Bizarre graphics problem - visible seams in all games.

Joined
Jul 3, 2008
Messages
53
After a year of dealing with this issue, I am stumped. At first, I thought it was a quirk of my old card, or perhaps underperformance brought on by a poor PSU. Evidence is now showing me that neither one of those is correct.

In any and all games, objects have extremely visible seams when viewed from a distance. On a darkly colored object, these typically appear white, on a lightly colored object, these appear dark gray or black. As the camera approaches an object, the lines fade and eventually disappear as the camera draws close. Anti-aliasing somewhat reduces the appearance of the lines, but cannot eliminate it. A few rare lines are extremely stubborn, appearing even at point blank range. Depending on the camera angle, only bits of lines may show through at the edges, producing a static-like effect along the edge, a broken line or dots.

Now we hit the weird part.

All temperatures in my case are well below normal. I use an antec 900, my cable management while not the most awesome thanks to the old-revision 900's lack of cable management options is as good as it can get in the case, and temps always fall well below standard. As of last week, the system is running on a power supply well above its needs.

Absolutely nothing is overclocked. In fact, underclocking the GPU doesn't help either.

Now the really weird part.

This has happened on 4 separate video cards in the same system. Whatever video card I put in there makes no difference, I have now tested with 2 ATI cards and 2 Nvidia cards in the same system, and still the lines appear. I've tested with a completely fresh windows xp install, absolutely nothing works.

If anyone has any suggestions at all as to what could be causing this, they'd be very much appreciated. My current build is in my sig.
 
can u name some specific games it happening in? and screenshots?
 
Either Screenshots or these "lines" are just side effects of those pills you take.

:)
 
Depends on the monitor you use. Is it just with the new card or did it occur before. Some large monitors are basically 4 panels stuck together and seams can be seen. I see it on my 52 inch aquos. Called Banding. Not sure if this is what you are experiencing.
 
Agreed, try a different monitor or provide us with a screenshot as we may be able to diagnose it..
 
Last edited:
The lines appear in every game I have that uses 3d acceleration, including World of Warcraft, Team Fortress 2, Bioshock, The Sims 2, Half-Life 2...to a greater or lesser extent it appears in all of them. As I said in my original post, this has persisted across 4 cards that I've either owned or tested with.

These are:
ATI x1950 512mb
XFX Nvidia 8800GT 512mb Black Dog (Zalman cooler version)
HIS ATI 4870 512mb
XFX Nvidia 9800 GTX+ 512mb

The nature of the problem makes it a bit hard to capture in screenshots. The lines change rapidly as I move, often being hard to pin down into a screenshot. That said, there's some screenshots from World of Warcraft that are the best I've managed to do so far. You'll need to view them at full size to see what I'm talking about.

Please note that the examples are far more obvious and "pop" more visually when seen in motion. There were also usually other examples of the lines in most shots, the ones I call attention to are just the ones I managed to capture in the still.

EXAMPLE 1

http://i67.photobucket.com/albums/h282/LuminousAlchemy/example1a.jpg

In this far-away shot, note Ophera Windfury in the middle towards the back (you'll need to view the image at full size). There's a white line running down the center of her dress. You might at first think this is part of the detail, but zooming in...

http://i67.photobucket.com/albums/h282/LuminousAlchemy/example1b.jpg

We can now see that her dress contains no center seam, and is dark all the way down in the center.

EXAMPLE 2

http://i67.photobucket.com/albums/h282/LuminousAlchemy/example2a.jpg

The next stable image came from our dead friend in front of the Temple. I've circled the obvious line, bisecting his boot along the side.

http://i67.photobucket.com/albums/h282/LuminousAlchemy/example2b.jpg

Zooming in, once again the white line disappears.

EXAMPLE 3

Finally, while an up-close view usually erases the lines, there are some very stubborn examples, like this one from my character select screen. The line has been circled, on the glove of my shaman's right hand.

http://i67.photobucket.com/albums/h282/LuminousAlchemy/example3.jpg

EXAMPLE 4

Finally, an example of some bisecting lines that are strangely resistant to zooming in, appearing clearly even up close.

http://i67.photobucket.com/albums/h282/LuminousAlchemy/example4.jpg

Note that for this last example, Anti-Aliasing was set to 8x...so while it reduces somewhat the appearance of these lines to turn up AA, it by no means gets rid of them and has no effect at all on many of them.

Circular textures/objects such as this one are particularly prone to the lines, this 4-way pie sectioned appearance pops up constantly on circular objects. The tops of mushrooms in Zangarmarsh, circular gems in the environment detailing in Ulduar.

In the Sims 2, for example, when viewed from a comfortable, average mid distance, most furniture is bisected by a white line through the center which again, disappears when viewed up close. Characters hairstyles are likewise often split straight down the center by a white line in the mid distance, again also disappearing up close.
 
