iPhone 3G vs. iPhone 3G S

Its hard to find apps for windows mobile.

You're kidding right? It's EASY to find Windows Mobile apps. Check out Handango.com. Tons of vendors. I don't think people realize just how many apps are out there for Windows mobile. You gotta check out Skyfire, the mobile web browser for WinMo and Symbian that just came out of beta a couple of weeks ago. Nice mobile browser. Check out Orb, Kinoma Play and Spb offerings.

Don't know if you were looking for anything in particular. The iPhone's got a lot going for it these days but there's a lot for WinMo and my guess is that with Windows 7 Mobile you're going to see a whole new generation of apps flood the market. Now doubt the fine makers of many iPhone apps will be porting them as many WinMo developers are also working on the iPhone now.
 
Something that would allow me to navigate and execute options quickly, with one hand, and with minimal fuss. Like I said, I've seen no traditional interface on a phone that fits the bill. The only mobile interface that can deliver on these in an intuitive way is a touchscreen interface, in my opinion.

I'm not talking about the form aspect, but indeed the function. I am not concerned about whether my icons look shiny or not, if that's what you're suggesting.

Fairly obvious you haven't tried the Blackberry phones.
 
You're kidding right? It's EASY to find Windows Mobile apps. Check out Handango.com. Tons of vendors. I don't think people realize just how many apps are out there for Windows mobile. You gotta check out Skyfire, the mobile web browser for WinMo and Symbian that just came out of beta a couple of weeks ago. Nice mobile browser. Check out Orb, Kinoma Play and Spb offerings.

Don't know if you were looking for anything in particular. The iPhone's got a lot going for it these days but there's a lot for WinMo and my guess is that with Windows 7 Mobile you're going to see a whole new generation of apps flood the market. Now doubt the fine makers of many iPhone apps will be porting them as many WinMo developers are also working on the iPhone now.

Developing for Windows Mobile is a nightmare compared to making new iPhone apps. iPhone all have a common interface and screen resolution. Developing for Win Mo means you need to try accounting for keyboard or not, touchscreen or not, different screen resolutions, different screen formats, vastly different speeds, different storage setups, you need to worry about full UI mods that some companies try, and there is the fact that some devices have sliders and some do not.

This is why so many developers quickly migrated over to the iPhone platform. WM development is simply a pain in the ass and the tools MS put out to support it are crap. Their lack of standards and control over what the OEMs did just made the problem worse.

It is just simply easier to make an iPhone app and spend more time on the user experience compared to working on WM apps and worrying about if the damn thing is going to work. That is why you see so many people making iPhone apps and also why you see so many people buying iPhone apps.
 
Developing for Windows Mobile is a nightmare compared to making new iPhone apps. iPhone all have a common interface and screen resolution. Developing for Win Mo means you need to try accounting for keyboard or not, touchscreen or not, different screen resolutions, different screen formats, vastly different speeds, different storage setups, you need to worry about full UI mods that some companies try, and there is the fact that some devices have sliders and some do not.

This is why so many developers quickly migrated over to the iPhone platform. WM development is simply a pain in the ass and the tools MS put out to support it are crap. Their lack of standards and control over what the OEMs did just made the problem worse.

It is just simply easier to make an iPhone app and spend more time on the user experience compared to working on WM apps and worrying about if the damn thing is going to work. That is why you see so many people making iPhone apps and also why you see so many people buying iPhone apps.

This is a classic problem when dealing with a platform that is ten years old. The iPhone is only two years old. When Windows 7 Mobile comes out my guess is that older Windows CE stuff will fall by the wayside and people will jump on the new platform.

Actually Windows CE has some decent development tools. Visual Studio has a very nice IDE for Windows Mobile 5/6.
 
Something that would allow me to navigate and execute options quickly, with one hand, and with minimal fuss. Like I said, I've seen no traditional interface on a phone that fits the bill. The only mobile interface that can deliver on these in an intuitive way is a touchscreen interface, in my opinion.

I'm not talking about the form aspect, but indeed the function. I am not concerned about whether my icons look shiny or not, if that's what you're suggesting.

It's blatantly obvious you haven't used a Blackberry, or at least anytime in the past several years.
 
Define "incredible".

