Chevy Volt Gets 230 mpg City?

I can't believe GM is serious about this and going to subsidize it. No wonder the company is bankrupt, the upper level management is filled with old morons.

1. Not marketable
At $35k+ no one will buy this for any reason other than to enlarge their green penis when there are so many other options (Prius type cars, Honda Fit type cars) unless gasoline goes well over $5

2. Battery
I have a serious lack of faith in the battery being used
 
sorry guys I only read the first few pages but I really want but from those couple pages it seems to me people in this thread are substantially more underwhelmed by this car than I would have thought.

NYtimes version btw:
http://www.nytimes.com/2009/08/12/business/12auto.htmlXXXXXXXtechnology

Anyways, this figure they're coming up with is totally and completly useless. The abstraction that all of us use to judge a cars efficiency, that is, its "MPG", is a totally useless one to the consumer in the scenario GM has built, unfortunatly it seems the EPA isn't intrested in finding a new one. Disclosing the batterys no-charge duty cycle, and then the various efficiencies of the engine when it's on would probably be perfectly undstandable to people.

In short, the way the volt works is you get 40 "free" miles, after that the mpg is up to the efficiency of that engine which, because its able to run at its maximum output regardless of the speed its moving at, is probably somewhere along the lines of 90-110 "mpg".

If the testing methodology required less than the ~40 mile duty cycle the battery then this cars MPG rating could legitimatly be stretched to pretty huge numbers. If you could keep this car off its 4 cyclender gas powered turbine then... well its possible GM is using some diesel power company's efficiency numbers (keeping in mind a diesel power plant gets about 70% of the total expended energy from the gas, compared to a standard gasoline car engines measily 20%) which would put this car at 3 or 4 times the "mpg" as even the highest efficiency diesel cars.

That said, if you push it beyond the no-charge cycle and power from the turbine is needed its important to note that this measily 20% gas engine turns into a much more substantial 30-35% as its able to run at its maximum efficiency putting energy into the car even while the car is "idled". It's as if, while your waiting at a red light, your engine idling at 300 RPM was winding a spring conneced to the rear axle such that, when you wanted all that energy to accelerate (to the next red light if your commutes anything like mine :eek:), you might never have to get your engine out of 300RPM, this coiled spring would just push you to the next point where you needed your brakes.

I was a strong "believer" in global warming back in high school, since then I sorta lost intrest until, in vancouver BC, the air became stagnent so the gasses collected, and it hovered around 35C such that the N20 in the air shifted to the brown state of its equilibrium producing a quite literally brown moon.

and just... for the record, ever since those new prius ads toyotas decided to start running (the one with the whisling people?) I've had the nearly overwhelming urge to punch every prius owner I see in the face. "The world needs more prius"... the fucking smugness of it is just... gah...
 
I am disappointed GM chose the low road in making up an inflated number. They can't hide behind EPA, GM is working with the EPA and pushed them to have a ridiculous test.

The 230mpg based on 5 full charge cycles and a little bit of running the engine is wrong on so many levels. It tells the consumer nothing. It is like political speech, all hot air and no content.

What you really need, and it covers all situations and tell you everything you need to know is:

Charge sustaining MPG.


If GM were an honest company, this is the number they would tell us. Once you have this number you can figure out what it will do in any situation that you can use it in, instead of one artificial situation that meets no actual usage.

Further it is just plain wrong to pretend the electricity is some free MPG enhancer as GM does. The two drivetrain modes will be looked at independently with an EV range and range extender MPG (which is probably closer to 40mpg, but GM won't tell us).

It seems GM chose to assume their audience was unthinking. The sad thing in the mainstream they may be right.

But I went from supporting the "new GM" to turning my back on them after this nonsense. This kind of misleading hucksterism is not the way to reboot the company. Sad.
 
Do what I did...buy a motorcycle!

More fun...
Less gas...
Costs a fraction of what a low end hybrid does...
HOV lane usage...
FTW!
 
Do what I did...buy a motorcycle!

