Tech Giants Deny Helping Iran Eavesdrop

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
So what do you think? Do you think these two companies are involved in helping the Iranian government eavesdrop on its citizens or do you believe them when they say they aren’t helping them?

The company's denial comes as protests over Iran's disputed election enter their second week, amplified by Twittering from the Iranian diaspora and cell phone videos showing ongoing street conflicts and the apparent death of young Iranian woman called Neda.
 
I think iran will do it regardless, so the real question is, Does it really matter?
 
I think iran will do it regardless, so the real question is, Does it really matter?

In a world where no one is morally accountable for their actions, death after torture becomes a relief.

Thank you for not being a part of the solution.
 
In a world where no one is morally accountable for their actions, death after torture becomes a relief.

Thank you for not being a part of the solution.

My point is they are going to eavesdrop if they want to no matter if tech giants help them.

Thanks for your smart ass remark
 
With the long list of immoral things Siemens have done like stealing the technology behind the MRI scanner from The Beatles sound Engineer. I wouldn't be surprised. Is really tasty to make a profit over other people's suffering and lack of freedom when you take yours for granted.
 
My point is they are going to eavesdrop if they want to no matter if tech giants help them.

Thanks for your smart ass remark

I think the issue here is not the Iranian Government but Nokia Siemens, or did you not read the article?

Regarding the Smart Assness, it all comes down to knowing what you're talking about before commenting so lightly. But I guess that's something you'll never experience.
 
Gun manufacturers are helping the basij kill and harm demonstrators, car and motorcycle manufacturers are helpig the basij transport themselves to do the deed, oh boohoo.
 
I have no doubt the 2 of them sold the high tech equipment that is used by Iran to crack down on the dissenters...

I would prefer to see some sort of retribution tarriff slapped on them because of it, for a set limit of years.(2-5ish)
 
So should we also go against the manufactures of radios and televisions since they are used by countries all over the world to pass their own propaganda to their people, thus in a sense, monitoring what they can see. Or how about we slap tariffs on all countries which import oil from Iran which provide the funds for the Nokia software to be purchased. Look people, Nokia can not dictate who it allows to use its software because just like Nokia was being used to monitor the Iranians, Nokia's were also used to allow people to record the protest and send sms.
 
It would be one thing if the companies offered their services free of charge. It's another thing if the company SELLS a product, and Iran purchased it.

If I bought the product that Iran is using and implimented it at work, would Siemens, Nokia be snoping on my employees?
They are mearly a supplier of a product, it is the ultimate end user of the product that you need to concern yourself with.
 
Damn the no edit button.
We should also hold Intel/AMD and the other hardware vendors that have hardware there that the software is running on. Those evil bastards. I can't beleive they would sell those murdering pigs Dell servers. Fuck you Dell I hate you you racist insensative bastards.
 
So much for RTFA action by [H] readers.

The point isn't selling them hardware. Or guns. Or fucking motorcycles, you dumb fucks.

It is that FSC and others actually helped build and design a state of the art data center and software to allow this level of censorship. They just didn't box up a PC and ship it to Iran. The built an internet management solution specifically designed to censor and control access.

All they need do do now is brand it.

Orwellsoft 2009?
Despot NewThinkStation Pro?
Freedom Enablement Suite Deluxe?
 
So much for RTFA action by [H] readers.

The point isn't selling them hardware. Or guns. Or fucking motorcycles, you dumb fucks.

It is that FSC and others actually helped build and design a state of the art data center and software to allow this level of censorship. They just didn't box up a PC and ship it to Iran. The built an internet management solution specifically designed to censor and control access.
Amen

Here's another snippet:
The Wall Street Journal, which claimed that the Iranian government has developed "one of the world's most sophisticated mechanisms for controlling and censoring the Internet" with the help of Nokia Siemens Networks.
It is claiming that the companie(s) in question actively assisted a dictatorial (tyranical?) regime in developing a solution to further supress it's citizens. These companies didn't mail them an off-the-shelf solution, they helped IRAN develop it.

Similar to as if Albert Einstein would have taken a plane flight over to Germany in 1941/1942 to steer the nazi's nuclear program in the right direction. Would that have made Einstein an absolute traitor ? Of course it would have...
 
Similar to as if Albert Einstein would have taken a plane flight over to Germany in 1941/1942 to steer the nazi's nuclear program in the right direction. Would that have made Einstein an absolute traitor ? Of course it would have...

Ummm... Einstein was German. He was a traitor.
 
Ummm... Einstein was German. He was a traitor.

He was also Jewish, so he could not really be a traitor to Nazi Germany.


Back on topic. They sold Iran telecom equipment, most likely assuming it would be used normally, in a normal way. They had no real expectation it would be used the way it is currently. That is, assuming they really did sell that equipment and software to Iran. Currently they deny web monitoring equipment/software was a part of the package they sold Iran.