In my book, function comes before form.

Apple's interfaces are among the most logical, intuitive, functional ones out there, glitz has nothing to do with it. Hell, the current OS X UI is austere compared to the day-glo colors and reflections everywhere glitz of Windows. With Vista in particular, that was all surface BS while settings and functions were still obfuscated underneath layers of menus and tabs that make no logical sense to anybody except the UI "engineer" that designed it (fortunately Windows 7 has done a LOT to streamline and clean up the UI). Note, I like Vista, Windows 7, and OS X, but to accuse Apple of focusing on glitzy form when comparing it to what other guys do is ridiculous.

The same goes for their mobile interfaces. Simple simple simple and fast to do whatever it is you need to do. OS 3.0 goes even further by adding Spotlight. Just type the name of something and launch the app/phone number/song/game/whatever right there, easy.

"Form follows function" is the old saying, and Apple's UIs follow that to a T. You want to talk about frivolous design, look at the "lipstick on a pig" they put on HTC WinMo devices. Sure it has flashy graphics but the structure underneath is still fundamentally broken. The looks are completely superficial.
 
Apple's interfaces are among the most logical, intuitive, functional ones out there, glitz has nothing to do with it.

I decided to view a post to see, you know... If you're still a member of the Apple Cult, and I never read past that first line.

PLEASE explain to me how you ship a phone with out cut/copy/paste. Yea, you're so fucking right: it's so damned logical, intuitive, and functional.
 
This is a classic problem when dealing with a platform that is ten years old. The iPhone is only two years old. When Windows 7 Mobile comes out my guess is that older Windows CE stuff will fall by the wayside and people will jump on the new platform.

Actually Windows CE has some decent development tools. Visual Studio has a very nice IDE for Windows Mobile 5/6.

The only way application development is going to find real traction with WinMo is if there is a standardized hardware platform to develop for, and more importantly, if there is a centralized place in the UI where all WinMo users can download and purchase applications from.

Basically, do it the way Apple has done it for a year and how BB and Palm are doing it now. Unless you have a good way to reach the most customers possible and deliver a consistent experience to each and every one of them, there is little incentive to develop for that platform.
 
Here's my thoughts on this thread:
The touchscreen is nice simply because it makes everything compact and gives the phone a bigger screen to work with. I prefer physical buttons for everything (just replaced a toucscreen with a single DIN in the car) but with a phone I'd rather have a large screen and a slim package.

Fanbois.....I'm sick and tired of hearing how Apple's interfaces and OS's are so intuitive, easy to use, blah, blah, blah, blah. Stop regurgitating old 80's advertising tag lines that aren't true anymore. I will give Apple credit where credit is due, they nailed the iPhone interface but lets put the Kool-aide down when it comes to everything else.

The iPhone as a phone sucks. I'm sorry but it is the worst telephone I've ever used. It's saving grace is that it does everything else under the sun, albeit not very good sometimes but one mediocre device is better than a pocket stuffed full of good ones. Beggars can't be choosers in that regard.

Anyone who couldn't navigate my old blackberry with one hand easily and quickly is a retard. Nuff said.

As far as copy and paste goes, it shouldn't have taken them this long to include it. There is no excuse for that.
 
It's blatantly obvious you haven't used a Blackberry, or at least anytime in the past several years.
Again, how is it "obvious" (blatantly so, apparently) I haven't used a Blackberry recently? Can that be detailed for my own edification?

Otherwise, you completely dodged phide's points, good work there!
The strangest thing is that I have no recollection of making any points worth attacking or even acknowledging. I said, essentially, "touchscreens are the best mode of interfacing, in my opinion" (I purposefully included the last bit) and it's been nothing but a trollfest because of it. I'm apparently no longer even allowed to have an opinion on any subject without a thorough grilling. Yikes!
 
The iPhone as a phone sucks. I'm sorry but it is the worst telephone I've ever used.
In what way?

Anyone who couldn't navigate my old blackberry with one hand easily and quickly is a retard. Nuff said.
I guess that's directed at me. Thanks :rolleyes:

As far as copy and paste goes, it shouldn't have taken them this long to include it. There is no excuse for that.
I don't think any iPhone owner would disagree.
 
