Prosecutors Seeking Prison Time In MySpace Case

The problem is, you are not crazy. And I highly doubt you have ever experiences anything that would break your prissy little bubble. You are a plague to society. Go die.

You're really going to tell that guy that? In this thread? Common, in THIS exact thread you're going to say something like that? You do realize if that guy turns out to be some kid that lied about his age when he registered for these forums that now you've just said that to a kid. A lot of people would say for a comment like that you deserve 3+ years in prison.
 
The whole point of the matter is not tthat she did it over the internet, but that she purposefully caused enough emotional distress to a child to make that child not want to be alive any longer.

Compare it to a father who continually calls his son a "faggot," and emotionally abuses him every day until his son commits suicide. Is the father liable for the death? I say he certainly should be. Did he commit murder? No. Manslaughter? Arguably. He should still do some jail time. I see no real difference here.
 
This is just child abuse, child abuse is a crime, you commit a crime you get punished.
 
Most of you seem not to have read what she was actually CONVICTED of. Hint: It wasn't abusing, being mean, or anything of that nature.

What a joke of a prosecution.
 
http://www.concurringopinions.com/archives/2008/11/lori_drew_and_t.html

btw, anyone interested in the facts of the case, not the emotional nonsense and hyperbole, should read up on it. Especially you should know the federal prosecutor's theory of the case, which essentially is:

If you violate the TOS of any website, you have committed a federal crime. Create a fake name on Hardforum, violating the TOS? Federal crime. Go on eharmony.com as a married person? Federal crime. And they can indict you 1000 miles away in another state you've never been to, and put you on trial. Prosecutorial overreach and grandstanding in order to get media heavy convictions is a pretty scary thing.

The good news is these convictions won't survive an appeal to the 9th district, assuming that the judge doesn't grant the rule 29 motion to dismiss first, which he just might do. (and should do)
 
IMHO,
Anyone following US incarceration trends should not be surprised the prosecutor in this case is seeking a prison term for the woman involved. The numbers of people being thrown into prison are staggering:

http://www.westernprisonproject.org/not_reviewed/story/1257

http://www.pewcenteronthestates.org/uploadedFiles/PSPP_1in31_report_FINAL_WEB_3-26-09.pdf

The United States incarcerates more people per capita than any nation in the world....
"worlds highest incarceration rate"

http://www.csmonitor.com/2003/0818/p02s01-usju.html

I wish we would stop being such victims of everything, blaming other people, institutions, governments, bosses, neighbors, teachers, on and on. We seriously need to all lighten up, become more forgiving and understanding. STOP throwing so many people in prison! There are many other solutions/remedies/courses of action.
 
Alright, I'm being a bit of a douche here, but there's no argument in the world that someone can make that I can't refute. Its an easy talent for both of us.
At some point though, people have to start acting like human beings again. The anonymity of the internet does seem to have taken away the soul of some people. If this woman had a concious I would say that knowing she caused some poor girl to die would be punishment enough. She probably could give 2 shits. I think her punishment should be the father gets to go over to her house, smash her computer, punch her in the face and tell her to grow the F up and act like an adult. Wouldn't solve anything but would probably feel good.

Right on man!
 
3 Years? lol.

The repeated drunk driver that killed 4 kids here the other day will not even be getting that much.

The government makes money off of alcohol, MySpace isn't filling their coffers.
 
the girl could have stopped it at any time by simply ... not signing into myspace. Myspace offers the tools to completely block out anyone you don't want to talk to, so if you MUST HAVE MYSPACE, you still could've at least done something about it.

and yea I think the 40 y/o woman is a complete jerkoff, but if being a jerkoff on the internet was a crime, who wouldn't be in jail?
 
If it were two children, or two adults, that's one thing. Children can't be expected to be emotionally mature, so going after one for dumping his girlfriend who killed herself would obviously be a bad idea. Adults are supposed to be a little more level headed, and they kill themselves over breakups all the time, so one dumping another and resulting in a suicide is again, not a problem.

However, when you have an adult taking advantage of a child's weaknesses, I think it's more severe. 3 years isn't a lot of time for a crime that caused a death, so I think it's more than fair. Some people get more time than that for accidentally killing someone, and this woman clearly had intent to cause harm. She may not have expected the girl to kill herself, which is why 3 years is an acceptable sentence rather than something more severe. If they can't get her jail time, then mandatory psychiatric help for the rest of her life seems warranted.

If a 40 year old woman walked up to some 13 year old girl on the street and started telling her she was worthless and she should kill herself, and I saw it, I'd rethink my stance on hitting women.

You certainly cannot send the signal that using an adult intellect to manipulate a child's emotions to harm them is okay.
 
... 3 years isn't a lot of time for a crime that caused a death, so I think it's more than fair...

