Chevy Volt Gets 230 mpg City?

Not what I was trying to say at all. I never made the claim $32,500 was a reasonable price for the car, and I certainly didn't insinuate you pay $32,500 up front. I said the cost was not $40,000. I didn't insinuate it was for the "average" consumer. My point was, without any twisting or extrapolating or spinning, the car will not have a total cost of $40,000 to the buyer. That's the truth, and it's annoying that people keep going on about how the car will cost them $40,000 when it won't.

Henderson conceded the cost of building a Volt will be expensive, about $40,000 per vehicle. But he said the vehicle will qualify for a $7,500 tax credit, which will reduce the vehicle cost by that amount for consumers.

linky


$40,000 is the cost to GM, the invoice number. The article even says they may have to subsidize the car, i.e. take a loss. If they don't subsidize the cost will be HIGHER than 40,000$. Tax credits run out after so many have been sold. At best, they will last 6 months and then we are back at the 40K invoice price point without subsidizes. There is no extrapolation or spinning, the truth is you are going to be looking at a very real 40K price point within 6 months of the cars release.

TBH I'm not even sure where you got 7500$ tax credit as no vehicles have ever gotten that big of a tax credit.
 
Agreed, the math is certainly fuzzy, but I'm sure we'll get some better numbers by the time it's released to the public.
Yes, the truth will be out by the end of next year, and I have a feeling Volt owners will be disappointed that they're not getting 230 mpg.

It's kind of like hybrid owners (not necessarily Prius) who drive 15 kmi./yr. and think that their new hybrid will get double the mileage they were getting compared to their previous car, only to find out mpg is not much better. They find out the hard way hybrids don't do diddly squat on highway driving.

In the Volt situation, unless grandma is driving it, lead foot will get a lot less than 40 mi. before the gas engine takes over. And when it does, the gas engine will get a lot less than 50 mpg than what was quoted in the CNN article.

Speaking of CNN articles, check out my next post.
 
Volt vs. Prius: What's the better deal?

CNN said:
It'll take higher gas prices, or a big subsidy from GM, for the new plug-in Volt to be cheaper to drive than the Toyota. But that doesn't mean it won't find buyers.

...

The battery needs about 8 kilowatts hours to recharge, and most consumers would pay about 11 cents a kilowatt hour, or 88 cents. During the course of year, that means a typical Volt owners' electrical bill would increase by $321.

In contrast, the hybrid Prius' electric motor is charged from the excess energy thrown off by the gasoline engine, as well as the energy generated from braking the vehicle.

The electric motor powers the car at low speeds. The gas engine generally takes over on the highway and during fast acceleration or uphill driving. That allows it to get an average of 50 miles to the gallon.

Driving a typical 14,000 miles a year, or 38 miles a day, the Prius would use about 280 gallons of gasoline.

With gas at its current price of about $2.65 a gallon, that would come to about $742 a year in gas, or $421 more than the Volt owners would pay if they can stick with electricity.

Even if gas goes back to the record high of $4.11 and stays there, gassing up a Prius would cost about $1,150 a year, giving the Volt an $830 a year cost savings.

But a Prius costs $25,428, on average, according to sales data from Edmunds.com, while GM will probably have to spend $40,000 or more to build each Volt.

While Volt buyers will get a $7,500 tax credit that reduces the still undisclosed purchase price by that amount, the fact is that GM will have to subsidize much of the remaining $7,000 difference in cost to make it competitive with the Prius.

At current gas prices, the $421 a year savings over a period of six years that a new car is typically owned, would mean that a Volt would only be cost competitive with a Prius if was about $34,500 before the tax credit.

That means GM would have to take about a $5,500 loss on each Volt if it is to be strictly competitive.

...
 
Yes, the truth will be out by the end of next year, and I have a feeling Volt owners will be disappointed that they're not getting 230 mpg.

