Has TPB Lost Appeal or is NYT Wrong?

Terry Olaes

I Used to be the [H] News Guy
2FA
Joined
Nov 27, 2006
Messages
4,646
TechDirt found a NYTimes article saying that appeal was denied for the case against The Pirate Bay. However, they can’t find anything else that supports it and wonder if the NYT is wrong. I checked a bit and couldn’t find anything either so I’m skeptical of the NYT piece. My normal source for this type of news, TorrentFreak, doesn’t have anything recent about TPB except an article about misreporting on a biased judge. Hm…

But I haven't seen anything that says the Appeals Court has ruled one way or the other on the issue. It looks like the reporters at The Hollywood Reporter and the NY Times may have gotten confused about the difference between the District Court and the Appeals Court -- and assumed that because theDistrict Court claimed the judge wasn't biased, the Appeals Court had ruled that way.
 
It is by no ways over. In Sweden we have a three-stage court system, I guess you can call them District Court, The Kings Court and Supreme Court in that order. All trials will begin in the District court, which was the case with TPB trial. After that it is up to either part if they want to appeal and that is done in The Kings Court. The verdict in The Kings Court can then be appealed in the Supreme Court.

What happened here is that The Kings Court have stated that they don't think the judge in the District Court was biased and that there is no cause for a re-trial in the District Court. This statement though can be appealed as well.

The main trial against TPB though is waiting for the appeal to The Kings Court.
 
go NYT keep reading blogs and citing fake sources and making "real" news articles out of it! woot.

lol i just watched the daily show on this, they interviewed NYT it was hilarious.
 
Hmm, a corporate sponsered news service reporting misinformation that benefits a huge industry? Say it ain't so.
 
This TPB case is probably still a long way before receiving final verdict.
 
Back
Top