Love your i7 920 ?

I'm reading EVEREST, as in what is REALLY in use and what isn't. My point stands. There is no way you have 6Gb in full memory use on a fresh Vista install with no other apps installed or running. I call shens. Swap file doesn't count. If your counting swap file, your original point was misleading.

RTFP:
After I finished installing eg Vista (and nothing else than Vista, updates and driverpacks) I only had ~6 GB RAM free (meaning it wasn't in use or being used a cache)...guess what will happen when I install programs? ;)

Fail...

.oO(I guess have to load files from slow HD's, instead of using the RAM cached files, is more your thing?)

EDIT:
Now have Arma, Crysis Warhead, World in Conflict - RA, Office 2007 Enterprise, AVG, Webcam, MX5500, WinRAR, Nero 9, BOINC installed, and guess what:
cache.jpg
 
Last edited:
I love my i7 as I'm always wanting the latest and greatest,but I do wish I would stayed with my q6600.In games there is very little difference and thats all I do anyway.If your a gamer stay away from this as it will cost you out the butt to upgrade to a whole new system for what little it will offer you in gaming.If you do photo editing,riping,compression or rendering, then by all means go for it.

Actually, x58 shows great improvements on SLI over 790i and improvements in crossfire over x48. The main reason i went to i7 was because i could have an intel chipset AND sli.
 
RTFP:


Fail...

.oO(I guess have to load files from slow HD's, instead of using the RAM cached files, is more your thing?)

EDIT:
Now have Arma, Crysis Warhead, World in Conflict - RA, Office 2007 Enterprise, AVG, Webcam, MX5500, WinRAR, Nero 9, BOINC installed, and guess what:
cache.jpg

HAHAHAHAHAHA, you've got a bit to learn. Most of that IS on your hard drive, you simply don't know how to read. You only have 2Gb physical ram in use, the rest of it (over 10Gb) is swapped out. Learn to read your specs before making crazy claims.
 
Last edited:
Your yet another noob fooled by the stupid wording MS used in the task manager. They count swap as physical memory for some crazy reason. But if you put task manager next to a REAL tool for reading hardware like Everest, you find out the real deal pretty quickly.

txachrh821x08ugmtp00.jpg


By your logic, I'm using up my whole 6Gb sitting on the desktop! Bullcrud. That's just silly. As Everest quite accurately shows, I'm only using 1.3 Gb of my physical ram. If you learn to cross check anything Windows reports to you before making crazy claims, you won't catch this kind of heck.
 
Yep I love my i7 920 and my EVGA X58 mobo. Running overclocked mixed GTX 260 Tri-SLi. That's two GTX 260 Core 216 cards with an old 192SP 260. Complete system is in my sig.

I was on Vista HP x64 SP2. Now I am trying Win 7 x64. So far so good.
 
Your yet another noob fooled by the stupid wording MS used in the task manager. They count swap as physical memory for some crazy reason. But if you put task manager next to a REAL tool for reading hardware like Everest, you find out the real deal pretty quickly.

txachrh821x08ugmtp00.jpg


By your logic, I'm using up my whole 6Gb sitting on the desktop! Bullcrud. That's just silly. As Everest quite accurately shows, I'm only using 1.3 Gb of my physical ram. If you learn to cross check anything Windows reports to you before making crazy claims, you won't catch this kind of heck.


Do read up:
http://www.codinghorror.com/blog/archives/000688.html

It's been common knowlegee since 2006...or so I thought :rolleyes:

BTW, how much RAM does Everst tells you that yoy are using for cache?
If it dosn't mention any at all..you are doing it wrong.
 
Do read up:
http://www.codinghorror.com/blog/archives/000688.html

It's been common knowlegee since 2006...or so I thought :rolleyes:

BTW, how much RAM does Everst tells you that yoy are using for cache?
If it dosn't mention any at all..you are doing it wrong.

