Current Battery Life Tests Suck

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Ever wonder why that advertised “8 hour battery life” never equals more than 4 hours in real life? This ought to give you an idea where those inflated claims come from:

According to Advanced Micro Devices, the problem with most battery life claims stems from the wide use of a test called MobileMark 2007. Patrick Moorhead, a vice president for marketing at AMD, said the parameters for this test include having the screen at just 20 percent brightness, Wi-Fi turned off and no music, video, games or Web pages running. More or less, the test turns a computer into a dimly lit clock, then sees how long it can run.
 
honestly, the tests don't seem to be too wacky. They need some sort of common ground and I bet the standard was set before wifi became common (hence shutting it off)...I'm sure they don't mind the inflated numbers either though lol
 
maybe they should just upgrade the test. Add in wifi, 1 webpage with a site using flash or silverlight, and 40% brightness.
 
Um how about these settings.
Screen at max resolution and 70% brightness
Wi-fi on
Bluetooth on
DVD/BR playing or playing a DVD/BR movie stored on HD for netbooks
 
Wifi is the "Destroyer of Batteries" there is no way they would ever include in their test...
 
Gonna need a metric to divide their results by then. If they say 8 we divide it and get 2 or something.
 
Um how about these settings.
Screen at max resolution and 70% brightness
Wi-fi on
Bluetooth on
DVD/BR playing or playing a DVD/BR movie stored on HD for netbooks

lol then they'd have to market an '8 hour' battery as a 45 min. unit :D
 
Same with when they advertise the Miles Per Gallon for a car. This is never in a realistic stop\go drive round town. It is always on a rolling road, with all of the car's electrics turned off.

The only thing these numbers can be used for is a comparison to another model.
 
Best Buy ads seem to give realistic numbers in the 2 and a half hour range in their advertisements...unless those are really only going to run for 30 minutes :p
 
In terms of real world usage, I get about 5 hours of battery life out of my EEE 1000HE which is not bad as far as I am concerned. As for my Dell 9300 well that is a different story, it runs for oh about 45 mins real world usage playing games like WoW.
 
LOL @ AMD wanting a PR rating for battery life. The platform needs more work, not the standard battery life ratings.
 
Same with when they advertise the Miles Per Gallon for a car. This is never in a realistic stop\go drive round town. It is always on a rolling road, with all of the car's electrics turned off.

The only thing these numbers can be used for is a comparison to another model.

Odd, I always get either more mpg's then the vehicle's rated mpg or right near the hwy rating. If you move your foot from the gas to the brake immediately, those numbers are pretty reflective. As the EPA does that testing, it's very reflective of what vehicles get.
 
I'm not really surprised by this at all. I personally think there should be multiple tests. 0% load, 50% load, and 100% load at 50% screen brightness for all 3 tests. Then provide those results. Users can guestimate what they'll be at for their own settings.
 
Same with when they advertise the Miles Per Gallon for a car. This is never in a realistic stop\go drive round town. It is always on a rolling road, with all of the car's electrics turned off.

The only thing these numbers can be used for is a comparison to another model.

Except that is EXACTLY why the EPA recently revised the way the tests they use to calculate mpg... to make it a better account of what people ACTUALLY do in the real world!

Revising laptop battery tests is long overdue; it's pretty ridiculous how far off their estimates are.
 
Yea except if you actually read this whole article, the new MBP cores 8 hours of battery life with all that stuff on.

Pretty fucking impressive.
 
Odd, I always get either more mpg's then the vehicle's rated mpg or right near the hwy rating. If you move your foot from the gas to the brake immediately, those numbers are pretty reflective. As the EPA does that testing, it's very reflective of what vehicles get.

that all really depends on the vehicle (gearing, tires, aerodynamics, etc). My gto "should" get 20mpg, but in reality it gets approx 14. I can hit near 20 at times, but deff. not for an average.

If you're getting more than what it's rated for, consider youself lucky lol That is deff. not the norm
 
that all really depends on the vehicle (gearing, tires, aerodynamics, etc). My gto "should" get 20mpg, but in reality it gets approx 14. I can hit near 20 at times, but deff. not for an average.
I drive exactly 50% street and 50% highway. My EPA *estimated* (key word) mileage on the old scale was 18 city/25 highway (=~21.5mpg at 50/50 mix). With a poorly maintained car and often driving on underinflated tires (not to mention the old lead foot on acceleration and 75 on the freeway), I've been getting 20mpg on average for years. That's within 10% of the EPA estimate.

It is a huge YMMV, depending on climate (local here = very mild) and driving habits. But the numbers are somewhat reasonable if 1) there's nothing wrong with the vehicle and 2) the driver doesn't have very wasteful fuel habits.
 
