Trent Reznor Slams iPhone App Process

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Trent Reznor is a bit pissed off over the whole iPhone app process and shared his feeling about it with the world. Be warned, there is a lot of colorful language in Mr. Reznor’s comments.

My reasoning was this: I can understand if you want the moral posturing of not having any "indecent" material for sale - but you could literally turn around 180 degrees from where the NIN record would be and purchase the film "Scarface" completely uncensored, or buy a copy of Grand Theft Auto where you can be rewarded for beating up prostitutes. How does that make sense?
 
Sounds like sour grapes.

Anyways, its Apples store... if they don't want to sell albums with green covers they have a right to do so. Why does everyone think that anything popular should automatically give rights to those who uses it? Don't like the product or service? ... many companies are happy to fill your needs.
 
Is there a Grand Theft Auto ap in iTunes? I haven't seen any.

Reread the article. He was talking about walmart there. They would only carry clean albumns, but sold unrated movies and M rated games.
 
Reread the article. He was talking about walmart there. They would only carry clean albumns, but sold unrated movies and M rated games.

Yup. Big chains love posturing to PTA's with this nonsense. His last paragraph is pretty win, but is only preaching to the choir (and not the suits at Apple). Oh well, it was funny as hell to read though.
 
Bah... quite frankly, I agree with him about the app store...but his statement in regards to a website/email on the iPhone really doesn't have anything to do with Apple...unless they wanted to monitor the content that is allowed to be viewed by the iPhone (which could possibly be...but then I would launch my iPhone into the nearest Apple store as hard as my arm would allow me to throw it). If I want to look at pr0n on my iPhone, that's my business..

But back to the point: As much as I think Trent is a douche, he does have a solid argument. However, Apple is either a) going to completely ignore him, or b) tighten down on *everything* they do. In which case, I hope it is a).
 
His point was Apple's issue with his new app was that it gave access to a podcast with Downward Spiral with offensive language.

Further down there is a report that a twitter app was denied due to again offensive language not from the app but from possible twitter content.

aka since email and internet can provide offensive language then Apple should disable these features.
 
Bah... quite frankly, I agree with him about the app store...but his statement in regards to a website/email on the iPhone really doesn't have anything to do with Apple...unless they wanted to monitor the content that is allowed to be viewed by the iPhone (which could possibly be...but then I would launch my iPhone into the nearest Apple store as hard as my arm would allow me to throw it). If I want to look at pr0n on my iPhone, that's my business..

But back to the point: As much as I think Trent is a douche, he does have a solid argument. However, Apple is either a) going to completely ignore him, or b) tighten down on *everything* they do. In which case, I hope it is a).

I think you are slightly misunderstanding the issue. NIN tried to release an app for the iphone, however it was rejected for some unknown reason. Best that Trent can guess is that it has to do with that fact it references their albumn which contains "foul" language in some of the songs. He was using Walmart as a example of selective censoring and where he stood on it then. His was showing that he has the same belief here. They will let him sell a song on itunes, but not play the same song in an app that you buy through their app store. So Apple, like Walmart, is using selective censoring where they will require some stuff to be clean, but not others.
 
I think you are slightly misunderstanding the issue. NIN tried to release an app for the iphone, however it was rejected for some unknown reason. Best that Trent can guess is that it has to do with that fact it references their albumn which contains "foul" language in some of the songs. He was using Walmart as a example of selective censoring and where he stood on it then. His was showing that he has the same belief here. They will let him sell a song on itunes, but not play the same song in an app that you buy through their app store. So Apple, like Walmart, is using selective censoring where they will require some stuff to be clean, but not others.

So? It is there store they can do as they wish. If a number of people protest by not using it then they will get the message. Hell I bet enough e-mail traffic could get this fixed. I dont think any one really cares besides Trent. I
 
I want to see more quality control from Apple. The store is bombarded by cheap aps that are made in a few weeks at most. It's like the early 1980's in the video games business (which is why that business collapsed until the introduction of the NES where there was a quality control).

