Video Game Minority Report

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
A recent study has concluded that video games are racist. A professor at USC Annenberg School for Communication supposedly studied the top 150 games in a year and found a lack of minorities in the games. No word on whether aliens, mushrooms, plumbers, cyborgs and monsters are being unfairly depicted. :rolleyes:

The first comprehensive survey of video game characters, encompassing the top 150 games in a year across nine platforms and all rating levels, and weighted by each title's popularity, shows that the video game industry does no better than television in representing American society. In some cases, video games do worse.
 
Fuck. These are the people making society shit. I hope they die.
 
What sort of video games? How many are the ones produced in Japan, compared to the ones made in the states?
 
Someone in marketing or sales will see this as an opportunity. It's all about money at the end anyway!
 
Wait, wasnt there just a shit storm over Resident Evil 5 because there were black people in africa being attacked by zombies?
 
This is like the Resident Evil 5 controversy again. It's just pointless. When a game is in Africa, there are going to be mostly African American people. No one is racist, you are just stupid.
 
Well, damn, while we are on the soapbox over computer games, what's up with all the massively chested women in computer games? Do these ladies get like free boob jobs or what? LOL :eek:
 
Uhm... ??
No.

Uhm... ??
Yes.

There are Africans in Africa. Therefore i you want to properly set a game in Africa you are going to end up showing a lot of Africans.

Please, enlighten us he-who-says-little-with-so-much-meaning- how as the game racist?
 
This is like the Resident Evil 5 controversy again. It's just pointless. When a game is in Africa, there are going to be mostly African American people. No one is racist, you are just stupid.

rofl. please reread what you wrote.
 
OH CRAP!!!!!!!

He said African-American! Oh man- I fail!!!!!

LOL!

Going away now...
 
Uhm... ??
Yes.

There are Africans in Africa. Therefore i you want to properly set a game in Africa you are going to end up showing a lot of Africans.

Please, enlighten us he-who-says-little-with-so-much-meaning- how as the game racist?

There are not African Americans in Africa though, which is what the post said.
 
Uhm... ??
Yes.

There are Africans in Africa. Therefore i you want to properly set a game in Africa you are going to end up showing a lot of Africans.

Please, enlighten us he-who-says-little-with-so-much-meaning- how as the game racist?

LOL they aren't American so they can't be African-American
 
Uhm... ??
Yes.

There are Africans in Africa. Therefore i you want to properly set a game in Africa you are going to end up showing a lot of Africans.

Please, enlighten us he-who-says-little-with-so-much-meaning- how as the game racist?

Africans, yes.

African-americans, no.

The original post stated african-americans. As such it was wrong.
 
The true question in my mind is which is more useless:

A. those that conduct these useless studies
B. the numbnuts that keep giving group A the money to conduct these useless studies...
 
How is that movie, everyone I talk to gives mixed reviews.

I laughed my ass off, but its wrong is SOOOO many ways. If you like dirty humor and the ocasional penis on the big screen go see it.

I could have done without the penis though.
 
As a hardvore gamer I knew the results would be similar to this, but its interesting to see what the numbers ended up looking like. Nobody is really being made out to be a villan here, and the word 'rasist' being in the article may server to distract from the content.
It simply shows that the characters in games reflect the makers of the games more than the players of the games. In any form of art you will find this to be somewhat true. It wont really change all that much unitll more minorities are making the games, are there even any major studios based in hispanic countries? There is definantly money to be made for sombody based on this data. Capitalisim will adjust the ratios soon enough.
 
One thing I never quite liked about L4D was that it was obvious that Louis was just the token black man... :rolleyes:
 
And besides- what about Grand Theft Auto San Andreas- that portrayed minorities! What are they bitching about?
 
The true question in my mind is which is more useless:

A. those that conduct these useless studies
B. the numbnuts that keep giving group A the money to conduct these useless studies...

"Williams received funding for the survey from the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, where he started the research before moving to USC." Looks like the mojority of the fundiing came from students (or thier parents) in the psychology department at the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign.
I doubt a study of 150 games headed by an assistant professor costs all that much and in the field of social psychology the data gathered will be of some use. Don't ge tme wrong, there are some truely useless studies being conducted at univeristies, but im not seeing this as one of the offenders.
 
So when they looked at RPG's or MMORPG's they created a character that was a white english person?

Did they completely ignore the Orks, Elves, Dwarfs, cyborgs, superheroes that can be anything you want, jedi's, stormtroopers (who can be whatever under the armour), robots, and lord knows what else?

