Google Earth Used for Koi Theft

Terry Olaes

I Used to be the [H] News Guy
2FA
Joined
Nov 27, 2006
Messages
4,646
If you’ve got some expensive fish in your outdoor pond, you might want to invest in some video monitoring. Apparently, there’s been a surge in koi carp theft in the UK in recent weeks and police say that the thieves are using Google Earth to locate ponds that are easy pickings. Since those fish are worth hundreds of dollars in the open market, they’re an attractive target. I've always thought that tool was a bit fishy. *rimshot* :D

PCSO Gregory said: "Google shows what is in your garden and you can see people's ponds. One of the properties targeted has an eight foot fence and is set back from the road. The pond is in the corner and can't be seen. Unless you were standing right next to the wall, you wouldn't be able to hear the running water."
 
Haha, my buddy and his uncle both have Koi ponds with $1000+ dollar fish in them. I'll be emailing them this link asap. ;)
 
Haha, my buddy and his uncle both have Koi ponds with $1000+ dollar fish in them. I'll be emailing them this link asap. ;)

Yea, I was gunna say... "Hundreds of dollars" is nothing.

If you've got show-quality Koi fish, decent size (2-3')... You're talking THOUSANDS of dollars.
 
There was an asian guy around here who got busted for stealing .... then eating the Koi in a pond, apparently in the thousands of dollar range.

But things like this makes me more dislike Google Earth that much more... I mean hell solar panels are expensive as hell... I'd like to get some for my house... hell let me just whip it open and see who around me has them!
 
That is pretty low.. If I had a nice Koi pond I'd set up a motion sensing paintball turret or something and just hope the UPS man doesn't get too close! hehe.
 
That is pretty low.. If I had a nice Koi pond I'd set up a motion sensing paintball turret or something and just hope the UPS man doesn't get too close! hehe.

Most people don't keep in their front yards due to insurance purposes... Needs to be fenced in :D

All I've ever had problems with is Herons flying in and trying to eat the fish... Which is also why I don't keep any of the expensive stuff.
 
These thefts were quite common with our friends homes. Eventually the friend started trip wiring the pond and slept next to his rifle.
 
All the more reason to get a pond full of mixbreed Piranha Kois.
 
if the pond is say in your backyard, then isn't google earth in some violation of privacy peering into your backyard if someone's pond is there and then they could go after google for aiding in theft?
 
WTF! The only theft that has occurred to moi was by them raccoons (the animal). My pond is in the back with a black mesh cover over it.
 
if the pond is say in your backyard, then isn't google earth in some violation of privacy peering into your backyard if someone's pond is there and then they could go after google for aiding in theft?

Good question.

I'm sure we might see some sort of legislation in the next few years on this.

Public Photography is legal as long as it's public. If you've got a fenced in yard that people can't see, then that's private property that you'd have to break the law to photograph.
So, Google Earth is basically bypassing all those laws.
 
Good question.

I'm sure we might see some sort of legislation in the next few years on this.

Public Photography is legal as long as it's public. If you've got a fenced in yard that people can't see, then that's private property that you'd have to break the law to photograph.
So, Google Earth is basically bypassing all those laws.

What laws? So if you go up in a helicopter or airplane, you can't take pictures of the ground? I understand where there could be complaints on the privacy issue, but you don't have to break the law to get pictures of what's in someone's yard. What if you live near a mountain and someone on the mountain takes the pic? Or what if you live in the city and a tall apartment complex is right next to your house? Then people in the high rise can't look out their window, or take pictures of the ground? Or what if you live in the middle of nowhere, thinking no tall buildings are around (and thus you're safe!), but then someone comes along and wants to build a tall structure. They should thus be barred to protect what's in your yard?

Also, the property is still "private" even without a fence. You don't have the right to trespass on it. The fence would be a structure that prevents people from outside of the property from looking in or physically accessing the property, but in this case Google is not circumventing any measures that protect the property from being seen from above. Street View would still be blocked by the fence.

As with most of this the complaints will fall on two fronts. The first front is the general unease with other people being able to see things one may not want to be seen. Just as people complain when Google Street View captures them coming out of porn shops. The other issue is with ease of access to this type of information, and in my mind that's the total BS view. Ninety percent of the things I do during my day have been made easier relative to years past because of modern technology. It's not that I'm doing anything different, I'm just doing it more easily.

This is like the US vs Russia approach to cyber crime law. The US has the correct approach in saying that we must recognize there will always be hackers and people trying to mess with us, so accept that fact and come up with ways to strengthen defense and make ourselves stronger. That's the mindset anyone who is successful will use. The Russians have the wussy mindset of the bottom-feeders who argue we shouldn't have to worry about defense. They want to make "laws" that try to cut off any offense, as if that will stop anything. These approaches parallel the Google debate. Some people want to make or support existing laws that stop things that make people uncomfortable, whereas others recognize it's not in anyone's best interest to stop the progress, the instead we should focus on solutions that work. Is the problem here that the Koi thieves use Google Earth, or that the measures of protection on the ground weren't strong enough? Again if the thieves were determined enough, they could just go up in a helicopter and see the same thing. If you're banning Google Earth, all forms of air transportation should be banned as well.

If you went back to the 1700s and talked to the Founding Fathers about privacy and their views, they'd acknowledge that if you're walking down the street and you have eyes, you can see what other people are doing in public spaces. Thus a concept like Street View *should* be legit because it doesn't offer anything that you couldn't otherwise see. Now if you're saying that SV gave access to something like Mecca, which is restricted to a certain group of people, then I could see the complaint, but this general photography of things out in the open from ground or above just doesn't seem like that much of a concern to me.
 
