Video Game Minority Report

Damned if you do damned if you don't.

L4D2 got called racist because there are black zombies in it...
I'm sure if black people WEREN'T in the game it would be called racist for not including any considering the area the game is set in.

Video games were largely out of the negative spotlight and BAM! Racist allegations! Well fuck that.
 
You used this article to start whinning about how it's unfair that you have to watch a white person on a TV show. Seriously? That's what it has come to these days? You have to whine that someone's race isn't represented enough on a TV show? Seriously, go take a look at what the people before you overcame. To say that the number of white people on TV or video games means you can't have class mobility is insulting to what they did for you.

As a white guy, I think it's pretty easy to say it doesn't matter, but I had an East Asian roommate several years ago, and I can promise you that seeing during that time it became clear just how unusual it was. I may not get excited about a show with a white guy on it, but he did get a bit excited if an Asian was on...when I questioned him on it, he said that it was because it was fairly rare to see characters that looked like him on TV.


TV and video games aren't real life. They doesn't even come close to representing average joe.

No, but most of them look similar to the average white Jane and Joe. It's clearly better now than it was 20 or 30 years ago, but we're not there yet.
 
The knee jerk reaction here - and the boneheaded way Steve put the question - proves that basically none of you read the fucking report.

#1: The report doesn't call anyone "racist" anywhere, at least not from what we can glean in the article. It's just a study of representation.

#2: By adding in contemptuously, "No word yet on whether monsters, zombies, etc. were also offended" you drew a probably unintended but nonetheless implicit connection between minorities and monsters - you put them on the same level by way of comparison.

The guy who conducted the study wasn't exactly Al Sharpton. His utterly mild and sensible conclusion was "These are highly underserved groups. It's a missed sales opportunity."

So stop freaking out and channeling the Limbaugh-esque "oh noes white people are being demonized by the ebil Elite yet again!"
 
The knee jerk reaction here - and the boneheaded way Steve put the question - proves that basically none of you read the fucking report.
...
So stop freaking out and channeling the Limbaugh-esque "oh noes white people are being demonized by the ebil Elite yet again!"

Sounds like someone just stereotyped the posters on this thread.
 
guys theres a lot of truth to this!

left4dead - the black guy usually dies first and the girl is a sex object! not that i have a problem with that.
 
African-Americans appeared in proportion to their numbers in the real world, but mainly in sports games and in titles that reinforce stereotypes, such as 50 Cent Bulletproof.

Lol.

"These are highly underserved groups. It's a missed sales opportunity."

Really? They'll make more sales by selling to a minority and alienating the majority? I'm pretty sure I'd rather sell to the majority and alienate the minority.

And by steve's comment about games being racist, I haven't had a game simply not work on me just because I'm not a specific race.
 
Well to capitalize on it the main hero's race could be altered by interchangable skins. Of course if you had to unlock those skins it might not end well.
 
The Elder Scrolls is racist because I cannot make a white reguard nor a black imperial.
Funny you mention that, did you know that statistically, Redguards (i.e. "the black race") start out with higher physical strength and lower intelligence? Yeah, that was kind of a dick move.
 
You used this article to start whinning about how it's unfair that you have to watch a white person on a TV show. Seriously? That's what it has come to these days? You have to whine that someone's race isn't represented enough on a TV show? Seriously, go take a look at what the people before you overcame. To say that the number of white people on TV or video games means you can't have class mobility is insulting to what they did for you.
I never said anything of the sort. My point is that by limiting the images of various racial groups seen in entertainment media, including games, to a handful of stereotypes (gangsters, ninjas, athletes, etc.), we are not exposed to the diversity that exists in real life, and as such we form preconceptions and misconceptions about these groups of people. Do you think that teenagers and blacks are more likely to be criminals than other groups? Do you think that Hispanics are lazy? Do you think Asians and women are bad drivers? Maybe you don't, but I'll bet you know at least several people who do. Such ridiculous ideas (which are in most cases verified statistically as incorrect) are in part formed and fostered by the media.

I have never, ever said or implied that I do not appreciate the contributions of civil rights advocates, as well as the incredible amount of progress that has been made over even the last sixty years. The systems that we have in place, including government, industry and business, and media, however, are still discriminating on a daily basis through either policies that value traditionally white values, attributes, behaviour, etc.; many also do harm to non-whites. This is much the same opinion that most people have of feminism, that "the battle is over". No, it is not over, and we have a long way to go in building a society that actually does treat everyone equitably, and can compensate for the gross historical injustices that have been done. That does not mean, however, that I don't value the advances we've had.