It's kind of like hybrid owners (not necessarily Prius) who drive 15 kmi./yr. and think that their new hybrid will get double the mileage they were getting compared to their previous car, only to find out mpg is not much better. They find out the hard way hybrids don't do diddly squat on highway driving.

Hybrids doing squat on the highway is a myth:
http://www.edmunds.com/advice/fueleconomy/articles/153866/article.html

Fuel economy test at Edmunds. The Prius got nearly the same mpg in three tests, backroad, highway and city. It got between 47mpg and 48mpg on all the tests. Which btw is close to double what a typical sedan gets.

And it isn't just the new Prius:
http://www.popularmechanics.com/automotive/new_cars/4284188.html?page=2
Here the Old Prius scores 44.8 highway/44.7 city.

Now in the Volt case we basically have a whole lot EV miles counted in the MPG. A soon a someone drives one without a recharge, and sees it getting REAL mpg in the 40's or less, you can bet squawking will ensue. I am curious what ranger extender MPG is...
 
Hybrids doing squat on the highway is a myth:
http://www.edmunds.com/advice/fueleconomy/articles/153866/article.html

Fuel economy test at Edmunds. The Prius got nearly the same mpg in three tests, backroad, highway and city. It got between 47mpg and 48mpg on all the tests. Which btw is close to double what a typical sedan gets.

And it isn't just the new Prius:
http://www.popularmechanics.com/automotive/new_cars/4284188.html?page=2
Here the Old Prius scores 44.8 highway/44.7 city.

Now in the Volt case we basically have a whole lot EV miles counted in the MPG. A soon a someone drives one without a recharge, and sees it getting REAL mpg in the 40's or less, you can bet squawking will ensue. I am curious what ranger extender MPG is...

Interesting, but the Honda Insight suffered mightily on the highway compared to city, so I wonder what Toyota w/ the Prius to make its mileage so good on the highway.

But in any case, from what I've read over the past couple years, many hybrid owners are frustrated that they're not getting the EPA advertised mileage for their expensive new car.
 
linky


$40,000 is the cost to GM, the invoice number. The article even says they may have to subsidize the car, i.e. take a loss. If they don't subsidize the cost will be HIGHER than 40,000$. Tax credits run out after so many have been sold. At best, they will last 6 months and then we are back at the 40K invoice price point without subsidizes. There is no extrapolation or spinning, the truth is you are going to be looking at a very real 40K price point within 6 months of the cars release.

TBH I'm not even sure where you got 7500$ tax credit as no vehicles have ever gotten that big of a tax credit.

A) The tax credit has been all over the news, in CNN's article as well as others, and as stated earlier was part of the stimulus bill and is $7500.
B) I never stated the manufacturing cost was lower than $40K.

I disagree with your analysis. The price will remain subsidized until the manufacturing costs go down. At which point the losses will decrease. That's an opinion, however. And we're both entitled to that.
 
A) The tax credit has been all over the news, in CNN's article as well as others, and as stated earlier was part of the stimulus bill and is $7500.
B) I never stated the manufacturing cost was lower than $40K.

I disagree with your analysis. The price will remain subsidized until the manufacturing costs go down. At which point the losses will decrease. That's an opinion, however. And we're both entitled to that.

The price point of the car has to go down to 30K when the consumer buys it even be the same life cycle cost as alternative options. To sell at 30K, you'll need a MSRP of 37.5K which gives an invoice cost of around 34-35K putting GM on the hook for over 5K loss for every vehicle. Good thing GM has lots of financial strength to take those losses. :rolleyes:
 
Interesting, but the Honda Insight suffered mightily on the highway compared to city, so I wonder what Toyota w/ the Prius to make its mileage so good on the highway.

But in any case, from what I've read over the past couple years, many hybrid owners are frustrated that they're not getting the EPA advertised mileage for their expensive new car.

