iPhone 3G vs. iPhone 3G S

lol here in canada we dont get unlimited anything at all :( I'm paying 30 bucks extra a month for 6 gig data plan for iphone 3g :( in addition to voice plan.
 
Wow, $1000 difference over two years between 200 texts a month and unlimited texting. I save a little bit with 1500 texts for $15 a month, but man they kill you on those. That and ringtones are just the biggest ripoffs that any phone carrier has.
 
lol here in canada we dont get unlimited anything at all :( I'm paying 30 bucks extra a month for 6 gig data plan for iphone 3g :( in addition to voice plan.

Yeah, people in the US complain about plans but everyone else on the planet gets absolutely slaughtered on usage and data plans. You poor guys in Canada have it worse than the Europeans in some ways because at least their cellular data networks seem to be faster and more reliable. :(
 

The Pre is kind of stillborn at this point. For $99 you can get a 3G iPhone with the same amount of storage, a huge selection of applications, better quality hardware (Palm really shouldn't have skimped on this), and a cheaper data plan, all at a third of the price for the hardware. Spend as much as the Pre and you're talking 32GB and the new features of the 3Gs.

I'm convinced that Apple kept the old 3G at $100 just to curbstomp the competition. Getting it to more people, yes, obviously, but absolutely destroying the other guy before they even have a chance to get out of the gate had to be another factor.
 
The Pre is kind of stillborn at this point. For $99 you can get a 3G iPhone with the same amount of storage, a huge selection of applications, better quality hardware (Palm really shouldn't have skimped on this), and a cheaper data plan, all at a third of the price for the hardware. Spend as much as the Pre and you're talking 32GB and the new features of the 3Gs.

I'm convinced that Apple kept the old 3G at $100 just to curbstomp the competition. Getting it to more people, yes, obviously, but absolutely destroying the other guy before they even have a chance to get out of the gate had to be another factor.

Sprint has the Everything 450 plan for $69 with 450 minutes + unlimited texting + data. $99 gets you unlimited everything for voice minutes + data + texting on Sprint. I am not really seeing anything comparable to these offered on iPhones.
 
Sprint has the Everything 450 plan for $69 with 450 minutes + unlimited texting + data. $99 gets you unlimited everything for voice minutes + data + texting on Sprint. I am not really seeing anything comparable to these offered on iPhones.

Yeah, but all that comes with sprint, which is enough for me to chose anything else, regardless of the cost, cause frankly sprint is the prime example of "you get what you pay for"
 
Sprint has the Everything 450 plan for $69 with 450 minutes + unlimited texting + data. $99 gets you unlimited everything for voice minutes + data + texting on Sprint. I am not really seeing anything comparable to these offered on iPhones.

I see. Does that plan also apply to the Pre? I'm just going off of the numbers from the link that Bullfrog2099 posted.
 
June 19th :C. I knew it was comming lol. 499 with out upgrading contract! Was 799 for 16gb before but 499 for 32gb is GREAT!
 
Still not worth it in my opinion. Though that's mostly also because I want a qwerty keyboard. :(
 
All this talk and no mention of the bluetooth stack.

Do we get a full bluetooth stack? I use bluetooth gizmos that the iPhone previously didn't work with.
 
lol here in canada we dont get unlimited anything at all :( I'm paying 30 bucks extra a month for 6 gig data plan for iphone 3g :( in addition to voice plan.

That is actually better than what you get stateside.

We get 5gb a month for 30 dollars with tethering banned. That is what the fine print on the "unlimited" plan really says. Its an extra 30 a month if you want tethering.
 
Sprint has the Everything 450 plan for $69 with 450 minutes + unlimited texting + data. $99 gets you unlimited everything for voice minutes + data + texting on Sprint. I am not really seeing anything comparable to these offered on iPhones.

and thats just with one phone, for a family of iphones, the savings is huge. We have 3 iphones, costs us about 240.00 bucks a month. 1500 texts. 2100 minutes. We never use all of our minutes.

You can get 1500 minutes on sprint, unlimited texts, 3 palm pres. 150.00 a month. Or 3000 minutes, unlimited everything else. 190 a month. Either way a huge savings over AT&T. Still cant decide if I will make the jump.
 
I am kinda chuckling at this whole thread.

I was waiting to hear what the new Apple model was going to be and I am sadly disappointed.

-Same camera with an extra 1.2MP, no flash( LED or Xenon )
-No removable media slot
-No removable battery

Those are the hardware issues I have with the new model.

On the carrier side of things:

-$30 data plan


Being an AT&T Customer already who owns a unlocked( not jailbroken, unlocked which is perfectly legal )Nokia N82, I was looking for a touchscreen device with a decent hardware package. The iPhone, old model or new, doesn't even come close to what the N82 packs in her case. The only thing an iPhone has over mine is touch screen and how well Apple implemented it, otherwise it is a very crappy phone.

