Seven Reasons to Avoid Windows 7

Terry Olaes

I Used to be the [H] News Guy
2FA
Joined
Nov 27, 2006
Messages
4,646
Wired has the companion article to their previous “7 reasons” W7 article. This time, it focuses on the seven reasons to avoid W7. Judging by some of your reactions to the earlier article, this should garner even more “love” for Wired. ;)

Windows 7, like any product, has flaws — some of them big ones. …Now let’s look at the other side of the story: The reasons you might consider skipping this upgrade altogether.
 
It's like they cut out the word "Vista" and replaced it with "7". Hell, some of those reasons apply to any OS upgrade or migration.
 
It's still Windows...? Really? That list was so piss poor. I don't think he could think of 7 bad reasons.
 
Wow... some of those reasons are really out there.

It's still Windows...... Have they ever considered I might not want a window popping open with the files on a flashdrive when I put it it. Last time I checked customization is a good thing.

My fav has to be the DRM rant. I guess the amazingly smart guys over at wired don't understand that this required to play highdef content like Blu-ray, not per MS spec, but Blu-ray spec
 
Ahhh, Wired, the mouthpiece of Apple.

What a horrible article.

Of 7 "points" we have...

"The Software isn't free"
-duh?

"Installing software takes time"
-duh?

"It doesn't automatically "do something" the first time you insert a thumb-drive"
-Is it supposed to predict whether I want to run the contents... or browse the contents... or...? I'd be scared if it "just worked".

"It's still Windows"
-Isn't that an upside? The other options are Linux and TurdOS.

"Security isn't automatically better"
-Still better then TurdOS

"Snow Leopard Is Almost Here"
-So? I can get TurdOS a month earlier... Now with many new features that have been available in Windows since XP! AWESOME!

I see one even remotely valid point.
 
Like Vista, Windows 7 includes support for digital rights management technologies that could potentially regulate how you use your media.
Can I have a side of non-critical thought with that FUD, please?
 
I was thinking the same think as Nemesis. It sounds as if they could not give a legit reason so they made up bs ones.
 
I can only give 1 good reason not to read this article - the author is a dumb ass!!
 
Wow, it's articles like these that actually make people want Windows 7. The undecided would ask, "Is this the worst of Windows 7? I'll get a copy."
 
LMAO, this is great:

"Windows XP user must do a clean install"
-You should be doing a clean install anyway.

"The upgrade is expensive"
-Not if you took advantage of the preorder for $50.

"It's still Windows"
-WTF? When you plug in a flash drive, it gives you a list of options; and that's somehow a bad thing?

"It's not automatically more secure"
-I'm not even going to touch this one. Wired clearly has no idea what they're talking about.

"It has DRM"
-To everyone sticking with XP for fear of DRM; good luck getting BD playback working smoothly.

"Snow Leopard is almost here"
-Are you serious? "64-bit addressing" is really the best "new" feature they could brag about in Snow Leopard? I don't know much about Macs, but I can only hope Apple made some more significant improvements than that.

The only thing I agree with is the conclusion: there's no killer feature in Windows 7 to make Linux and Mac users switch. And that's okay: I think MS's intention with Windows 7 is not to make users switch from Apple, but to make users stop switching to Apple, as many of them did after the Vista debacle.
 
None of those are valid reasons. I have never seen a full retail version of an OS that costs less than $100 , excluding linux.

I would be pissed if I inserted a usb thumb drive and any OS did what it "thought" it should do with that material.

" It's still Windows" - is this a valid reason?
 
That article was garbage. If they're gonna pay someone for that, at least have them do a little homework on the facts. I can't believe they bitched about thumbdrives. Microsoft specifically changed the autoplay on thumbdrives because of the conficker worm and other viruses. (http://blogs.technet.com/srd/archive/2009/04/28/autorun-changes-in-windows-7.aspx) 64bit Vista/7 is much more secure out of box than OSX, pwn2own shows that year after year.
 