Ratings are alwways a problem. Espeically the old EPA ones, I think it was two years ago the updated their measurements and they are fairly close now. So if you see the old Prius numbers it was 55mpg combined, after revision it came down to 46mpg combined. Which is very close to what popular mechanics.

So yes if they got the old window sticker that said they would get 55mpg I could see some dissapointment with getting 44mpg. But these days the ratings are a lot closer, well until this silliness it was, getting 44mpg when the rating is 46 shouldn't be too upsetting.

Personally I prefer Consumer Reports for MPG testing. They actually drive the cars instead of putting them on a treadmill. FWIW The combined number that CR got for the Prius was 44mpg.

So EPA old 55, EPA new 46 and CR 44.
 
The price point of the car has to go down to 30K when the consumer buys it even be the same life cycle cost as alternative options. To sell at 30K, you'll need a MSRP of 37.5K which gives an invoice cost of around 34-35K putting GM on the hook for over 5K loss for every vehicle. Good thing GM has lots of financial strength to take those losses. :rolleyes:

When you have the U.S. Gov't backing you, anything is possible! :D
 
Doesn't anybody get it, launching the Volt is a very bad idea. It is a lose, lose proposition. GM cannot make any money selling it. Taxpayers will subsidize it to hell on both ends. GM takes a loss on every car, Taxpayers take a hit cause we freakin own GM and we will have to recapitalise it yet again with another $70 billion. We provide a taxcredit for it, so less taxes here means more taxes for everybody somewhere else. This whole lose money initially idea is BS and doesn't work, especially if you dont' have a plan on how to make money from it. Even with economies of scale, there is no way GM will be able to bring the cost down to the level of the Prius or the Leaf. Sony is still up to their eyeballs in losses from the PS3 doing exactly the same thing and they had a good plan to turn things around(only that it still isn't working). GM needs to come up with a good product that will sell. Ford is already turning things round with the Escape and Focus leading the way. At some point taxpayers are going to have to tell GM enough, we aren't going to pay your way anymore.
 
Doesn't anybody get it, launching the Volt is a very bad idea. It is a lose, lose proposition. GM cannot make any money selling it. Taxpayers will subsidize it to hell on both ends. GM takes a loss on every car, Taxpayers take a hit cause we freakin own GM and we will have to recapitalise it yet again with another $70 billion. We provide a taxcredit for it, so less taxes here means more taxes for everybody somewhere else. This whole lose money initially idea is BS and doesn't work, especially if you dont' have a plan on how to make money from it. Even with economies of scale, there is no way GM will be able to bring the cost down to the level of the Prius or the Leaf. Sony is still up to their eyeballs in losses from the PS3 doing exactly the same thing and they had a good plan to turn things around(only that it still isn't working). GM needs to come up with a good product that will sell. Ford is already turning things round with the Escape and Focus leading the way. At some point taxpayers are going to have to tell GM enough, we aren't going to pay your way anymore.

You make it sound like Volt is all they have.
 
Doesn't anybody get it, launching the Volt is a very bad idea. It is a lose, lose proposition. GM cannot make any money selling it. Taxpayers will subsidize it to hell on both ends. GM takes a loss on every car, Taxpayers take a hit cause we freakin own GM and we will have to recapitalise it yet again with another $70 billion. We provide a taxcredit for it, so less taxes here means more taxes for everybody somewhere else. This whole lose money initially idea is BS and doesn't work, especially if you dont' have a plan on how to make money from it. Even with economies of scale, there is no way GM will be able to bring the cost down to the level of the Prius or the Leaf. Sony is still up to their eyeballs in losses from the PS3 doing exactly the same thing and they had a good plan to turn things around(only that it still isn't working). GM needs to come up with a good product that will sell. Ford is already turning things round with the Escape and Focus leading the way. At some point taxpayers are going to have to tell GM enough, we aren't going to pay your way anymore.