The Pros of an iPhone:

-Touchscreen
-......touchscreen?

I cannot even say App Store....I have just as many apps for the S60 that are useful to me as I would on the iPhone.

I cannot even get the phone subsidized at a cheaper price and turn around to sell it, because I would then have to pay $30 a month for an unlimited data package, whereas with another unlocked phone, I would pay just $10 for unlimited data and the $20 Unlimited Family Messaging plan...

I cannot believe how much hype is going into this phone, and it's not even a smart phone for crying out loud!!!
 
AT&T is the reason I've never considered getting an iPhone. I'm sorry, but their plans are way too expensive compared to others. I'd consider taking a dive if and when Apple decides to leave AT&T in the dust.

Their network is oversold, they have no support as of yet for MMS, Tethering is going to be at an extra cost, of that I'm pretty confident.

IMO, Apple's marriage to AT&T at this stage is doing more harm than good. Seriously, I'd like to know what type of uptake they'd be looking at dumping exclusivity with AT&T.
 
That is actually better than what you get stateside.

We get 5gb a month for 30 dollars with tethering banned. That is what the fine print on the "unlimited" plan really says. Its an extra 30 a month if you want tethering.

Heh, Rogers allows tethering for ALL plans that consist of 1GB and up but honestly, the company is a major ripoff. The only way to save is either a) Sign a contract or b) Threaten to cancel and sign a contract of which the latter saves you more money.

My bill(s) over the last two years have gone up several times and I'm currently paying $30 extra after the last hike and lost my 15% (another $30 or so odd dollars) discount because I refuse to sign a 2 year contract with them to save myself the 15%.

Anyhow, it should change when Globallive comes in Q4 or Q1 of next year. The company has already done quite a bit of viral marketing on HoFo and the plans seem VERY reasonable (even if they are $10 more expensive) as they consider "local" calls as in nationwide.
 
AT&T is the reason I've never considered getting an iPhone. I'm sorry, but their plans are way too expensive compared to others. I'd consider taking a dive if and when Apple decides to leave AT&T in the dust.

Their network is oversold, they have no support as of yet for MMS, Tethering is going to be at an extra cost, of that I'm pretty confident.

IMO, Apple's marriage to AT&T at this stage is doing more harm than good. Seriously, I'd like to know what type of uptake they'd be looking at dumping exclusivity with AT&T.

Right now Apple can probably get away with it having the iPhone only on AT&T. I do think that in the near future that could become more on an issue. Microsoft I think is going to pull out a lot of stops with its upcoming Windows 7 Mobile. From rumors I've been hearing this is really going to shake up the mobile space a bit, could be totally wrong but I think Microsoft knows that anything LESS then fairly impressive for its revamped mobile platform could be a serious black eye.

BTW, congrats to iPhone users! You guys FINALLY got built-in voice control and dialing, something that's been on WinMo phones in the form of Voice Commander (which it awesome) and other voice control apps for many years now.

But the Apple mystic will make people think that Apple had it first, oh well.!
 
and thats just with one phone, for a family of iphones, the savings is huge. We have 3 iphones, costs us about 240.00 bucks a month. 1500 texts. 2100 minutes.

You are clearly doing something wrong. We pay $180/month for four (soon to be five) iPhones, 1800 minutes, and unlimited texts.
 
You are clearly doing something wrong. We pay $180/month for four (soon to be five) iPhones, 1800 minutes, and unlimited texts.

My Verizon plan runs me about $210 a month. I have an HTC Touch Pro, and two Motorola flip phones with 1400 minutes an unlimited data plan on the HTC Touch Pro and standalone data card with an unlimited data plan and unlimited texting. Not to bad except for the low amount of voice minutes but now that Verizon has a friends and family circle deal with any ten numbers not costing any minutes, minutes are not a problem anymore. I'm on the phone a fair amount and now only use about half my minutes a month.
 
200 text messages/month for a whopping, massive, fiscally insane $5 more. My god... someone call the FCC. Charges must be filed against Apple immediately.

200 isn't enough? Here's a novel idea: call someone. There's a reason it's called an i-PHONE.

Sadly, your seeming hatred for text messaging made you blind to a blatantly obvious irony in your statement.

iPhone - it's also an app and game device, an mp3 player, a camera, and much much more - it's a jack of all trade device. What's text messaging to all this??

it's hardly just an i PHONE.

:rolleyes:
 
Yeah, but all that comes with sprint, which is enough for me to chose anything else, regardless of the cost, cause frankly sprint is the prime example of "you get what you pay for"

Flawless clear reception and great signal strength everywhere I have been?