TV and video games aren't real life. They doesn't even come close to representing average joe. The poor person is clearly under represented on Sitcoms today. The magic user is obviously way over represented as wiccans represent a very small part of the population but have a huge number of people in video games. If you look at the number of playable characters in games, there are WAY more playable atheletes in video games than any other profession. Clearly we are repressing engineers! Won't anyone think of the engineers?!?!
You're being facetious. Nobody, especially me, has ever denied that classism, sexism, ageism, and other types of discrimination exist in the media and in society. I discussed this in my original post. Just for kicks, would you like another example of negative and under-representation? Let's take the elderly (for our intents and purposes, this is pretty much everyone over 40-45). By and large, they are stereotyped in the media as being senile, physically incapable, and otherwise fairly useless; rather than valued for their positive traits (knowledge and experience, teaching ability, role in raising children), in all forms of media they are regularly and almost universally portrayed as burdens. Furthermore, the actual number of characters past the age of about 40 is incredibly small in virtually all forms of entertainment media. I can speak anecdotally that the majority of people I know tend to hold these same negative opinions; considering that it was only about a hundred years ago that the aged were valued for their contributions in society, I don't think the media's contribution to these beliefs can be discounted.

I believe I made it quite clear in my second post I think that his whole post and attitude of "I'm not being represented properly by a video game and/or TV show" is a load of crap. I probably should have avoided being drug into his deliusions. Frankly, I find it offensive that he can sit there and spout how bad and how horrible it is that someone isn't properly represented in a tv show or a video game. Seriously, if that's all that it takes to "keep someone down", they are never going to amount to anything to begin with.
Could you please respond to my actual points rather than dismissing what I say as "deliusions" with little actual backup? Your arguments thus far have relied upon either misrepresenting my points, or insulting me for somehow being "offensive" because I "don't appreciate the sacrifices" made, or some such.

I have to agree with the ridiculousness of this concept. It just creates a web of circular logic. It'd be racist to stereotype a black man/woman as a "street thug", however it's also racist to project traits of success onto these characters as well - since we've all "decided" that traits of a successful person are synonymous with being white.
That's an easy conclusion to come to, but also incorrect. Whitewashing is a method the media uses to make minority groups more palatable to a wider audience by essentially removing their unique cultural traits, whether that be religious practices, style of dress, music, etc. The issue is that when this happens, minorities tend to only be valued for things that are associated with whiteness. That doesn't mean that minorities cannot be valued for these things, or shouldn't be, but it does mean that we need to be mindful of the diversity that exists in our world. This can absolutely have real-world implications. When someone from the Middle East has to change her name to something that "sounds American" in order to get a job, or has to forgo wearing her hijab despite its cultural and religious value, I think we can agree we still have problems.

Points 2 and 4 are largely contradictory.
Not particularly, as I discussed above. Furthermore, it's not as if all media that is discriminatory relies on all of these, all at once.

According to the last Census report, the country is ~81% white, so point 1 is over exagerrated. But we'll roll with it, should developers make every 5th game with a minority protagonist? Should we break it down even further by ethnicity and gender?
I should probably point out that any statistics I've cited have been from memory, and while I can vouch that they are reasonably accurate, they're certainly not perfect. However, I frankly can't be arsed to hunt through dozens of articles for statistics; I'm already spending a good hour each on these responses. :p

In any case, I can't profess to being an expert in this field. I'm a fourth-year university arts student, and while most of the classes I've taken have been in sociology, I'm neither a sociology major nor a professional scholar. I am certainly not doing all of the concepts I've outlined justice, and I'm also not able to provide the most well-worded, concise or exact responses to members here; frankly, this is the [H]ard Forum, not an essay or discussion panel at an academic conference. I encourage all of you to do your own reading on these subjects.
 
The Key difference between TV and Video Games is that: TV is being "pushed at you" and Video Games are a form of entertainment that you "buy into". Still I think this entire "study" is completely flawed.
 
Appeal to nature? Really? It might feel natural for me to bludgeon you to death when you make me angry, but that hardly makes it a good thing to do.

Where exactly did I appeal to nature or state that our natural inclinations are a good thing?
I simply stated that part of our nature is to be biased towards ourselves and those most like us. I most certainly do not feel that our nature is something that is good; quite the opposite, although I believe that most desire to be good.


