Computer Repair Shops Put To The Test

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Stories about undercover reporters putting computer repair shops to the test by asking for repairs on a rigged PC are always fun. Well unless you are the person that ended up with a $580 bill for an unplugged IDE cable. :eek:

A test of computer repair shops in the Portland area this month revealed a local store that required $580 to fix a problem other shops fixed for free.
 
Last edited:
Ah, i'll never forget my first IT job outa college with my associates degree in Information Systems Managment, A+ and Network + trying to find my first IT job in the market still recovering from the .com bubble crash. Working in the dark back room with no outside windows and learning the ways of the "real" IT work and spending hours upon hours removing viruses and spyware from mom and pop machines and porno from student laptops.

Met every person who owned a PC in the world in that old shop. From lowly poor preacher who had no money to fix his small churches old Packard Bell, to a insane bi-polar lady who insisted that I destroyed her computer because I didn't plug in a "HP certified" VGA cable into the video card. From meeting some VERY cute Japanese girls and trying to fix their Toshiba Satellite in Japanese font on Windows ME *shudder* who invited me to their dorm room for green tea as a thank you. To the mormon woman who paid us $500 to find evidence on the family machine for porn to have her husband excommunicated from the church *only to find none, he simply was caught with a porn up up add at the wrong place at the wrong time* I learned alot from that job....

And now I sat in my house most of the day working on my R/C monster truck, took a nice walk ouside in the sunshine, worked on my car and got paid salary for it and all because work didn't need me to fix any clients issues for a VERY large investment firm.

Been there, done that. :cool:
 
I can see an employee making the mistake of assuming the hard drive was broken right away without looking at it and then plugging in a new one to confirm their suspicion, but he then said the computer had a virus... So it is pretty obvious something was up with the tech.
 
Two days later, a Geek Squad employee said the hard drive was broken and $580 was needed for repair. When FOX 12 picked up the computer, the Geek Squad technician also said the computer had a virus and suggested purchasing a new computer, an area in which it would be glad to help.[/QUOTE

This is a blatant attempt at a rip off....hopefully the offender gets fired.
 
I love how they call it a misdiagnosis when it was obviously an outright scam. Now the question is, was the technician doing it on his own, or did his manager instruct him to do so?
 
99.999/100 times its because the managers insist or imply that employees need to meet some sort of quota, or gauge the situation (whether the customer is a gullible moron or not) and prescribe services from there.

I know, I've worked for a retailer as pc tech.
 
Ah, i'll never forget my first IT job outa college with my associates degree in Information Systems Managment, A+ and Network + trying to find my first IT job in the market still recovering from the .com bubble crash. Working in the dark back room with no outside windows and learning the ways of the "real" IT work and spending hours upon hours removing viruses and spyware from mom and pop machines and porno from student laptops.

Met every person who owned a PC in the world in that old shop. From lowly poor preacher who had no money to fix his small churches old Packard Bell, to a insane bi-polar lady who insisted that I destroyed her computer because I didn't plug in a "HP certified" VGA cable into the video card. From meeting some VERY cute Japanese girls and trying to fix their Toshiba Satellite in Japanese font on Windows ME *shudder* who invited me to their dorm room for green tea as a thank you. To the mormon woman who paid us $500 to find evidence on the family machine for porn to have her husband excommunicated from the church *only to find none, he simply was caught with a porn up up add at the wrong place at the wrong time* I learned alot from that job....

And now I sat in my house most of the day working on my R/C monster truck, took a nice walk ouside in the sunshine, worked on my car and got paid salary for it and all because work didn't need me to fix any clients issues for a VERY large investment firm.

Been there, done that. :cool:


Thats what I like to hear, the crazier the better. Good stories, but you should come out of retirement for more.
 
Hey! Something local!

There's this place out here that charges $110 an hour labor, typical jobs being 2 hours labor + parts.

Where I used to work we charged $45 an hour and people still complained.
 
~$50/hr is a fairly standard rate for most pc repair jobs around my area. i make 50 freelancing here. dont see what the big deal is.. most jobs dont take very long.
 
