Apple Rejects Bittorrent Control App

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Apple’s App store has rejected a Bittorrent app because there is only one thing that all you filthy thieves do with Bittorrent…download copyrighted material.

Just as we thought Apple's ridiculous App Store approval process was about to get better with the advent of parental controls in iPhone OS 3.0, it goes and pulls another boneheaded move that makes us wonder if the entire system isn't hopelessly broken forever. This time the company's rejected Maza's Drivetrain, an app that allows users to remotely control the Transmission Bittorrent app, because "this category of applications is often used for the purpose of infringing third party rights."
 
I often use the "aroundme" app to find convience stores to rob, they should remove that one too. And you won't believe what I use the internet for.
 
So sick, how can anybody stand this disgusting big brother attitude towards software. I mean jesus, deciding FOR you what software you can and cant use? I dont see how anybody tolerates this for a second. What a horrible horrible precedent these idiot apple drones are setting.
 
I really hope you're right heatlesssun

Windows mobile 7 is Microsoft's last chance to be a serious contender in the mobile market.

But they have the Tegra hardware on their side... I'm hoping that they will pull it off!
 
Fuckin' Apple. *sigh*

So, we have a rejected Tweetie update (baseless), a passed baby shaker app (explain that!), a rejected nin: access update (baseless) that was later passed without a single change (what?) and now a Tramission controller app rejection (baseless). Pure brilliance.

I have a pretty good feeling that whoever Apple has doing these rejections is just pulling slips of paper marked either "rejected" or "passed" out of a hat. If they pull a "rejection" slip, they have to come up with a line of boilerplate reasoning for the rejection e-mail. If they pull a "passed", hooray! Less work for Apple!
 
Forgive me for my ignorance (haven't used an Apple OS in about a decade), but does Apple ultimately decide what software gets used on their operating systems? If not, then why is the iPhone singled out? And thirdly, do they think "torrent" is the only file transfer protocol? They better ban http and ftp also, because illegal file transfers go through those also. :rolleyes:
 
Apple doesn't sell the majority of OS X applications and they don't restrict third parties from selling OS X software (regardless of what it is), no.
 
the craziest part is this app doesn't load or upload any software whatsoever, it controls your transmission application installed on your mac. if this app is pulled, apple should not allow their computers to do any downloading of bittorrents whatsoever; which in itself is ridiculous as well. I am sick of apple's hypocritical nature.. I see why this app would be helpful on my iphone, and have high hopes for windows mobile 7. This app crap is the reason I and so many others jailbroke their iphones. It's a great little device, but apple sticks their damn noses into too much of my personal preferences.
 
Because most people who own Apple products never hear about this kind of news cause they are too busy on their Apple product being "cool".
 
the worst part is, they're probably right.

So what about thwe legit users?

Sure, i will agree, i am sure %90+ of P2P traffic is illegal worldwide, i dont think we can deny that, but then your screwing the legit users.

As the above person said, what about their store app, he can locate stores and rob them!
 
I really hope you're right heatlesssun

Windows mobile 7 is Microsoft's last chance to be a serious contender in the mobile market.

But they have the Tegra hardware on their side... I'm hoping that they will pull it off!

I hope I'm right too. Honestly, I don't think that its a difficult technical issue as much as its getting it fit and finish right. Some current WinMo 6.1 phones are pretty slick, like the HTC Touch Pro. The only problem is underneath the slickness are the old Windows CE components which are terribly dated.

The biggest problem is Microsoft's refusal to brand a device, which I guess makes sense if you are a software maker and you don't want to compete against your other customers. This is one area that gives Apple an advantage but their overzealous control is the negative of this model as well.
 
I've got a solution:

Use this mobile phone instead:
image.axd
 
Because most people who own Apple products never hear about this kind of news cause they are too busy on their Apple product being "cool".
Or we buy them before we have any idea Apple is going to be so ridiculous about the way they run things. I think any Apple user expects a certain degree of this-doesn't-make-much-sense-ness with respect to the way Apple does things, but this App Store nonsense is far beyond that. This feels like entirely new territory.
 
How dare Apple, a private company, decide what software it carries on its servers! It must carry the software you want! Even though you don't have an iphone!

As if pirates aren't spoiled enough that they feel entitled to other people's intellectual property, now you have the right to Apple helping you pirate stuff as well by carrying the software you demand! :rolleyes:

Wow, talk about a world of entitlement.

So sick, how can anybody stand this disgusting big brother attitude towards software. I mean jesus, deciding FOR you what software you can and cant use? I dont see how anybody tolerates this for a second. What a horrible horrible precedent these idiot apple drones are setting.
 
uclajd... you realize that it's remote software to control the application on your Mac... right?

So you can run the software on your Mac... just not control it... with your IPhone...

Apple is a silly company...
 
