Dual Xeon 1366 overclocking or using i-920 question

tlc4tvm

Limp Gawd
Joined
Nov 24, 2008
Messages
341
Dual Xeon 1366 overclocking and i-920 question.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

I'm looking at the dual 1366 boards and can't find any information on overclockability or if they will support one i920 etc.

Yes I have google searched but google is getting pretty poor lately with all the ads and links to review (cough, place your review here) sites.

Anyways easy questions.

First do any of the dual 1366 boards support the i920, i9## processor as a single processor option. I understand that the 920 is for single processor use but that doesn't nessarily mean they will work in a dual 1366 board if you only install one.

They sound pin compatible and I know you can use the xeon's in the single socket boards.

Second,
Does anyone know of any dual 1366 boards that support overclocking?
Most of the ones I looked at do not.
Any review out there?

Thanksin advance, I simply love dual boards, back from the dual socket 7 days.
 
You can't run an i7 in a dual socket board. You can't run a Xeon 1366 in an i7 board. if you run a single socket populated (the other one empty) in a dual socket board, you should expect half of your I/O slots to not function. Additionally, you will not be able to use half of your RAM slots. Also, any features that rely on the population of the second CPU/RAM bank will also be disabled (memory mirroring, online memory spares, correction fo double bit errors, NUMA, etc).

The Xeons for single socket boards are Xeon SP models, and specifically list compatibility with the desktop boards in their specs. Normal Socket 1366 Xeons are officially MPs or DP series. Moreover, the Xeons for servers and workstations that are Socket 1366, say so on the packaging, and no not come with heatsinks or fans. Desktop CPUs are labelled as such, and do come with fans.

Out of the 20 or so dual socket 1366 systems I have built so far, not a single one has had an OC option in the BIOS. (6 different boards)
 
The only dual Xeon boards offering overclocking in any form, are running custom BIOS and have very limited capability. Xeons are not for overclocking, period. They bin Xeons at highest full test pass, not based on demand.
 
sabregen,

Thanks,

"if you run a single socket populated (the other one empty) in a dual socket board, you should expect half of your I/O slots to not function. Additionally, you will not be able to use half of your RAM slots. Also, any features that rely on the population of the second CPU/RAM bank will also be disabled (memory mirroring, online memory spares, correction fo double bit errors, NUMA, etc)."

Yup and thanks, The I/O slots I'm familiar with from my socket 940 overclocking bulid about 6 of those, generally can't use the second LAN, a PCI-X slot, etc. Generally the boards can funtion with just one socket populated, it works just not everything.

On the memory no biggie I generally turn those features off if I can anyways.

NUMA afaik it will be installed but of course there isn't a second processor so...

"You can't run an i7 in a dual socket board. You can't run a Xeon 1366 in an i7 board.
MPs or DP series."

Really??? I can't find much information on that and looking on-line people are using xeons in i7's?

There is even a customer review at newegg...
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16819117213

AreEss
Do you have any info or suggestions for sites to look at for custom bios availibility.


Basically I have a decent scsi raid setup using a PCI-X adaptec card and some u160 15k's
I also like the ability to have dual processors as well as access to the 6-cores when they come out.

The binning of Xeons is really weird I always though they were less heat more stable, inother words you could pick up a Pair of 5502 and at least get something extra out of the 1.8GHz, the opterons certainly overclock very well (at least 940's)
 
"You can't run an i7 in a dual socket board. You can't run a Xeon 1366 in an i7 board.
MPs or DP series."

Really??? I can't find much information on that and looking on-line people are using xeons in i7's?

There is even a customer review at newegg...
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16819117213
The W3xxx is single socket only. It doesn't have the extra QPI link for dual socket setups. You can also run both Xeons and regular i7s in certain workstation motherboard. My Asus P6T6 will accommodate both for example.
 
Xeons are not for overclocking, period.

This.

FYI guys

I've found a suitable thread...

http://forums.2cpu.com/showthread.php?t=94220

Looks like the dual 1366 boards are hanging at 137 mhz, but there is hope with a potential hardware mod.

So what is the reason you want to OC your dual Xeon?

If you're still thinking you can OC your server chips like you were with old Opterons you're sadly mistaken. The point of Xeons and servers are to be reliable as possible. OCing removes any reliability which would have been there.
However, Intel wants you to purchase their faster CPUs when putting them in your system, since OC functions aren't even available on the boards. As AreEss said what you get when you buy a Xeon is an already maxed out CPU - so you can't really OC a maxed CPU, can you?

Just trying to understand things. Also (especially) when you OC server boards or dual socket systems they can and do become EXTREMELY flaky. Good luck...
 
Out of the 20 or so dual socket 1366 systems I have built so far, not a single one has had an OC option in the BIOS. (6 different boards)

Ever just want to load up a minesweeper and haul ass on one of those boards?

Xeons overclock just fine. It's just the boards that get pissy.

+1. I had dual quad opterons that would not overclock 100mhz, i'm pretty sure it was the board.
 
There are plenty of posts about people overclocking their Xeons in a single processor board. The issue is with the motherboards allowing dual CPU overclocks.
 
Last edited:
They were overclocking the dual 771 Xeons by "pad/pin modding" them. Search the DC subforum for details.
 
More relevant - LGA1366 Xeons can be overclocked on X58 motherboards.
 