Look, we are going to loose money on every unit sold but we'll make it up in volume.;)
 
SSDs have a major preformance benefit. The volt has no preformance benefits. The life cycle cost is not less, the cargo capacity is not better, the preformance ("racing preformance"). The only "advantage" to this is you get to be "that eco prick".

What do you mean the Volt has no benefits? Show me another mass produced hybrid or electric with better performance (acceleration/handling). Tesla is all I can think of, but it's over $100,000 and near impossible to get. Better yet, show me another mass produced car that can run totally off electricity OR totally off gas. There are CLEAR benefits to plug-in hybrid tech, but it will take time for the prices to drop.

Stop whining because you can't afford one. You're just like the people who whine because they can't afford SSDs.
 
i think regardless of the vehicles efficiency or real impact on fossil fuel emissions, we need to buy cars like this and the prius. We need to show auto makers that there is a profitable market to design and sell more fuel efficient hybrid/electric vehicles.
 
What do you mean the Volt has no benefits? Show me another mass produced hybrid or electric with better performance (acceleration/handling). Tesla is all I can think of, but it's over $100,000 and near impossible to get. Better yet, show me another mass produced car that can run totally off electricity OR totally off gas. There are CLEAR benefits to plug-in hybrid tech, but it will take time for the prices to drop.

Stop whining because you can't afford one. You're just like the people who whine because they can't afford SSDs.

You're funny. I could instead buy any number of preformance cars like a 370Z and have a lower life cycle cost. BTW, I can more than afford one, however I'm not stupid enough to spend 40K on something that is suppose to help me "save money" on gas.
 
I don't know if you have checked lately, but GM is exactly successful in their other prodcut lines.

Well then give the Volt a chance. You can't say that they're not trying.

They tried the Volt a decade ago and it got buried under red tape. People complained that plug-in electric cars would be cheaper now if they had started on it 10 years ago. They have to start sometimes.

(whats the acronym for plug-in electric cars? I doubt if PIE is correct :-P)
 
What do you mean the Volt has no benefits? Show me another mass produced hybrid or electric with better performance (acceleration/handling). Tesla is all I can think of, but it's over $100,000 and near impossible to get. Better yet, show me another mass produced car that can run totally off electricity OR totally off gas. There are CLEAR benefits to plug-in hybrid tech, but it will take time for the prices to drop.

Stop whining because you can't afford one. You're just like the people who whine because they can't afford SSDs.

It may be the best plug in EV but it still doesn't make good business sense to do this. GM is not a charity but it sure is looking like a charity case. You have to at least break even on the product to fund further R&D.

You have to produce a product people want, at a cost they can afford and still turn a profit. These are the basics of running a business. You can't afford to find another way to lose money as the other GM products lines are already doing.
 
Well then give the Volt a chance. You can't say that they're not trying.

They tried the Volt a decade ago and it got buried under red tape. People complained that plug-in electric cars would be cheaper now if they had started on it 10 years ago. They have to start sometimes.

(whats the acronym for plug-in electric cars? I doubt if PIE is correct :-P)

Trying is not good enough, this is our money we are talking about. We are all share holders in Government Motors. They don't have a realistic plan to monetize this product, it should be an automatic no go on this. Personally I don't think the Volt is ready to market, they need to bring costs down further.

Not true that the Volt got buried 10 years ago. It was not possible to build a usable vehicle then. The battery technology was not there to even manufacture a usable battery that could run the car for 40 miles. Battery R&D has advanced far enough now that it is even feasible(although $10,000 for batteries for each car still sounds too high)
 
You're funny. I could instead buy any number of preformance cars like a 370Z and have a lower life cycle cost. BTW, I can more than afford one, however I'm not stupid enough to spend 40K on something that is suppose to help me "save money" on gas.

You're still failing to understand that the Volt isn't for people simply looking to save money. If you don't understand the desire for the Volt, then you're obviously not the demographic they're targeting. A lot of people looking for alternate energy vehicles at this point aren't in it simply to save gas money. If you were ONLY looking to save money, why even buy a Prius? You would have a much lower life cycle cost if you bought a Nissan Versa for $10,000.
 