I did potential hire testing at a very small company back when I worked in college. I setup a practical exam with 7 different issues, one being the the speakers plugged into the wrong port on the sound card.

I think in two years of giving that exam only one tech actually figured out the issue without trying everything else first, if they figured it out at all.

I think some of the tech applicants were nearly as dumb as the users. This case sounds like a pure fraud though.
 
An old Cisco instructor taught me something I will never forget and turned out to be true over and again, "90% of all issues are media related".
 
I can see an employee making the mistake of assuming the hard drive was broken right away without looking at it and then plugging in a new one to confirm their suspicion, but he then said the computer had a virus... So it is pretty obvious something was up with the tech.

Yea really, the 2 things don't go together.

^^ i know i wouldnt pay $45 an hour to have my pc worked on.

It is a field with professionals just like anywhere else. PC techs are just a new generation of techs. Really its just a new form of a mechanic, plumber, or electrician. Business IT rates at a lot higher. Figure 80 to 90 bucks an hour starting with most being 110 to 130ish for basic support.

I did potential hire testing at a very small company back when I worked in college. I setup a practical exam with 7 different issues, one being the the speakers plugged into the wrong port on the sound card.

I think in two years of giving that exam only one tech actually figured out the issue without trying everything else first, if they figured it out at all.

I think some of the tech applicants were nearly as dumb as the users. This case sounds like a pure fraud though.

As simple as that test is checking the connection would be one of the last things I could see people checking unless they knew the person just moved the machine or something. Still it is something one should be able to figure out.
 
I really want to ask the geek squad guy how the hell he found a virus in a dead hard drive?!



And even if there was...its a dead hard drive!
 
The geek squad at my old store was not like this. What a shame because one bad apple spoils the bunch.
 
I am a seasoned tech with 10 years professional experience and 16 years geek experience. I've done all kinds of repairs, troubleshooting, servers, and networking. I'll meet a person here and there that knows what they are doing, but a lot of young techs a very questionable. They may know the stuff on books, but lack the experience to apply it. The techs I meet from the dot com days are usually pretty good.
 
I myself have almost 22 years dealing with computers myself and like you said crispb the technicians today are booksmart and have certs. But myself I will take experience anyday good ole hands on before anything else. You can get youre hands dirty and find the problem, but you cannot always read a book and find the problem. After years and years of computers, I still today remember my first job 44 people went there and applied came down to me and one other guy and he caved so I got it. Anyways I remember going on a service call for this brain surgeon, anyways got there he had a networking problem well he just could not install the drivers lol, hey thats what the disk is for anyways after setting him up verifying everything he bitched cause I charged him 30 dollars. Well to make a long story short I asked him how long he had taken on this problem he said 5 different cards numerous calls and so forth and total about 5 weeks, I thought to myself and laughed and gave him the bill. Anyways a week later got my pay check and was 500 more than ususal thought what the hell boss said the surgeon sent me $500 cause the time he wasted was worth the thirty in the first place. So anyways if you cannot find the problem with out cheating someone you dont need to be in the business anyway. And yes I got bored with comps and became a master plumber more rewarding for me at at least.
 
An old Cisco instructor taught me something I will never forget and turned out to be true over and again, "90% of all issues are media related".
Yeah my MCSE instructor told me "Always, Always, Always check physical first."
 
Workin at a computer repair shop I can say that we never gave someone a mis-diagnosis, and would never tell them to buy a new computer unless it was something like a 5 year old computer needing a new motherboard, at that point it's not really cost effective.

But I can say that I was told to ask a "standard rate" of 2 hours... $85 an hour... so $170 + tax for any job, if it took me 10 minutes or 2 hours.. but that still applied if I spent 6-8 hours (usually most of that was letting programs run, so I wasn't "actually" working for 6-8 hours...). But it was dumb, because if we did a "data transfer" it would be the same rate... so lets say their laptops motherboard died, we'd charge $170 to transfer 30GB to an external drive that we'd sell them or have them go buy from a local store.

I can understand that they have to make money, but there have been times where it was a really simple problem, and I had to bullshit to the customer to make it seem like it was something difficult.