Here's my thoughts on this thread:
The touchscreen is nice simply because it makes everything compact and gives the phone a bigger screen to work with. I prefer physical buttons for everything (just replaced a toucscreen with a single DIN in the car) but with a phone I'd rather have a large screen and a slim package.

The large screen with soft buttons is a huge plus for me. I use all kinds of apps for work all the time that benefit from having such a big screen (sun path, gel pack swatches, as well as video and pictures).

I think the Bold is a great phone but I couldn't go back to losing so much usable screen space to a physical keyboard. Fortunately, BB makes awesome devices for people that want a keyboard (and a really crummy one for people that want a touchscreen :/ ).

Fanbois.....I'm sick and tired of hearing how Apple's interfaces and OS's are so intuitive, easy to use, blah, blah, blah, blah. Stop regurgitating old 80's advertising tag lines that aren't true anymore. I will give Apple credit where credit is due, they nailed the iPhone interface but lets put the Kool-aide down when it comes to everything else.

Fortunately there are plenty of MS engineers that agree with me and put a lot of effort into improving their products because the pressure from the "other guy" is very real. My source for all of my copies of Windows and Office since 2001 is an engineer there and he'll tell you the same thing. Hell, Jim Allchin's memos to Ballmer and Gates are public and they'll say the same thing. If there was no competition then we'd be stuck with Vista's convoluted UI instead of the streamlining in Windows 7.

Competition is good. Oh, crap, sorry, its that Kool Aid making me say that!

The iPhone as a phone sucks. I'm sorry but it is the worst telephone I've ever used. It's saving grace is that it does everything else under the sun, albeit not very good sometimes but one mediocre device is better than a pocket stuffed full of good ones. Beggars can't be choosers in that regard.

AT&T sucks. My experience using an iPhone in Europe and even Morocco of all places was better than here in the US. Its awful, and unfortunately AT&T have both of the best smartphones on the market, the iPhone and the Blackberry Bold. Its why I was bummed staying with T-Mobile for so long; they had the better network but Cingular had WAY cooler phones.

Nothing has changed in that respect. :/

Anyone who couldn't navigate my old blackberry with one hand easily and quickly is a retard. Nuff said.

I see plenty of retards that can BB with one hand, I think you need to go down a few notches from there...

As far as copy and paste goes, it shouldn't have taken them this long to include it. There is no excuse for that.

It is silly. I really want to know how many iterations they went through internally before they settled on the current solution. To their credit, they negated the need for cut/copy/paste as much as they could by including buttons to copy http addresses/youtube links/contacts/phone numbers/etc to emails.

That said, a clipboard, finally.
 
Again, how is it "obvious" (blatantly so, apparently) I haven't used a Blackberry recently? Can that be detailed for my own edification?


The strangest thing is that I have no recollection of making any points worth attacking or even acknowledging. I said, essentially, "touchscreens are the best mode of interfacing, in my opinion" (I purposefully included the last bit) and it's been nothing but a trollfest because of it. I'm apparently no longer even allowed to have an opinion on any subject without a thorough grilling. Yikes!

Its TechieSooner's opinion or no opinion, you're a mindless zombie otherwise.

I'm convinced that if Project Natal had come out of Sony, he'd be bashing it as ridiculous and posting this stupid video as much as he could: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pXN7vLPsDSM

I wonder how much it smells being that far up Ballmer's ass...
 
Fortunately there are plenty of MS engineers that agree with me and put a lot of effort into improving their products because the pressure from the "other guy" is very real. My source for all of my copies of Windows and Office since 2001 is an engineer there and he'll tell you the same thing. Hell, Jim Allchin's memos to Ballmer and Gates are public and they'll say the same thing. If there was no competition then we'd be stuck with Vista's convoluted UI instead of the streamlining in Windows 7.

Competition is good. Oh, crap, sorry, its that Kool Aid making me say that!
Competition is one thing, usability is another. The physical competition Apple gives MS is a drop in the bucket, what they're competing against is public opinion....same as the American car manufacturers. Last year Buick was the second most reliable car manufacturer yet all people see is an American car manufacturer and therefore assume it's unreliable. MS is dealing with the same thing as is Creative and every other company competing against Apple. The claims that the iPod was easier to navigate and use than the Vision:M is a perfect example. Everything Apple makes is automatically labeled as intuitive, revolutionary, blah, blah, blah. Apple benefits greatly from stereotypes and yes, anyone who can't see that is drinking the Kool-aid. Like I said, with the iPhone....yeah, navigation is pretty amazing but as far as usability is concerned in other areas...well....not so much.