It may be the best plug in EV but it still doesn't make good business sense to do this. GM is not a charity but it sure is looking like a charity case. You have to at least break even on the product to fund further R&D.

You have to produce a product people want, at a cost they can afford and still turn a profit. These are the basics of running a business. You can't afford to find another way to lose money as the other GM products lines are already doing.

It certainly isn't going to help GM in the short term, but I believe the Volt, and more so the technology behind the Volt, is something GM NEEDS to invest in NOW if they plan on being around in 20 years.
 
Ratings are alwways a problem. Espeically the old EPA ones, I think it was two years ago the updated their measurements and they are fairly close now. So if you see the old Prius numbers it was 55mpg combined, after revision it came down to 46mpg combined. Which is very close to what popular mechanics.

So yes if they got the old window sticker that said they would get 55mpg I could see some dissapointment with getting 44mpg. But these days the ratings are a lot closer, well until this silliness it was, getting 44mpg when the rating is 46 shouldn't be too upsetting.

Personally I prefer Consumer Reports for MPG testing. They actually drive the cars instead of putting them on a treadmill. FWIW The combined number that CR got for the Prius was 44mpg.

So EPA old 55, EPA new 46 and CR 44.
OK, so it has changed from a couple years ago, so that's good. There's obviously a big diff. bet. 55 and 46. But the EPA still slightly overestimates as CR observed.

You've probably heard of "hypermilers" whose sole purpose in life seems to be able to beat the EPA's mileage w/ their hybrids. Whatever floats their (hybrid) boats!

You make it sound like Volt is all they have.
Unfortunately, between the Volt and Corvette ZR-1, that is all GM has. And neither is or will be a mass volume seller. :(

Look, we are going to loose money on every unit sold but we'll make it up in volume.;)
I had to LOL. :D

Well then give the Volt a chance. You can't say that they're not trying.

They tried the Volt a decade ago and it got buried under red tape. People complained that plug-in electric cars would be cheaper now if they had started on it 10 years ago. They have to start sometimes.

(whats the acronym for plug-in electric cars? I doubt if PIE is correct :-P)
Marketing anything as "PIE" to Americans will, at minimum, double sales. :eek:
 
Trying is not good enough, this is our money we are talking about. We are all share holders in Government Motors. They don't have a realistic plan to monetize this product, it should be an automatic no go on this. Personally I don't think the Volt is ready to market, they need to bring costs down further.

Not true that the Volt got buried 10 years ago. It was not possible to build a usable vehicle then. The battery technology was not there to even manufacture a usable battery that could run the car for 40 miles. Battery R&D has advanced far enough now that it is even feasible(although $10,000 for batteries for each car still sounds too high)

I'm pretty sure that GM developed the NiMH battery and sold it to Chevron for a profit, and in turn, Chevron lawyers issued a cease and desist to Toyota to stop making electric cars with NiMH batteries. Toyota settled and was allowed to make them as long as they're hybrids, which suspiciously sounded like the Big Oil still wanted to sell oil to people who drove cars.

That's red tape if I've ever heard one.

It was a pretty big scandal if I remember with people accusing GM of being in the Big Oil's pockets.
 
You could talk me out of the guy that tweaked the Hummers, with the right argument (I don't know what that'd be, considering it's air-tight...)

But you WON'T talk me out of the fact of the 45MPG truck. I witnessed that one first hand.

This thread is silly long at this point so someone already covered this and the OP or anyone else with these crazy ideas were already run off. But I still feel a need to comment.

I grew up with a dad who was a mechanic his whole life. He always liked to tell this story of how a guy that came to his garage for service had bought a new Pontiac boat with a V8. This would have been in the late 60's or 70's.

