Hard drive next to subwoofer

aye29

Weaksauce
Joined
Jun 20, 2006
Messages
76
I have a set of Logitech Z-5500 speakers in my room. When I opened the box there was a paper with a warning not to place the sub within 2 feet of any computer or the magnet in the sub would negatively effect the hard drives. Is the sub really that dangerous to hard drives? I'm planning on putting a computer about a foot away from the sub on the other side of a wooden desk.
 
The magnetism shouldn't be an issue. The vibrations caused by the sub are likely to be more problematic, if anything. I'd recommend moving the sub away if only out of paranoia.
 
Yep...bad idea. My friend thought it would be cool to build speakers into his case...he put a fairly powerful bass into the front of the case...right infront of the HD.


Needless to say...the HDs didn't survive a week :D
 
aye29 said:
I have a set of Logitech Z-5500 speakers in my room. When I opened the box there was a paper with a warning not to place the sub within 2 feet of any computer or the magnet in the sub would negatively effect the hard drives. Is the sub really that dangerous to hard drives? I'm planning on putting a computer about a foot away from the sub on the other side of a wooden desk.


yeah from what ive heard, the Z5500s have a fairly powerful sub, and if i recall i dont think its shielded (correct me if im wrong). So it wouldnt be a great idea to keep it next to the computer tower. Like the other guy said the vibrations alone is what would probly end up killing the hard drives.
 
I doubt that sub would be powerful enough to cause any damage in the short term, long term maybe. Hard drives these days are supposed to be quite a bit more resilient than the drives of yore. I do remember Digital Designs doing some test or something with one of their monster 17" woofers or something where it could screw CRTs up from like 3 feet away, but thats a highly specialized multiple-kwatt woofer and not something I bet most will ever toy with ;)
 
I have a friend who has two 12" paradigm subs in his basement. The Hometheater case sits in a converted Server rack drilled into the cement floor very solid.
The home theater case is isolated by Vibro-Pods.
Within this three drive system there have already been 4 drive failures...all mechanical. 5th one starting to fail.
Latest bios, intel chipset and ahci drivers in place. 2 WDC YS Raid edition and 2nd time 2 Seagate 7200.11's (yes firmware is updated). Complete backups being made to removable drives that stay turned off other than when backing up. (never done when stereo is on) Anyone seen anything that could cure this? My searching has found alot of solutions to isolate for hard drive noise but not damage caused to drives by vibration. SSD drives not big enough for this solution would worry vibration could cause similar problems in them due to number of solder connections.
 
When I opened the box there was a paper with a warning not to place the sub within 2 feet of any computer or the magnet in the sub would negatively effect the hard drives. Is the sub really that dangerous to hard drives?

If the paper with the warning said "Danger! Do not eat!", would you eat it? Do you ever consider eating the silica packets that are packed with hard drives, that read "do not eat"?

You did a great thing. You read the docs that came with a piece of hardware. Those docs told you not to do a specific thing.

Don't ignore the hardware documentation.
 
SSD drives not big enough for this solution would worry vibration could cause similar problems in them due to number of solder connections.

The motherboard hasn't failed, yes? It has way more solder connections than any SSD. SSDs are generally rated for 1500G acceleration or so, compared to 200 or so for 3.5" disks. See, for example, this Samsung shock test.

You might also consider trying a 2.5" disk; they're often rated for higher shock tolerance than 3.5" disks.

And, last, I'd take a look at the power supply if you can. #2 killer of disks (after heat) in my experience.
 
You could always put the media on a server in another room, and stream your content over a network. You could also just turn down the stereo. ;)
 
Back
Top