The Decade's 25 Biggest Tech Flops

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Here we go again, another “biggest tech flops” of the decade article. At least the list has a picture with some boobs in it. Mmmmm, boobs.

Before we get to the list, let's get the parameters straight. This isn't a list of all the most spectacular tech failures. I chose to exclude dot-coms, corporate debacles (AOL-Time Warner), search engines (i.e., Cuil), and assorted other Web 2.0 flame outs (I'll let Webware handle that). No, this is a roundup of gear, the stuff that turns on and off, the stuff I've been covering for almost 10 years at CNET (yes, I started in 2000).
 
*considers the irony of a website claiming to know our "biggest technical flops" not loading.*
 
I almost made it to the second slide before getting annoyed with the slideshow format and closing the window. Thanks, CNet!
 
I almost made it to the second slide before getting annoyed with the slideshow format and closing the window. Thanks, CNet!

Yeah, agreed.

I went through 10 of them and it was such a bitch I just closed it.

lol @ DC being #1 though, along with those silly sony robot dogs. I'll get a real dog, thanks.
 
media center? satellite radio?

Those 2 really don't seem to belong on that list
 
Since the list includes a few technologies that are just not taking off that quickly, like HD Radio. Shouldn't Blu-Ray also be on the list?
 
yeah just took like 8 reloads and then the slide was being lame. Probably traffic. Anyway I disagreed with about 15 of the 25 big flops. Comparing N64 to dreamcast Id still pick dreamcast. If something is still in production or on hold like SED then its not exactly a flop is it?
 
Media center? WTF?

You know what I think has been the biggest flop of the last decade? Tech Journalism (hell, journalism in general). Top 5/10/25 articles are fail.
 
1. Dreamcast
2. Standalone DVD Recorder
3. Sony Aibo
4. DVD Audio/SACD
5. Modo
6. Media Center
7. Satellite Radio
8. Sony MicroMV
9. Segway
10. Tapwave Zodiac
11. HD Radio
12. Nokia N-Gage
13. Microsoft SPOT Smart Watches
14. UMD
15. CableCard
16. SED Flat Panel TV
17. Location Free TV
18. Gizmondo
19. Palm Lifedrive
20. Gameboy Micro
21. ROKR E1
22. HD DVD
23. Sony Mylo
24. UMPC
25. Pam Foleo
 
Honestly, how is Satellite Radio a failure? I love it. FM Radio sounds like crap, I can't listen to it anymore.
HD Radio is about the only option different, but wait... They mark that as a failure, too. So do they suggest us going back to Ham radios or ?????

HD-DVD was the only other one that stood out. It didn't really fail, it just didn't have the studio backing.

Other than that, anyone notice how many Sony products made the list? :p
 
Honestly, how is Satellite Radio a failure? I love it. FM Radio sounds like crap, I can't listen to it anymore.
HD Radio is about the only option different, but wait... They mark that as a failure, too. So do they suggest us going back to Ham radios or ?????

HD-DVD was the only other one that stood out. It didn't really fail, it just didn't have the studio backing.

I think the struggling financial status of satellite radio providers mark that up as a failing. I think their definitions of failure try (even try to define flop is terrible) be more along the lines of adoption and future viability of the product rather than the quality of the product. I know I loved my dreamcast and it would've been nice to have better digital audio with dvd-a, but sometimes things just don't work out.

As for HD-DVD I think if you can't garner support then that would be called a failure.

Media Center is my only question for this as it seems more and more people seem to be looking into 7mc, but its hard to say as this is one of the few forums I visit.
 
Yeah, Sony is a big scorer on the list.
At that time when Dreamcast came, I thought it to become much more popular than it did, sadly it had too few titles and was quite late for the console wars back then.
Segway is also something that was much hyped, though it seems still to bee ridiculous and too futuristic. :D
 
The Folio is a really sad story. Had Palm actually thought to make it fully WiFi capable (some of the software didn't work through wifi) and not just something that synchs to a Treo and uses cell data for a connection... this would have been a hit, I think. It was exactly what I wanted before the Asus Eee was announced and the 'Netbooks' started popping up. I still think it's better designed than most of the netbooks currently out there... and we are just now starting to see similar, but ARM based, subnetbooks being announced now.

Hell of a missed opportunity. Wouldn't mind getting ahold of one of those things, though.
 
As for HD-DVD I think if you can't garner support then that would be called a failure.

BluRay actually looked to be the failure until "undisclosed sums" swayed the last 3 studios over exclusively to the format. HDDVD had several exclusive studios and some that were supporting both that and BluRay. Deep pockets won here, not format superiority. HDDVD at the time was a far, far more mature format with a better price range. It also had some very nice features, well, for consumers... it's probably one of the many reasons why studios couldn't or wouldn't stay on for it... but Region coding was NOT part of HDDVD.
 
The Folio is a really sad story. Had Palm actually thought to make it fully WiFi capable (some of the software didn't work through wifi) and not just something that synchs to a Treo and uses cell data for a connection... this would have been a hit, I think. It was exactly what I wanted before the Asus Eee was announced and the 'Netbooks' started popping up. I still think it's better designed than most of the netbooks currently out there... and we are just now starting to see similar, but ARM based, subnetbooks being announced now.

