x BD burner with HD DVD Rom hits $100 (Black Friday) I'm on it like a fly on shit.
 
Is this really any surprise when the DRM on a Blu-ray disc is absolutely fucking retarded?

I don't support that shit, so I don't buy Blu-rays. Plain and simple.
 
i have one in my computer! but i use it to play blu-rays to my lcd tv.

i havent burned any blu-ray discs with it yet and ive owned it almost a year.

15 pack single layer blu-ray discs are down to around $45...once they get down to $30 im on it. i cant wait for dual layer media to become cheaper and more readily available also!
 
Per GB media prices > Per GB HD prices

Epic fail?

Why the hell would I want a $10+ disk that holds 25GB when I can get a $60 2.5" external drive that is smaller, holds far more data, is reusable, and most importantly, doesn't support Sony?
 
It's really not a matter of pricepoint or DRM. It's necessity. We moved from Floppies to CDs because it was more convenient to install from one CD as opposed to 20 floppies. That goes the same for the jump from CDs to DVDs (Playing the original Wing Commander IV back in the day was a pain when you had to swap discs.) With the amount of HD storage that's available now disc swapping is pretty much dead and there isn't a need to waste all that money and resources towards investing into BD.
 
Yea, until software/games start requiring 3 or 4 DVDs typically, BD is not going to take off.
 
What the fuck do they expect? You can still get a stand alone, guaranteed to work, player for about 100$ less than the hardware and software you need to make it work properly in a PC.
 
I've got a BluRay player in my laptop, but only to drive the 1080p widescreen and 5.1 surround sound. On the laptop.
 
i dont have burners, but i have readers BDROM/DVDRW burner combos. in fact, i have 3 combo drives and 1 standalone BD player =P.
 
That goes the same for the jump from CDs to DVDs (Playing the original Wing Commander IV back in the day was a pain when you had to swap discs.)

Ha, that actually came to mind. Wing Commander III was 7 CD's.....epic game calls for epic disc swapping!

I have thought about buying a BD drive, but as (obviously) mentioned there is simply no use for it atm as far as data reasons go.
 
No surprise to me.

Blu-ray sucks on the PC.

I got a blu-ray to play movies, and the amount of DRM crap you have to go through to play in on a monitor sucks.

Your monitor needs to be HDCP, your video card needs to be HDCP, you need an audio card that has HDMI 1.3 that streams Dolby TrueHD or DTS HD, you need a receiver that can interpret the HDMI 1.3 stream, speakers. That's why I laugh when I see a 15-inch laptop with a blu-ray player, are you kidding me?

Of course there are software that bypasses all of the DRM. So once again, the industry has no idea what it's doing, and only making it more difficult for paying customers. Blu-ray will probably last about 5 to 7 years. Just think of blu-ray as this decades laser disc.
 
Im guessing the amount of PC BR drives out there right now are ~90% laptops and Dell/HP machines that just come with them.
 
what I want to know is why hasn't the price for DL media dropped yet. It's still what it was 5 years ago.
 
Software runs off the hard drive anyway so there's little reason to have games come out on a single blu-ray as opposed to multiple DVDs. Long gone are the days of disk swapping on the PC. Also, burnable disks are still far too expensive for what little capacity they offer - might as well just get an external hard drive or two if you want external storage.

So long as Blu-ray video is doing fine, then I don't care. BD has no rival when it comes to quality; and they never will for a long time.
 
Makes sense, if you're going to have Blu Ray it will be for movies, not for file storage.

I do not think that it will catch on for media backup the way that DVD did, simply because other current methods of data storage are much more convenient than optical mediums. Flash drives are super cheap, rewritable, and have faster transfer speeds. They will continue to drop in price as they grow in capacity, and by the 2013 date in the article I suspect that they will either meet or exceed the space of a Blu Ray disc. Hell, I look at things like the built-in SD card slot on the new Macbook Pros and see that as a more viable future for laptops; no more optical drives, just use an SD card instead. You have a cheap medium that is easily rewritable with faster data transfer rates, and it involves less bulk and no moving parts (saving on both size and battery life).

Yeah, I'm a massive fan of Blu Ray but I don't see it catching on anywhere past the living room (and I actually have a BR/HD-DVD combo drive in my PC :)).
 
this, its not like any of us were buying DVD burners when they were $450
I remember when CD burners were $2000 for a consumer oriented model. :p
------

The price of BD burners isn't that bad. A manufacturer would only pay about $100 more than a DVD burner. There must not be much demand. I'm definitely going to pick one up when retail models hit $100.
 
I remember when CD burners were $2000 for a consumer oriented model. :p
------

The price of BD burners isn't that bad. A manufacturer would only pay about $100 more than a DVD burner. There must not be much demand. I'm definitely going to pick one up when retail models hit $100.

Yeah back when most CD players and burners were of the SCSI type. Oh how I hated configuring "plug and pray" Adaptec SCSI cards.
 
I have absolutely never watched a dvd movie on my PC, I use my tv for that stuff and that wont change with bluray. I wont bluray drive until I have an actual need for one or if its price was like $35.
 
I have absolutely never watched a dvd movie on my PC, I use my tv for that stuff and that wont change with bluray. I wont bluray drive until I have an actual need for one or if its price was like $35.

My first DVD player was a computer drive I bummed off a friend because it was broken, it couldn't read CDs (and eventually couldn't read DVDs:p). I was actually disappointed the first time I watched a DVD on TV with a conventional player, no where near as nice as on a PC monitor (some monster 20"+ CRT my friends pop picked up at Fry's for like $20, those were the days). My second DVD player was a PS2.

With BD it went a bit faster. I picked up a BD Rom for my notebook, hooked it up to a 42" HDTV and hooked the sound to her Bose once for my mother because she wanted to watch Wall-e and I had it on BD. With in a month she bought a BD Player and was already buy her favorite movies in the in between. I still haven't seen the point in buying a player since I have my notebook at home, but she was hooked faster then on DVD, mainly because of the crappy TV she had (25" SDTV, 27" SDTV and a 32" HDTV CRTs, still looked crappy).
 
Per GB media prices > Per GB HD prices

Epic fail?

Why the hell would I want a $10+ disk that holds 25GB when I can get a $60 2.5" external drive that is smaller, holds far more data, is reusable, and most importantly, doesn't support Sony?

QFTMFT

Buying a Blu-ray burner for backing up PC files is an UBER epic fail.
Buy a spare HD, hell you can buy 2 1TB drives for the cost of a Blu-ray burner and a spindle of single layer discs.
 
Per GB media prices > Per GB HD prices
I'm also going to agree with that. Look how much cheaper, faster, and convenient Hard drives are.

A 1TB hard drive is only $75. That would be 40 Blu-ray disks. A burner is $150, and the disks are $3 a piece. Not to mention how much better a hard drive is.
 
I have a Blu-ray drive in one of my computers. And that computer is connected to a 42" 1080P TV. The curious thing is that when I compare the same movie in DVD and BD, they look pretty much identical, with the exception of the Menus. :eek:

So WTF is the point? I personally would rather pay $5-$13 per movie than $20-$30. It's a no brainer!
 
Back
Top