AT&T sucks.
I wouldn't know, I'm on T-mobile.


I see plenty of retards that can BB with one hand, I think you need to go down a few notches from there...
Good point.



It is silly. I really want to know how many iterations they went through internally before they settled on the current solution. To their credit, they negated the need for cut/copy/paste as much as they could by including buttons to copy http addresses/youtube links/contacts/phone numbers/etc to emails.

That said, a clipboard, finally.
I doubt they went through many iterations at all. Hell, the jailbreak community has had copy/paste for a while now so you know it wasn't that hard.
 
In what way?
In what way does the BB suck? My BB is a breeze to navigate. One button brings up the menu, one click selects the feature I want...bam, done. It doesn't get much easier than that.

As far as the iPhone sucking. It's painfully slow, reception is horrific, call quality blows, the BT unbelievably bad (anyone that owns a BMW knows this), voice dialing is non existent, etc, etc. There isn't a day that goes by that I don't curse the phone features in one way or another.


I guess that's directed at me. Thanks :rolleyes:
I still use my blackberry daily and how anyone thinks that phone is difficult to navigate and use is beyond me. In fact, it's easier to use than my iPhone for the simple fact that it shipped with a manual. Apple is so full of themselves and believes in the "we're so much easier to use" mantra they didn't even bother shipping the phone with anything but a terrible leaflet that didn't explain anything.
 
Does the Blackberry have YouTube, Google Maps, Facebook, mp3/video player etc? I don't follow cell phones very closely, but it seems like the iPhone is by far the best choice for combination of form & function. It obviously has some flaws and AT&T plans pretty much suck, but from what I've seen nothing can match it in features and price. I'll be picking one up in a couple months when my current contract is done, but if there's something better out there, I'd love to take a look at it.
 
Does the Blackberry have YouTube, Google Maps, Facebook, mp3/video player etc? I don't follow cell phones very closely, but it seems like the iPhone is by far the best choice for combination of form & function. It obviously has some flaws and AT&T plans pretty much suck, but from what I've seen nothing can match it in features and price. I'll be picking one up in a couple months when my current contract is done, but if there's something better out there, I'd love to take a look at it.

Yes on YouTube, Google Maps (including Latitude), and MP3 player. Blackberries can also record videos. No idea about Facebook though because I don't do Facebook.
 
Does the Blackberry have YouTube, Google Maps, Facebook, mp3/video player etc? I don't follow cell phones very closely, but it seems like the iPhone is by far the best choice for combination of form & function. It obviously has some flaws and AT&T plans pretty much suck, but from what I've seen nothing can match it in features and price. I'll be picking one up in a couple months when my current contract is done, but if there's something better out there, I'd love to take a look at it.


Yeah, my BB does....Watching Youtube video now, updated FB this morning, used GPS enabled Google Map yesterday.
 
Does the Blackberry have YouTube, Google Maps, Facebook, mp3/video player etc? I don't follow cell phones very closely, but it seems like the iPhone is by far the best choice for combination of form & function.

Does all that and more.

It did that BEFORE the iPhone came out.
 
While not condensed down into one App Store like Apple does, the applications for Blackberry are pretty slick, too.

One word that comes to mind regarding Blackberry apps is "quality"... Just seems like they're all done much better than anything I've used on WinMo or iPhone. They're all painfully easy to use as well.
 
I was looking at a BB Pearl for a long time, because I liked the form factor, but the iPhone really caught my eye after spending some time with an iTouch. The touch screen interface and gui are fantastic. Maybe I'll check out another Blackberry, but most them seem too unwieldy with the huge keyboards.
 
I was looking at a BB Pearl for a long time, because I liked the form factor, but the iPhone really caught my eye after spending some time with an iTouch. The touch screen interface and gui are fantastic. Maybe I'll check out another Blackberry, but most them seem too unwieldy with the huge keyboards.