If you went back to the 1700s and talked to the Founding Fathers about privacy and their views, they'd acknowledge that if you're walking down the street and you have eyes, you can see what other people are doing in public spaces. Thus a concept like Street View *should* be legit because it doesn't offer anything that you couldn't otherwise see. Now if you're saying that SV gave access to something like Mecca, which is restricted to a certain group of people, then I could see the complaint, but this general photography of things out in the open from ground or above just doesn't seem like that much of a concern to me.

Very poor example, you must work for Google. They didn't have cameras back then that I know of. The major difference is billions of people can see the exact same image. In the 1700s, everybody would have to take the time and energy to see/view the same thing. Even then, it wouldn't be exactly the same because the owners or whatever would increase precautions. Streetview or any kind of satellite image offers people something they would most likely never see or could have experienced. That is a huge difference. Freezing something in time can have major repercussions. It's obvious that it's being abused and exploited easily.
 
What laws? So if you go up in a helicopter or airplane, you can't take pictures of the ground?
Well, it's the same concept. Except not everyone has the money to fuel up a plane with jet fuel and fly over everyone's houses to take a peek and take photos. Just about everyone has internet and Google Earth though.

I understand where there could be complaints on the privacy issue, but you don't have to break the law to get pictures of what's in someone's yard. What if you live near a mountain and someone on the mountain takes the pic?
If taken from a public place (like if the mountain is a park or something), then it's perfectly fine.
Again- what you can observe from public places I have no issue with. I have no issue with Google Street View.
What there is an issue of is the satellite imaging, that can look into private locations. If it was fine and dandy, why do they cater to the US Government and block out stuff behind fences that's important to them??


Or what if you live in the city and a tall apartment complex is right next to your house? Then people in the high rise can't look out their window, or take pictures of the ground?
Again- if public can view it, it's fine.

Or what if you live in the middle of nowhere, thinking no tall buildings are around (and thus you're safe!), but then someone comes along and wants to build a tall structure. They should thus be barred to protect what's in your yard?
Again, if viewed from a public location, it's fine.
The difference there is the people actually know that a tall building is being erected, and can prepare for that.
 
If they are japaense koi with certain patterns,etc - you can spend ALOT more then 1000$ per fish.

I buy 5$ baby koi (known as fry), but they grow very big and are worth $$$ when they get older
 
I think this is an issue because people are using a tool from google to find items and then steal them....

they are using a very specific tool, sure someone could climb a mountain and see in your yard, but this is google, obtaining arial footage, not normally available and making it publicly available to anyone...Where does the line get drawn on your own properties privacy? especially if say i have a fenced off back yard that is not visible from street level? What if there are no mountains or hills around allowing someone to see in... then google is the only source for somone to see into my yard, they are aiding in the theft of my fish because otherwise, with no google, it would not be known what is in my yard.
 
google earth is changing the world, literally. more then ever, people need to be smarter to stay safer. you can have a koi pond, you just gotta make it invisible to space now. it sucks, but google earth benefits society more then it hurts it, so you just have to do what you gotta do. the internet is another perfect example... the world is changing and you just have to adjust or else technology will expose you.
 
so what, now people have to put roof's on their backyards?

at some point, the government needs to step in to these companies with limitations, laws are potentially being broken and nothing done about it.

What if i took a ladder, and started taking pictures of people's backyards to put on my new website.. sure i would be stopped pretty dam fast
 
What if i took a ladder, and started taking pictures of people's backyards to put on my new website.. sure i would be stopped pretty dam fast

Exactly...

It's pretty ridiculous that we all have to live in shoe boxes just to protect our basic rights of privacy and freedom anymore.
 
so you guys would rather have google earth not accessible to civilians so you can leave your fenced in backyard hiding the things you have- only for "authority" to see? its your backyard, not your bedroom. i think giving up google earth to protect privacy is giving up way too much freedom. its outside, just from a different angle. nobody thinks twice about having fences, and putting a tree over your koi pond is not hard either.
 
so you guys would rather have google earth not accessible to civilians so you can leave your fenced in backyard hiding the things you have- only for "authority" to see? its your backyard, not your bedroom. i think giving up google earth to protect privacy is giving up way too much freedom. its outside, just from a different angle. nobody thinks twice about having fences, and putting a tree over your koi pond is not hard either.

Yea... I can plant a tree, and maybe by the time I'm dead it'll be big enough to actually hide something :rolleyes:
 
We are talking about thieves here. I am sure they had no problem trespassing to look for Koi ponds before Google Earth. Dress up as a cable or telephone person and no one even questions you in the yard. It is not like the image is good enough to see the fish. Someone needs to make a piranha pond as a deterrence.
 
I wouldn't be surprised if there were in option in the future to remove your address from these images. Would probably have a fee though.
 
We are talking about thieves here. I am sure they had no problem trespassing to look for Koi ponds before Google Earth. Dress up as a cable or telephone person and no one even questions you in the yard. It is not like the image is good enough to see the fish. Someone needs to make a piranha pond as a deterrence.

good point. google earth does make things easier for them, but again, its outside. get used to people seeing it. they always have been able to.
 
I wouldn't be surprised if there were in option in the future to remove your address from these images. Would probably have a fee though.

Which is shouldnt, people should simply be able to request it and it be done

Do I hear a whiney "OMG FREEDOMZ" American in this thread? ;)

Google Earth is great, and you know it.


yes, it is great, but at what point is a corporation going to be stopped becase it is invading your privacy...
 
I thought that a thousand bucks for a fish sounded like a lot but then saw that they can live 50-200 years (one supposedly lived for 226 years). That's frickin insane. I can definitely see how they'd be worth the scratch.
 
WTF! The only theft that has occurred to moi was by them raccoons (the animal). My pond is in the back with a black mesh cover over it.

are you thinking of the word coon? you can't use raccoon in its place anyway, what other definition of raccoon is there?
 
Back
Top