Finding something good on the ap store is like wadin through the sewers to find a piece of gold in a sea of crap.
 
So? It is there store they can do as they wish. If a number of people protest by not using it then they will get the message. Hell I bet enough e-mail traffic could get this fixed. I dont think any one really cares besides Trent. I

He isn't angry about that, he is angry about the fact that the app got approved already and that content was already there and now when they are pushing stability fixes Apple is denying them because of the podcast which had nothing to do with the update they are trying to release.
 
i like trent, but i think he sounds like a 12 year old forum poster that live in his moms basement here.

walmart had to censor their music because at that time there was HUGE backlash from eminem albums, and walmart would have surely lost in court if they didnt try to keep their content clean. and is it really true you can buy gta4 at walmart? that seems unlikely.
 
Wow. Are we no longer allowed to complain about a company's policy?

:rolleyes: Yeah, don't listen to the guy you quoted. It's obvious he hasn't though through his "just take it and like it" argument.

But really, this is just more reason to dislike Apple.
 
I must say, the double-standard is kind of ridiculous.

The iTunes music store has a simple "Explicit" system, where music is marked as such when needed, and parents can restrict a child's account from purchasing such music. I'm fairly certain that you can do the same thing with movie ratings in the iTunes video store. Why are they being so staunch about this in the app store? Just extend their simple content control system to apps. The foundation is already in place. The hardest part is someone reviewing them, but that's already being done right now.
 
As much as I think Trent is a douche, he does have a solid argument.
How is he a douche? I'm genuinely curious.

walmart had to censor their music because at that time there was HUGE backlash from eminem albums, and walmart would have surely lost in court if they didnt try to keep their content clean.
Wal-Mart folded to market pressure: nothing more. They were targeted only because they were, at that time, the largest American music retailer (which I think says something pretty depressing about American music-listening consumers, but I digress).

Wal-Mart didn't have to do anything.
 
Reread the article. He was talking about walmart there. They would only carry clean albumns, but sold unrated movies and M rated games.

I can't reread the article if I never read it in the first place. Duh. :D
 
Kinda funny because I remember reading his interview on Wired and he's a pretty hardcore, self-admitted Apple fanboy.
 
If it really is due to the references to his songs, it's really funny and hypocritical of Apple. They sell those same albums through iTunes, so why is ok to sell the some on their one service but not have an app that references those same songs that you allow people to download.
 
Kinda funny because I remember reading his interview on Wired and he's a pretty hardcore, self-admitted Apple fanboy.

I actually found that funny myself. I guess now he's starting to see what all those non-Apple fanboys have been saying all along about their business model.
 
Trent Reznor is bitching about something. In other news, the sky is blue.
 
Trent is 100% correct. The rules for the app store are inconsistent and some developers will have no idea if they have broken any rules until their app has been submitted and then rejected. Hell, you can submit an app similar to one already out there and get turned down for some arbitrary reason. Remember the Twitter app a few weeks back? It was one of many already out there and it was initially turned down because whoever was vetting that app decided that what was out there on Twitter was objectionable content. Stupid!

And the fact that you can get all of the same "objectionable" NIN material on the iTunes store makes this even more crazy.

Maybe there aren't enough people vetting apps at the app store, I dunno. There needs to be a list of rules that is kept consistent, as well as people at Apple that interface directly with developers. Having the same rules apply for one developer and not another for inconsistent reasons is only going to drive them away from the platform.
 
I agree with Mr. Reznor completely.

Plus, Apple sucks. Seriously. Don't slam the forum rulebook on my face, please. It's not just opinion, it's fact. There will never be any apple products in my household because of Apple's policies about MANY things, including but not limited to the iPhone app store, the iTunes EULA, the "we can charge way more for the same hardware because we're Apple," etc etc the list goes on.

The only question I have left is why Mr. Reznor would even care, Mac users buy into that yuppie indie sub-culture, they don't listen to NIN anyway.
 
I agree with Mr. Reznor completely.