Uhm ... I can sort of see what your point is, but you're wrong. The way Vista "caches" that memory is different than what you're thinking. To say that because taskman says only 4MB of RAM is available, therefore all of it is used up - is WRONG. Vista operates in a different way than that.

That memory is cached with programs that are prefetched, and it's INSTANTLY available to other programs that need it. I might not be explaining it in the exact precise technical terms, but if a different program needs to access that cached memory, it will be able to with no discernible delay. Your logic and argument here is flawed. Vista will not use 6GB of RAM just sitting there, and hog it, not allowing other apps to use it. Please check your facts and dig deeper than what merely meets the eye in your argument. In the mean time, I'm going to see if I can find a more eloquent explanation than the bumbled one I've typed up here.

Edit: Some quotes from different forums - I'm still trying to find the official ones I've seen though -

"As soon as an application needs more memory the memory is immediately reallocated from the cache for whatever application needs it."

If you really want all your memory to always be "free" then disable superfetch completely. If I did that, then Photoshop wouldn't load in 1.2 seconds anymore, word wouldn't load in .7 seconds, etc., etc. etc. ... That's all possible because of that caching taking place. WELL WORTH IT. If vista had to load every app from the HD, then I would go back to XP in a heartbeat.
 
Last edited:
Uhm ... I can sort of see what your point is, but you're wrong. The way Vista "caches" that memory is different than what you're thinking. To say that because taskman says only 4MB of RAM is available, therefore all of it is used up - is WRONG. Vista operates in a different way than that.

That memory is cached with programs that are prefetched, and it's INSTANTLY available to other programs that need it. I might not be explaining it in the exact precise technical terms, but if a different program needs to access that cached memory, it will be able to with no discernible delay. Your logic and argument here is flawed. Vista will not use 6GB of RAM just sitting there, and hog it, not allowing other apps to use it. Please check your facts and dig deeper than what merely meets the eye in your argument. In the mean time, I'm going to see if I can find a more eloquent explanation than the bumbled one I've typed up here.

Edit: Some quotes from different forums - I'm still trying to find the official ones I've seen though -

"As soon as an application needs more memory the memory is immediately reallocated from the cache for whatever application needs it."


Damn there are a lot of (deliberate?) misunderstandings going on here.
Do people don't understand the word "cache"?

Or that you current process can be using 1.88 GB RAM...but that Vista have cached eg 4 GB of RAM.
CACHED(!!!)
Not used...and not apparent on those pretty graphs that seems to be confusing everyone...CACHED.


Even Tom's hardware got it:
http://www.tomshardware.com/reviews/windows-vista-superfetch-and-readyboostanalyzed,1532-2.html

"Simply spoke, SuperFetch tries to relocate application data from the slow hard drive into all available memory. It utilizes the available capacity to create a so-called warm memory state for the single purpose of making applications available almost instantaneously."

Hell just look at what Microsoft writes:
http://www.microsoft.com/windows/windows-vista/features/superfetch.aspx

"Windows SuperFetch enables programs and files to load much faster than they would on Windows XP–based PCs.
When you're not actively using your computer, background tasks—including automatic backup programs and antivirus scans—run when they will least disturb you. These background tasks can take up system memory space that your programs had been using. On Windows XP–based PCs, this can slow progress to a crawl when you attempt to resume work.
SuperFetch monitors which applications you use the most and preloads these into your system memory so they'll be ready when you need them. Windows Vista also runs background programs, like disk defragmenting and Windows Defender, at low priority so that they can do their job but your work always comes first."

But I guess this will settle, when we all run Win7, not Vista, because it has a nifty little feature under Task Manager -> Recource Monitor - RAM:
resourcemonitor.jpg


Se that pretty dark blue color?
That is CACHED RAM!

EOD!!!
 
Honestly, seeing it just annoys me. Oh well.
 