I don't see anything.
Edit: Wait nevermind I see it. Kind of...
 
Depends on the monitor you use. Is it just with the new card or did it occur before. Some large monitors are basically 4 panels stuck together and seams can be seen. I see it on my 52 inch aquos. Called Banding. Not sure if this is what you are experiencing.

Not in this case. The seams are oriented on objects in 3d accelerated games, not on the screen itself. It's weird, I haven't yet come across anyone describing artifacting or etc. resembling this.

For the record, the monitor is an HP w1907.
 
Last edited:
I don't see anything.
Edit: Wait nevermind I see it. Kind of...

Like I said, it's hard to pin down in a screenshot, the lines are much more visible within the games. Make sure when looking you zoom in to the full size.

The lines should be extremely obvious in example 4. On a normal image, the green circle that dominates the center of the image should not be divided into 4 parts like that.
 
What are the things (hardware/software/drivers) which each configuration has in common?
 
Have you been using the same monitor with all four different gpus that you tested?
 
What are the things (hardware/software/drivers) which each configuration has in common?

With the exception of video card, all hardware has remained the same as it currently is in my sig. I've tried a variety of drivers both old and current, problem remains the same. The only exception to this is that my power supply used to be a BFG 650w. It's a terrible unit with greatly exaggurated amps on the 12v combined, and I was hoping that the switch to a better PSU would have a shot at resolving the problem, but no dice. Problem present with old PSU and new PSU.

Have you been using the same monitor with all four different gpus that you tested?

Yes. Like I said though, the issue involves object textures and their seams, especially anywhere a texture is mirrored or repeated across a symmetrical object (though there are exceptions). In no case is it centered around a particular area of the screen. Unless there's something I'm missing, I doubt the monitor could be the cause.
 
Try downclocking your RAM and/or loosening the timings.

That's one thing I hadn't tried yet. I've never messed with RAM timings / clocks before though, always ran stock. Is there a good source/tutorial on how to do that / what timings to try?
 
Go into your BIOS, go to the Advanced tab, then JumperFree Configuration, and finally DRAM frequency. Change to DDR2-667MHz. Now go to DRAM Timing Control and change CAS# Latency to 6, RAS# to CAS# Delay to 6, RAS# Precharge to 6, and RAS# Activate to Precharge to 18. Save and exit and try your games.
 
Go into your BIOS, go to the Advanced tab, then JumperFree Configuration, and finally DRAM frequency. Change to DDR2-667MHz. Now go to DRAM Timing Control and change CAS# Latency to 6, RAS# to CAS# Delay to 6, RAS# Precharge to 6, and RAS# Activate to Precharge to 18. Save and exit and try your games.

I put all settings per your instructions. On save and reboot, computer failed to post. Sat there with power on, but no display at all. After reset I get a post, and a Overclock Failed message. Choosing to reset to defaults allowed me to get back into a normal boot and into windows.
 
Try it again and this time also go to DRAM Voltage and change to 2.10V. I have no idea why your computer wouldn't post with the settings above... any set of DDR2 should be able to run that.

Also, try 5-5-5-18 this time instead of 6-6-6-18.
 
If that doesn't work, try removing two sticks of RAM and see if that fixes the problem.
 
Try it again and this time also go to DRAM Voltage and change to 2.10V. I have no idea why your computer wouldn't post with the settings above... any set of DDR2 should be able to run that.

Also, try 5-5-5-18 this time instead of 6-6-6-18.

The plot thickens on this one. I bought these 4 sticks a couple of months apart, 2 sticks at a time. My friendly neighborhood computer store assured me they were the same sticks.

In retrospect, I should have examined closer.

Here's the info off the original 2 sticks.

T800UB1GC5
1GB DDR2-800
PC6400
Blue Heatspreader 64MX8
CL5
MM#9306

Those were in channel A. Examining the 2 sticks I got later...

T800UX2G4C4
2GB Kit
DDR-800
PC6400
64MX8
4-4-3-8

I'm thinking I should probably take out the older sticks, move the newer ones into channel A and see what happens.
 
the T800UB1GC5 (silver stick) supports 5-5-4-12 and 5-5-5-15

i would say (if you want both sticks) try the 5-5-5-15

and i can see from an OC review of the seconed set (T800UX2G4C4) that they will post at 5-5-5-12 (so 5-5-5-12 or 5-5-5-15 shouldnt be an issue)
 
Sadly, as interesting as this revelation is, I've put the 2nd set of ram in with default settings (Auto) on ram freq. and timings, and the problem hasn't changed. I'll try an adjust on the ram in the bios and see if that produces any changes.
 