This was discussed on 2cpu quite a bit.

I didn't follow every post, but from memory it is clear that no pinmod hole exists for any SMP Nehalems.

And I don't remember anybody who found a clock chip accessible on the i2c bus yet. This is how we overclocked the dual 771 system, most boards have fairly common ics chips hanging out on the i2c bus. Intel boards usually didn't, though.

Having said all this, I haven't seen anybody trying more than existing Windows utils for i2c based clockchips either. A visual inspection of the board to look for known ics chips would be the first step.
 
Welcome to the multiprocessing subforum...we don't talk about X58 boards here since they aren't relevant. :p

I'm aware of that - my comment was in response to the earlier post that implied that Xeon CPUs themselves were binned to their maximum potential and were not capable of being overclocked, and that is simply not the case as can be proved by taking an appropriate Xeon to a LGA-1366 mobo. I would love to find out how to overclock LGA-1366 CPUs in a 5500 board, but the limiting factor is the motherboard / utilities, not the CPUs themselves, is all I was trying to say.
 
I'm planning to build a dual Xeon (Nehalem based) machine later this year, maxing it out with 24GB of RAM working in triple channel model and still on the fence as to what mobo to buy myself.

But I gotta say this: if dual i7-based Xeons aren't fast enough at bin/stock speeds, then something is wrong. :D My intention for building this machine is to make it an x264 crunching monster box, which it will handily do thanks to the dual Xeons. Sure it would be great to be able to max out the potential performance, but if I wanted to go that route I'd be building an i7 box with a single CPU and overclocking.

"How fast is fast?"
 
I'm surprised there isn't a SkullTrail II® type product from Intel - if anything, the Xeon 55xx series seems tailor-made for an extreme platform that would really eclipse everything else out there once tweaked and overclocked.
 
I'm surprised there isn't a SkullTrail II® type product from Intel - if anything, the Xeon 55xx series seems tailor-made for an extreme platform that would really eclipse everything else out there once tweaked and overclocked.

Don't be surprised if you never see something exactly like Skulltrail out of Intel again. Almost no one bought the platform. The motherboard might have been an ok seller but the QX9775's sure as hell weren't. I'd be interested to see actual sales numbers from Intel on the platform, as well as a break down of motherboards and processors sold.

I'd wager that not many made it in the market. Beyond myself, I think there were one or two other people that had them on the forum here. One of them was a real Skulltrail (D400XS, 2x QX9775's) that DarthBeavis had, but I believe his was for sponsored build. Someone else on here had one but I think they just used the board and had a couple of LGA771 Xeons in it. I have 2 QX9775's and two D5400XS motherboards. The second board was a repalcement for the first board which died on me.

I think Intel learned their lesson. I think they learned that no one really wants to spend that kind of money on a platform like that and even if they did, the Skulltrail platform was sort of a bust in that the requirement of FB-DIMMs, few memory slots and a few other issues held the platform back. It was nice on paper but in the real world any old 790i Ultra SLI board combined with a standard QX9770 was more than capable of overclocking just as far, if not farther and provided better performance thanks to the DDR3 memory performance compared to the unimpressive performance of DDR2 FB-DIMMs.

I think Intel learned their lesson. Server hardware is not desireable in an extreme gaming platform. Not only does it not perform up to par with hardware designed for that role but it's too expensive. I think the X58 platform is representative of a far better effort. It provides the extreme performance at several price points for both processors and motherboards and It isn't tied to oddball server memory and they get to use the same technology developed for their Xeon line. Really if you think about it, X58 + Core i7 9xx series does in fact replace Skulltrail. LGA1156 systems cover the lower and mid-range product line and even transcends the mid-range into the higher end spectrum. X58 + Core i7 covers the higher end of the performance spectrum leading up to the extreme performance segment. It delivers more than Skulltrail could with normal hardware compatibility and it does so at less than half the price of Skulltrail.

I think that Skulltrail was nothing more than a "checkmate" move in the "my dick is bigger than yours." contest that was raging between Intel and AMD at the time. AMD brought out 4x4 platform and Intel said, "Oh yeah, we maybe a little late to the party, but we have all the hookers and blow".

That's my $.02 on the subject anyway.
 
I think that Skulltrail was nothing more than a "checkmate" move in the "my dick is bigger than yours." contest that was raging between Intel and AMD at the time. AMD brought out 4x4 platform and Intel said, "Oh yeah, we maybe a little late to the party, but we have all the hookers and blow".

This statement is priceless. And I completely agree.
 
I've got a Skulltrail on water and a z7s on air. Both have dual E5420s o/cd to 3.0GHz (an easy o/c). I use both for work and, um, other simulations.... they are fantastic. I also have an i7 920 in a Smackover on water o/cd to about 3.8 GHz. All stable running at these speeds all the time.

On most benchmarks, the i7 wins hands down.... but if I had to choose only one machine day in day out it would be one of the dual proc Xeons.

If there was a dual 1366 socket Xeon that allowed o/c ing, I would by it in a flash.

There is a market for these boards and Intel should feed it. It's not huge, but its like F1 racing. What you learn from producing products for this market improves your mainstream products.
 
Very true. But another way to look at this is to say "If only AMD would bring out the big guns in their Phenom II party, Intel would do a follow up to Skulltrail."

Please, AMD? Pretty please?
/puppyeyes
 
Back
Top