Diskeeper to Launch File System Driver That Stops Fragmentation

Terry Olaes

I Used to be the [H] News Guy
2FA
Joined
Nov 27, 2006
Messages
4,646
PCMagazine has an article about Diskeeper’s upcoming file system driver that is supposed to eliminate most file fragmentation before it occurs. There are details such as what OS and file systems are supported, though pricing and release date was not available. If this isn’t more vaporware, it would be a very nice thing to have.

But the filter driver is designed to weed out about 75 percent of fragmentation before it ever occurs, by intercepting the data before it is written to the file system, and organizing it appropriately. "It will be a green technology, in the sense that it will minimize the amount of [disk] activity in terms of defrag operations... including use of the drive, power, and wear and tear," Materie said.
 
Wouldn't this put themselves out of business?................................................................................................................
 
The file systems currently used need to be altered at the lowest levels to truly reduce fragmentation. A new system of organization would need to be derived based not only on file size but type. A smart system that understands that .log files tend to get bigger over time and other files such as .dll or .mp3 tend to remain static.

The problem of this comes from the fact that file extensions are not locked, I have seen many different programs use .log or .txt when they should really be .ini, the lack of standardization is something that would need to be tackled first.
 
The file systems currently used need to be altered at the lowest levels to truly reduce fragmentation. A new system of organization would need to be derived based not only on file size but type. A smart system that understands that .log files tend to get bigger over time and other files such as .dll or .mp3 tend to remain static.

The problem of this comes from the fact that file extensions are not locked, I have seen many different programs use .log or .txt when they should really be .ini, the lack of standardization is something that would need to be tackled first.

The first step is to stop using file name extnsions to indicate file type.
 
If we stop with file extension naming, wouldn't this have to be done by the OS itself and not some third party tool? How would we than tell system files from a song? I'll it would seem we would see is just blank white files.
 
The first step is to stop using file name extensions to indicate file type.

I see no logic in this idea. Would you care to expand on this statement?


Ideally I would say put something in the file header that says something to the effect of, "the size of this file is static", "the size of this file is dynamic".
 
This sounds like a bloated add-on driver that's just going to fuck your disk performance. Nothing 'green' increases performance. I'm happy with NTFS + nightly defrags thanks to the Vista/7 scheduled defragmentation.
 
This sounds like a bloated add-on driver that's just going to fuck your disk performance. Nothing 'green' increases performance. I'm happy with NTFS + nightly defrags thanks to the Vista/7 scheduled defragmentation.

+1

I have auslogics defrag set to work every night on all disks. The fact that I do this means less disk use overall, because most of it is defragged anyways. By the time the next defrag happens, everything is mostly in order so the system doesn't have to work hard at all.
 
Erm. Has people forgotten that Diskeeper is a Scientology outfit?
 
This sounds like a bloated add-on driver that's just going to fuck your disk performance. Nothing 'green' increases performance. I'm happy with NTFS + nightly defrags thanks to the Vista/7 scheduled defragmentation.

This.

There is no longer a need for a third party de-fregger (and hasn't been since Vista).


Erm. Has people forgotten that Diskeeper is a Scientology outfit?

Yea, I will never use their products.
 
I see no logic in this idea. Would you care to expand on this statement?

Most OSes (basically all of them that aren't Windows) determine the file type based on its contents. File extensions in Linux, etc.. don't actually mean anything.

Ideally I would say put something in the file header that says something to the effect of, "the size of this file is static", "the size of this file is dynamic".

That is definitely possible with current file systems (most modern ones allow for metadata), but how much space do you leave after it? Depending on the system, log files can grow as fast as 1 MB a second or 1 MB a year. The real problem with Windows fragmentation isn't growing files, it is that the page file is on the filesystem instead of its own isolated partition. If Microsoft made a fixed size page file, that alone with greatly reduce fragmentation if not nearly eliminate it for most people.
 
lul? what?

Germany banned Win2K due to the inclusion of a Diskeeper utility until Microsoft provided the option for the utility to be removed. Unfortunately, Win2003 and XP also include the defragment tool based on Diskeeper.

The CEO of Executive Software is an outspoken Scientologist.

Employees had been faced with attempted indoctrinations under the threat of being fired.

http://www.lermanet.com/cisar/survey/bm.htm
http://www.wired.com/techbiz/media/news/2000/03/35054
http://yro.slashdot.org/article.pl?sid=08/12/20/2239255
http://forums.randi.org/showthread.php?t=86231
http://digg.com/tech_news/Diskeeper_Accused_of_Scientology_Indoctrination
 
Pardon me while I laugh.