Now I quit that place to go back to school, but now over the summer I'm only going to have 1 class.. I'm debating if I should do work on the side (Maybe throw up ad's on craigslist) or go back to that place...

They did hire me with no certifications, no formal experience, and I showed up 2 hours late to the interview... and they'll still take me back after I quit only a few months ago... probably cause I was working on 5-6 computers at the same time and only getting paid $10 an hour, the other "senior" tech was getting $14 and would work on 1 computer at a time...

Blah...
 
LOL @ shock that geek squad is a huge scam.

i dont even see it as a scam. its a disguised donation. best buy knows they cant fix most people's stupid crap, most people know some national chain can't do specialized repairs. but there are so many stupid people out there that best buy, or somebody, had to make a market for them.

you know that market... the walmart people. the people who trust a big name box store over a local shop... the people that wouldnt even be at best buy if walmart had it....
 
Workin at a computer repair shop I can say that we never gave someone a mis-diagnosis, and would never tell them to buy a new computer unless it was something like a 5 year old computer needing a new motherboard, at that point it's not really cost effective.

When I worked in as a notebook tech in retail we would give people the option of buying a new computer all of the time. Might tell a customer that from what they are describing it will be say close to 300 bucks to fix on the low end. Tell them that a new machine that would be faster then their 4 year old desktop is 450 bucks. With that they get a faster machine and a year warranty on the entire box. A lot of people would just go with a new machine happy they were given the option. We might use it to up sell our warranty showing how we would have covered it if it was in warranty or something.
 
I can see an employee making the mistake of assuming the hard drive was broken right away without looking at it and then plugging in a new one to confirm their suspicion, but he then said the computer had a virus... So it is pretty obvious something was up with the tech.

^^^ This, is what turned it from incompetent repair person to scam artist. Unfortunately a news undercover story most likely won't bring any legal attention against the place.
 
I thought the Geek Squad's #1 response was, "You need a new motherboard." :confused:

And I agree with the poster who said if they declared the HD dead, how in the heck did they find a virus on it? That's a total crock.
 
I am a seasoned tech with 10 years professional experience and 16 years geek experience. I've done all kinds of repairs, troubleshooting, servers, and networking. I'll meet a person here and there that knows what they are doing, but a lot of young techs a very questionable. They may know the stuff on books, but lack the experience to apply it. The techs I meet from the dot com days are usually pretty good.

Even back in the dot com days, there were people like this article is describing. Maximum PC did the same thing and guess what, the ratio was 4 out of 5 shops failed. The problem, the computer was not recognizing the hard drive. The guy at MaxPC made a small cut near one of the IDE connectors so that the hard drive would not be recognized by the computer. Solutions were a new hard drive and reload windows, a new motherboard because the IDE controller died and Windows needed to be reloaded, and a few other wrong solutions. Once shop even suggested buying a new computer from them.

This should have been a simple fix. When I was working in a shop back then, I would have charged $20 for the cable and sent the customer on his way. When he does have a real problem that does require something major, a good chance is the customer will be back to my shop. This is how I do things and I have a large repeat customer base because of it. Many of my customers tried Geek Squad and were not happy.

Yeah my MCSE instructor told me "Always, Always, Always check physical first."

+1 Normally, what I do is start with cables and work my way thru the trouble shoot. It's really just like anything else, a good tech with common sense should be able to figure out what the problem is without ripping off the customer.
 
They did this exact same thing in Las Vegas last year. A local TV station got 7 identical PCs and took 'em over to UNLV's computer lab, had the director basically unplug the hard drive cable just enough so it wouldn't boot, then dropped 'em off at local repair shops (not Geek Squad, however). 4 of 'em fixed it for free, as the should have, 2 tried to upsell a bunch of useless shit but when refused said "here, it's fixed, no charge" and the other 2 were popped big time for scams.