I'm not sure if you read my post at all, because I mention at least once or twice that a lot of progress has been made, and I cite companies such as EA for Mirror's Edge and Ubisoft for Beyond Good & Evil. Those still remain exceptions rather than rules, however.

I don't believe I singled your post out regarding this. I was speaking in the larger sense, hence that paragraph that followed regarding Jackson, Sharpton, etc.; an issue , I believe, we are somewhat in agreement on.
Nor did I infer that the cretins like Jackson somehow mitigate the very real racism that still exists.
I thought I was quite clear that when pinheads like Jackson and Sharpton attempt to find racism in the very air that we breathe, they create an atmosphere of racism fatigue.
To many false cries of wolf tend to inure people to the real racism.
 
Unsympathetic racist spotted.
Given that you have zero knowledge of me, this simply proves my point; My opinion differs from you; therefore I'm an " Unsympathetic racist".

Perceiving someone else as inferior is not human nature. Perceiving other people as inferior is merely a social construct, one born of elitism and class systems and incubated and perpetuated over history.

The very fact that that the opposite exists (thinking of a different person as superior in their differences) proves you are wrong.
I beg to differ.
One only has to look at the entirety of human history to prove that opinion wrong.
Regardless of where in the world, or where history you look, you will find that perceived differences, whether it be accent, hair or skin color, geographic location or even which neighborhood you come from, have been sufficient cause in someones eyes to start a fight.
If there's one thing that humans excel at, it's the ability to find fault in others for the most trivial of reasons.
Pick any thread on this board and you're almost certain to find differences of opinion stated in the most hyperbolic language imaginable.

You don't like ATI? You're a @$$@*!! idiot!!
You don't like NVIDIA? Your mother's a whore!!
That's not a social construct, that's human nature.

For what it's worth, my statement was that it was human nature to have the inclination to view someone different as inferior.
 
Yes and no, its has to do with context

but what bothers me, is that in games based world wars, civil wars, whatever you call the mess were in now, races aren't represented equally for fighting and dying for their country.

the only reinforcement of stereotypes i can think of, is Counter Strike.Good guys are white, terrorists are middle eastern. How many times does one have to be pwned through a crate on de_dust2 before we start making hardwired connections in our brain to associate well dressed middle-easterner's with wire rimmed glasses to bombs, ak47's, and hostages?
 
Yes and no, its has to do with context

but what bothers me, is that in games based world wars, civil wars, whatever you call the mess were in now, races aren't represented equally for fighting and dying for their country.

the only reinforcement of stereotypes i can think of, is Counter Strike.Good guys are white, terrorists are middle eastern. How many times does one have to be pwned through a crate on de_dust2 before we start making hardwired connections in our brain to associate well dressed middle-easterner's with wire rimmed glasses to bombs, ak47's, and hostages?

Nah man there are also white terrorists in CS, they just wear ski masks. i forgot what they are called in game but they are a representation of the IRA.
 
Given that you have zero knowledge of me, this simply proves my point; My opinion differs from you; therefore I'm an " Unsympathetic racist".


I beg to differ.
One only has to look at the entirety of human history to prove that opinion wrong.
Regardless of where in the world, or where history you look, you will find that perceived differences, whether it be accent, hair or skin color, geographic location or even which neighborhood you come from, have been sufficient cause in someones eyes to start a fight.
If there's one thing that humans excel at, it's the ability to find fault in others for the most trivial of reasons.
Pick any thread on this board and you're almost certain to find differences of opinion stated in the most hyperbolic language imaginable.

You don't like ATI? You're a @$$@*!! idiot!!
You don't like NVIDIA? Your mother's a whore!!
That's not a social construct, that's human nature.

For what it's worth, my statement was that it was human nature to have the inclination to view someone different as inferior.

How is that "human" nature? Sounds like socially induced actions, purely animal instinct, or just simply people being dicks because they happen to be a jerk, depending on the situation. Its purely nature to be threatened by something that seems different or a threat. When someone starts thinking of someone that is different as being inferior, that is not "human" nature. Children who aren't raised by racists (both blatant ones and mild ones) don't have those social hang ups. Only once they are poisoned by social hate is when they begin to have those thoughts of others being inferior. Why do I say this? Simple, you aren't threatened by things you think are inferior. Casting another to be inferior is just a way to socially oppress them, which we did pretty damn well back in the day. It has nothing to do with any naturally occurring "human" nature.

