Recomemdations for a Access Point

videobruce

Gawd
Joined
Jan 21, 2005
Messages
515
I'm looking for a Access Point to use in a nearby building off of a existing wireless router. My needs/wish list is as follows;

1. Removeable antenna(s),
2. At least a 'G' or possibly a 'N' depending on price,
3. metal case woul;d be a plus,
4. Wall mountable,
5. Cost under $70,
6. Speed holding up under weaker signal conditions (as much as possible),
7. Decent support and user friendly config. menu.

Questions;

A. Are diversty (dual) antennas really better?
B. Is the price difference between 'G' and 'N' type AP's worth the price difference?

What I didn't like was those Linksys blue and black routers and AP's that have a dozen different variations and version numbers that only confuses which one to get.
 
Last edited:
I was never impressed with fab-corp a few years back when I looked, I like hdcom for that stuff, you should be using them to YeOlde :)
 
...
5. Cost under $70,
...
B. Is the price difference between 'G' and 'N' type AP's worth the price difference?
At this price bracket, I believe not.

5 or 6 years ago, when I started doing SOHO networking professionally, many G APs from major brands were still rubbish. They were a pain to setup, with obscure configuration options - they would work capriciously and were unreliable (e.g. just stopped working for no apparent reason, periodic soft & hard resets required).

This was when 802.11g was already an established standard.

I believe this approximately reflects the current state of 802.11n - or "pre-N" as the are more accurately described - units. 802.11n is still not ratified and in the last report I saw it was typical that a NIC from one manufacturer would not work with an AP made by another.

Besides this, only a single 802.11g client will cause 802.11n to fall back to G speeds. We all have laptops with built in wireless, G of course - what are you going to do? Buy external pre-N wireless adaptors for all your laptops?

All the manufacturers of 802.11g APs have been making them for years with incremental improvements, and as a consequence wireless-G tends to be mature & stable. I don't know that this applies to all APs on the market, but I certainly haven't come across any unreliable or quirky ones in the last couple of years.

Stroller.
 
802.11n is still not ratified and in the last report I saw it was typical that a NIC from one manufacturer would not work with an AP made by another.

I have worked with many 11n devices on the same network from different vendors and never run into a compatibility problem. Not saying it won't happen, I'm just giving my experience.

Besides this, only a single 802.11g client will cause 802.11n to fall back to G speeds.

This is not true at all.
 
This is not true at all.
My apologies.

If I'm reading correctly, then, N uses multiple channels; when G devices are present one channel falls back to G speeds, the other is reserved for N at a higher speed (but not the full speed that would be attained if only N clients were present & able to use both channels). Is this correct?

The brief Googling I've just done indicates that current pre-N kit looses some speed when G devices are present, but indeed may indeed not fall back all the way to 54Mbps. The question, then, is how much speed does it loose?

(IMO pre-N is still not worth the hassle; I am quite happy to revise my opinion when N is deployed widely and I see it working easily & everywhere).

Stroller.
 
Strolls; thanks for the reply. What is the holdup with 'N'?? It's been available for a few years now.
The reason for the removable antenna is I have 3rd party antennas available I want to try.
 
I was never impressed with fab-corp a few years back when I looked, I like hdcom for that stuff, you should be using them to YeOlde :)

I may next time I do an odd order. So far ordering stuff from Fleeman has worked well for me. Granted their website is very dated looking.
 
Back
Top