And they're still harping on the "more secure out of the box" bullshit.

It's security through obscurity. MacOS is still a niche market. Thus, of COURSE virus writers are going to go after a larger target like Windows. Hitting 1% of the Windows market with crapware yields more than 5-10% of the Mac market.
 
Wow, I swear this article was written by someone who has NEVER used Windows 7. None of the reasons speak to specific issues with 7 and could be written for any other Microsoft OS. Way to go Wired. :rolleyes:
 
To put things in perspective....

It's now 2009. Windows XP has been out for 8 years: since October 2001.

If you had been running your previous OS for 8 years (since 1993) when Windows XP came out... you'd have been running Windows 3.11 and DOS.

Yes folks, it's time to upgrade if you're still running XP. Don't be scared!
 
And that's okay: I think MS's intention with Windows 7 is not to make users switch from Apple, but to make users stop switching to Apple, as many of them did after the Vista debacle.

Source?

It is not the OS that took market share away from MS but it was Apples ability to market their hardware and sell it as the next cool thing. Im sure many people out there do not even use most features of any OS. Music Player, Web Browser, and Productivity Suite. Get those working on a machine and no one really cares about the OS.
 
None of those are valid reasons. I have never seen a full retail version of an OS that costs less than $100 , excluding linux.

I would be pissed if I inserted a usb thumb drive and any OS did what it "thought" it should do with that material.

" It's still Windows" - is this a valid reason?

Even Linux can be expensive if you don't know where to look or what you're looking for.
 
The only 2 real reasons they gave (3 if you count the XP bit) is the cost and time factors. Rest seems like stuff he pulled out of his ass.
 
The only thing I agree with is the conclusion: there's no killer feature in Windows 7 to make Linux and Mac users switch. And that's okay: I think MS's intention with Windows 7 is not to make users switch from Apple, but to make users stop switching to Apple, as many of them did after the Vista debacle.

There was no significant market share gains by apple during the Vista period (apple is still at ~4% to this day.) Vista a debacle? Well everyone keeps saying that, but I found it to be a great OS, oh and it sold 50%-75% more than MS expected. But I guess you could point out any minor flaw in the OS and call it a 'debacle' if you were so inclined. If you're judging based on hatred of the OS, you should know by now the ABMers will hate any OS MS makes equally.
 
"It doesn't automatically "do something" the first time you insert a thumb-drive"
-Is it supposed to predict whether I want to run the contents... or browse the contents... or...? I'd be scared if it "just worked".


How DARE an OS ask you what you want to do with your own device. It should be able to do what ever it pleases at the time, and if that means formatting the device then so be it. What you actually want it to do should be irrelevant.
 
Wow, Windows 7 bashers are looking more and more ignorant everyday. Since the vast majority of people get Windows on new machines, his article is pointless.
 
There was no significant market share gains by apple during the Vista period (apple is still at ~4% to this day.) Vista a debacle? Well everyone keeps saying that, but I found it to be a great OS, oh and it sold 50%-75% more than MS expected. But I guess you could point out any minor flaw in the OS and call it a 'debacle' if you were so inclined. If you're judging based on hatred of the OS, you should know by now the ABMers will hate any OS MS makes equally.

I think he refers to launch day Vista. It stumbled a bit out of the door, but mostly because there were a few finished drivers for it.

Being that 7 uses the same driver as Vista for the most part, 7 launch is much smoother.

The same thing happened when 2000 launched. It was an entirely new kernel. XP was smoother than 2000 because XP could use 2000 drivers.

Second biggest debacle was the negativity from people who were either misinformed, doesn't like changes, or their hardware just couldn't handle Vista. Apple didn't help matters with their ads. At least in my opinion.

And finally there were quirks, which were fixed in the first service packs for the most part, such as network transfer speed for example.

But if you can get over all that and stop using legacy software and hardware, Vista is actually a pretty damn good operating system.
 