And to be honest, most of that hyperbole and ad hominem stuff comes from ignorant idiots who can't be bothered to use more than two brain cells when thinking about something they are trying to argue about or those who forgo all fact and logic and make shit up as they go. (INB4 that is "ironically" turned around on me :rolleyes:)
 
Funny you mention that, did you know that statistically, Redguards (i.e. "the black race") start out with higher physical strength and lower intelligence? Yeah, that was kind of a dick move.

lul, I didn't realize that I was always a wood elf or kajite(sp?).
 
How is that "human" nature? Sounds like socially induced actions, purely animal instinct, or just simply people being dicks because they happen to be a jerk, depending on the situation. Its purely nature to be threatened by something that seems different or a threat. When someone starts thinking of someone that is different as being inferior, that is not "human" nature. Children who aren't raised by racists (both blatant ones and mild ones) don't have those social hang ups. Only once they are poisoned by social hate is when they begin to have those thoughts of others being inferior. Why do I say this? Simple, you aren't threatened by things you think are inferior. Casting another to be inferior is just a way to socially oppress them, which we did pretty damn well back in the day. It has nothing to do with any naturally occurring "human" nature.

And to be honest, most of that hyperbole and ad hominem stuff comes from ignorant idiots who can't be bothered to use more than two brain cells when thinking about something they are trying to argue about or those who forgo all fact and logic and make shit up as they go. (INB4 that is "ironically" turned around on me :rolleyes:)

I sit corrected.
Inferior was a poor word choice.
It would have been more accurate to say that our inclination would be a response ranging from ill at ease to outright threatened.
I believe my basic point stands, however, which is that our human nature tends to exclusive of those perceived as different from us, as opposed to being inclusive.
Even though the article focused on race,I did not limit those perceptions to race.

You are certainly correct that children untainted by racism will play easily with each other, but those same children will go into the "Mine!, Mine!" mode at the drop of a hat.
That isn't a social construct, that's human nature.
 
Umm it's because most of these games are originally done by the Japanese and, for the most part, have no concept of American social values and only know of the superficial american stereotypes?

Don't get me wrong, it's not like the Japanese have a concept of what racism is. It's just that they don't see or understand it in our culture.

Japanese knows racism very well first , what a braindead comment.
(Hint: Open a historybook)
 
In Everquest, the Smart race (Erudites) are black

In EQ2, however, they look like aliens

I guess the human evolutionary chain goes white->black->k-pax
 
Oh, I see. You just lack any intelligence. Never mind.


Looks like need your "ears" checked.

Despite the fact that I quoted the article that specifically states "children" (read as not teenagers) and the nature of the games being discussed it is only logical to assume that the "children" are playing said games and forming there identities off of them. Obviously this illustrates a complete lack of intelligence. OR you feel that children should be forming their identities off of virtual experiences, in which case my lack of intelligence is rather a difference of opinion. But you are always right. I am adding in the rolleyes smiley to make you sure don't have another failure to communicate. :rolleyes: Enjoy.

The second point is merely a comment that the original poster states that we almost all of us obviously did not read the article. And in turn lashed out in a neo-con anger. Which in itself is a stereotype. Which I found humorous and you did not. I am glad you were able to respond without a ad hominem attack.
 
As a white guy, I think it's pretty easy to say it doesn't matter, but I had an East Asian roommate several years ago, and I can promise you that seeing during that time it became clear just how unusual it was. I may not get excited about a show with a white guy on it, but he did get a bit excited if an Asian was on...when I questioned him on it, he said that it was because it was fairly rare to see characters that looked like him on TV.




No, but most of them look similar to the average white Jane and Joe. It's clearly better now than it was 20 or 30 years ago, but we're not there yet.

I roomed for a year with an asian (Vietnamese). Can't say I ever saw him do anything remotely like that. In fact the only time race was ever noticed was when I tried to get him to take me to a specific Vietnamese pool hall, and lets just say you didn't go there alone if you were white.
 
Hey I'm asian, and in Crysis I play a white guy and all I do for the first half of the game is kill asians, with insanely (funny) stereotypical accents. But I still find it very strangely entertaining. Hmm... Maybe I need to go see a doctor?

I think that the suckas out there that are getting their panties in a bunch over videogame representation are reading too deeply into things.

Though it is true that in Crysis the black dude dies first and the Latino gets eaten. Hmm... I smell a conspiracy!!! J/K...

http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/BlackDudeDiesFirst
 
Back
Top