One big huge problem here...."CAUSED". You are assuming she caused another person to commit suicide. Thats not only an assumption but it's almost irrational...how does anyone have that power to make another person commit suicide? I'd like to here an explanation of how that happens. You don't even know all the facts... do you even know half of the facts ? Sounds like assumed guilty unless found innocent...thats the exact opposite of true justice.
 
She deserves a lot more than 3 years. She conducted this process over months. She feels remorseful after the fact, but the execution of the act was with full intent to cause emotional harm. A death resulted directly connected to her actions.

She's lucky she's not facing life... She deserves 20 years imo. People have done lesser acts, often killing fellow passengers in auto accidents and done a lot more than 3 years. To have planned and executed this attack over a period of months with the intent of causing crushing emotional damage to a minor, is an act worth of a few decades behind bars.

$.02
 
Alll of you people giving your uninformed 2 cents haven't even bothered to read what she was convicted of. God forbid you ever get on a jury.
 
absolutely put her sorry ass in jail, that is pretty screwed up thing to do to a kid
 
One big huge problem here...."CAUSED". You are assuming she caused another person to commit suicide. Thats not only an assumption but it's almost irrational...how does anyone have that power to make another person commit suicide? I'd like to here an explanation of how that happens. You don't even know all the facts... do you even know half of the facts ? Sounds like assumed guilty unless found innocent...thats the exact opposite of true justice.

And you don't know any of the facts. She's already been convicted of the events in question.

As far as your question, it's very easy to make someone kill themselves if they are en emotionally turbulent teenager and you use your adult intellect to abuse their weaknesses. Yes, it would be virtually impossible to talk an emotionally stable adult into killing themselves, but it's a far different story when you're dealing with an irrational and emotional child.

Your post almost looks like you've copy pasted it as a typical opinion nullification. "You aren't all-knowing therefore you can't have an opinion." Maybe after you've spent more than 18 days here you'll learn a thing or two.
 
None of us have seen all the eveidence so we are really not in the best position to judge this woman, but if what has been released to the public is all true, then this woman intentionally caused a 13 yr old girl emotional harm unintentionally resulting in her suicide. For me, this just brings to mind Silence of the Lambs where Hannibal talks his fellow inmate into killing himself. I would say her crime is on par with that of a drug dealer selling to a child. Yes the dealer is selling something that will intentionally harm the health of the addict but does not actually intend to cause the death of the addict beacuse 99.99% of the time the addict will survive. As an, adult she should have known what she was doing was wrong and could have more far reaching consequences. If the number of years she serves in prison could bring the girl back then she should serve as long as required, however this is not the case. What is the purpose of jail time for her? To rehabilitate her? To deter her or others from the same actions? Punishment? If you feel you have to deter others and punish her, then 3 yrs is all you can met out according to the laws she has been found to have broken. That in my opinion is fair. I hate wrongful death civilsuits in general because it puts a price on human life and to me cheapens it.
Well said, /thread
 
And you don't know any of the facts. She's already been convicted of the events in question.

As far as your question, it's very easy to make someone kill themselves if they are en emotionally turbulent teenager and you use your adult intellect to abuse their weaknesses. Yes, it would be virtually impossible to talk an emotionally stable adult into killing themselves, but it's a far different story when you're dealing with an irrational and emotional child.

Your post almost looks like you've copy pasted it as a typical opinion nullification. "You aren't all-knowing therefore you can't have an opinion." Maybe after you've spent more than 18 days here you'll learn a thing or two.

QFT, you got to it before I did.
 
And you don't know any of the facts. She's already been convicted of the events in question.

As far as your question, it's very easy to make someone kill themselves if they are en emotionally turbulent teenager and you use your adult intellect to abuse their weaknesses. Yes, it would be virtually impossible to talk an emotionally stable adult into killing themselves, but it's a far different story when you're dealing with an irrational and emotional child.

Your post almost looks like you've copy pasted it as a typical opinion nullification. "You aren't all-knowing therefore you can't have an opinion." Maybe after you've spent more than 18 days here you'll learn a thing or two.

You apparently don't know either, since you seem to think she was convicted for something related to the girl killing herself.
 
You apparently don't know either, since you seem to think she was convicted for something related to the girl killing herself.

I wasn't talking about what she was convicted of, I was talking about the sentence she deserved. This was a case where the law hadn't caught up with technology and prosecutors had to settle for a lesser charge, whicih is why she isn't facing much more than 3 years.
 
I wasn't talking about what she was convicted of, I was talking about the sentence she deserved. This was a case where the law hadn't caught up with technology and prosecutors had to settle for a lesser charge, whicih is why she isn't facing much more than 3 years.

Oh, so now people should be sentenced for crimes that they didn't commit. Fascist garbage.
 
Why didn't they just hit her with a harassment charge or something similar? Then give her the max possible sentence. It would have been a lot easier to defend the appeal. As it stands she is almost certainly going to walk on appeal. If she did not this would set one hell of a bad precedent. Break TOS go to jail.