How dare Apple, a private company, decide what software it carries on its servers! It must carry the software you want! Even though you don't have an iphone!

As if pirates aren't spoiled enough that they feel entitled to other people's intellectual property, now you have the right to Apple helping you pirate stuff as well by carrying the software you demand! :rolleyes:

Wow, talk about a world of entitlement.

Sigh, I swear there are three or four people that post in this news section that are loving the *AA's nuts.
 
How dare Apple, a private company, decide what software it carries on its servers! It must carry the software you want! Even though you don't have an iphone!

As if pirates aren't spoiled enough that they feel entitled to other people's intellectual property, now you have the right to Apple helping you pirate stuff as well by carrying the software you demand! :rolleyes:

Wow, talk about a world of entitlement.

this app does nothing to pirate software.. it monitors a client that apple users can use to transfer software. Yes, it can be used maliciously, but this app does nothing but let you monitor and change settings within your uploading and downloading progress of your client. Hence, the hypocrisy of apple
 
So sick, how can anybody stand this disgusting big brother attitude towards software. I mean jesus, deciding FOR you what software you can and cant use? I dont see how anybody tolerates this for a second. What a horrible horrible precedent these idiot apple drones are setting.
Big Brother? Give me a break. This isn't "big brother", why shouldn't Apple have a say on what applications can or can't be run on their Iphone? I mean, it's their product, they can do whatever they want. If you don't like it or have a problem with it then don't buy one. It's that simple. This has nothing to do with the government, all this is is one company asserting control over it's own creation. I don't see anything wrong or frightening about that.

Seriously guys, there are plenty of reasons to bash Apple, but this isn't one of them. :rolleyes:
 
Big Brother? Give me a break. This isn't "big brother", why shouldn't Apple have a say on what applications can or can't be run on their Iphone? I mean, it's their product, they can do whatever they want. If you don't like it or have a problem with it then don't buy one. It's that simple. This has nothing to do with the government, all this is is one company asserting control over it's own creation. I don't see anything wrong or frightening about that.

Seriously guys, there are plenty of reasons to bash Apple, but this isn't one of them. :rolleyes:

I think it is wrong that they sell you an iphone and tell YOU what YOU can and can not put on YOUR iphone.
 
I think it is wrong that they sell you an iphone and tell YOU what YOU can and can not put on YOUR iphone.
they can't.... jailbreak it and problem solved (the app store wouldn't even exist if not for hackers enabling the phone to execute 3rd party code)
 
Big Brother? Give me a break. This isn't "big brother", why shouldn't Apple have a say on what applications can or can't be run on their Iphone? I mean, it's their product, they can do whatever they want. If you don't like it or have a problem with it then don't buy one. It's that simple. This has nothing to do with the government, all this is is one company asserting control over it's own creation. I don't see anything wrong or frightening about that.

Seriously guys, there are plenty of reasons to bash Apple, but this isn't one of them. :rolleyes:

last I checked, it's their product but your own damn phone. Should I have to call samsung and check what I can watch on my tv??? screw apple. I hate how stupid people are and just follow other idiots around never questioning anything
 
You mean I can't download my distros to my frikkin iPhone now? That's horseshit. :D
 
Freedom doesn't translate to illegal activity. 'Your' item doesn't mean you casn do illegal stuff with it.

When you guys were in pre-school, did having a pencil mean that you had the freedom to stab a fellow kid to death?
 
Freedom doesn't translate to illegal activity. 'Your' item doesn't mean you casn do illegal stuff with it.

When you guys were in pre-school, did having a pencil mean that you had the freedom to stab a fellow kid to death?

Merely a flesh wound. :D
 
You can't do anything illegal with the app. Re-read the article.

In some ways you could. I agree with this Apple is being two faced, but if you guys are talking freedom from this angle, it's not freedom.
 
I think the real problem, besides the fact that you own the phone, so you should be able to do anything you want with it, is that they are inconsistent with what they allow and what they ban.

They have every right to block programs, but they have to do it in an inconsistent way and not some 'blah cause some people might use it for bad things.' people dont like inconsistency, cause it's like lying.

if they're going to ban this, they should also ban what people can run in their other devices.
 
I think it is wrong that they sell you an iphone and tell YOU what YOU can and can not put on YOUR iphone.
No, Apple just isn't selling it in their app store. If you want to create your own app do to the things you want, then by all means go for it!
 
here's an idea apple... seeing as you're so against tools of piracy.. how about you stop allowing your ipods iphones etc etc to play mp3 files without a drm signature seeing as MOST mp3 files without drm are pirated... hyporcites.
 
OMG! How will all of the iPhone users manage their linux distro downloads!?!?!?!?!11?!
 
Apple likes to restrict what you can do with your toys. Nothing new that is. One reason not to buy applewere.
 
Back
Top