More fun...
Less gas...
Costs a fraction of what a low end hybrid does...
HOV lane usage...
FTW!

Practical driving? pssshh gtfo. we need more hybrid sports cars and hybrid 8 seater SUV's not some low cost, low maintenance, small footprint efficient means of transportation!
 
"The hacked H3 is a hybrid with the gasoline fuel system removed. In its place, Goodwin installed a biodiesel-burning jet turbine to recharge the electrical system:"

You don't really think facts are going to change his point of view do you?:(
 
As for Goodwin's conversions, they are interesting, but misleading IMHO. Stuff gets quoted as 100% more power and 50% less gas usage! However, I think the key to understanding these claims is mutual exclusion.

E.g. I had a friend who owned a Dodge Power Wagon (Diesel). By playing with the ECU and other minor mechanical adjustments, he was able to gain significant power; on the order of the 100% we are discussing here. Particularly when increasing boost pressures (remember these are turbo-diesels). Look at all the drag racers and their power numbers. Very possible to tweak significant power, over the manufacturers spec, out of positive pressured engines. Just don't ask about durability/reliability!

His website claims that Hydrogen can be used safely up a 50% split of diesel and hydrogen. Ignoring any questions about what this 50% split actually is and how it was measured (mass, volume, etc.), let us take it at layman’s face value. A vehicle using this technology would use approx. 50% less diesel by definition. However, just like these electric vehicles, they ignore the fact that you are using significant quantities of hydrogen or other fuels. In addition, it is unlikely that while operating in this mode you are getting those huge power increases or if you are it will not last the many miles we expect out of today’s automobiles. The 50% mix is only under ideal circumstances as he claims.

The hype becomes 100% power increase, 50% less fuel and runs, lasts, feels just like your automobile today.
 
I drive a Civic Hybrid and I think 45-50mpg at the cost of a 1.3 liter engine is just fine ^^.
 
Considering it's not the same guy? No.

So it is a completely different guy who did the EXACT SAME THING? Yeah, BULLSHIT. There is no 60 MPG gas hummer, Goodwin is the exact person you were thinking of (even modified other people's hummers), and did everything you described. My guess is you just heard about him through a 3rd party that screwed up the details, kind of like you were doing in this thread.

Feel free to prove me wrong, of course - but I think we all know you can't.
 
As for Goodwin's conversions, they are interesting, but misleading IMHO. Stuff gets quoted as 100% more power and 50% less gas usage! However, I think the key to understanding these claims is mutual exclusion.

Remember, it is a *HYBRID* with the diesel turbine powering a generator which in turn powered the electric motors that powered the wheels. So it isn't entirely impossible for his claims, but I would agree that they are probably bloated
 
No, not at all, but I wanted to at least point it out for those who are not familiar with his ignorance.

You have to remember 90%(1) of people who post on a forum come there because people in real life stopped listening to them a long time ago. So now they just attempt to yell over each other in forums.

(1) Remember kids, 96.324% of statistics are made up.
 
Remember, it is a *HYBRID* with the diesel turbine powering a generator which in turn powered the electric motors that powered the wheels. So it isn't entirely impossible for his claims, but I would agree that they are probably bloated

He makes several conversions. One is a diesel turbine turning a electric generator (really just a motor) to store power in what appears to be a carbon aerogel capacitor bank (details are fuzzy on this). He is playing with this idea, but his bread and butter sales are installing diesel engines with/without hydrogen/ethanol injection schemes. The concern with a turbine would be operating efficiency, i.e. most of the designs I've seen need time to "warm up" before they are really efficient.

Same diesel electric idea could be done with a regular turbo-diesel engine. If I recall correctly the military had a Humvee prototype using laptop lithium-ion batteries doing just that. It provided something like 15mins of pure electric run time. The motors are in the wheel designs so no traditional drive train was needed. Since the electric generator was designed to be most efficient at the most efficient RPM of the standard Humvee turbo-diesel, things worked well. If done correctly a diesel electric can be much more efficient than other "hybrid" designs that both "fuels" drive the wheels.