Last edited:
It made me feel better :D

Besides you are punking the wrong person...looks like he's got it...unlike others :p

Wow, I just realized a total newb mistake. Hahaha. I was arguing against nobody! For some reason I thought that Atech (or maybe it was someone else) complained about all the RAM being gobbled up, when he really wasn't - I don't think. We're both like arguing the same thing. I'm sorry I said "you're wrong" when we're both right. I just misunderstood. I still don't know who's talking to whom in this thread, LOL!!!

Sorry, Atech, or anyone else that I just stupidly misunderstood.

This is kinda funny ... my bad.


Anyhow, I like caching. It makes me happy. Vista does it quite well, and it looks like 7 will continue to build on that ability, and even do it more efficiently. I love how fast apps load. I use a particular set of non-gaming but heavy duty apps on a regular basis, and performance in both Vista and Windows 7 is accelerated and enhanced in ways that XP could never even dream of employing.

I just can't believe how much I misunderstood what's been going on in this thread. I have been arguing with no one. :rolleyes:

Edit: Looking back, I'm more confused. What was moshpit trying to point out?
 
Wow, I just realized a total newb mistake. Hahaha. I was arguing against nobody! For some reason I thought that Atech (or maybe it was someone else) complained about all the RAM being gobbled up, when he really wasn't - I don't think. We're both like arguing the same thing. I'm sorry I said "you're wrong" when we're both right. I just misunderstood. I still don't know who's talking to whom in this thread, LOL!!!

Sorry, Atech, or anyone else that I just stupidly misunderstood.

This is kinda funny ... my bad.

It is kinda fynny yeah ;)


Anyhow, I like caching. It makes me happy. Vista does it quite well, and it looks like 7 will continue to build on that ability, and even do it more efficiently. I love how fast apps load. I use a particular set of non-gaming but heavy duty apps on a regular basis, and performance in both Vista and Windows 7 is accelerated and enhanced in ways that XP could never even dream of employing.

Agreed.

I just can't believe how much I misunderstood what's been going on in this thread. I have been arguing with no one. :rolleyes:

You live, you learn ;)

Edit: Looking back, I'm more confused. What was moshpit trying to point out?


No clue really...perhaps that he dosn't understand how Vista/Win7 works?
 
The way I see it, caching is just a cheap software workaround for the abysmal access times of mechanical hard drives. When SSD's become more popular, it won't be needed.
 
The way I see it, caching is just a cheap software workaround for the abysmal access times of mechanical hard drives. When SSD's become more popular, it won't be needed.

OMG, from one stupid notion to a worse :eek:

Is RAM faster than SSD yes/no?
 
As far as games, is anyone finding hyperthreading somewhat broken in Vista64?

Wondering if it's just me. :eek:
 
On games like crysis or even 3dmark06, randomly, when I launch the game or benchmark, my framerate will be less than it should by a significant margine. And it's not Vista background activity, I'm watching for hard drive access too. The performance hit doesn't vary once launched, it's almost as if I've lost a static 25% framerate throughout until the application is closed. However if i close the game and launch it again, it will be restored (sometimes). Sometimes, I have to try more than once before it's restored to it's correct framerate. It's almost as if SLI doesn't always kick in but enabling the SLI bars, shows it still is. :confused: However if I disable HT, it NEVER occurs. Framerate is always consistent and is as expected. This also does not occur in XP (dual boot 32bit, don't have 64bit at the moment so i cant test if it's a 64bit only issue).

I'm running the latest nvidia drivers and my specs are in my sig. The only thing I can chalk it up to is Vista. I've tried disabling all sorts of services that seem unnecessary (since it's vista business), but that didn't help either so i restored those services. I'm at a loss. :confused: :( Currently I'm keepin HT off since I can't stand it any longer. I'm thinking bout trying windose7 also, see if it happens there. I just don't like the idea of me having to reinstall everything once win7 actually is released.
 