The numerous analogies we have seen so far seem fairly on the money. With what we see in that article, placing blame on Seimens and Nokia right now is foolish. Many companies in this world have made something or another that some ass has used in an inappropriate, illegal, and/or reprehensible way.
 
Ah, but the point was, if helping the Germans would have been treason, then helping the Jews/Americans was definitely treason.
haha, even with keeping Gorankar's viewpoint in mind, i guess i used a terrible example :p

lol
 
I think iran will do it regardless, so the real question is, Does it really matter?
m1
I think the issue here is not the Iranian Government but Nokia Siemens, or did you not read the article?

Regarding the Smart Assness, it all comes down to knowing what you're talking about before commenting so lightly. But I guess that's something you'll never experience.
i1
Gun manufacturers are helping the basij kill and harm demonstrators, car and motorcycle manufacturers are helpig the basij transport themselves to do the deed, oh boohoo.
m2
So should we also go against the manufactures of radios and televisions since they are used by countries all over the world to pass their own propaganda to their people, thus in a sense, monitoring what they can see. Or how about we slap tariffs on all countries which import oil from Iran which provide the funds for the Nokia software to be purchased. Look people, Nokia can not dictate who it allows to use its software because just like Nokia was being used to monitor the Iranians, Nokia's were also used to allow people to record the protest and send sms.
m3
It would be one thing if the companies offered their services free of charge. It's another thing if the company SELLS a product, and Iran purchased it.

If I bought the product that Iran is using and implimented it at work, would Siemens, Nokia be snoping on my employees?
They are mearly a supplier of a product, it is the ultimate end user of the product that you need to concern yourself with.
m4
Damn the no edit button.
We should also hold Intel/AMD and the other hardware vendors that have hardware there that the software is running on. Those evil bastards. I can't beleive they would sell those murdering pigs Dell servers. Fuck you Dell I hate you you racist insensative bastards.
m5
So much for RTFA action by [H] readers.

The point isn't selling them hardware. Or guns. Or fucking motorcycles, you dumb fucks.

It is that FSC and others actually helped build and design a state of the art data center and software to allow this level of censorship. They just didn't box up a PC and ship it to Iran. The built an internet management solution specifically designed to censor and control access.

All they need do do now is brand it.

Orwellsoft 2009?
Despot NewThinkStation Pro?
Freedom Enablement Suite Deluxe?
m2
Amen

Here's another snippet:
It is claiming that the companie(s) in question actively assisted a dictatorial (tyranical?) regime in developing a solution to further supress it's citizens. These companies didn't mail them an off-the-shelf solution, they helped IRAN develop it.

Similar to as if Albert Einstein would have taken a plane flight over to Germany in 1941/1942 to steer the nazi's nuclear program in the right direction. Would that have made Einstein an absolute traitor ? Of course it would have...
m3

Ummm... Einstein was German. He was a traitor.
m6
He was also Jewish, so he could not really be a traitor to Nazi Germany.


Back on topic. They sold Iran telecom equipment, most likely assuming it would be used normally, in a normal way. They had no real expectation it would be used the way it is currently. That is, assuming they really did sell that equipment and software to Iran. Currently they deny web monitoring equipment/software was a part of the package they sold Iran.

The numerous analogies we have seen so far seem fairly on the money. With what we see in that article, placing blame on Seimens and Nokia right now is foolish. Many companies in this world have made something or another that some ass has used in an inappropriate, illegal, and/or reprehensible way.
n1
Ah, but the point was, if helping the Germans would have been treason, then helping the Jews/Americans was definitely treason.
m7

haha, even with keeping Gorankar's viewpoint in mind, i guess i used a terrible example :p

lol

n2

So we have morons: 7. Thinking people 3. Neutrals: 2. That's a pretty rough resemblance of the world's IQ distribution...hehe.
First off. If we're going to about treason then Hitter was a Traitor since the first country The Third Reich invaded was Austria, where Hitter was from.
Second. You dumb fucks do not have any idea of what is to live under a totalitarian system and hence cannot fathom anything of what is going on in Iran or why this is happening. At least have the decency of learning some God Damn History besides what Stupidpedia teaches you so you can have at least an idea of what you're talking about. So feel lucky you are so stupidz in these matters. You have been blessed with ignorance as a child is blessed with innocence.The problem is that you lack the humility to recognize it and Excel in arrogance. And that is what makes you look so dumb.

Third. If I remember my history well I think it was an American who developed the Atomic Bomb. Not Albert Einstein. His Theories helped surely, but much effort was put by the American, English and Norwegian special forces into sabotaging the German Nuclear program. That and the fact that Hitler was an egomaniac miss coordinated wacko also helped, A LOT. Again, learn history dumb fucks.