Anyway the story goes this car some how got sold with a experimental carburetor that got him 60 miles to the gallon. GM offered this guy all kinds of money to get this it back including deals for a new car every 2 years for the next 10 years and crap like that. But the guy refused and in 4 years something happened to the the carb and no parts could be bought to service it so he had to put a standard carb on it.

Now I grew up believing this story as it came from my father.

Then I got in to working on modern 4 cylinders that he hates and ended up with a job at a performance automotive shop with a bunch of great guys that could do far more then just turn a wrench and read a wiring diagram. As I learned more about turbos and how crucial air to fuel ratios are it became clear that this story was BS.

A gasoline powered 400 cubic inch small block will intake X amount of air requiring X amount of fuel and nothing is going to change that.

With an old carburetor setup on a small block V8 the actual mixing of the air and fuel leaves room for improvement. Along comes fuel injection and it's ability to get a better mix giving us better fuel mileage since less unburnt fuel will be expelled in the exhaust. Add the rest of the electronic sensors we have on cars today and you reach about the best fuel efficiency you can expect from a small block V8.

You are left needing to come up with other ideas such as shutting down fuel and spark to 4 of the 8 cylinders when the power isn't needs as a means to get better fuel mileage.
 
On the whole CHINA owns AMERICA thing, a little reality check please:

National Debt ~ $14.8 TRILLION

Amount owed to China ~ $1.1 TRILLION

Total owed to foreign nations ~ $3 TRILLION

Amount owed to AMERICANS..... ~ $11.8 TRILLION

So, no, they won't be borrowing from China, they will be borrowing from the....

.... FILTHY RICH (tm)

... You know, the people Bush gave $5 TRILLION in tax cuts to, who proceeded to loan it back to the Treasury because the tax cuts left us with huge deficits for 8 years.
 
I would never drive this, or a prius.

I would just go for a motorcycle/motard, both prolly have better gas mileage in all situations also.
 
OK, so it has changed from a couple years ago, so that's good. There's obviously a big diff. bet. 55 and 46. But the EPA still slightly overestimates as CR observed.

The way the EPA tests cars is flawed, I'm surprised that no one has gone into any detail about it (but confess to not reading the whole thread)

The EPA bases MPG on tailpipe emissions, NOT on the fuel actually consumed by a car running a drive cycle.

Insane isn't? but that is why the hybrids get such high numbers, they game the system.

Toyota had a press release that pretty much states this explaining please don't blame them for the inflated numbers but how the EPA tests cars.
 
On the whole CHINA owns AMERICA thing, a little reality check please:

National Debt ~ $14.8 TRILLION

Amount owed to China ~ $1.1 TRILLION

Total owed to foreign nations ~ $3 TRILLION

Amount owed to AMERICANS..... ~ $11.8 TRILLION

So, no, they won't be borrowing from China, they will be borrowing from the....

.... FILTHY RICH (tm)

... You know, the people Bush gave $5 TRILLION in tax cuts to, who proceeded to loan it back to the Treasury because the tax cuts left us with huge deficits for 8 years.

Nothing like injecting BDS (Bush Derangment Syndrome) in a subject when none was required sport.

Off your meds this morning?
 
I would never drive this, or a prius.

I would just go for a motorcycle/motard, both prolly have better gas mileage in all situations also.

Not a bad idea, Sir, just make sure to put studded tires on and lower the pressure when there's 6 inches of snow on the ground.

:rolleyes:
 
That is why I have my 2004 gtp =P

I am sure my avg mpg will still be higher than a prius over the year, at a fraction of the cost.
 
The way the EPA tests cars is flawed, I'm surprised that no one has gone into any detail about it (but confess to not reading the whole thread)

The EPA bases MPG on tailpipe emissions, NOT on the fuel actually consumed by a car running a drive cycle.

Insane isn't? but that is why the hybrids get such high numbers, they game the system.

Toyota had a press release that pretty much states this explaining please don't blame them for the inflated numbers but how the EPA tests cars.

