Developing Countries Used as E-Waste Dumping Grounds

Terry Olaes

I Used to be the [H] News Guy
2FA
Joined
Nov 27, 2006
Messages
4,646
According to a Gartner report, countries that don’t want to deal with environmental requirements in disposing of their used PCs and other E-waste products are “passing the buck” and dumping their stuff in developing nations in Africa and elsewhere. Though the article appears to focus on the UK, it’s a pretty safe bet that other countries are doing it as well. That sucks.

Gartner says that although some exported used PCs are handled responsibly in demand countries with effective regulatory regimes and by companies with advanced technologies, many end up in developing countries where they are frequently handled and disposed of unsafely. Emerging economies often lack the capacity to safely handle and dispose of used PCs, and extremely low labour costs and lack of environmental controls make unsafe recycling commonplace.
 
whats with all the racism today? The russia vs USA on cyberwar thread needs editing too please.
 
It'll get taken care of when a mod is available. Don't quote or feed the trolls please.
 
No shocker, dumping wastes of many types have been going on in 3rd would countries for quite some time.... it sucks, at most the fines are tiny compared to how much money they saved by doing it.

What's with calling them "developing" countries though? Is calling them 3rd world just not politically correct anymore?
 
Not really news. Not recent news anyway it's been happening for a long long time.
 
What's with calling them "developing" countries though? Is calling them 3rd world just not politically correct anymore?

Something like that. I believe I read that calling a country first and third world denotes superiority over the other. "Developing" gives the notion that it is on the pathway to become "developed."
 
Not really news. Not recent news anyway it's been happening for a long long time.

Yeah, but if we keep it in the news for awhile, maybe we can do something about the people that leach precious metals out of the trash using mercury and nitric acid while not really realizing what they're doing.

Exploitation FTL.
 
This has been going on for a long, long time. Old news.

I believe I read that calling a country first and third world denotes superiority over the other.

Well I'd much rather live here than there.

"Developing" gives the notion that it is on the pathway to become "developed."

Which also implies that our way is the only right way and that they're a bunch of pseudo-men who need to be enslaved and dragged off so they can be taught to speak and other such civilized arts.

Or was that Columbus?
 
China has been a dumping spot as well for US companies for a long time. One of the news shows showed the mess that was caused from the dumping and it was pretty bad.

The local news (Kansas City) followed a shipment of CRT monitors from a local company and they were being shipped to China, its not legal but companies everywhere are doing it.
 
Something like that. I believe I read that calling a country first and third world denotes superiority over the other. "Developing" gives the notion that it is on the pathway to become "developed."

1) Define something with a new word/phrase.
2) Spread the new word/phrase.
3) Cry about how the new word/phraseis derogatory
4) Work to fight new word/phrase.
5) Return to step (1).

I call it the cycle of retardation. In about 10 years we'll hear whining about how it's insulting to be a "developing" nation and they'll think up some new stupid word/phrase.
 
1) Define something with a new word/phrase.
2) Spread the new word/phrase.
3) Cry about how the new word/phraseis derogatory
4) Work to fight new word/phrase.
5) Return to step (1).

I call it the cycle of retardation. In about 10 years we'll hear whining about how it's insulting to be a "developing" nation and they'll think up some new stupid word/phrase.

Read three posts above yours. In 10 years?
 
Read three posts above yours. In 10 years?

The XXXXXXXs are still quite happy with the word "developing". They're pretty slow. They'll catch on that it (as with every other word/phrase) can be seen as insulting in another decade or so.
 
The XXXXXXXs are still quite happy with the word "developing". They're pretty slow.

Seriously, what's with the fucking racism in this thread? If someone turned your hometown into a fucking garbage dump, you'd probably be pissed off too.
 
Seriously, what's with the fucking racism in this thread? If someone turned your hometown into a fucking garbage dump, you'd probably be pissed off too.

I think your analogy would be more accurate if you amended it to reflect that I was responsible for turning it into a dump in the first place, or at least for being so concerned with my immediate welfare to try to prevent it from becoming a dump.