Granted a lot of the races are fantasy, but still it's anyone's guess who's on the other end playing as that character.
 
I skimmed the article and what I read alone made me facepalm so hard that I managed to push my hairline back an inch.

GTA4 was ALL about the minorities.
Halo games - you had a little bit of everyone. Yes you played the Master Chief, but so what?
L4D - one black guy and he only dies first if you let it happen.
RE5 - It takes place in Africa and there's a male and female main character. What more do you want?
Rainbow Six Vegas 2 - if you pick the white guy to represent your custom character, that's your damn fault that your race isn't being "represented".
Crackdown - you pick your own race. If you fuck that up, that's your fault.

Video games aren't racist. The video game developers aren't racist either. Its people who sit there and read too much into shit that are racist.

Would I like to see more asians represented in video games as main characters? Its a nice gesture, sure, but I honestly could care less. I play games to have fun, not ponder about what kind of sociological implications are being made in them. If things happen to have equal representation, fine. But it isn't a selling point for me.

White, black, red, yellow or brown, it doesn't matter - you're getting fragged equally in the end.
 
And besides- what about Grand Theft Auto San Andreas- that portrayed minorities! What are they bitching about?

Pretty much everybody in GTA games is a gangster. It says something about what we think about latinos as a society when they pretty much only appear in games where there is gang violence and car tuning and nobody thinks there is any need for improvement. Like is said in a previous post, capitalisim will take over and there will be studios in latin countries putting out games with hispanics in more realistic non-steriotyped scenarios soon enough.
Dmitri Williams is just showing the tuth and is not pasing judgement anywhere in the article. I can see how that could be a problem for anybody.
 
Women, Native Americans, children and the elderly also were underrepresented. For example, only 10 percent of playable characters surveyed were female, though women now make up 40 percent of video game players.

1) They should break it up by genre--RPGs tend to allow women main characters or party members.

2) What game are the other 39.9% playing because I'm not seeing 40% representation in anything I play (as long males playing as females in MMORPGs are counted as males.)

African-Americans appeared in proportion to their numbers in the real world, but mainly in sports games and in titles that reinforce stereotypes, such as 50 Cent Bulletproof.

Maybe the games like 50 Cent Bulletproof are stereotyping black people because the developer and publisher think that marketing towards a stereotype will increase sales. Kind of like, oh, I don't know, rap music? :rolleyes:
 
One other thing, every time I see an Asian male with sunglasses and a sneer on his face, I look for a create to hide behind because I know a boss battle is coming. :D
 
I'd say the elderly were well represented in MGS4!!!

I've never seen an old mofo that badass before.
 
TheArticle said:
Williams noted that some newer games give players more options for customizing their characters. Those games were included in the survey, with characters chosen randomly.

wtf? Yeah so we had the option to play what we wanted, but because instead of doing that we chose to just click random.

TheArticle said:
"Ironically, they may even be less likely to become game makers themselves, helping to perpetuate the cycle. Many have suggested that games function as crucial gatekeepers for interest in science, technology, engineering and math."
Yes, the reason "minorities" can't get good jobs is now because of video games. Seriously? I'm sitting 5 feet from a guy who's mom said he shouldn't even bother to go to college. He's hispanic and has is Mechanical Engineering degree, man those video games sure hosed him. :rolleyes:


Then I saw this:

TheArticle said:
African-Americans appeared in proportion to their numbers in the real world, but mainly in sports games and in titles that reinforce stereotypes, such as 50 Cent Bulletproof.
Your mad that they didn't put more white people in a video game about gangs?

Which was a little bit after this:
By contrast, fewer than 3 percent of video game characters were recognizably Hispanic, and all of them were non-playable, background characters.

And how exactly did you miss the main character from GTA: San Andreas?

Furthermore do you realize that a significant amount of the games we play are imports from Japan where get this, where over 99% of the people are Japaneese which means they are 99% white? :rolleyes:
 
I'd say the elderly were well represented in MGS4!!!

I've never seen an old mofo that badass before.

LOL! yeah, cause we all know 90 year olds play soo many video games! Furthermore, they make perfect sense to be your star quarterback too!
 
There's nothing like shouting racism to turn a non-issue into a public and political sandstorm.
 
Although I'm glad that so many people here are defending the credibility of the medium, the fact of the matter is that many videogames are actually relatively racist, especially in their portrayals of minority groups. The difference is that this racism is a subtle thing and rarely manifests itself as overt acts of aggression. In many ways, games tend to be better than other forms of media, but still fall into some of the same pitfalls. These include:

1) Invisibilising. This is probably the number one sin of all games, and media for that matter. Despite the fact that non-whites make up as much as 20-30% of people in the United States and Canada (much more in many other places), there are very few minorities seen in videogames, especially in leading roles. Non-whites are much more likely to be sidekicks rather than protagonists, and tend to be villains as well (though not necessarily the "big bads").