On games like crysis or even 3dmark06, randomly, when I launch the game or benchmark, my framerate will be less than it should by a significant margine. And it's not Vista background activity, I'm watching for hard drive access too. The performance hit doesn't vary once launched, it's almost as if I've lost a static 25% framerate throughout until the application is closed. However if i close the game and launch it again, it will be restored (sometimes). Sometimes, I have to try more than once before it's restored to it's correct framerate. It's almost as if SLI doesn't always kick in but enabling the SLI bars, shows it still is. :confused: However if I disable HT, it NEVER occurs. Framerate is always consistent and is as expected. This also does not occur in XP (dual boot 32bit, don't have 64bit at the moment so i cant test if it's a 64bit only issue).

I'm running the latest nvidia drivers and my specs are in my sig. The only thing I can chalk it up to is Vista. I've tried disabling all sorts of services that seem unnecessary (since it's vista business), but that didn't help either so i restored those services. I'm at a loss. :confused: :( Currently I'm keepin HT off since I can't stand it any longer. I'm thinking bout trying windose7 also, see if it happens there. I just don't like the idea of me having to reinstall everything once win7 actually is released.


Sounds like your CPU is throttling when HT is neabled due to a to high O.C.

A O.C that is stable under XP, dosn't mean it is stable under Vista.
 
Sounds like your CPU is throttling when HT is neabled due to a to high O.C.

A O.C that is stable under XP, dosn't mean it is stable under Vista.

Perhaps. But it's prime95 stable under vista64 and that's far more load than crysis. In crysis, it looks like my cpu is nearly idle! The highest load on a given core is 30% and that's only at moments. Usually my cores bounce around at 10-20% and heat never exceeds 65 even at peaks!

It's all very odd. I remember someone mentioning that windows schedular service handles load balancing on multipule processor cores and that it was possible it didn't handle virtual cores correctly. Can anyone expand on that? Just trying to figure this out. In the mean time I've already arranged to have my xp partition blown out for windows7 RC this weekend. I'll report back my findings once I test that.
 
The way I see it, caching is just a cheap software workaround for the abysmal access times of mechanical hard drives. When SSD's become more popular, it won't be needed.

When they get fast enough, I doubt we will even need RAM anymore either... the cache on-die will likely grow to a gig or so, and the speed of the SSD's will just allow direct access just like virtual memory now. Then *poof* no more system memory as we know it.
 
When they get fast enough, I doubt we will even need RAM anymore either... the cache on-die will likely grow to a gig or so, and the speed of the SSD's will just allow direct access just like virtual memory now. Then *poof* no more system memory as we know it.

I doubt it. RAM will always be needed in PCs as we know them. It will always be made faster than storage devices. RAM is fast and can handle infinite writes and reads. The problem is that RAM can't store data without power. SSD's don't have that issue as they are a type of flash memory. I just don't see the type of memory needed for flash drives getting faster than system RAM or anywhere close for the next decade. Even if it did, it would still be constrained by the bus it works off of now. SATA can't hold a candle to triple channel memory interfaces in terms of speed. Not now and not for the near future.

Huge changes in technology, computer design and software would need to take place before that could happen.
 
The way I see it, caching is just a cheap software workaround for the abysmal access times of mechanical hard drives. When SSD's become more popular, it won't be needed.

Did you really just write that? Not everyone can afford an array of raided SSDs now or in the near future. And find one providing more than 320GB of storage that's not otherworldly expensive, even though SSD prices have halved since they first came out. I have easily had applications and games only take more than 320GBs of a hard drive, not including the OS and its files. Very fast 640GB hard disks can be had regularly now for $65-70 from more than one vendor. They are fast, reliable, and cheap. Caching from them saves us a LOT of wait time. Call it a "cheap workaround" if you want, but sometimes the best things in life are free, or at least cheap. And even with SSDs RAM is still faster - in some cases MUCH faster. Caching will boost performance even on an SSD system.