And your attempt at being PC fails. Acknowledging "racism" ackowledges the discredited theory of different races as opposed to different population groups.
 
I think your analogy would be more accurate if you amended it to reflect that I was responsible for turning it into a dump in the first place, or at least for being so concerned with my immediate welfare to try to prevent it from becoming a dump.

And your attempt at being PC fails. Acknowledging "racism" ackowledges the discredited theory of different races as opposed to different population groups.

Are you saying that the third world countries screwed themselves over? Because that was us taking advantage of them.
 
I'd give it about 80% us screwing them, 20% them becoming convinced they should bend over.
How about an alternate viewpoint?

Depends on what you mean by "them". Do you mean the people of these developing countries, or do you mean their governenments? Because most of the time it is the corrupt governments that make these decisions, or at least permit their country's businesses to accept this "E-waste". Remember, we didn't force this E-waste on them, we asked and their decisionmakers accepted our offer.

Are we wrong for asking them to accept our pollution? It may be a different discussion entirely but it's also something to think about. "Asking" may have included some bribes to grease the deal, but on the flipside they still accepted our offer

So assuming there was bribery involved i would say 50% us, and 50% them. But if there was no bribery involved, then i would say 20% us and 80% them, especially they have an all too typical corrupt authoritarian government.

But like i said, this is just another viewpoint, i have no data to back me up, just more opinion like the rest of us ;)
 
How about an alternate viewpoint?

Depends on what you mean by "them". Do you mean the people of these developing countries, or do you mean their governenments? Because most of the time it is the corrupt governments that make these decisions, or at least permit their country's businesses to accept this "E-waste". Remember, we didn't force this E-waste on them, we asked and their decisionmakers accepted our offer.

Are we wrong for asking them to accept our pollution? It may be a different discussion entirely but it's also something to think about. "Asking" may have included some bribes to grease the deal, but on the flipside they still accepted our offer

So assuming there was bribery involved i would say 50% us, and 50% them. But if there was no bribery involved, then i would say 20% us and 80% them, especially they have an all too typical corrupt authoritarian government.

But like i said, this is just another viewpoint, i have no data to back me up, just more opinion like the rest of us ;)

true, but you have to look at how the governments got there. Many of these places were former colonies and as such we are the people who put those governments there. Also do you know what happens to governments that refuse us? generally we back the opposition either through political means or military means.
 
true, but you have to look at how the governments got there. Many of these places were former colonies and as such we are the people who put those governments there. Also do you know what happens to governments that refuse us? generally we back the opposition either through political means or military means.
Not trying to sound like an ass but personally i don't think most western governments would meddle with a country's elections if they don't accept our E-waste.

I mean we could debate this all night long but many post colonial governments put themselves there by force of arms, and not greased in by us with "elections". In other words their governments are entirely different than the ones they had 30 years ago. Even some of the ones that were greased in have been overthrown by now (south africa being just one example).
 
Not trying to sound like an ass but personally i don't think most western governments would meddle with a country's elections if they don't accept our E-waste.

I mean we could debate this all night long but many post colonial governments put themselves there by force of arms, and not greased in by us with "elections". Even some of the ones that were greased in have been overthrown by now (south africa being just one example). In other words many of their governments are entirely different than the ones they had 30 years ago.

Corrected, darn the no edit button :p
 
lol.. as if this is news... this is like NEWSFLASH there's a war going on... :rolleyes:
 
Not trying to sound like an ass but personally i don't think most western governments would meddle with a country's elections if they don't accept our E-waste.

I mean we could debate this all night long but many post colonial governments put themselves there by force of arms, and not greased in by us with "elections". In other words their governments are entirely different than the ones they had 30 years ago. Even some of the ones that were greased in have been overthrown by now (south africa being just one example).

true I was generalizing a bit too much over the E-waste, what I was saying is more true of countries that resist SAPs. As you say many post colonial governments put themselves in by force of arms, but in many cases it was our fault for creating the issues(or whomever the colony belonged to). As a case look at Rwanda, please correct me if I am wrong I am doing this off the top of my head, but the belonged to Poland(I think, might be Belgium, or I might be entirely wrong), they left an unsuitable government in charge, leading to revolution. As such even though we are not directly responsible it is still a result of our interference that they are saddled with these governments.
 