I knew that's how they tested batteries from the first time I went laptop shopping. In some of the laptops I've seen, I'd swear they derived their numbers from testing the battery with the laptop in standby, because some of them go totally dead in standby after 8 hours. They should rate their batteries by starting 3D Mark on a full charge, wait til it dies and see how long it lasts to give it a "minimum" longevity rating, hah.
 
I drive exactly 50% street and 50% highway. My EPA *estimated* (key word) mileage on the old scale was 18 city/25 highway (=~21.5mpg at 50/50 mix). With a poorly maintained car and often driving on underinflated tires (not to mention the old lead foot on acceleration and 75 on the freeway), I've been getting 20mpg on average for years. That's within 10% of the EPA estimate.

It is a huge YMMV, depending on climate (local here = very mild) and driving habits. But the numbers are somewhat reasonable if 1) there's nothing wrong with the vehicle and 2) the driver doesn't have very wasteful fuel habits.

Same here, my car is 29/34 and I average very close to that for each type of driving. So overall I am averaging 30.2 mpg at the moment. So yea, the EPA Estimate is at least reasonable, these batter life tests are not at all.
 
Battery capacity (in Ah) should be given and the current for mixed load, full load and idle should also be specified.
 
I don't know about you guys, but my Laptop battery life last for a week when it's hibernating...

does that count?

it's still "On" :D
 
I knew that's how they tested batteries from the first time I went laptop shopping. In some of the laptops I've seen, I'd swear they derived their numbers from testing the battery with the laptop in standby, because some of them go totally dead in standby after 8 hours. They should rate their batteries by starting 3D Mark on a full charge, wait til it dies and see how long it lasts to give it a "minimum" longevity rating, hah.

That's not a bad idea, instead of an "Average" battery life rating, you get minimum life (full power, everything on and cranked up), and maximum life. Extrapolate your average from those, depending on personal usage habits.
 
AMD figures out that canned benchmarks lie. Good for them. Now if they can't just build a CPU that will at least win some canned benchmarks maybe they will leave the poor EpenisMark guys alone.
 
Yea except if you actually read this whole article, the new MBP cores 8 hours of battery life with all that stuff on.

http://anandtech.com/mac/showdoc.aspx?i=3580&p=1

Pretty fucking impressive.

You beat me to it.

I'm glad that Anand and a few other sites use practical tests for battery life, SSDs, etc, instead of synthetic tests and benchmarks.

On a side note, this is one of the few cases where a company is being conservative with their battery life claims, pretty crazy.
 
Decadent A holes:D... My laptop last all of 1.5 seconds without a power cord.:( I need to buy some cells and make a few battery packs. It was free, what can I say?
 
That's why they say "up to X hours" and it should ve been clear for years to people who have used a laptop, cellphone or other battery devices that the claimed battery life is never the same as the real life battery life.
 
Yeah, no one should take it for real what they usually advertise for battery life. Those are always way to high, with all features turned off or to minimum. A new way of testing and the way to report it should be introduced.

However that new macbook is seriously going in the right way regarding battery life and therefore mobility.
 
Wifi is the "Destroyer of Batteries" there is no way they would ever include in their test...
Reading an ebook in a browser with mirc and gmail running in the background (to generate a low level of background traffic) I get 5:45hrs with wifi on my wind. very close to the officially claimed numbers.
 
the way i see it, people shouldn't be as picky about the thickness of their laptops. Seriously, whats the matter with having that extra half inch or so for a battery that takes up the entire underside of a laptop. you could get crazy time. I add cells to my current battery from 9 to 15, its amazing what you can get for life... they just need to make it standard. the amount of companies using lithium ion cells should make the cost less!
 
the way i see it, people shouldn't be as picky about the thickness of their laptops. Seriously, whats the matter with having that extra half inch or so for a battery that takes up the entire underside of a laptop. you could get crazy time. I add cells to my current battery from 9 to 15, its amazing what you can get for life... they just need to make it standard. the amount of companies using lithium ion cells should make the cost less!

Not everybody can practically pack the extra bulk/weight around. Instead of packing around more CRAP why can't we just make the technology better? Like others have mentioned, look at the new Macbook pros. People are reporting better than average battery life on those.

A lot of netbooks are getting 5 hrs or more, too. It's doable, but we've got to make better batteries and more efficient OS's. I think Windows 7 with all the fat trimmed will do quite well once they hit RTM.

But heaven forbid we expect technology to actually improve as time goes on. Let's just make batteries BIGGER!

I agree with you that costs need to come down a bit, but I think we're seeing that happen finally .... slowly ....
 
Back
Top