ARM based netbooks will never be able to take off. Netbooks have enough of a performance disadvantage as it is. Removing their ability to run x86 code for slightly improved battery life is not a plus no matter how you want to twist it.

Deep pockets won here, not format superiority.

Waaa. For better or worse that's how the world works. Blu Ray currently offers equal features and higher capacity, and its always had higher mandatory audio and video bitrates than HD DVD, the extra features like ethernet are pointless, IMO.

I'm just glad the format war is over.
 
I actually like Media Center. And I have a stand alone DVD recorder as well. It is actually a DVR-DVD-VCR all-in-one from Panasonic. And I use it all the time.
 
1. Dreamcast
2. Standalone DVD Recorder
3. Sony Aibo
4. DVD Audio/SACD
5. Modo
6. Media Center
7. Satellite Radio
8. Sony MicroMV
9. Segway
10. Tapwave Zodiac
11. HD Radio
12. Nokia N-Gage
13. Microsoft SPOT Smart Watches
14. UMD
15. CableCard
16. SED Flat Panel TV
17. Location Free TV
18. Gizmondo
19. Palm Lifedrive
20. Gameboy Micro
21. ROKR E1
22. HD DVD
23. Sony Mylo
24. UMPC
25. Pam Foleo

thanks for the break down, damn CNET sucks!
 
I love my Dreamcast!

I hope Sega makes another quirky console. :)
 
Media Center just keeps getting better. I use it exclusively in my bedroom for TV/media. Once a good HD alternative to Cable Card is available, I'm ditching my DVR, and adding a Media Center PC to the living room. The biggest problem with Cable Card is you have to buy a prebuilt PC with the Cable Card tuner. Those morons at Cable Labs won't let AMD sell to anyone but approved vendors. Any one of us could build a system that would beat those approved systems in price, performance, and customized case. I mean, really, most of them are standard PC cases. Like I'm gonna put that in my living room.

Satellite radio - it ain't dead yet. I don't know if it will make it or not, but I wouldn't call it a flop by any means. The people that I know who subscribe wouldn't live without it.

Cable Card - If Cable Labs will stop trying to micro manage who and what uses it, it would take off in a big way. Think about it. You decide what hardware you want to use without having to rely on some provider's crappy box/software.
 
Only one I ever owned was Standalone DVD recorder. First one was a Panasonic ES15 which died after 2 years, and now I have a Toshiba DVR560. They are not difficult to use, maybe for Joe Schmoe. At least you own the unit instead of having to rent Cable/Sat DVR boxes.
 
Only one I ever owned was Standalone DVD recorder. First one was a Panasonic ES15 which died after 2 years, and now I have a Toshiba DVR560. They are not difficult to use, maybe for Joe Schmoe. At least you own the unit instead of having to rent Cable/Sat DVR boxes.

My old ladys folks are not the most computer savvy people around so they use a standalone dvd recorder to make dvd movies of what they film on the camcorder so I see a real use for the standalone dvd recorders.
 
Super Audio CD's sounds absolutely amazing if you have the right sound system to play them on, but most people don't.
 
Do these people ever even know what they are talking about in teh slight?

Media center does NOT replace your cable / satellite box. It isn't suppose to.

It is to allow you to watch and record shows on your computer.

they also didn't add it to all versions of Vista or 7 either, only certain editions.
 
Couldn't make it to #3. I do wish in time we will have better TV/HD tuner's.

I had the same problem trying to go from page to page, had to refresh it a few times to view them. after awhile i gave up as the list looked like crap to me.
 
Super Audio CD's sounds absolutely amazing if you have the right sound system to play them on, but most people don't.

Most people don't care or are willfully ignorant about audio. Nearly everything people listen to now are lossy mp3s that they claim sound as good as a CD (which itself is generally inferior to vinyl or SACD). What crap.
 
BluRay actually looked to be the failure until "undisclosed sums" swayed the last 3 studios over exclusively to the format. HDDVD had several exclusive studios and some that were supporting both that and BluRay. Deep pockets won here, not format superiority. HDDVD at the time was a far, far more mature format with a better price range. It also had some very nice features, well, for consumers... it's probably one of the many reasons why studios couldn't or wouldn't stay on for it... but Region coding was NOT part of HDDVD.

Well I'm assuming you didn't disagree with me, but HD-DVD in hindsight is a sure failure since its all but dead now, and yes I too would have preferred HD-DVD to win.
 
Well I'm assuming you didn't disagree with me, but HD-DVD in hindsight is a sure failure since its all but dead now, and yes I too would have preferred HD-DVD to win.

At the time I would have preferred HD-DVD to win since it was a mature standard when it launched while Blu Ray came out half finished. That said, I'm happy now that Blu Ray won out. All the bugs have long since shaken out and it is as functional as HD-DVD was, but on top of that you have a format that is more physically durable with significantly higher storage capacity. This means less compression for video and lossless audio, the latter of which was never practical on HD-DVD due to its storage constraints.

Blu Ray was a mess when it came out but having both formats being mature at this point, I think the better format by virtue of its storage capacity won out.
 
Well I'm assuming you didn't disagree with me, but HD-DVD in hindsight is a sure failure since its all but dead now, and yes I too would have preferred HD-DVD to win.

Well, I guess if one could argue with the Popularity and Support standpoint, I could see Satellite Radio and HDDVD being on this list.

But as actual tech failures? They are not.
 
Back
Top