Update: With only the 2nd set of sticks installed, system will post and boot into windows at 667Mhz and 6-6-6-18. Problem, however, is unchanged.
 
i just think it has something to do with the low resolution you are operating at.

as has been suggested in this thread i would try a different monitor, preferably one that is capable of 1920x1200 resolution or higher.


got any better examples other than wow?
 
That fact that it shows in his screenshots should indicate it's not the monitor. The only other thing I can think of is the motherboard, but that's a long shot. Next thing I would do is create a new partition and try installing the Windows 7 RC. The graphics subsystem has been reworked in Windows 7.
 
i just think it has something to do with the low resolution you are operating at.

as has been suggested in this thread i would try a different monitor, preferably one that is capable of 1920x1200 resolution or higher.


got any better examples other than wow?

I'm working on some very clear screenshots that show the phenomenon in The Sims 2, but trying to show them is proving difficult with how much a free photobucket account degrades the image. I'm searching for a way to get full quality images up, I'll post them if I can manage to do that.

Unfortunately, this is the only monitor I have access to atm. The previous monitor was a 15" craptastic lcd with some ridiculously high latency that was so dim by the time I managed to replace it that I junked it, and that wouldn't do higher res at any rate. The res I'm currently running at is the monitor's native, 1440x900.

I've thought of trying to update the motherboard's bios, but something with that much brick potential I'm a little wary of doing out of warranty unless all other options fail. In theory it has that "crash-free" bios but I've mostly heard reports that its reliability and usability is spotty at best.

I actually have a spare partition already set up for just such an occasion as 7 or possibly testing an RC candidate. That particular endeavor...OS install, driver install, and game install...would likely take the rest of the afternoon, but at this point I'm willing to try just about anything.

The thought of forking out for windows 7 in the RSN future though...well, here's hoping I find another solution.

EDIT: As an addendum, SpeedFan reports what could be considered dodgy numbers, with Vcore at 1.32V and +12V at 11.40V, but the general impression I've gotten is that software power readings aren't to be trusted, and the BIOS puts the +12V at 12.X.
 
Last edited:
Alright, here's some high quality images from The Sims 2 to give a very clear picture of the problem as it is on the average.

Once again, make sure you zoom into full size for all of these.

EXAMPLE 1

http://yfrog.com/10example1cp

Okay, for these examples, the viewer should pay attention to 2 spots. First, the red display pedestals in the store area on the lower right. This is at the maximum view distance, and we can very clearly see them split in two down the center by white lines. Secondly, notice the high amount of white lines/dots/visual noise around the rods of the front porch railing, towards the right hand side of the porch. These seem a bit more innocuous at first, but we'll be seeing more of them in the following shots, and in all cases this noise pops and shimmers making it far more obvious in motion. There's also some visible seams on the houses of the other lots, but with the aggressive Level of Detail being used on those that's neither particularly here nor there.

EXAMPLE 2

http://yfrog.com/0oexample2xp

Mid-distance shot. The lines bisecting the red display pedestals have faded, but are still visible. White noise on the front porch railing still visible.

EXAMPLE 3

http://yfrog.com/ehexample3p

Closer shot. Line on closest pedestal has almost completely disappeared. Others are growing more faint. Static on the vertical rods of the front porch railing have somewhat cleared up, but at this distance those on which the noise remains are even more visible, standing out sharply as noise against the darkness of the porch.

EXAMPLE 4

http://yfrog.com/ehexample4p

Very close range shot. Lines have completely vanished from the pedestals.

http://yfrog.com/ehexample4bp

Shifting over to the porch railing. Most of the noise has disappeared, however on 2 of the rods the noise remains stubbornly very visible. In motion, the pillars that show the noise shift as the camera pans from left to right.

All images taken at 1440x900, with smoothing set to max.

There are some lines that remain completely visible no matter what range I view them at. This seems to be more the exception than the rule, however.
 
Last edited:
You sure it's not just the render detailed distance? I remember on wow and others unless u set it far enough out it seemed like u had an invisible seam u alwys were runnng to.
 
You sure it's not just the render detailed distance? I remember on wow and others unless u set it far enough out it seemed like u had an invisible seam u alwys were runnng to.

This possibility is kind of knocked out by seeing it in motion. LoD settings, if any, have no effect on the appearance of the lines. There are also enough lines that appear regardless of distance as in some of the examples. (World of Warcraft Example 4 on the first page.
 
check the freq/refresh rate of video card and on the monitor itself. Ensure they are set to the same number(usually 60htz)
 
Am I the only one who thinks this is just due to a lack of AA and a low resolution? I see nothing indicative of any errors per se, these look like shitty texture issues.
 
Am I the only one who thinks this is just due to a lack of AA and a low resolution? I see nothing indicative of any errors per se, these look like shitty texture issues.

If 8x AA isn't enough to squash it...there's a problem.

