Take Two Sues 3D Realms

If Take 2 DID pay for publishing rights (which was the trend back in the late 90's), they are well within they're rights to sue 3d Realms for breach of contract. This suite like others have stated are a 2 fold positive for Take 2.

a) It forces 3DR to start making payments back to Take 2 or go into bankruptcy. (waiting over a decade is long enough for one's money)

b) If 3DR goes into bankruptcy, its assets will be liquidated to its creditors (such as Take 2) and they will recover SOME of the money, probably the DNF IP, and be able to write off the other part of the debt to help its current balance sheets.
 
If 3DR were to go bankrupt, however, Take2 would be one of their creditors; probably one of the primary ones.
In that event, they would be legally owed any money or assets that 3DR could come up with to pay off the $12Mil T2 gave them for publishing rights, including any IP.
This really depends on what was in the contract. I assume the $12 million was to purchase the publishers rights, and not a loan, in which case we have to see if the contract was violated somehow.

Purely hypothetical, but the publishing contract could have stated "You agree that we will be the publishers if and when the game comes out", in which case T2 is owed nothing since the contract was not breached.

Without knowing what was in the contract it is impossible for anyone to say who is owed what.
 
This really depends on what was in the contract. I assume the $12 million was to purchase the publishers rights, and not a loan, in which case we have to see if the contract was violated somehow.

Purely hypothetical, but the publishing contract could have stated "You agree that we will be the publishers if and when the game comes out", in which case T2 is owed nothing since the contract was not breached.

Without knowing what was in the contract it is impossible for anyone to say who is owed what.

The exact details are up to the courts to decide, but I highly doubt Take2 bought the rights expecting to have to wait so long for something to happen. T2 believes it is owed something and I doubt they'd waste time and money suing 3DR if they didn't believe the publishing contract was broken.
 
Maybe this could lead later on that Take Two would finish the game. That would also be win for the community.
 
Jesus where are you people getting the idea that they paid 3drealms any money? They inherited the publishing rights to Duke3d. That is it. They have never given 3drealms any money. George Broussard did go to them and ask for 5 million to finish development of the game. They intern said no.. but if you take 30 million and give us the ip of the game and finish it that would be great. 3drealms of course turned that down. They shopped it to Id, Shopped it to Epic and possibly have shopped it to Ms.

Take Two has no finances involved in 3drealms publishing rights.. They took the contract based on a tax right off! Meaning that 12 million they are asking for ..was already wiped off the boards years ago. Let's be honest they just want the ip. Which is perfectly understandable because it does have value the 12million crap is just a legal smokescreen to try and grab it.
 
what t2 wants is the 12 million they paid info games that again did not give 3dr 1 dime for the rights to the product all t2 has is publishing rights that is for a finished product payable upon delivery to them they have not a leg to stand on and trying to take the gamers side in this is bullshit they want to kick 3dr when down and get the source of 12 years work and the ip so they can run duke into the ground

Just had to highlight something that i found amusing.... work.. lol.. work
 
were did you see the bankrupt part all i seen is the studio closing they are not bankrupt the studio still legally exists. please do some research before you come here and post wild accusations . AGAIN T2 never paid 3dr a dime all t2 has is the rights to publish the game. that they acquired 3rd-handly from infogames that got it second-handly from gt interactive, that was the principle holder to the rights to publish. any money given from gti to 3dr back in the day does not ammount to 12 mil and does not ammount to t2 having any right to any money from 3dr or one line of code till the game is completed end of story the whole thing is 99.9% all funded by 3dr t2 can go fuck themselves

what does secondhand thirdhand matter anyways... its $12 million dollars... so if you go buy something from a op shop (2nd hand store) are you now a thief because you didnt buy the item from the original creator? I fail to see your logic...
 
what does secondhand thirdhand matter anyways... its $12 million dollars... so if you go buy something from a op shop (2nd hand store) are you now a thief because you didnt buy the item from the original creator? I fail to see your logic...

It matters a great deal. I do not think take2 has much chance of thier suit getting pass a motion to dismiss. 1. I don't think they have standing. 2. I think they are suing the wrong party. 3. I think the tax write off already makes them whole.
 
Jesus where are you people getting the idea that they paid 3drealms any money? They inherited the publishing rights to Duke3d. That is it. They have never given 3drealms any money. George Broussard did go to them and ask for 5 million to finish development of the game. They intern said no.. but if you take 30 million and give us the ip of the game and finish it that would be great. 3drealms of course turned that down. They shopped it to Id, Shopped it to Epic and possibly have shopped it to Ms.

Take Two has no finances involved in 3drealms publishing rights.. They took the contract based on a tax right off! Meaning that 12 million they are asking for ..was already wiped off the boards years ago. Let's be honest they just want the ip. Which is perfectly understandable because it does have value the 12million crap is just a legal smokescreen to try and grab it.

Do you have any proof at all that they took it as a tax write-off?

I don't blame T2 for not giving them money. 3DR lost their chance to gain funding years ago. No one believes their bullshit anymore and no one is willing to take chances with them. To be honest, them shopping around has never actually been confirmed it was only a rumor.

They're suing for a breach of contract, which is fully within their rights. T2 has a right to expect a return on the money they spent. They have a right to expect 3DR to make a game after 12 years.

You can argue whether or not it would've been smart for 3DR to take that 30 mil, but it would have kept them from closing their doors and would have kept their employees from the the unemployment line.
 
Again any money given to 3dr was from GT INTERACTIVE for the publishing rights to DNF that contract has been passed around more than a penny hooker. the flow of rights here goes GTI > INFOGAMES > (this is were the rights gets sold for 12 mil hence what T2 is trying to recover money they paid another publisher for the rights to publish the damn game 3dr got zero money from anyone other than gti and that ammount is .01 % since it was all 99.9% funded by 3dr) GOD > T2

again this a shameless grab for the Intellectual property rights to DUKE NUKEM and the source code to 12 years of work that they never paid 3dr one dime for
 
Thank you.

Yeah, but I doubt T2 would just start a lawsuit without having something to stand on. T2 would've been stupid not to get some clauses in their publishing contract.

do you think if take two gave dime one to 3dr the damn game would have a solid date instead of WID. how about the comments made by george and steve on shack that basically amounts to take two needs to stfu and wait for the game. if t2 gave money they would of not been waiting for it they would of had a hand so far up 3dr's ass pressureing them to complete it so the game would be out according to take two's scedual not 3dr's
 
do you think if take two gave dime one to 3dr the damn game would have a solid date instead of WID. how about the comments made by george and steve on shack that basically amounts to take two needs to stfu and wait for the game. if t2 gave money they would of not been waiting for it they would of had a hand so far up 3dr's ass pressureing them to complete it so the game would be out according to take two's scedual not 3dr's

Yeah, because 3DR is such a trust worthy source to give money to. I mean its not like they've out-right lied to everyone for 12 YEARS. T2 was waiting. They've been waiting for something like 8 years for the game to finish. 3DR is dead. T2 can't wait anymore because the developer is gone. Millar and Broussard ran his company into the ground, this is entirely their fault.
 
maxius:

You're not impossible to understand, but it is difficult. Another thing is that what you've quoted is very similar to your writing. I'm not doubting these quotes since you've provided a reference, but it's quite humorous at the same time. :)

Arguing in this discussion is obviously a test of people's knowledge with laws and contracts. So, I'll just say that I don't give a rats booty if T2 does get the IP. Just as long as the game is completed and the voice actor is still Jon St. John!
 
Back
Top