XXXXXXXs == lib-tards

What racism?

Sorry. The first user who replied to this thread had his comment turned into XXXXXXXs for using a racial slur. I didn't realize that there were more words that filtered to Xs. When I saw your comment X'd out, I thought it was because you had used the same word. Apologies.
 
I'd give it about 80% us screwing them, 20% them becoming convinced they should bend over.


It wouldn't take much stretch of the imagination to assume that figure was accurate. Besides, we've got a colorful history of screwing people/countries over. At the same token, we screw ourselves over pretty well, too. I saw a guy toss a 32" flat screen TV into the dumpster at our landfill just last month. 20' away was a location designated for such appliances to be recycled (and not end up in the landfill). Not to be a recycle Nazi but that was pretty pathetic.
 
Hope I didn't miss it but I didn't see this here: http://ngm.nationalgeographic.com/2008/01/high-tech-trash/carroll-text

National Geographic did a good article on "High Tech Trash" last year. Lots of pictures of people cleaning circuit boards with cooking utensils and one of my favorite parts, kind of puts a little light on the UK aspect of the article:

" "Near the port I enter a garage-like building with a sign over the door: "Importers of British Used Goods." ...A price tag on one of the monitors bears the label of a chain of Goodwill stores headquartered in Frederick, Maryland, a 45-minute drive from my house. A lot of people donate their old computers to charity organizations, believing they're doing the right thing. I might well have done the same. I ask the proprietor of the shop where he got the monitors. He tells me his brother in Alexandria, Virginia, sent them. He sees no reason not to give me his brother's phone number. "
 
See there? No matter what ridiculous laws governments pass, we will just go around them....

...which is why all of our jobs are being shipped overseas. Thanks for the great laws government! Had you not tried to micromanage and tax every facet of business we would have never learned we could get employees for much cheaper in other countries. We can move shop, establish facilities, and fire employees all for less money and hassle than it would take to stay in the U.S. Thanks again!
 
http://www.pbs.org/frontlineworld/stories/ghana804/

i highly suggest watching the above 30min piece about the dumping of ewaste. best part is when a reporter in Ghana picks up a CRT with a Philadelphia school system sticker on it. close to that are the hard drives that Frontline bought on the streets around the dump site in Ghana. one of them came from Northrop Grumman and contained details about sensitive, multi-million dollar U.S. government contracts with the defense intelligence agency, NASA and Homeland Security. i think [H] has a video that at least shows how to destroy data :p.

- Robert (PmR)DeathInJune
 
It's all a cycle. At the rate that China, India, and other developing nations are growing and getting richer while we in the US are getting poorer, it won't be long until they buy us all up and start shipping their e-waste over here.
 
1) Define something with a new word/phrase.
2) Spread the new word/phrase.
3) Cry about how the new word/phraseis derogatory
4) Work to fight new word/phrase.
5) Return to step (1).

I call it the cycle of retardation. In about 10 years we'll hear whining about how it's insulting to be a "developing" nation and they'll think up some new stupid word/phrase.

I think it was more of a PC move than the other countries getting offended. In fact, I do think it is the PC crowd who do most, if not all, of the whining. This cycle of yours will continue until the PC crowd will leave it alone or are satisfied.

Read three posts above yours. In 10 years?

"Hispanic" and "Latin American" seems to be a acceptable long-term PC term when referring so people south of the border, despite the continent being America. I only bring this up because one of my old English professors of Mexican decent despises the term "Hispanic."

I'm not a PC follower by any means... I just read/learned about it when I was in school.
 
This is old news, known for over a year that some guys back garden in China is full of the crap that's supposedly "recycled".
 
Yea but think about all the stuff that can be salvaged and repaired. I doubt it all goes straight into a dump. Fuck OLPC, just give them this shit for free.
 
Back
Top