One way to cheat on the numbers with a diesel electric design is to not make it a 1:1 ratio of power generation vs power delivered. That military prototype above used four 50kW motors in the wheels which approx. matched the output of the diesel engine. However, I could also put four 100kW motors in there and leave the turbo diesel engine alone. As long as the energy storage system can handle loads of 400kW I technically have doubled the max power output. Too bad I have to stop and recharge the thing (when using more than 200kW to drive) all the time since I still only have 200kW of power coming out of the turbo-diesel.

Lots of ways to cheat the numbers. His stuff is interesting, but from what I have read/researched on his conversions he is playing fast and loose with the circumstances those numbers were generated under. The layman accepts them as true under all conditions. Sort of like expecting to get EPA highway MPG while blasting down the interstate at top speed.
 
http://www.toyotaequipment.com/taylortow.htm <- Hey, look. Little electric tow tractors that can haul payloads greater than 30,000lbs.

I'm sure once we get past the "OMG Electric cars are a scary new technology" hurdle, building a mainstream electric truck that can tow your boat won't be much of an issue.

You realize that those can't even reach 30mph? Much less haul something 400 miles? There is some technophobic reaction going on here, but there is a much more funadmental problem with energy density for battries and energy density cost density going on here as well. 40K to go 40 miles on electricity doesn't work for hauling a boat.
 
I can't believe GM is serious about this and going to subsidize it. No wonder the company is bankrupt, the upper level management is filled with old morons.

1. Not marketable
At $35k+ no one will buy this for any reason other than to enlarge their green penis when there are so many other options (Prius type cars, Honda Fit type cars) unless gasoline goes well over $5

2. Battery
I have a serious lack of faith in the battery being used

While I am not a big proponent on Hybrids. The costs alone usually destroy any chance on further savings and I am not sold on the whole saving the worlds resources by using a bunch of much more rare and much more toxic components for the batteries. But the Volt intrigues me, I like this serial setup, and the car itself should be a decent performer and its going to fit the mold of a 28k-30k car anyways. The performance and features sit at about the level of a Malibu SS. This isn't a Focus, Caliber, Cobalt type car.

Second they aren't subsidizing it and never were, the US government will/is because they want to see more of these cars out there. This was long before GM started to hit financial trouble. Maybe you can consider it one and the same now but the money is coming from different areas.

While there are several hybrids more affordable they are not that much cheaper. They also are also more of a green penis badge then the Volt, because they have a more difficult time being much more then a barely capable vehicle. With this serial design the Volt will always perform the same whether your on the basic charge or the ICE is feeding power to the electric engine. Whereas with the Prius and other parallel hybrids you have two weak engines that trade between each other doubling the weight.

Whether or not it sells I don't know. Its up to GM to build up a market for it. But this isn't a Prius it isn't horribly priced for the car and isn't why GM is in trouble. Its cost of ownership will probably set it above the MPG means everything crowd because if they can afford a 30-35k car then they probably can afford the gas that this would save. I hope they can produce a market for this, I hope they can bring the cost down, but while I think the true next leap in cars will be hydrogen based, if I am going to be forced to look at hybrids I would rather have more options like this.
 
GM and the EPA should be sued for false advertisement and customer deception. Why do they think us so fucking stupid that they can't give us an electric mileage as well as a gas mileage? How about you work to inform and educate the consumer, EPA, GM, and other industry whores (I mean government agencies), rather than intentionally misleading us?
 
Not to mention that it sounds like they pretend the electricity to charge it is free when they present that 230 MPG soundbite.
 