Diskkeeper's current "defragmenter" is as much of a farce as it was almost a decade ago when they got it swindled into win2k. It makes McAfecces and Norton Internet Instability look like fast stable high quality products.
 
The real problem with Windows fragmentation isn't growing files, it is that the page file is on the filesystem instead of its own isolated partition. If Microsoft made a fixed size page file, that alone with greatly reduce fragmentation if not nearly eliminate it for most people.

I setup a 2gb RamDisk on my quadcore rig with the intent of putting the pagefile on the ramdisk. I set the drive and pagefile size up in windows and one would of figured it would work faster then being on a hard drive. It did not work all that well, *I encountered quite a bit of system hitching and BSOD's in both XP64 and Vista64*.

What I would like to see would likely require a damn near rewrite of most of Windows but can we please get an option to truly turn off pagefile and purely use ram for this task? What good is my 8gb of ram if I can't get my system to use more then 2/3 of it running everything I normally do.

*I tested the hell out of my ram, no errors after +48hr of memcheck etc...
 
Tried Diskeeper, it was rubbish. I much prefer PerfectDisk.

Agreed, on the diskeeper part anyway.

I tried it last year, and it kept corrupting my files, specifically MAME torrents. I'd have to redownload gigabytes of data again due to that "defrag" program. As soon as I uninstalled it, bingo, no more worries.

As if I'd trust a disk system driver from them.

Shouldn't matter soon anyway with ssd coming down in price, all I'll continue using my mechnical drives for are backups, and fragmentation on those is absolutly nothing to really care about as it's just a backup drive.
 
Hmm...I didn't have any problems with Diskeeper the one time I tried it.

And I don't make purchasing decision based on the religious affiliations of the company executives. That's like boycotting McDonald's because they support gay marriage, IMO.

Having said that, I don't need any defragger anymore, as the automatic ones in Vista and 7 work just fine.
 
And I don't make purchasing decision based on the religious affiliations of the company executives. That's like boycotting McDonald's because they support gay marriage, IMO.

Nice thing about America is that I can not buy what I don't want, from companies I don't want it from, for whatever reason I feel like.
 
Nice thing about America is that I can not buy what I don't want, from companies I don't want it from, for whatever reason I feel like.

And another nice thing is that I can not make purchasing decision the same way you do.

Sorry if I offended you? :confused: I didn't say you were wrong for not wanting to buy Diskeepr, just that I personally don't participate in boycotts like that.
 
And I don't make purchasing decision based on the religious affiliations of the company executives. That's like boycotting McDonald's because they support gay marriage, IMO.

What if McD's started firing people who don't support gay marriage just because they're don't support gay marriage?

That's basically what happened... Would be absolutely none of McD's business whether you support it or not, and wouldn't affect the employee's ability to flip a burger...
 
There is no longer a need for a third party de-fregger (and hasn't been since Vista).

Except for the fact that MS's defragmentation program is total crap.

I have seen both XP and Vista machines where the built in defrag program basically chokes and can't figure out what to do. Even after running it 5-6 times it would defrag a little and then decide it was done.

This generally happens on systems where the files are horribly fragmented.

And I also have never been impressed with the lack of full defragmentation that the MS one offers.

Jkdefrag (freeware) on the other hand doesn't generally have any issues with massively fragmented drives. If it is too bad for it to figure it out some stuff in one step, it will redo that step a second time. It also seems to organize the files better as well.

And it actually has a good GUI that you can actually tell what it is doing.
 
I setup a 2gb RamDisk on my quadcore rig with the intent of putting the pagefile on the ramdisk. I set the drive and pagefile size up in windows and one would of figured it would work faster then being on a hard drive. It did not work all that well, *I encountered quite a bit of system hitching and BSOD's in both XP64 and Vista64*.

What I would like to see would likely require a damn near rewrite of most of Windows but can we please get an option to truly turn off pagefile and purely use ram for this task? What good is my 8gb of ram if I can't get my system to use more then 2/3 of it running everything I normally do.

*I tested the hell out of my ram, no errors after +48hr of memcheck etc...

Well of course that wouldn't work. You tried forcing windows to use real ram to hold fake ram. You basically turned off the page file entirely, which isn't a good idea. Microsoft should steal a page from other OSes and dedicate a partition to the page file. You can force windows to use another partition if you really want to, but its kind of a pain.
 
I can schedule a weekly defrag job in less time than it'll take to download and install this driver.

Product fail.
 
