Hating On Project Natal

Sugar Ray Leonard and Erik Dickerson must not be black. Someone should tell them!

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i-443dE5-gk

Dickerson...HAHAHAHAHAH.....

My only hesitation about getting too excited. Regardless of how it looks... Lack of physical feedback. Kicking air or kicking a real soccer ball are two totally different things.
What r u waiting for? Go outside and play some ball. Feel the sun, get burned by the ball when it hits you in the chest. Live life well.

M$ fanboys to the rescue!! :eek:
I think you all are doing a pretty good work.

They can integrate feedback into hand controllers - but that will only get you so far. If you want feedback like kicking a real soccer ball or punching a real face would provide, but in a game situation, perhaps the game interface you are really seeking is a holodeck.

I'll see if Scotty can beam you up and let you use his sometime.

Perhaps getting a life and actually doing it?
Can you imagine the possibilities of that!!! Larry Flint won't fill for bailout anymore.

Like I said... While some of those games seem cool on paper, once you actually play them I think you'd get tired of kicking air around after awhile. It's more strenuous to kick air than kick an actual ball.

You're right, there's no resistance compared to the forces involved with solids. That's why there's something called real life.
 
I'm going to avoid starting a flame war here and will just provide facts.

I knew that the "racism" Natal thing was a rumor hence why I mentioned it as such (and saying non-oranges is clearly sarcasm).

No M$ (that is for you, mon amie) operating system has had as many and as significant problems, all around, as Vista. I won't even bother with links because I would just be pulling links that support me.

The Zune sucks. It does. I do like the Xbox 360 though, that's why I own one.

Every single OS has a weak point. You simply can't use them for everything with the same level of success. Saying otherwise is just B.S.
 
Just medial scam, the program is bad only because it have problems with recognizing lower-contrasted black skin users it does not mean it's racist. Just someone wanted to get attention on internet and started posting shit so it's now total boom. That program is not perfect and probably later development will improve it.
 
I just hope someone makes a Virtual Sex game with Natel, Imagine how much money they can make when you have to pay for downloadable women! $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$
 
A few problems with Natal:

-Virtually no software that was built from the ground up was really shown for it.

-If it does release for the 360, it won't have a 100% attach rate. This means that developers are going to be very reluctant to work with it.

-It lends credence to the Wii's motion sensing capabilities and further reaffirms Nintendo as the market leader.

Bottom line, no new controller that was released in the middle of a generation has ever played any role, much less a significant or decisive one.
 
A few problems with Natal:

-Virtually no software that was built from the ground up was really shown for it.

-If it does release for the 360, it won't have a 100% attach rate. This means that developers are going to be very reluctant to work with it.

-It lends credence to the Wii's motion sensing capabilities and further reaffirms Nintendo as the market leader.

Bottom line, no new controller that was released in the middle of a generation has ever played any role, much less a significant or decisive one.

No software built from the ground up for it? Of what they've shown, everything was built specifically for it, except burnout, which is just to show that it can be integrated into existing games, which is...a good thing.

Wiimotion + doesn't have a 100% attach rate either, I guess nobody will make games for that, right?

Of course nintendo is the market leader, did anyone ever say that the 360 would start selling DS/Wii numbers just because of natal? That's you projecting.

Yeah, the wii balance board certainly hasn't sold for shit :rolleyes:

Wrong all around, but give it a few more tries.
 
Jimmy falon's video not available in US due to copyright restrictions...Way to go globalization.

Yeah, there have been much of that lately. That is just stupid.
There were rumors (engadget?) that Natal will come fall 2010? That's still a way to go. Maybe Natal will give some boost, but I can't think that it would be anything major, at least at that point. This is something still to bee seen with actually real games and usage.
 
Yeah, there have been much of that lately. That is just stupid.
There were rumors (engadget?) that Natal will come fall 2010? That's still a way to go. Maybe Natal will give some boost, but I can't think that it would be anything major, at least at that point. This is something still to bee seen with actually real games and usage.

Is burnout not a real game now?
 
I think it's funny how people say "Oh, this just shows MS and Sony are trying to emulate the Wii's capabilities!" See, what the Wii did was take a novelty technology and build a console around it. They didn't design the console for superior processing or anything of the sort; wholly motion sensor. So they led the industry, big fucking deal. Now Sony and MS can come in, having learned from Nintendo's mistakes, with considerably better motion sensor technologies and considerably better consoles (performance wise) and kick Nintendo's ass.
 