Yeah, I read somewhere how the EPA way is flawed, but didn't they recalculate their mpg estimates for vehicles a few years ago? Basically, one should take what the EPA says with a grain of salt. It's far more accurate to see the mpg figures from mags. and Web sites that publish those stats, like Consumer Reports, Motor Trend, etc., even if some of the car mags. tend to be slightly more lead-foot than grandma. :cool:
 
Yeah, I read somewhere how the EPA way is flawed, but didn't they recalculate their mpg estimates for vehicles a few years ago?

Yes and no- The whacked 10% off the numbers to reflect what people might actually see but that was a few years before hybrids came out.

Since there are parts of the drive cycle where a hybrid has no emissions at all it skews the test results to a false higher reading.
 
The way the EPA tests cars is flawed, I'm surprised that no one has gone into any detail about it (but confess to not reading the whole thread)

The EPA bases MPG on tailpipe emissions, NOT on the fuel actually consumed by a car running a drive cycle.

Insane isn't? but that is why the hybrids get such high numbers, they game the system.

Toyota had a press release that pretty much states this explaining please don't blame them for the inflated numbers but how the EPA tests cars.

I can see this. I own a 2003 Mustang cobra that i bought new. I paid a 1000 dollar gas guzzler tax on top of of the price i paid for the car. A month or so after owning it i read a mustang magazine article testing it and an AWD Subaru WRX in launching. Anyway during all the few days of driving they said the Cobra got about 2 mpg more than the wrx in daily driving lol but the wrx didn't get the gas guzzler tax like the cobra guys had to pay. Its bullshit how they test and i can tell you the car now makes over 500 rwhp and can get an average of 24 mpg on the highway.
 
Since there are parts of the drive cycle where a hybrid has no emissions at all it skews the test results to a false higher reading.

No. Measuring carbon emissions is simply another way of measuring fuel burned. If there are no emission, it is because no fuel is burned. It is not a way to game the system. The reason hybrids do so much better on the city test than standard cars is because the EPA includes 18% idling as part of their simulated LA traffic test. Hybrids usually waste no energy while idling. It doesn't matter if you measure fuel or carbone emissions, there is none of either while idling a hybrid. Now if you stop and go isn't like this the results will be different for you.

Yes and no- The whacked 10% off the numbers to reflect what people might actually see but that was a few years before hybrids came out.

Again No. The last update was in 2006 well after hybrids were on the market:
http://www.epa.gov/fueleconomy/regulations.htm


No cycle is going to work for everyone. Some people get more than EPA some worse.

The problems I have with EPA:
1: it is run on a dyno instead of roads
2: they use low speeds and lower acceleration (change in latest update)
3: They let manufacturers do some of the tests and take their word for it.

For these reasons I prefer consumer reports. The do 3 tests in real cars they buy off the lot like the rest of us. And maybe they will make Donovan happy as they use a fuel flow meter instead of carbon emissions.
1: City test: Harsher than the EPA, the prius only go 35mpg on it and that was the best score I have seen.
2: Highway run at 65mph.
3: 150 mile day trip with a mix of roads.

http://www.consumerreports.org/cro/cars/how-we-test/fuel-economy/fuel-economy.htm

But it doesn't hurt to look at both, but as flawed as EPA it still serves as a comparison much better than "my friend got ....".

It's is whole different kettle of fish with this new GM test (with an EPA rubber stamp). They drive most of the time on EV mode then drive a small amount on gas and then calculate like they never used any EV juice and just the tiny amount of gas. That is just plain wrong.
 
Gasoline MPG vs Electric MPG is not rocket science. That the EPA fk's it up, typical.

A gallon of gasoline contains 36.6 KWH of energy. End of story.

