Building a C2Q non gaming rig

exe163

[H]ard|Gawd
Joined
Nov 15, 2005
Messages
1,366
Hi, my friend wanted to build a quad core computer. Sadly he cannot wait for i5 and i7 as of now is a bit out of the budget range. I know little about Core 2 from intel as I jumped from X2 to i7. Budget is around $800 exclude monitor. He use this computer mainly for everyday use (typing, surfing), nothing require too much processing power. Of course the cheaper the better.

There are some limitation since he lives in China atm. The price of Q9550 = i7-920 which is double the cost of Q8200 according to Newegg China. My guess is Q8200 would probably be a better choice.

Any suggestion is welcome, Thanks in advance.
 
Then, what's the point?

A Pentium for or Athlon 64 x2 would suit his needs or even an Athlon XP or PIII.


Honestly if he's in need for just a new computer, go AMD x3 or Phenom II now, if he's on a budget. Or just a normal Core 2 Duo.
 
I am pretty sure a C2Q under $800 is not a problem at all. As for your other suggestions, going with Intel is merely a preference. From my point of view, 4 cores would give a smoother more pleasant experience even in everyday computering. And I am pretty sure you have your reason going a intel quad also.
 
If he won't be gaming, he probably won't be overclocking either. The Q8200 would be a good choice if he won't be doing anything too stressful, so just pair that with either an inexpensive G3x or G4x board with integrated graphics, or a P43 or P45 motherboard and a cheap video card like an 8400GS or 4350. Get him 4GB of RAM, a quality ~350-400W PSU, an optical drive and case of his choice, and he'll be set.

If you want specific parts recommendations, we'll need some info about what he has available to him, since I'm sure the selection in China (as well as the prices) are very different from what's available in the US.
 
I would just get a DUAL CORE PENTIUM. it's cheaper than the Core 2 Duo, and a pretty good chip for the price.
 
Day to day computing would see more benefits with an upgrade of hard drive speeds. 10,000 rpm? RAID0 configuration? SSD! I mean... don't completely cheap out on the CPU, but a Core 2 Duo would be just fine, or an AMD chip since they have gotten so much cheaper.

Hard drive! Hard drive!
 
I thought it was Allendale / gimped Conroe...?
The original Core 2 Duo E6300 was a 65nm Conroe CPU with 2MB of L2 cache (4MB on-die but half was disabled). The Allendale core differed from the Conroe core used by the E6300 and E6400 in that it actually had only 2MB of physical cache on-die, and wasn't just a Conroe die with half the L2 cache disabled.

The current Pentium Dual-Core E6300 is a 45nm Wolfdale-3M CPU with 1MB of cache disabled, so it only has 2MB of accessible L2 cache. It runs at 2.8GHz, has a 1066MHz FSB speed, and supports VT-x unlike most of Intel's other budget CPUs.
 
The e6300 is a good bang/buck value. I've got one, and it does 3.5GHz without boosting voltage. Gets a little warm under IBT with only the stock hsf fan, but it passes test without destabilizing. I think it's a fantastic cpu, but I'm not very demanding. I don't have a game on this PC that is less than 5 years old, and if I rip a DVD, i set the pc about it's business and walk a way, so if it takes 5 minutes longer than a quad core, BFD. Point is, it's not the fastest thing around, but it's good enough for me, for now.

I upgraded from a E2160 @3.0GHz, not because I needed more speed, but because I needed VT. It was a tough choice between this cpu, and a quad (9550 or 9650). In the end, I decided I get the e6300 for $80 now, and in a year or two, I get a quad. By delaying the purchase of that quad, when I do get it, it will have dropped by at least the $80 I spent on the E6300, so by waiting, I'll get 2 cpus for the same or less $ than if I bought a quad at today's price.

If you're on a budget, and a dual core is enough for your needs, the e6300 is a great choice, especially if you give it a little OC action.
 
I would just get a DUAL CORE PENTIUM. it's cheaper than the Core 2 Duo, and a pretty good chip for the price.

I would honestly go AMD at this transition point to the i7.

The Core 2 Duo is being phased out quickly, while the AMD is still holding one, and a decent performer too.


But, alas I think we scared away the O.P. guys. Guess he didn't realize this is [H]ard and not general surfing, e-mailing forum. ;)

Just kidding if he comes back. ;)
 
The Core 2 Duo is being phased out quickly, while the AMD is still holding one, and a decent performer too.
Core 2 CPUs are still faster clock-for-clock than AMD's current lineups and overclock just as well or better. And they will be phased out eventually, but probably not until the beginning of next year at the earliest.

AMD's real advantage right now is price, since they have pretty well-performing chips for very cheap. But compared to similarly-priced Core 2 CPUs, there isn't really any benefit to choosing an AMD system.
 
I would honestly go AMD at this transition point to the i7.

The Core 2 Duo is being phased out quickly, while the AMD is still holding one, and a decent performer too.


But, alas I think we scared away the O.P. guys. Guess he didn't realize this is [H]ard and not general surfing, e-mailing forum. ;)

Just kidding if he comes back. ;)

Haha, if this was general surfing forum I wouldn't be here.

Thanks for the inputs. I told my friend but he still insist on a quad core so this is what he ended up with so far:


Q8200
Asus P5G41
Corsair VX 450w
1TB WD Green (they don't have black sadly)

Just some RAM and I think he's all set. And he wasn't too happy when I keep "downgrading" his system, but I think he will thanks us later for saving him money.

I had a 4400 X2 at AMD's heydays. And I have to say I wasn't too happy about it in both performance and OCability, also a dead platform.

Since he had some extra fund left, he wants to get a decent sound card to accompany his Audio Technica headphone. Just for headphone and not for gaming at around ~50 range, which I can't think of any besides Creative junks. Suggestions?


P.S. AMDXP suggesting AMD while you own two intel rig.... umm.... :):D
 
I would probably look into another drive for the OS - from what I understand that green drive may be less than 7200 RPM which may increase seek times making overall computing much slower. For the same price there are a number of other options - did he already buy these items?
 
I'd personally go with a cheap DDR3 AMD system. Why? Upgrade path. S775 has none, and AMD AM2+ has none. You can do an AM3 AMD system for cheap, and still have a viable upgrade path, and have pretty nice components for th rest of the system.
 
I'd personally go with a cheap DDR3 AMD system. Why? Upgrade path. S775 has none, and AMD AM2+ has none. You can do an AM3 AMD system for cheap, and still have a viable upgrade path, and have pretty nice components for th rest of the system.

srsly, get an AMD II x4 920 for the same price of the q8200.
 
Back
Top