Get the Blackberry Bold and don't look back. It's fast and awesome.
 
I was looking at a BB Pearl for a long time, because I liked the form factor, but the iPhone really caught my eye after spending some time with an iTouch. The touch screen interface and gui are fantastic. Maybe I'll check out another Blackberry, but most them seem too unwieldy with the huge keyboards.

The Pearl is only good for a consumer that wants phone and texting... It's really underpowered for any Power Users.

I carry a Bold myself, although if you don't care about 3G the Curve would work too. The Curve is lighter and smaller.

Bold is one of the fastest phones you can buy... Has plenty of RAM in it, SD slot is awesome, so I've got 16GB of music and movies on my phone.

It flat out kicks the iPhone's ass, minus (again) the touchscreen and "glitz" factor. The thing is, I've yet to find anything the iPhone does that I wishes my Bold could do. But I can point out many things my Bold does that the iPhone DOES NOT do.

Especially if you hook it up to a BES server (For one person that probably is not economical)... Features expand all the more.
 
I can point out many things my Bold does that the iPhone DOES NOT do.

Such as? There's nothing that I can fathom doing with my cell phone that I couldn't do with the iPhone. There's actually much more available on the iPhone than I probably should be doing. :p

I found this article comparing the Bold and the iPhone with side by side comparisons and iPhone still wins out. Not only in function, but also in form. The UI seems much better designed overall. The Bold has some nice features that have caught up to what the iPhone offers, but for total package iPhone still seems to be the winner.
 
Such as? There's nothing that I can fathom doing with my cell phone that I couldn't do with the iPhone. There's actually much more available on the iPhone than I probably should be doing. :p

I found this article comparing the Bold and the iPhone with side by side comparisons and iPhone still wins out. Not only in function, but also in form. The UI seems much better designed overall. The Bold has some nice features that have caught up to what the iPhone offers, but for total package iPhone still seems to be the winner.

The article wasn't entirely truthful about the Blackberry, and some of them are opinions.

Trust me, Blackberry's easy to use, fast and reliable. It didn't become the top selling smartphone by being junk.

For example:

The BlackBerry (right) places apps in multiple folders, so they're harder to find.

Not true. The folder names are self explanatory. Applications, Games, Internet and so forth. Besides, you don't have to have folders. You can take them out and put them on your main screen just like the iPhone.

As for OTA installation (over the air), they're full of shit. It doesn't get any easier than getting a full screen prompt "Download" and then another full screen window saying a software is being installed, please wait. If that's what they consider hard to do, then they better go back to using Fisher Price phones.

Blackberries are very easy to use. I've been a Blackberry user for about 6 years now and counting. If it was as terrible as the article makes it out to be, then why are people still using Blackberries?
 
Blackberries are very easy to use. I've been a Blackberry user for about 6 years now and counting. If it was as terrible as the article makes it out to be, then why are people still using Blackberries?

Because RIM has a cult following on its CEO and its products?
Oh wait...
 
Such as? There's nothing that I can fathom doing with my cell phone that I couldn't do with the iPhone. There's actually much more available on the iPhone than I probably should be doing. :p
Encryption from the device all the way back to the server? Remote wipe? Ability to configure basically any aspect or feature of the device as well...

I found this article comparing the Bold and the iPhone with side by side comparisons and iPhone still wins out.

Home Screen- Can be skinned and customized on the Bold.
Emails- The iPhone originally didn't even have Exchange support... Other than that, tactile feedback with full QWERTY keyboard pretty much wins out on a touch device, considering I can type by feel and not have to look at what letter I'm hitting.
Folders- Author is a jackass and obviously doesn't know these are changeable settings.
Calendars- Pretty equal IMO, but Blackberry again has the enterprise edge.
Contacts- Author says letter navigation is faster on the iPhone? :rolleyes: I can type out a portion of someone's name on my Blackberry and instantly get to them, like Vista's search does. Blackberry wins that one hands-down, alll without having to pull up a search function. OR I can type a single letter. Either way is faster than the iPhone.
Apps- Blackberry can download stuff OTA too. Again, it's just the difference of an App Store on iPhone compared to many developers on many websites with the Blackberry. Both have good application support.
Folders (again)- Customizable. Author even says this yet still knocks it against the Blackberry :rolleyes:
Documents- The Bold actually comes with Documents to Go... It wins. However editing docs on ANY phone sucks...
Maps- Google Maps, Live Maps, Blackberry Maps... All good options. And FWIW, the Blackberry has a true GPS, whereas the iPhone didn't get one until 3G version.
Mobile websites- OK so the author is knocking the Bold for how someone designs their mobile website? :rolleyes:
The web- Given, this is the one thing the iPhone does better than anything else.
 