How DARE an OS ask you what you want to do with your own device. It should be able to do what ever it pleases at the time, and if that means formatting the device then so be it. What you actually want it to do should be irrelevant.

lol.gif
 
The only 2 real reasons they gave (3 if you count the XP bit) is the cost and time factors. Rest seems like stuff he pulled out of his ass.

Yep, it is a really lame article. They should have better standards than that.

But these two reasons remain highly valid ones.

I don't see any point wasting my time/money simply upgrading for the sake of upgrading.

Like most people, I'll get a new OS when I get a new computer. But that seems to be blasphemy in these forums.
 
Sent this email to Mr. Chen

Upgrading From Windows XP Requires a Clean Install

Clean upgrade installs are a preferred path by many for ANY OS, Mac and Linux as well. It tends to be the least problematic across all platforms.

The Upgrade Is Expensive

You forgot about the $50 dollar deal a while back and Windows is ALWAYS on sale. You simply have to look around. Plus that $120 upgrade is for 3 years so over a three year period Mac upgrades will run you about the same.

It’ll Cost You Time, Too

So no Mac upgrade has ever gone bad? Upgrading an OS, any OS ALWAYS involves time and risk. That’s life, not Windows.

It’s Still Windows

And your Mac STILL doesn’t run half the software I need. Yes, I sure am glad it’s STILL WINDOWS!

Security Isn’t Automatically Better

And neither will your Mac when you upgrade to Snow Leopard. Oh the hypocrisy!

Built-In Support for Egregious Hardware-Based DRM

Yes, that blasted DRM that prevents me from doing…. Nothing. Speaking of DRM, you know that DRM is products forces this. Ever heard of AnyDVD? Yep. Linux gets is HD content from Windows machines REMOVING the DRM it can’t handle.

Snow Leopard Is Almost Here

And I would almost care if I didn’t have to go out and buy an overpriced piece of hardware to run a $30 OS upgrade.
 
I don't think most people switched to Mac over the Vista debacle so much as Apple (to their credit) capitalized on the Ipod phenomenon. I have no beef with Apple. I will use Windows 7 and maybe Snow Leopard if I get another Mac, but I haven't seen any good reason to get another Mac lately, plus most of the apps I use are Windows based anyway.

This article was a stretch at best. I'm not sure how an editor let this be published at all.
 
To put things in perspective....

It's now 2009. Windows XP has been out for 8 years: since October 2001.

If you had been running your previous OS for 8 years (since 1993) when Windows XP came out... you'd have been running Windows 3.11 and DOS.

Yes folks, it's time to upgrade if you're still running XP. Don't be scared!

When the new OS's do something the old ones dont, then its time to upgrade.
I run Win7 at home because I wanted 64bit goodness, but we still use nothing but XP and server 2003 @ work and they work great.
 
If you’re currently using Windows Vista, the upgrade to Windows 7 is a no-brainer.

Wait, what? Why would Vista be a no-brainer but XP not be?

Was this article even meant to be taken seriously?
 
alot of comments on their site are upset that this is ad.

they talk about costs of the o/s which do suck, but then suggest to wait for leapoard that costs money + new pc lol which is easily 1k$ plus. retarded.

honest truth:
its easier to use... its slick.. best best thing: network performance. i can transfer a file from xp to windows 7 10gb in the time it takes me to copy 1gb from xp to xp or even lol the same computer xp's hard drive to another hard drive in the pc. so its a major network file transfer boost.

bad things: bsod's on some machines during install, requires fresh install, still NTFS and still vista 2.0... it was not the groundbreaking longhorn we read years ago on hardocp... its a mix bag o/s

-its neat, nice and not ground breaking
 
lol i forgot in the other article you can upgrade to over 200gb ram unlike that pesky x64 of other operating systems only allowing 128 or 192... yeah BECAUSE WE ARE ALL DOING THIS WITH END USER MACHINES.

more like 8-32gb lol
 
Back
Top