It also was the German Nazi Party and dumb fucks like yourselves, who took care of electing Nazis as leaders of Germany. Who betrayed Germany in the first place. Albert just survived and continued on with his life. And you dare call him a traitor. That's an amazing proof that Stupidity is much more dangerous than evil alone! I would call it a catalyst for disaster.

But I guess learning how to read properly would have to come before learning history.
 
So we have morons: 7. Thinking people 3. Neutrals: 2. That's a pretty rough resemblance of the world's IQ distribution...hehe.
First off. If we're going to about treason then Hitter was a Traitor since the first country The Third Reich invaded was Austria, where Hitter was from.
Second. You dumb fucks do not have any idea of what is to live under a totalitarian system and hence cannot fathom anything of what is going on in Iran or why this is happening. At least have the decency of learning some God Damn History besides what Stupidpedia teaches you so you can have at least an idea of what you're talking about. So feel lucky you are so stupidz in these matters. You have been blessed with ignorance as a child is blessed with innocence.The problem is that you lack the humility to recognize it and Excel in arrogance. And that is what makes you look so dumb.

Third. If I remember my history well I think it was an American who developed the Atomic Bomb. Not Albert Einstein. His Theories helped surely, but much effort was put by the American, English and Norwegian special forces into sabotaging the German Nuclear program. That and the fact that Hitler was an egomaniac miss coordinated wacko also helped, A LOT. Again, learn history dumb fucks.

It also was the German Nazi Party and dumb fucks like yourselves, who took care of electing Nazis as leaders of Germany. Who betrayed Germany in the first place. Albert just survived and continued on with his life. And you dare call him a traitor. That's an amazing proof that Stupidity is much more dangerous than evil alone! I would call it a catalyst for disaster.

But I guess learning how to read properly would have to come before learning history.

I really havn't kept up with this thread so I have no idea where the Nazi's come in. However the US recuited a whole lot of scientists from Germany after WW2, why should any of them be considered traitors? It doesn't, plan and simple they are some of the greatest minds and led us to countless advances in technology.

The problem with this issue is that the world is upset at companies for providing and profiting off technology that will be developed regardless. You and I both know that Global companies in these days have very little moral or ethical restraint, if they see enough profit thats all they need to justify ignoring their ethical code.

Iran could hire its own developers and code the monitoring software themselves, which could have happened, and the "Tech Giants" could have provided voice monitoring. Does that make it wrong? Sure in the US it would be, but your dealing with a Islamic government that holds to very strict ideology.

The bottom line is that there monitoring technology will be developed regardless, we can say how unethical, or un-American it was but the truth of the matter is its not America, not even China. Your dealing with Iran, keep that in mind
 
m1


So we have morons: 7. Thinking people 3. Neutrals: 2. That's a pretty rough resemblance of the world's IQ distribution...hehe.
First off. If we're going to about treason then Hitter was a Traitor since the first country The Third Reich invaded was Austria, where Hitter was from.
Second. You dumb fucks do not have any idea of what is to live under a totalitarian system and hence cannot fathom anything of what is going on in Iran or why this is happening. At least have the decency of learning some God Damn History besides what Stupidpedia teaches you so you can have at least an idea of what you're talking about. So feel lucky you are so stupidz in these matters. You have been blessed with ignorance as a child is blessed with innocence.The problem is that you lack the humility to recognize it and Excel in arrogance. And that is what makes you look so dumb.

Third. If I remember my history well I think it was an American who developed the Atomic Bomb. Not Albert Einstein. His Theories helped surely, but much effort was put by the American, English and Norwegian special forces into sabotaging the German Nuclear program. That and the fact that Hitler was an egomaniac miss coordinated wacko also helped, A LOT. Again, learn history dumb fucks.

It also was the German Nazi Party and dumb fucks like yourselves, who took care of electing Nazis as leaders of Germany. Who betrayed Germany in the first place. Albert just survived and continued on with his life. And you dare call him a traitor. That's an amazing proof that Stupidity is much more dangerous than evil alone! I would call it a catalyst for disaster.

But I guess learning how to read properly would have to come before learning history.

In any case. all we know is for certain, is that Iran is using tech they may have purchased from Seimens/Nokia in a way that disgusts most of the free world. I, for one don't intend to hang Seimens/Nokia's boards at dawn over this till more info is available on what was actually sold to them and what intent Iran put forth at the time it was purchased.

Call us morons all you want, but the most innocent of equipment/software/ideas can be turned to evil use in the hands evil men. That may have been what happened here.

The Albert Einstein stuff was a side tangent hardly worthy of such angst, but you are free to pop a vessel if you want. Also, it is foolish to call other people morons, glass houses and all that.
 
Back
Top