Because RIM has a cult following on its CEO and its products?
Oh wait...

What other options are there???
Your only other option is Windows Mobile, which still doesn't come close to the enterprise features of the Blackberry, and it's buggy as can be, too. Just because a device (iPhone) has Exchange support doesn't make it an enterprise device.

Only time my Blackberry has crashed is when it played a corrupted WMV file.
 
What other options are there???
Your only other option is Windows Mobile, which still doesn't come close to the enterprise features of the Blackberry, and it's buggy as can be, too. Just because a device (iPhone) has Exchange support doesn't make it an enterprise device.

Only time my Blackberry has crashed is when it played a corrupted WMV file.

You fail @ sarcasm.
 
In what way does the BB suck?
When exactly did I say that Blackberries suck? I never said that.

I still use my blackberry daily and how anyone thinks that phone is difficult to navigate and use is beyond me.
Once again, I never said Blackberries are "difficult", as you put it. I implied that the iPhone was unmatched in ease of use and interface intuitiveness, and I expressed clearly that it was my opinion having played with a variety of other phones. That's it.

In fact, it's easier to use than my iPhone for the simple fact that it shipped with a manual. Apple is so full of themselves and believes in the "we're so much easier to use" mantra they didn't even bother shipping the phone with anything but a terrible leaflet that didn't explain anything.
Well, let me pull a Blown 89 here, if I may:

Anyone who couldn't navigate an iPhone easily and quickly is a retard. Nuff said.
 
Anyone who couldn't navigate an iPhone easily and quickly is a retard. Nuff said.

True. I was just hanging out with some friends for lunch and I borrowed my friends 3g and I needed no instructions on how to use it. Pretty slick interface.
 
This is ridiculous. The Blackberry, especially the Bold, is an excellent product. I don't see how one being good automatically makes the other one bad.

If I was in the market for a phone with a keyboard I'd snap up a Bold in a second. You're missing out on a large screen but what it does have works great, certainly better than any other phone with a physical keyboard that I can think of.

My personal preference is for soft keys; at this point I type faster on it than I ever did with a physical keyboard interface (I blame decades of violent videogames for my speed there :eek: ). Having a full screen for things like my sun path app, my photo apps, gel swatches, etc, are also very useful for my work. But again, personal preference, if I wanted a keyboard it would hardly be a step back if I went with a BB Bold.

Seriously, this isn't frigging Windows Mobile or Symbian we're talking about here. :rolleyes:
 
True. I was just hanging out with some friends for lunch and I borrowed my friends 3g and I needed no instructions on how to use it. Pretty slick interface.

I've seen two year olds that can navigate an iPhone and play games on them. If you can't figure one out then you're either legally retarded or at best, dumber than a baby :D
 
Does the Blackberry have YouTube, Google Maps, Facebook, mp3/video player etc? I don't follow cell phones very closely, but it seems like the iPhone is by far the best choice for combination of form & function. It obviously has some flaws and AT&T plans pretty much suck, but from what I've seen nothing can match it in features and price. I'll be picking one up in a couple months when my current contract is done, but if there's something better out there, I'd love to take a look at it.

The Bold does all of those things very well. You're sacrificing screen size for a keyboard (which is a plus if you're not good at using soft keyboards) and you don't have as big a selection of applications for it, but otherwise it is an excellent device. IMHO it is the best keyboard based smartphone out there, you should check it out.
 
Well, let me pull a Blown 89 here, if I may:

Anyone who couldn't navigate an iPhone easily and quickly is a retard. Nuff said.
Navigation is one thing but the manual barely even touches on the gestures and general operation of the phone. I can't tell you how many people I've met who didn't know how to move a cursor or have a permanent caps lock.
 
Back
Top