2) Stereotyping. Probably the second biggest problem in games and certainly the most apparent and obvious. Simply, when non-white characters are portrayed in games, they are almost always stereotypical caricatures. Archetypes like the black thug and the Asian nerd/scientist instantly come to mind. The important thing to remember is that while these stereotypical portrayals are not necessarily negative in and of themselves, by relying on them we rarely if ever see a diverse cast of characters; they homogenise our perceptions of these people. There are definitely exceptions (EA and Ubisoft both get points for making games with strong non-white protagonists and supporting characters that don't rely on stereotypes), and things are improving, but we still have a long way to go.

3) Ornamentalising. This one is not as common in videogames as it is in TV, but is still present. Essentially, this treats minority groups as scenery, giving them tiny, unimportant parts to give the impression of inclusion while rarely giving them significant contributions.

4) Whitewashing. This one doesn't really exist extensively in videogames, but it's still worth pointing out. Essentially this is the projecting of "white" traits onto non-white characters, and ascribing their success to those white traits. A great example is the ghetto thug who turns away from his life of crime by going to university. The point to this one is that non-white characters can rarely stand on their own merits and must adopt the majority's to gain acceptance. Louis from Left 4 Dead comes to mind, but that's debatable and there aren't too many other examples I can think of.

There are a couple of other ways that racism proliferates in the mainstream media, including videogames, but these are the ones that are most obvious and perhaps the most negative. Simply put, videogames rarely acknowledge non-white culture, lifestyle, etc. and when they do they usually rely on negative stereotypes in order to do it. This is a very fine line to walk - I don't want to say that just because a game uses a stereotype, it is racist, or that just because a game lacks non-white characters it is offensive. For example, depicting significant numbers of African-Americans in a World War II game makes little sense due to the segregation at the time. However, by limiting the number of images we show others and see ourselves, we create for ourselves perceptual frameworks that lead to prejudice - and while debatable, I would suggest that all prejudice is negative in nature.

Of course, this doesn't even begin to touch on sexism, sexuality, classism, ableism, and ageism in games, which are possibly even bigger problems these days. In any case, there is tons of reading that you can do on the subjects. I highly suggest avoiding knee-jerk reactions to many of these claims, because usually those are made due to a lack of full understanding of the discussion.
 
A professor at USC Annenberg School for Communication

Isn't that the equivalent of being a janitor of a real university like Harvard?

I'm sure my elementary school Janitor would love to weigh in on this issue as well, we should ask him. Maybe he will suggest that the next main character in Diablo 3 be a minority janitor of some sort?

I think it could work...:rolleyes:
 
<sigh>
More specious, "1+1=3" research.....


Williams noted that some newer games give players more options for customizing their characters. Those games were included in the survey, with characters chosen randomly.
The fact that random selection did not have a major impact on the results suggests that when players have a choice, their range of options is limited.

More like:
The fact that random selection did not have a major impact on the results suggests that when players have a choice, they chose to play non-minority characters.

The article states an important fact:
The study itself was limited in two important ways. Many games feature non-human characters, and many are first-person games where the player never sees himself or herself. The study only included visible characters that were clearly human.

But then strays off the fact path and on to the opinion path:
"Still, the breadth of the census and the growing popularity of video games make the findings especially relevant."

Says who?
Aside from the number of games (150), no figures are cited as to how many game players were involved or any demographics regarding the study group. What are stats on the age, ethnicity of the players, etc.?

At least one of the study's authors was honest:
In their study, the authors discuss possible reasons for their findings. But Williams cautioned against jumping to conclusions. "The characters the developers put in the games do not match the real world," he said. "Our thoughts about why are all informed guesses."
 
4) Whitewashing. This one doesn't really exist extensively in videogames, but it's still worth pointing out. Essentially this is the projecting of "white" traits onto non-white characters, and ascribing their success to those white traits. A great example is the ghetto thug who turns away from his life of crime by going to university. The point to this one is that non-white characters can rarely stand on their own merits and must adopt the majority's to gain acceptance. Louis from Left 4 Dead comes to mind, but that's debatable and there aren't too many other examples I can think of.
Go find a soap box to preach from. When part of your arguement starts "This one doesn't really exist extensively in videogames, but it's still worth pointing out." it means you are no longer on topic.
 
Back
Top