Not to mention that it sounds like they pretend the electricity to charge it is free when they present that 230 MPG soundbite.

yeah, how much is an owner's electricity cost going to increase when recharging the battery??:rolleyes::rolleyes:

And is the US electric grid ready to support millions of electric cars? LMAO

I don't understand why they don't make a fucking electric car that has power panels on the roof so when your vehicle is parked at work for 8 hours it recharges.:rolleyes:
 
yeah, how much is an owner's electricity cost going to increase when recharging the battery??:rolleyes::rolleyes:

And is the US electric grid ready to support millions of electric cars? LMAO

I don't understand why they don't make a fucking electric car that has power panels on the roof so when your vehicle is parked at work for 8 hours it recharges.:rolleyes:
1) About 1/3 what it costs in gas. Unfortunantly, if you're driving 40 miles a day that equates to a payoff of 17 years vs a civic hybrid with leather.

2) I agree 100%. At 30$ a month using the above numbers, figuring the average electric bill at 150$ a month (random guess, feel free to give me a better number), that's a 20% increase in energy useage.

3) Because you can't capture that much energy from a solar panel. Given a typical ratio of 12sqin per watt, and parking at your said 8 hours in direct light, and the 25kWhrs/100 miles from the article, you would need an pannel 15,000 sqin or 104 sqft or a 18'x6' rectangle. If you drive somewhere at night, it's cloudy, you park in a garage, you park in a parking garage, you want to go more than 40 miles every 8 hours..... You get the idea.
 
Not sure if this has been posted, but here are a few facts from the article on the gm-volt.com fansite:

1. According to U.S. Department of Transportation data, nearly eight of 10 Americans commute fewer than 40 miles a day http://XXXXXXXXXXXX/U-S-DOTStudy .

2. At the U.S. average cost of electricity (approximately 11 cents per kWh), a typical Volt driver would pay about $2.75 for electricity to travel 100 miles, or less than 3 cents per mile.

Link to the article: http://gm-volt.com/2009/08/11/chevy-volt-gets-230-mpg-city-epa-rating/


The 230mpg number is kind of strange. I guess they had to give it some designation. "Infinite" isn't accurate unless you never go over 40 miles between charges. And 50mpg isn't accurate unless you never plug it in. How do you pick a number between 50 and infinity? Apparently the EPA used a lot of data analysis to determine the average driver's driving habits, and based their number upon their expected fuel usage.

Personally, I think I'd be part of the group that rarely uses any gas at all, so essentially infinity mpg; and less than 50 cents per day for electricity. Even if for some reason I was unable to plug it in and "only" got 50mpg while in ER mode, I think I'd be quite happy.
 
Not to mention that it sounds like they pretend the electricity to charge it is free when they present that 230 MPG soundbite.

Actually, it appears that there is some sort of petroleum equivalence factor (PEF) included in the calculation. I don't know how they determine that factor, but electricity usage is not ignored.

I agree that 230mpg is pretty simplistic. I think it is a lot more informative to simply state that it goes up to 40 miles without using any gasoline, and gets 50mpg thereafter. However, to the average unsophisticated consumer, that may be a bit more information than they prefer to receive all at once. I've heard GM talk about the Volt for more targeted audiences (on NPR) that basically presented it like that, but it didn't seem to get them much attention. The 230mpg anticipated EPA rating seems to be working much better from a marketing standpoint.
 
I've got three big beefs with electric powered vehicles.
1) Power sucks. Yea, you can put along in it. I used to drive a 4cyl. I'll never drive anything that small again. V6 was improved and actually doable. But after my V8, I don't know if I could ever go to something so puny again.
2) You still use considerable amounts of oil to produce the thing. You might be saving oil at the pump, but you're using more of it in production. Our electrical grid also is very antiquated and old... IMO we need to get some nuclear plants up and running before pushing this too far.
3) The savings will NEVER justify the expensive of one. If you're buying a new car anyway, and not spending anymore to get the electric version (I don't know of any comparison like that yet, but I'm humoring the advocates), have at it. But to trade up or replace simply for MPG purposes, you'll never justify the cost.
 
How do you pick a number between 50 and infinity?

You don't. You give the actual MPG as one metric and the miles/charge, cost/charge, cost/mile, whatever metrics standard you want for the electric measurement. I'm tired of everything being dumbed down and then manipulated to be deceptive.
 