OMG, from one stupid notion to a worse :eek:

Is RAM faster than SSD yes/no?

Lol. RAM requires power to operate, as Dan mentions below, but it's way faster and more durable than SSDs for virtually innumerable random read/writes.

I don't love it, no. It's alright.

Please explain. Tell us about your experience - maybe we can help make it more "lovable."

Perhaps. But it's prime95 stable under vista64 and that's far more load than crysis. In crysis, it looks like my cpu is nearly idle! The highest load on a given core is 30% and that's only at moments. Usually my cores bounce around at 10-20% and heat never exceeds 65 even at peaks!

It's all very odd. I remember someone mentioning that windows schedular service handles load balancing on multipule processor cores and that it was possible it didn't handle virtual cores correctly. Can anyone expand on that? Just trying to figure this out. In the mean time I've already arranged to have my xp partition blown out for windows7 RC this weekend. I'll report back my findings once I test that.

You know, I'm on my second DEFECTIVE BFG GTX 295. The first one had bad memory chips. This one has either a bad second card or a bad NF200 chip. Entire patches of color are wrong and display incorrectly, but when I disable SLI the problem disappears. Performance also plummets. I've tried everything - drivers, clean Vista install, update motherboard BIOS, underclocking the video card, new PSU, everything I can think of (I'm going to try it with Windows 7 and the beta drivers now too.) Maybe you're having video card issues now.

I doubt it. RAM will always be needed in PCs as we know them. It will always be made faster than storage devices. RAM is fast and can handle infinite writes and reads. The problem is that RAM can't store data without power. SSD's don't have that issue as they are a type of flash memory. I just don't see the type of memory needed for flash drives getting faster than system RAM or anywhere close for the next decade. Even if it did, it would still be constrained by the bus it works off of now. SATA can't hold a candle to triple channel memory interfaces in terms of speed. Not now and not for the near future.

Huge changes in technology, computer design and software would need to take place before that could happen.

Correct. SSDs are getting better, faster, and cheaper, but RAM is still king for most applications. And look at the price it's dropped to these days. You can often snag a good 4GB kit for $20 after rebate if you watch the sales.
 
I doubt it. RAM will always be needed in PCs as we know them. It will always be made faster than storage devices. RAM is fast and can handle infinite writes and reads. The problem is that RAM can't store data without power. SSD's don't have that issue as they are a type of flash memory. I just don't see the type of memory needed for flash drives getting faster than system RAM or anywhere close for the next decade. Even if it did, it would still be constrained by the bus it works off of now. SATA can't hold a candle to triple channel memory interfaces in terms of speed. Not now and not for the near future.

Huge changes in technology, computer design and software would need to take place before that could happen.

Did you really just write that? Not everyone can afford an array of raided SSDs now or in the near future. And find one providing more than 320GB of storage that's not otherworldly expensive, even though SSD prices have halved since they first came out. I have easily had applications and games only take more than 320GBs of a hard drive, not including the OS and its files. Very fast 640GB hard disks can be had regularly now for $65-70 from more than one vendor. They are fast, reliable, and cheap. Caching from them saves us a LOT of wait time. Call it a "cheap workaround" if you want, but sometimes the best things in life are free, or at least cheap. And even with SSDs RAM is still faster - in some cases MUCH faster. Caching will boost performance even on an SSD system.


*snip*


Correct. SSDs are getting better, faster, and cheaper, but RAM is still king for most applications. And look at the price it's dropped to these days. You can often snag a good 4GB kit for $20 after rebate if you watch the sales.

Agreed.

One thing to remember in order to put this into perspective is this:
My DDR3 is rated at PC3-12800 at stock.
That is 12800 MB/s...single channel.
Intel's X25-M 80GB is rated at ~250 MB/s (for reads, writes are closer to 90 MB/s)

You do the math.

Even the upcomming PRAM won't topple RAM as the fastest storage outside the CPU
(L1, L2, L3 cache can only be effective up to a certain size, before lantency begins to rear it's ugly head.)
 