Is burnout not a real game now?

supposedly during the demo of burnout there was another person assisting. and that the pedal was either all the way or not. So i dont really count it.
 
This past year I worked on a rather substantial computer-vision project which performed human detection. Typically it worked less well on black or brown people, and this is commonly mentioned in literature for the field, so it wouldn't surprise me if the detection rates on the natal for these demographics are also somewhat lower.
 
supposedly during the demo of burnout there was another person assisting. and that the pedal was either all the way or not. So i dont really count it.

During which demo? E3? Good Morning America? Late Night? Any of the dozens of hands on?

Bullshit rumors are bullshit.
 
supposedly during the demo of burnout there was another person assisting. and that the pedal was either all the way or not. So i dont really count it.

Who would drive a car by putting his foot one step in front and brakes by taking a step back?
 
There was another pre-E3 blog that said while sitting down he played burnout using foot forward for gas and sitting up straight for brakes, which I kind of like better.

These motions can be whatever the developers want. And when more games are built with Natal in mind they should feel more natural. I think it'd be nice to see if Natal has a motion override setting to choose your own motions on a game by game basis. Other gameplay ideas that were mentioned in the interviews: physically ducking out of the way of an object in fps games and giving better hand/voice commands in stealth games.

Personally I think the fighting game would be pretty sweet or Fight Night 4. This does have a lot of potential, and MS is going to do all they can to get it in to market with dev's support. There is no point in trying to kill off a new technology. MS actually had a third party develop a motion controller shortly after launch, and I would bet that Natal is the final product based on the discussions of feasibility, marketing, and limitations of that controller.
 
I just hope someone makes a Virtual Sex game with Natel, Imagine how much money they can make when you have to pay for downloadable women! $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$

omg that combined with the glasses that have a display built into them and stereoscopic 3d, and a real doll, and allow user created 3d models. You could have sex with anyone in a way.

Man if I was rich I'd make this shit happen. Whoever does is going to be the next Bill Gates if done right.
 
No software built from the ground up for it? Of what they've shown, everything was built specifically for it, except burnout, which is just to show that it can be integrated into existing games, which is...a good thing.

If you're talking about Ricochet, Paint Party, and Milo & Kate, then MSFT is going to have to do better than that.

Wiimotion + doesn't have a 100% attach rate either, I guess nobody will make games for that, right?

Wiimotion+ is not a new control scheme, its just an improvement upon the already established Wiimote which devs have already been making games for. It's not the equivalent of releasing a new control scheme mid-gen like the Power Glove or Eye Toy.

Of course nintendo is the market leader, did anyone ever say that the 360 would start selling DS/Wii numbers just because of natal? That's you projecting.

No, I said that implementing a control scheme that's based upon what Nintendo has already done will just reaffirm the Wii's dominance and may even cause it to sell even better than what it is right now.

Yeah, the wii balance board certainly hasn't sold for shit :rolleyes:

The Wii Balance Board was made specifically for Wii Fit. It's not like the Wii was using standard controllers and then released the WBB as a new control scheme for all of its games.
 
If you're talking about Ricochet, Paint Party, and Milo & Kate, then MSFT is going to have to do better than that.

\Wiimotion+ is not a new control scheme, its just an improvement upon the already established Wiimote which devs have already been making games for. It's not the equivalent of releasing a new control scheme mid-gen like the Power Glove or Eye Toy.

No, I said that implementing a control scheme that's based upon what Nintendo has already done will just reaffirm the Wii's dominance and may even cause it to sell even better than what it is right now.

The Wii Balance Board was made specifically for Wii Fit. It's not like the Wii was using standard controllers and then released the WBB as a new control scheme for all of its games.

1. Oh, so first there was no software built for the system, but being wrong, now we're changing the argument. Well done....

2. Wiimotion + does not work on older games, so no, devs haven't been making games for it. They have to make games that only work with a new scheme. The new zelda is going to be motion+ exclusive. It's *exactly* a new control scheme released in the middle of the dev cycle.

3. How the hell would natal (or the ps3's system) increase wii sales? That's some really tortured logic there pal.

4. The wii balance board works with more than just wii fit, and even if it only worked for that, you said "no new controller has ever played a significant role. If you don't think wii fit has been significant, just take a look and you can see that the wii fit bundle itself will have outsold the ps3 in the US in probably a month and a half. Yeah...that's not a new controller and it's not significant.
 
Back
Top