230mpg is false advertisement, how they can get away with it is beyond me.. they need to post it as 40 mpc (miles per charge) and an extended 30 mpg there after... I can guarantee you that 50% of the morons out there are going to buy the car thinking it gets 230 miles per gallon of gas and not even know about this quirky math formula they came up with that allows them to lay these false claims....
 
Not sure if this has been posted, but here are a few facts from the article on the gm-volt.com fansite:

1. According to U.S. Department of Transportation data, nearly eight of 10 Americans commute fewer than 40 miles a day http://XXXXXXXXXXXX/U-S-DOTStudy .

2. At the U.S. average cost of electricity (approximately 11 cents per kWh), a typical Volt driver would pay about $2.75 for electricity to travel 100 miles, or less than 3 cents per mile.

Link to the article: http://gm-volt.com/2009/08/11/chevy-volt-gets-230-mpg-city-epa-rating/


The 230mpg number is kind of strange. I guess they had to give it some designation. "Infinite" isn't accurate unless you never go over 40 miles between charges. And 50mpg isn't accurate unless you never plug it in. How do you pick a number between 50 and infinity? Apparently the EPA used a lot of data analysis to determine the average driver's driving habits, and based their number upon their expected fuel usage.

Personally, I think I'd be part of the group that rarely uses any gas at all, so essentially infinity mpg; and less than 50 cents per day for electricity. Even if for some reason I was unable to plug it in and "only" got 50mpg while in ER mode, I think I'd be quite happy.

Where are you getting 50mpg in ER mode? That number seems way to high. Even if it's 120mpg, at an unreasonable 30,000 miles a year, the breakeven is still over 8 years vs buying a 25K civic hybrid with leather.
 
230mpg is false advertisement, how they can get away with it is beyond me.. they need to post it as 40 mpc (miles per charge) and an extended 30 mpg there after... I can guarantee you that 50% of the morons out there are going to buy the car thinking it gets 230 miles per gallon of gas and not even know about this quirky math formula they came up with that allows them to lay these false claims....

It's the EPA's math, not GMs.
 
They really just need to introduce a new category for miles/KWH and get rid of the average rating. They should also list mileage the Volt gets running just on gas, like for when you go home and forget to plug in your car for the next day or extended road trips. The 230 mpg is really just BS. If the battery could go 45 miles instead of 40, the rating can become 460 mpg. If the battery lasted 49 miles, the rating would be 2000+mpg which is really just ridiculous. Also the rating would start to fall as soon as you started to use the battery.
 
It's the EPA's math, not GMs.
Bull... Fritz was the one that made the claim, not the EPA.

The OFFICIAL statement from the EPA about this:

EPA has not tested a Chevy Volt and therefore cannot confirm the fuel economy values claimed by GM. EPA does applaud GM's commitment to designing and building the car of the future - an American-made car that will save families money, significantly reduce our dependence on foreign oil and create good-paying American jobs. We're proud to see American companies and American workers leading the world in the clean energy innovations that will shape the 21st century economy.
 
I doubt the car batteries will even make it to 100,000 miles because that would mean 2500recharges and no battery I have heard off can do that.
 
...I hope they can bring the cost down, but while I think the true next leap in cars will be hydrogen based, [but] if I am going to be forced to look at hybrids I would rather have more options like this.

Hydrogen is a dead tech. It's been discussed amongst the world's leading scientists for a while and the general consensus there is no affordable way to produce the cars or fuel vs. using regular electricity. Face it plug ins are the future, take it or leave it.
 
Bull... Fritz was the one that made the claim, not the EPA.

The OFFICIAL statement from the EPA about this:

That's funny I swear I said it was the EPA's MATH, not the EPA's claim.
From the article:
TheArticle said:
The EPA has released a new methodology for determining a draft fuel economy standard for extended-range EVs like the Volt, and under this new procedure, the Volt will have a composite urban fuel economy rating of 230 mpg
 
Back
Top