You know, I'm on my second DEFECTIVE BFG GTX 295. The first one had bad memory chips. This one has either a bad second card or a bad NF200 chip. Entire patches of color are wrong and display incorrectly, but when I disable SLI the problem disappears. Performance also plummets. I've tried everything - drivers, clean Vista install, update motherboard BIOS, underclocking the video card, new PSU, everything I can think of (I'm going to try it with Windows 7 and the beta drivers now too.) Maybe you're having video card issues now.

A possibility although odd that it is only something that occurs with HT on, I suppose more troubleshooting is in order. thanks for the suggestion.
 
A possibility although odd that it is only something that occurs with HT on, I suppose more troubleshooting is in order. thanks for the suggestion.

just fyi, changing out my videocards didn't help. Updating my bios to Asus' latest, and updating nvidia drivers to the latest released didn't make a difference either. The fact that everything works perfect with HT off in vista64 is making me leaning towards vista shitty'ness. Still working on it though... Hopefully I find a conclusion. Google searching for i7 hyperthreading performance hits doesn't show anyone reporting what I'm finding so who knows if that info just isn't easily found or it's just isolated to my system.
 
just fyi, changing out my videocards didn't help. Updating my bios to Asus' latest, and updating nvidia drivers to the latest released didn't make a difference either. The fact that everything works perfect with HT off in vista64 is making me leaning towards vista shitty'ness. Still working on it though... Hopefully I find a conclusion. Google searching for i7 hyperthreading performance hits doesn't show anyone reporting what I'm finding so who knows if that info just isn't easily found or it's just isolated to my system.

Well, I can tell you I definitely took a big performance hit in everything 3D with hyperthreading on - games, gaming benchmarks & the like.
 
Well, I can tell you I definitely took a big performance hit in everything 3D with hyperthreading on - games, gaming benchmarks & the like.

That goes against my own(and most sites experience) care to back up that comment with data?
 
That goes against my own(and most sites experience) care to back up that comment with data?

Sure. I didn't take screen shots, but my scores in 3DMark06 dropped by 3K on average with HT enabled. I tried at 4.0GHz, then again at 3.8 and 3.6 to make sure high temps were not causing throttling. The performance hit was less with the lower OC, but it was a hit, nonetheless. I have Windows 7 on now, and will test with that. FPS dropped in Assassin's creed by a noticeable 10-15fps, even load times lengthened in other games. System still tested stable with 8 threads of Prime95 running, and temps were still plenty safe. I have no idea why it's taking such a hit. I tried three different nVidia driver revisions as well. Similar results each time. I never got a chance to run Vantage's CPU score. I bet with HT that score would've been a lot higher. I'll try and get that running.
 

Yeah, weird, huh? I know that enabling does slow down some things just a tiny bit because it does require a little tiny bit extra management overhead, but it shouldn't be a noticeable hit, especially not to the tune of 3000 marks, over 12%! I'll do some more fine tuning and try even lower clock speeds with and without HT just to make 100% sure I'm not experiencing some temp throttling of some kind. Should I try with turbo turned off?
 
disable c1e and eist and all other thermal and/or power saving crap in bios (might be under "cpu settings") and your multi will remain the same.

like my i7 920 ok, but really like my x58 sli mb. dont find too much diff between this and my old q9550/p45 machine from last year, but i am only playing stuff like tf2 and l4d right now.

Ok, so I looked for all kinds of power saving settings from my P6T's BIOS but didn't find anything else. I disabled SpeedStep and Turbo Mode and manually set the ratio to 21 but in Windows, RealTemp still keeps showing that the ratio is changing when idle. In CPU-Z the ratio shows as 21 but I don't think CPU-Z shows the ratio "live". Anyone with a P6T or P6T who ahve their BIOS settings so that the ratio won't change?
 
Back
Top