Plus, Apple sucks. Seriously. Don't slam the forum rulebook on my face, please. It's not just opinion, it's fact. There will never be any apple products in my household because of Apple's policies about MANY things, including but not limited to the iPhone app store, the iTunes EULA, the "we can charge way more for the same hardware because we're Apple," etc etc the list goes on.

The only question I have left is why Mr. Reznor would even care, Mac users buy into that yuppie indie sub-culture, they don't listen to NIN anyway.

Because unlike Macs, and almost everything else Apple has, the iPhone is actually a good product that does better than lots of other phones at multiple things, such as web browsing, user interface, and availability of applications.

Don't like Apple's? Buy the iPhone used, and jailbreak. :)
 
^ that should say Apple, not Apple's. No edit button.
 
I agree with Mr. Reznor completely.
The only question I have left is why Mr. Reznor would even care, Mac users buy into that yuppie indie sub-culture, they don't listen to NIN anyway.

I laughed, thanks for this. :D


Listening to NIN is about the safest way of being "edgy" one can participate in aside from voting for Obama and buying Macs. These people probably also hate fox news.
 
Because unlike Macs, and almost everything else Apple has, the iPhone is actually a good product that does better than lots of other phones at multiple things, such as web browsing, user interface, and availability of applications.

Don't like Apple's? Buy the iPhone used, and jailbreak. :)

It's still an Apple product at that point... No thanks, I've got my Samsung Behold, which does everything the iPhone does with a couple exceptions: I don't have a storage limitation (my phone supports awesome amounts of micro-SD) and I don't have the app store. I don't buy anything on my phone, not apps, not games, not ringers. I can use anything in my entire music collection as a ringtone. My phone doesn't come with the worst 3G network in existence. See where I'm going with this? I spent less AND I don't have to deal with all the hassle. Oh, and yes, mine does the awesome touchscreen+accelerometer stuff. Plus I can change my background anytime I want... and my plan costs less than the lowest iPhone-associated plan... I mean really, the perks are immense. Should I keep going? Cuz I can.

See that rant I just had? I can do that about everything Apple-related. That is why Mr. Reznor is awesome. He's a famous person saying the exact same things non-famous people say about ridiculous and/or hipocritical policies companies make. I know somebody has already mentioned, and I'm sure others will again, the fact that "if you don't like their policies dont buy their products lololol i=clever." Never fear, I only buy in what I believe in. (mainly women as fast as my car)
 
I actually found that funny myself. I guess now he's starting to see what all those non-Apple fanboys have been saying all along about their business model.

Ha! Yeah, maybe Apple is just getting revenge on him distributing his albums for free and being anti-DRM.
 
Apple sucks. It's not just opinion, it's fact.
Okay, chief.

The only question I have left is why Mr. Reznor would even care, Mac users buy into that yuppie indie sub-culture, they don't listen to NIN anyway.
It could be because he sunk over $100,000 into the app out of his own pocket. He probably, you know, wants to be able to update it when he feels like it.

There's also the fact that Reznor's an iPhone user himself. That may or may not play some sort of role in this, I might imagine.

So, imagine buying a Porsche 911 and having Porsche tell you that you aren't allowed to drive it because you installed an unauthorized shift knob (and miss work that day because of it). But the guy down the street? He's using the same shift knob you are, and Porsche doesn't give a shit about him. It's understandably a little bit aggravating.

Listening to NIN is about the safest way of being "edgy" one can participate in aside from voting for Obama and buying Macs. These people probably also hate fox news.
I listen to NIN, am a libertarian (did not vote for Obamoid) and am not terribly bothered by Fox News :)

I can use anything in my entire music collection as a ringtone.
So can I. Easily.
 
Ha! Yeah, maybe Apple is just getting revenge on him distributing his albums for free and being anti-DRM.

Nah, Apple is just being incredibly stupid with their approval policy. Just dumb dumb dumb.