Well of course that wouldn't work. You tried forcing windows to use real ram to hold fake ram. You basically turned off the page file entirely, which isn't a good idea. Microsoft should steal a page from other OSes and dedicate a partition to the page file. You can force windows to use another partition if you really want to, but its kind of a pain.

Yes but you miss the point, why does windows need to page file data when I have 8gb( well 6gb of ram with 2gb ram disc setup) and even then it still had 1-2gb free.

We need a way to turn off page file and force windows to use only ram else migrating to SSD is just asking for problems much sooner then would be encountered on HDD.

Ultimately I would like to see Windows do a self imposed steady state mode on the hard drive where data is not changed unless it needs to be via user directed action.
 
Yes but you miss the point, why does windows need to page file data when I have 8gb( well 6gb of ram with 2gb ram disc setup) and even then it still had 1-2gb free.

We need a way to turn off page file and force windows to use only ram else migrating to SSD is just asking for problems much sooner then would be encountered on HDD.

Ultimately I would like to see Windows do a self imposed steady state mode on the hard drive where data is not changed unless it needs to be via user directed action.

You *can* turn off the page file (iirc), it is just a bad idea. Windows Vista and 7 aggressively use RAM (as it should - free RAM is wasted RAM). With 8 GB of RAM you can probably get away without a page file, but not by locating the page file on a RAM disk. There are very good reasons that pretty much every OS typically recommends a page file 1.5x the size of physical RAM ;)
 
Hmm...I didn't have any problems with Diskeeper the one time I tried it.

And I don't make purchasing decision based on the religious affiliations of the company executives. That's like boycotting McDonald's because they support gay marriage, IMO.

Having said that, I don't need any defragger anymore, as the automatic ones in Vista and 7 work just fine.

Yea I don't get it either.. why in the world should someone else's beliefs matter to your buying decision?
 
It's impossible to have a non-fragmenting file system, someday people will come to understand this. Yes it is possible to have something in between the actual storage device and the OS that can keep a closer eye on things and potentially improve the ability to store things without more serious fragmentation, but as for stopping it completely, it's impossible.

I think this is going to be a big gimmick to attract business to a company that's basically in trouble at this point. With Windows 7 about to be released, Diskeeper is scared shitless - and so should Raxco and other companies - because the OS does such a wonderful job of housecleaning and self-tuning that third party defragmentation software is unnecessary from this point on.

Sure, you can spend money if you want, pirate it if makes you feel good getting something over on "The Man," or just hoping to have a warm tingly feeling inside.

Windows 7 (and Vista before it to some degree) herald in a new age where tweaking and mucking around with things is unnecessary anymore and can actually have detrimental effects on the overall performance of the OS.

The mantra is and shall be Leave it alone forever more... it can take care of itself.
 
Yea I don't get it either.. why in the world should someone else's beliefs matter to your buying decision?

Depends on the actual RL effects of their beliefs. If a companies ideals/beliefs are personal and they still conform to societies moral standards and laws, then buying from them is not a big deal and shouldn't influence whether or not we use their services.
 
People should just stay 50 yards away from all matters related to beliefs at all times, as the two rarely mingle well :D
 
This place has the most off-topic bunch I think I've ever encountered, especially in the News forum - post something, and sure enough within a few responses someone will find a tangent and the whole lot of 'em just hops on board for someplace they'll never return from. ;)
 
Yes but you miss the point, why does windows need to page file data when I have 8gb( well 6gb of ram with 2gb ram disc setup) and even then it still had 1-2gb free.

We need a way to turn off page file and force windows to use only ram else migrating to SSD is just asking for problems much sooner then would be encountered on HDD.
Seriously, that'd be going way off-topic. A very brief explanation for why the Page File is still needed is this: Rogue app allocates a TON more RAM than it actually needs. RAM it won't use. Would you rather that RAM it's not using be sitting in virtual memory or in your actual RAM?


Windows 7 (and Vista before it to some degree) herald in a new age where tweaking and mucking around with things is unnecessary anymore and can actually have detrimental effects on the overall performance of the OS.
Come to think of it, there's a ton of companies out there that are probably worried right now. A ton of companies that offer tweaking and "performance" tools.

You're right: they're in trouble. About the only thing Win7 needs is clearing caches on occasion (CCleaner) and Malware Scans (MBytes). Other than that, good riddance to the other tools.

This place has the most off-topic bunch I think I've ever encountered, especially in the News forum - post something, and sure enough within a few responses someone will find a tangent and the whole lot of 'em just hops on board for someplace they'll never return from. ;)
I think we've all come to accept that... As long as it doesn't resort to personal attacks it seems to be OK with the moderators and those participating.
 
Back
Top