Clarification on Silverlight XBL Dashboard Ads

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Major Nelson has posted a little info on the pseudo-controversy over Microsoft’s plans to bring Silverlight ads to LIVE.

I’ve seen quite a bit of discussion today about how we’re bringing Silverlight ads to LIVE in the future. I need to let you know that you don’t need to worry about a huge influx of ads across the dashboard. One of our core principles is to enhance, not interfere with the gaming experience, and we work directly with our partners to only deliver experiences that are relevant to the LIVE community. Silverlight will help make those ads a more organic part of the dashboard, like we’ve done with some of the NXE slots in the past. No one on the team wants to turn the dashboard into something that looks like Shibuya Crossing. That’s just not good for anyone.
 
awesome, let me pay for a service, then start putting ads on it. It's freaking cable TV all over again.
 
awesome, let me pay for a service, then start putting ads on it. It's freaking cable TV all over again.

I paided $20 last week for two tickets to the movies, date night for the wife and me. Guess what, there were Ads before the movie started.

I pay around $80/month for DirecTV, lots of ads there.

I have multiple magazine subscriptions, complete with lots of Ads.

Since when does subscription = no ads?

Aren't some ads, targeted and relevant ads, actually a good thing? How many of us used to buy that big ass phonebook sized Computer Shopper specifically for the Ads?

If XBL does this in a reasonable, not intrusive manner, how is it any different than a magazine or other subscription media service?
 
I was banging the wife of some Microsoft guy and she had a Trojan Condoms advertisement on here arse. I liked how it lit up the room. Cool stuff those adds.:D
 
I paided $20 last week for two tickets to the movies, date night for the wife and me. Guess what, there were Ads before the movie started.

I pay around $80/month for DirecTV, lots of ads there.

I have multiple magazine subscriptions, complete with lots of Ads.

Since when does subscription = no ads?

Aren't some ads, targeted and relevant ads, actually a good thing? How many of us used to buy that big ass phonebook sized Computer Shopper specifically for the Ads?

If XBL does this in a reasonable, not intrusive manner, how is it any different than a magazine or other subscription media service?


WHAT A CROCK....

....You didn't pay $20 to see a movie, that was just to get in. Add in your two drinks and a small popcorn and that's another $20. :D
 
WHAT A CROCK....

....You didn't pay $20 to see a movie, that was just to get in. Add in your two drinks and a small popcorn and that's another $20. :D

Thats why your pants have pockets and the girl carries a purse, you dont have to buy food there.
 
WHAT A CROCK....

....You didn't pay $20 to see a movie, that was just to get in. Add in your two drinks and a small popcorn and that's another $20. :D

Indeed, popcorn, drinks and some candy was about another $20. Then add in the $75 earlier in the evening for Dinner and Drinks, and then add on the $60 we paid the babysitter to watch the kids for 6 hours. Date night ain't cheap!
 
I paided $20 last week for two tickets to the movies, date night for the wife and me. Guess what, there were Ads before the movie started.

I pay around $80/month for DirecTV, lots of ads there.

I have multiple magazine subscriptions, complete with lots of Ads.

Since when does subscription = no ads?

Aren't some ads, targeted and relevant ads, actually a good thing? How many of us used to buy that big ass phonebook sized Computer Shopper specifically for the Ads?

If XBL does this in a reasonable, not intrusive manner, how is it any different than a magazine or other subscription media service?

When I subscribed they didn't have these ads.
 
Pay for the service, pay for everything you download, and now get hit with adds. On top of paying extra for each game and buying the system. You console guys are getting a bargain lol.
 
Indeed, popcorn, drinks and some candy was about another $20. Then add in the $75 earlier in the evening for Dinner and Drinks, and then add on the $60 we paid the babysitter to watch the kids for 6 hours. Date night ain't cheap!

did you get any?
 
The problem with this kind of ad placement is the fact that it affects people with bandwidth caps. The ads themselves are probably fine (as long as they aren't obtrusive and interfere with the experience,) but if they're gonna take up a good portion of bandwidth then there should be an oiption to opt out for people that have to watch their bandwidth.
 
The problem with this kind of ad placement is the fact that it affects people with bandwidth caps. The ads themselves are probably fine (as long as they aren't obtrusive and interfere with the experience,) but if they're gonna take up a good portion of bandwidth then there should be an oiption to opt out for people that have to watch their bandwidth.

If that was a concern, then Google would have been out of business a long ass time ago.
 
The problem with this kind of ad placement is the fact that it affects people with bandwidth caps. The ads themselves are probably fine (as long as they aren't obtrusive and interfere with the experience,) but if they're gonna take up a good portion of bandwidth then there should be an oiption to opt out for people that have to watch their bandwidth.

How many people wouldn't opt out?
 
Great... Now I get to hear "Congratulations, you have been selected to win a Xbox 360!" on my computer and tv!
 
Raises hand...

I paid $60 for TW 2010 and what's the first thing i see (and hear) out on the course, just as I'm ready to swing?

This bleap noise and a friggin netflix Ad sliding onto the screen.
 
We've been married for over 14 years, she's kind of a sure thing :D

I've been married 19 years...pretty sure that means "I could have if I wanted to.....probably, but it was late so we just went to bed" :D



i keed i keed :)
 
A more organic part of the dashboard huh? Did they run out of bobbleheads for the dashboard? But seriously, when I go to play a game like call of duty will I see a silverlight ad for rifles and grenades? Or what about Halo? Will I see an ad for plasma weapons? JK LOL I would never play a console game! :rolleyes:

Enjoy Coke
Can't beat the feeling of killing blue team.
 
Seriously? Why can't there be an option for gold users to disable any adverts
 
Back
Top