As for DRM, Apple was the first company that told the RIAA that they had to drop it. Jobs very publicly said that DRM was useless and only hurting everybody, and hilariously Apple were the last ones to get DRM-free tracks granted to them because the RIAA hates how much leverage they have as the top selling online music store. Apple had also insisted on flat rate pricing on iTunes for years (something the RIAA and the movie studios didn't want), but they finally caved into the RIAA's insistence on tiered pricing in order to get the right to sell tracks without DRM. It is also why the RIAA will sell digital music to Amazon for wholesale prices that are far less than what Apple buys them for. This isn't a tirade against either, I love Amazon's service, but the politics go way beyond what any of these resellers can control.
 
I agree with Mr. Reznor completely.

Plus, Apple sucks. Seriously. Don't slam the forum rulebook on my face, please. It's not just opinion, it's fact. There will never be any apple products in my household because of Apple's policies about MANY things, including but not limited to the iPhone app store, the iTunes EULA, the "we can charge way more for the same hardware because we're Apple," etc etc the list goes on.

Newsflash: ALL companies have shitty policies somewhere. Microsoft, Apple, Sony, Nintendo, Blackberry, all of them somewhere have something that doesn't have the best interest of the consumer. But you know what, all of them make some great products. If you want to cut off your nose to spite your face (and you don't see to mind doing that based on the crummy phone and LCD in your sig), that's just fine.

I can excuse budgetary concerns for buying an inferior product, no problem there, but if its on something as naive and misguided as PRINCIPLE, I just have to laugh.
 
There's also the fact that Reznor's an iPhone user himself. That may or may not play some sort of role in this, I might imagine.

It goes way beyond that, he's one of the biggest, most public macheads out there. Aside from the fact that he's a recording artist (and all professional recordings are done on Macs, even more prevalent there than in the film business), he releases everything in Apple Lossless, releases GarageBand compatible tracks for fans to remix, and he even had the image of a BSOD flash on screen during his live shows (it was a news story a few months ago).

So yeah, nice to see him lashing back at Apple like this, at least he's not COMPLETELY brainwashed. :)

My prediction: This will get reevaluated and fast-tracked to approval. It won't surprise me if they try to get him to put a content filter function on the app (stupid). We'll see.
 
It's still an Apple product at that point... No thanks, I've got my Samsung Behold, which does everything the iPhone does with a couple exceptions:

Again, I didn't pay Steve Jobs for the product, so it doesn't matter who made it. I don't like his business practices either, and would never buy their product from them.

I don't have a storage limitation (my phone supports awesome amounts of micro-SD) and I don't have the app store. I don't buy anything on my phone, not apps, not games, not ringers.

I will agree with you on the micoSD card, however, the majority of my phone use is either SMS or Google Maps related, which is better on the iPhone than virtually everywhere else. And who the hell buys games for phones?

I can use anything in my entire music collection as a ringtone.

Jailbreaking is your friend. I happen to use Don't Tase Me Bro for mine.

My phone doesn't come with the worst 3G network in existence. See where I'm going with this? I spent less AND I don't have to deal with all the hassle. Oh, and yes, mine does the awesome touchscreen+accelerometer stuff. Plus I can change my background anytime I want... and my plan costs less than the lowest iPhone-associated plan... I mean really, the perks are immense. Should I keep going? Cuz I can.

Neither did mine - eBay is your friend. AT&T basically sucks, and my family does not do business with them. And I can almost guarantee I pay less than you - around $30/month, for unlimited text&data from T-Mobile (I hardly use voice).

See that rant I just had? I can do that about everything Apple-related. That is why Mr. Reznor is awesome. He's a famous person saying the exact same things non-famous people say about ridiculous and/or hipocritical policies companies make. I know somebody has already mentioned, and I'm sure others will again, the fact that "if you don't like their policies dont buy their products lololol i=clever." Never fear, I only buy in what I believe in. (mainly women as fast as my car)

Noone is forcing you to buy their products, but if you chose to do so, noone is forcing you to comply to their policies either. I personally don't.
 
[Reznor] even had the image of a BSOD flash on screen during his live shows (it was a news story a few months ago).
Yeah, during a performance of Me, I'm Not, if I recall. I got a good laugh out of that :p
 
Back
Top