So rating MPG for a hybrid gas/electric plugin is very simple, just assign the gas equivalent of the KWH's sucked down during charging, add it as "virtual gas" in the tank, and test how far the car goes on the tankful.

gdonovan.... actually a number of people in this thread have brought up GM and the Govt having no money, and how "WE" are going to have to borrow it from China. I simply pointed out, China is not our creditor, other American's are our creditor. They like to have us think big bad China is the boogey man, so we don't pay any attention to fellow American's making a buck off our national misery's. You go right ahead and keep apologizing for the Bushies actions if it makes you feel good. But if you aren't in the upper 1/2 of 1% of the income strata.... you got ripped off just like the rest of us.

In the meantime, I'll just keep pointing out the FACTS.

Basically from the consumer point of view, the Hybrids just don't make economic sense. The reasons to convert production in that direction... hybrid and pure electric... are National Security and National Economic Security. Eventually gas is going to run out, on the way it is going to get forever more expensive and act as a drain on our economy and threaten our security in numerous ways.

For many reasons that don't involve your wallet today, we need to be switching gasoline out of transportation. It shouldn't be anywhere near as expensive as the prices reflect right now. low production volume and the fact noone has put the effort into mass manufacturing the components needed... motor/generators, batteries, power electronic controls, etc, etc... the pricing we see now does NOT reflect what it will really cost fleetwide once the industry really gets to work mass producing hybrid and electric cars. The current crop are all "engineering samples" of what direction to pursue, rather than actual mature products.

If you cost analyzed Pre-Model T cars, you'd find they all cost way more than they should have, and people bitched about it then too. Years into the Model T, pricing was a whole different animal.... cars went from being toys for the wealthy to atool for the masses, but it took a good 5-10 years to make that happen.

But one MAJOR element of what is required for economic viablity is missing. True real (not marketing bullshit) regenerative braking. Recouping a large % of the energy it took to get the car moving the next time you have to stop. None of the cars being talked about are capable of this in any meaningful way. The energy to be recouped and stored is way beyond what batteries are capable of accepting as charge in the time period required. The batteries would melt if you tried it. This aspect remains in limbo.

Why would anyone with a brain think making a major paradigm shift in auto design would happen overnight and be glitch and hiccup free?

For many reasons, the true cost of which is hidden from our price at the pump, we cannot keep burning 142 BILLION gallons of gasoline per year. The electricity to replace it must come from not burning anyhting that pollutes. I would be happy with ACTUALLY Clean Coal, which can be done, provided the industry makes the capital investment as they were FORCED to do at the point of a gun for SO2.

No cap+trade, just cap + cap or I'll blow your fucking head off, and your replacement will make the investment you were too dumb to make. :cool:

If any of the car makers were legit on this subject, they woould enter the Automotive Xprize contest and take the $10 MILLION prize for the first 100 MPG car. Of course that is an ACTUAL 100 MPG, as in drive aeound a 100 mile test course with 1 GAL of gas type of actual 100 MPG :eek::rolleyes::p
 
I can see this. I own a 2003 Mustang cobra that i bought new. I paid a 1000 dollar gas guzzler tax on top of of the price i paid for the car. A month or so after owning it i read a mustang magazine article testing it and an AWD Subaru WRX in launching. Anyway during all the few days of driving they said the Cobra got about 2 mpg more than the wrx in daily driving lol but the wrx didn't get the gas guzzler tax like the cobra guys had to pay. Its bullshit how they test and i can tell you the car now makes over 500 rwhp and can get an average of 24 mpg on the highway.

So a Mustang magazine said the Mustang was better. What a shock.

In reality the 4cycl WRX gets much better mpg than a V8.

Gaz guzzler tax is based on combined fuel economy, not just highway mpg based on a Mustang magazine.

I just Checked the WRX vs the normal V8 Mustang (with a smaller V8 and better fuel economy than the cobra) at consumer reports. The WRX got 24mpg combined, the Mustang 20mpg. No funny EPA stuff here, just driving the cars in 3 detailed comparison tests.
 
Back
Top