My gut says she should do time, my head says it should not have been accomplished in federal court on such bull shit charges..
 
Oh, so now people should be sentenced for crimes that they didn't commit. Fascist garbage.

3 years is the maximum for the charges for which she was convicted, it isn't out of line. That's not fascist, my aptly named friend.
 
3 years is the maximum for the charges for which she was convicted, it isn't out of line. That's not fascist, my aptly named friend.

You're the one who said her sentence should reflect something for which she was never convicted. And in this case, when they charge you with a technical computer violation, they don't get to sentence you for some crime that doesn't exist like "making someone feel bad and kill themselves over the internet." Federal sentencing guidelines exist for a reason, to keep judges and prosecutors from making personal, stupid decisions in these matters.

Doesn't matter anyway, her conviction won't stand, and whether the rest of you care or not, that fact will be better for this country.

I might be a technoob, but I know a few things about law, as most who do it for a living do.
 
I wasn't talking about what she was convicted of, I was talking about the sentence she deserved. This was a case where the law hadn't caught up with technology and prosecutors had to settle for a lesser charge, whicih is why she isn't facing much more than 3 years.

Also, keep showing how little you know about the case...they actually did charge her with felonies, of which she was ACQUITTED. Get that? You don't get to sentence someone based on something for which they were found not guilty.

I said it before, god forbid any of you ever get on a jury.
 
Doesn't matter anyway, her conviction won't stand, and whether the rest of you care or not, that fact will be better for this country.

Yeah, you're right. Now everyone can log on to MySpace with a fake profile and begin harassing children.. That'll make our country much better. Maybe they can even get a few to kill themselves. Maybe they'll get real lucky and it'll be a relative of yours.
 
Yeah, you're right. Now everyone can log on to MySpace with a fake profile and begin harassing children.. That'll make our country much better. Maybe they can even get a few to kill themselves. Maybe they'll get real lucky and it'll be a relative of yours.

The fact that you still think that is what this case is about is pretty sad. You don't even know what she was charged with, what she was convicted of, or any other fact....so what makes you think you have any idea what you're talking about?

Tell you what, go read the charges, read the statutes, read the rule 29 motions post trial and all of the responses, and then get back to me. You might learn something. You'd rather pontificate with zero facts though I'm sure, that's much more fun that knowing what you're talking about.
 
Yup, I don't agree what she did was right, but they really pushed the envelope on how they prosecuted her. As Technoob has said, it is essentially saying you lie on any web site and you've committed the exact same crime they want to send her to prison for three years for.

Here is a very good summary of it written by the former head of Justice's computer crimes division http://www.securityfocus.com/columnists/473

This lady is pretty worthless as a human being and was in the wrong, but what they charged her with was completely bogus too.
 
Yup, I don't agree what she did was right, but they really pushed the envelope on how they prosecuted her. As Technoob has said, it is essentially saying you lie on any web site and you've committed the exact same crime they want to send her to prison for three years for.

Here is a very good summary of it written by the former head of Justice's computer crimes division http://www.securityfocus.com/columnists/473

This lady is pretty worthless as a human being and was in the wrong, but what they charged her with was completely bogus too.

Exactly. And I certainly hope that the parents of the deceased girl tear this bitch a new one in civil court. But what the prosecution has done here is quite scary.
 
And you don't know any of the facts. She's already been convicted of the events in question.

As far as your question, it's very easy to make someone kill themselves if they are en emotionally turbulent teenager and you use your adult intellect to abuse their weaknesses. Yes, it would be virtually impossible to talk an emotionally stable adult into killing themselves, but it's a far different story when you're dealing with an irrational and emotional child.

Your post almost looks like you've copy pasted it as a typical opinion nullification. "You aren't all-knowing therefore you can't have an opinion." Maybe after you've spent more than 18 days here you'll learn a thing or two.

Your still assuming she caused her to commit suicide..."it's very easy to make someone kill themselves.... " Wow ! How about giving us some facts rather than emotional nonsense.

This discussion is mostly about opinion and nobody said you aren't welcome to have yours...nice how you skip any facts and go for lame remarks like "Maybe after you've spent more than 18 days here you'll learn a thing or two" LOL...LOL Your assuming again...I've been reading the HardOCP forums since 2005. Thanks for proving my point about making assumptions :D
 
Lookup Al Capone. Look at his sentencing. Some sentences in this country are based on the known crimes committed, not the the crimes for which they are convicted. But you know that. And thus you are being selective in your dislike of this particular case. You are far more worried about the legal precedent being set. And that's partially a fair worry. But the facts and circumstances involved in this particular precedent, no matter how it goes, are unlikely to be easily associated with other cases in the future. That doesn't nullify the impact. But it does make conviction in this case far from a legal disaster.
 
Back
Top