It's always funny when someone makes that "I didn't do that, that's not how I remember it happening" claim and then gets caught on camera watching themselves on a tiny portable monitor as the playback shows them doing exactly what they just said they didn't do... ;)

There's enough money to be made just from basic tune-up work and AV cleanups, there's no reason to rip people off the way so many shops do. I remember many years past when I was a bench tech - had just started at a small shop only a day prior. Some elderly woman brought in her PC, the owner brought it to me in the back room and it was literally a 30 second fix; just needed to have the command.com file restored (this was pre-Windows 95 days back when DOS 6 and Win 3.11 were popular).

Was done in under a minute, took it back out and the owner wanted to charged her the $95 minimum for an hour, I told her "here, take your PC home and don't ever come back to this place, and don't recommend it to family or friends either" even as I slipped my own business card into her hand. The owner was furious, of course, but I just laughed, grabbed my coat and walked out. I can't work for people like that.

Besides, she would have badmouthed the place anyway, so... it's better to do a job like that for free and have a happy customer that won't shut up about your shop than it is to overcharge for nothing at all.

Anyway, she called me later that day and told me she'd tell those family and friends about me, turned out to get a lot of business and made some good friends in the process.

That store? Went out of business the next month, as expected. And he never paid me for the two days work I did give him... bleh.
 
~$50/hr is a fairly standard rate for most pc repair jobs around my area. i make 50 freelancing here. dont see what the big deal is.. most jobs dont take very long.

Yeah, thats about what I charge though im VERY careful not to get myself drowned in work and fustration as a result of being all my friends and families little tech support bitch. Been there done that as well.... :rolleyes:
 
When I worked in as a notebook tech in retail we would give people the option of buying a new computer all of the time. Might tell a customer that from what they are describing it will be say close to 300 bucks to fix on the low end. Tell them that a new machine that would be faster then their 4 year old desktop is 450 bucks. With that they get a faster machine and a year warranty on the entire box. A lot of people would just go with a new machine happy they were given the option. We might use it to up sell our warranty showing how we would have covered it if it was in warranty or something.

Yea, but if it was something like a HDD, Geeksquad will say "$450, you can get a new computer for $500!" but it's something we'd work out... I know our normal rate is 2 x $85... well I did one of those which included data recovery (on his dieing HDD) a new 160GB Laptop HDD, setup a new copy of XP, and transfer the data back. I actually mentioned a 17" Gateway on buy.com at the time was about $500 and he could consider that, he actually ordered one the next day, when we started negotiating down, he had the laptop fixed by us for $170, then sold it for $450 on craigslist the next day so he was happy :)

I know we did some jobs for free just because the customer can't afford a new computer, even if it is "only" $400...

One thing with testing HDD's I know we wouldn't fail is because we remove the HDD's and test them on our own computers with IDE to USB cables or plug them in directly (this lets us confirm the HDD itself is good) then we can move on to the cable / motherboard... I guess lemme rephrase that, I wouldn't fail that test because of how I go about testing hardware. But my colleagues at the time could easily fail...

I know I was pretty thorough at our shop, but it sucked cause I feel like an asshole charging what we did... even if the customer was happy...
 
this video is from last year...it was dugg almost a year ago and necroed...wtf im seeing it everywhere now. it already made rounds a long time ago
 
At the Geek Squad at Best Buy on Cedar Hills Boulevard in Beaverton, technicians again found the problem immediately and fixed it at no charge.
Best Buy probably fired him.

At the Geek Squad across from the Washington Square Mall, a technician initially said he was unable to figure out what was wrong. He said a $70 diagnosis was needed.

Two days later, a Geek Squad employee said the hard drive was broken and $580 was needed for repair. When FOX 12 picked up the computer, the Geek Squad technician also said the computer had a virus and suggested purchasing a new computer, an area in which it would be glad to help.
This one will soon be regional manager.
 
Yeah my MCSE instructor told me "Always, Always, Always check physical first."

I remember my windows instructor one day at college stating "Check simple things first" And to this DAY I would be saving myself ALOT OF GRIEF if I remembered that simple damn rule. Only to find a simple cable/jumper amiss after a hour's worth of work and fustration for some simple problem.
 
I guess that Jim Goldman guy at CNBC will need to go back on air and update people that the $129 for the Geek Squad visit is now $580. So you'll need to invest over $1000 more to make a PC run as well as a mac...
 
Back
Top