I suppose that this could be an issue with AA being poor...but then, if AA is that poor at highest settings, I'm back to square one with trying to figure out what is causing the problem.
 
Alright, here's some high quality images from The Sims 2 to give a very clear picture of the problem as it is on the average.

Once again, make sure you zoom into full size for all of these.

EXAMPLE 1

http://yfrog.com/10example1cp

Okay, for these examples, the viewer should pay attention to 2 spots. First, the red display pedestals in the store area on the lower right. This is at the maximum view distance, and we can very clearly see them split in two down the center by white lines. Secondly, notice the high amount of white lines/dots/visual noise around the rods of the front porch railing, towards the right hand side of the porch. These seem a bit more innocuous at first, but we'll be seeing more of them in the following shots, and in all cases this noise pops and shimmers making it far more obvious in motion. There's also some visible seams on the houses of the other lots, but with the aggressive Level of Detail being used on those that's neither particularly here nor there.

EXAMPLE 2

http://yfrog.com/0oexample2xp

Mid-distance shot. The lines bisecting the red display pedestals have faded, but are still visible. White noise on the front porch railing still visible.

EXAMPLE 3

http://yfrog.com/ehexample3p

Closer shot. Line on closest pedestal has almost completely disappeared. Others are growing more faint. Static on the vertical rods of the front porch railing have somewhat cleared up, but at this distance those on which the noise remains are even more visible, standing out sharply as noise against the darkness of the porch.

EXAMPLE 4

http://yfrog.com/ehexample4p

Very close range shot. Lines have completely vanished from the pedestals.

http://yfrog.com/ehexample4bp

Shifting over to the porch railing. Most of the noise has disappeared, however on 2 of the rods the noise remains stubbornly very visible. In motion, the pillars that show the noise shift as the camera pans from left to right.

All images taken at 1440x900, with smoothing set to max.

There are some lines that remain completely visible no matter what range I view them at. This seems to be more the exception than the rule, however.

This is normal (which is why you see it on every game you play, with every video card imaginable). All 3D graphics software has errors in it, AND all 3D graphics is an approximation using polygonal meshes and floating-point shaders.

The effect where you see white lines bisecting models is called a clipping error. Two polygon edges are supposed to align exactly, but due to a simple calculation error (or could be engine error, modeler error, or even video driver error), you see a white line visible between the polygons. It can be worse when you are far away because the accuracy of a floating-point Z value decreases as the magnitude of the distance gets larger.

The "noisy" errors on the edges of the railings are probably aliasing errors (increase your AA level), but may also be errors in the shadow model of the game engine.

Just consider yourself lucky that errors like this are so rare today. In times past, clipping errors were quite common due to different accuracies in the Z-buffer with different video cards.
 
This is normal. All 3D graphics software has errors in it, AND all 3D graphics is an approximation usinf polygonal meshes and shaders.

The effect where you see white lines bisecting models is called a clipping error. Two polygon edges are supposed to align exactly, but due to an engine error, modeler error, or even video driver error, you see a white line visible between the polygons.

The "noisy" errors on the edges of the railings are probably aliasing errors (increase your AA level), but may also be errors in the shadow model of the game engine.

Just consider yourself lucky that errors like this are so rare today. In times past, clipping errors were quite common due to different accuracies in the Z-buffer with different video cards.

Your explanation makes sense...there's just a couple of things bugging me about it.

1. I can distinctly recall a time when I didn't have these errors.

2. Those examples from Sims 2? Maximum AA settings.

3. The odd examples that remain consistant at extremely close range. (The last of the world of warcraft examples on page 1).
 
I can't find a way to blame hardware on this. Seems like some sort of driver setting. I remember playing Resident Evil 2 and Final Fantasy 7 with some driver tweaks and getting similar results. Have you done any driver tweaking in the nVidia control panel?
 
I can't find a way to blame hardware on this. Seems like some sort of driver setting. I remember playing Resident Evil 2 and Final Fantasy 7 with some driver tweaks and getting similar results. Have you done any driver tweaking in the nVidia control panel?

I've experimented with a lot of the different settings...aa transparency, lod bias, filtering quality, trilinear optimization, turning triple buffer on/off, texture clamp...none of them has had any particular effect. I've tried old drivers, new drivers, tweaked drivers...I've been trying to figure this one out for some time now.

On a side note...I'm not sure if WoW just has awful ingame AA settings or what...forcing 16xQ via drivers has me sitting in Dalaran with a steady 40C on the GPU...4x from within the game was netting me 44-45C under the same conditions. Does help increase the distance the camera can go before the textures start to break up, though something about those circular objects still holds tightly onto the lines...

EDIT: Trying the same thing with Sims 2 however, caused the first BSOD I've ever witnessed on this system. Le sigh...
 
Last edited:
Back
Top