The only gripe I had was my phone doing some funky power cycling, a few days later sprint pushed a patch for that and the phone has worked flawlessly.
 
Right now Apple can probably get away with it having the iPhone only on AT&T. I do think that in the near future that could become more on an issue. Microsoft I think is going to pull out a lot of stops with its upcoming Windows 7 Mobile. From rumors I've been hearing this is really going to shake up the mobile space a bit, could be totally wrong but I think Microsoft knows that anything LESS then fairly impressive for its revamped mobile platform could be a serious black eye.

BTW, congrats to iPhone users! You guys FINALLY got built-in voice control and dialing, something that's been on WinMo phones in the form of Voice Commander (which it awesome) and other voice control apps for many years now.

But the Apple mystic will make people think that Apple had it first, oh well.!

MS has done so little to develop their mobile OS is is almost insulting to consider them competition in the smartphone market. Current versions of Windows Mobile (6.1) are barely an improvement over versions of Windows CE available almost a decade ago. Some of the phone hardware is nice, however the OS *sucks*. Not only that, everything keeps getting delayed, delayed, delayed... Heck where is Pocket IE 6.0 anyway? Should have been released a long time ago and available to anyone as a free download (its never going to be release as a free download though).

A lot of the neat stuff done on some of the newer WM phones was done by the vendors like HTC and is not even from MS. And it does not help that MS will license out the OS for anyone to throw on mobile phones that would look cheap in a Cracker Jack box. Windows Mobile is a joke from 1998 compared to the Pre WebOS, Android phones, iPhones, and newer Nokias.

MS has been teasing "next version will be good" since well before WM 5.0 even came out. They have failed to deliver with each release and put out a medicore platform. I see no reason to expect WM 7.0 to be any different.
 
MS has done so little to develop their mobile OS is is almost insulting to consider them competition in the smartphone market. Current versions of Windows Mobile (6.1) are barely an improvement over versions of Windows CE available almost a decade ago. Some of the phone hardware is nice, however the OS *sucks*. Not only that, everything keeps getting delayed, delayed, delayed... Heck where is Pocket IE 6.0 anyway? Should have been released a long time ago and available to anyone as a free download (its never going to be release as a free download though).

A lot of the neat stuff done on some of the newer WM phones was done by the vendors like HTC and is not even from MS. And it does not help that MS will license out the OS for anyone to throw on mobile phones that would look cheap in a Cracker Jack box. Windows Mobile is a joke from 1998 compared to the Pre WebOS, Android phones, iPhones, and newer Nokias.

MS has been teasing "next version will be good" since well before WM 5.0 even came out. They have failed to deliver with each release and put out a medicore platform. I see no reason to expect WM 7.0 to be any different.

You have valid points about the CURRENT version of WinMo but I was talking about the NEXT version. As you have pointed out, Windows CE is 10 years old and it still has a good deal of support.

As the phone space moves so rapidly and is so big, Microsoft just needs to get in the game with a solid offering and I think they can do that. They need to market the hell out of their next mobile offering for sure however.

As for browsers on the WinMo platform, there are a lot out there actually. There's Opera, Skyfire and even the Mozzila offering. Pocket IE currently is just there to be there right now. Skyfire is actually rather cool and supports Flash in the browser so most Flash sites work well without the need for a dedicated app.
 
am I the only one that can't stand touchscreen's. I really want to get an affordable wi-fi phone (iphone 3g now fills most of that gap) but I need some tactile feedback, I try to browse and enter textboxes on my friends iphone. I NEVER hit the right spots (lots of guys have this problem, its not just me....)
 
Their network is oversold, they have no support as of yet for MMS, Tethering is going to be at an extra cost, of that I'm pretty confident.
MMs works perfectly fine on my Blackberry. I've had it on all the phones I've had for the past 5 years.
Heck, MMS has been around in basic form since the 90s (was just bold, color, etc...).

MMS is just another thing that the competition has had for years, that Apple has yet to pick up.

All the iPhone is is "OMG!!! Touchscreen!!!!" with a fancy interface. Featurewise it truly sucks, though getting better.

MS has done so little to develop their mobile OS is is almost insulting to consider them competition in the smartphone market. Current versions of Windows Mobile (6.1) are barely an improvement over versions of Windows CE available almost a decade ago.
Hence his mention of the future Windows Mobile 7.
Your reading comprehension fails.
 
Hence his mention of the future Windows Mobile 7.
Your reading comprehension fails.

Why would anyone expect WM 7 to be any different than past failures? With both WM 5.0 and WM 6.0, they could easily see the competition was going to eclipse them and they did nothing. Their developer support is horrendous, updates for the apps have been non-existant, they have 0 quality control on the phones that get released, and no attempt has been made to fix a lot of inherent problems on the platform. Heck they have not even redone most of the icons up even through 6.1. Microsoft does not give a shit about innovating in the phone space, if they did, they would have done something long before now.

Now people are like "Ok ok, this time Microsoft will get it right! Really! Who cares about that 0 developer support and the decade of terribleness by MS" By the time MS finishes delaying WM 7.0 and finally gets it out the door, its going to be another reskin of the same crap they have been pushing for a decade. Plus we can safely assume that BlackBerry OS, WebOS, Android, and the iPhone platform will all see further improvements before WM 7 get released.
 
All the iPhone is is "OMG!!! Touchscreen!!!!" with a fancy interface. Featurewise it truly sucks, though getting better.

App support is so far beyond what anybody else has it isn't even funny. Its the main reason I'm still on the platform.
 
My wife and I are on the Sprint family data plan. We have a 15% discount from my company. We pay 108.00 a month including taxes for 1500 anytime min, unlimited mobile 2 moble, data and texting as well as free nights and weekends starting at 7pm. The service is great, my 3g is fast and we pay a fraction of what ATT would charge.
 
Why would anyone expect WM 7 to be any different than past failures?
A few reasons.
A) Microsoft realizes WinMo sucks right now.
B) They've come out and said they're pretty much starting 7.0 from scratch
C) HTC has been having to write their own interface on top of WinMo, and that looks bad on Microsoft
D) Would you expect another failure? I mean Microsoft is on a freaking roll. Windows 7, Natal, the upcoming 360 features, etc... Microsoft is positioned to re-enforce itself as the dominate software authority.


My wife and I are on the Sprint family data plan. We have a 15% discount from my company. We pay 108.00 a month including taxes for 1500 anytime min, unlimited mobile 2 moble, data and texting as well as free nights and weekends starting at 7pm. The service is great, my 3g is fast and we pay a fraction of what ATT would charge.
Yea I've never had problems with Sprint, either. Their network does perform better IMO... The only issue is they don't have as much coverage as ATT though.
 
No touch screen?! Is this 1999? ;) One of the biggest appeals of the iPhone is the touch screen interface. My gf has an iTouch and I love the simple, easy to use interface.

I love your gf's simple, easy to use interface too!
 
I try to browse and enter textboxes on my friends iphone. I NEVER hit the right spots (lots of guys have this problem, its not just me....)
It takes a little time. You kind of have to learn that your finger is never quite where you expect it to be, so you have to learn to compensate. This isn't a fault of touchscreens but seemingly a human fault :)

All the iPhone is is "OMG!!! Touchscreen!!!!" with a fancy interface. Featurewise it truly sucks, though getting better.
I will say that I won't ever buy a phone that doesn't utilize a touchscreen after having owned an iPhone unless some manufacturer designs an incredible traditional interface. I haven't encountered such a phone yet.
 
A few reasons.
A) Microsoft realizes WinMo sucks right now.
B) They've come out and said they're pretty much starting 7.0 from scratch
C) HTC has been having to write their own interface on top of WinMo, and that looks bad on Microsoft
D) Would you expect another failure? I mean Microsoft is on a freaking roll. Windows 7, Natal, the upcoming 360 features, etc... Microsoft is positioned to re-enforce itself as the dominate software authority.



Yea I've never had problems with Sprint, either. Their network does perform better IMO... The only issue is they don't have as much coverage as ATT though.

I think the next year will be one of the most critical in Microsoft's history. How will it fare through the economic downturn? Will it Windows 7 cast off the negative Vista PR and become the true successor to XP and be well received? What about the the mobile space with Zune and Windows 7 mobile? Let's not forget new development tools in the form of Visual Studio 2010 and Expression Studio 3, good old Office 2010. And lets not forget online services. Bing, Office Online, etc.

Big year for my favorite software company! Can't wait for my Zune HD!
 
Right now i have an att fuze. i preordered the iphone 3gs (this will essentially give me two phones to switch between) . The two phones cost exactly the same on att's network . so between an iphone and winmo smart phone they are not any different per month.

Also i like the customization of the winmo smart phone but like all the apps in the app store better. Its hard to find apps for windows mobile.
 
Define "incredible".
Something that would allow me to navigate and execute options quickly, with one hand, and with minimal fuss. Like I said, I've seen no traditional interface on a phone that fits the bill. The only mobile interface that can deliver on these in an intuitive way is a touchscreen interface, in my opinion.

I'm not talking about the form aspect, but indeed the function. I am not concerned about whether my icons look shiny or not, if that's what you're suggesting.
 
Back
Top