Another X58 Mobo Question

MikeTek

n00b
Joined
May 1, 2009
Messages
1
Ok, guys after reading the forum for a week, I'm still confused.

I've been out of the Gaming PC realm for several years now and I'm ready to jump back in. I'm going to buy me a I7 920, 6GB of DD3 1600 ram, GTX 260 (maybe 2 with SLI), I just need to pull the trigger on the Mobo decision.

I'm either going to get the Asus P6T Deluxe V2 or the EVGA 132-BL-E758-TR LGA. Both seem to be getting good reviews and high praise. I'm never going to run more than the 2 GTX 260's in SLI and I want to make sure that if need to add a Soundcard that I have the room to do so with out the slot being covered up.

Which would be the better choice?

Thanks!
 
Adding a sound card to either of those boards with two large cards in SLI or Crossfire is no problem. Its when you get into 3-Way SLI and CrossfireX that you can have issues with that.
 
evga. if you look closely you will see that your other choice is actually an asus!!!

There wouldn't be just a little brand name prejudice in that remark, would there? What actual facts do you base your "judgement" on? Enlighten us, please.

CB
 
That makes no sense.

I'd go with the ASUS. Both should be solid boards, and comparable in terms of performance. In that price range, you may also want to take a look at the Gigabyte EX58-UD5.

well, that first one is definitely an asus. but if you look at the specs carefully, the other choice is a gigabyte!!! you will be able to tell, because it is blue-ish, and it wont work correctly. and bios updates cause problems, not fix them.
 
You have two excellent choices there.

I have used the EVGA X58 SLI boards and they are great.you will be able to SLi and use a sound card, no problem.

The "plain" X58 has two versions, the A1 and the TR, these are identical across the board except the A1 has lifetime warranty and is available to Step-up.

What I like about EVGA is service. Plus they have a great forum that their techs pour over and will often give you help without needing to contact support.
 
well, that first one is definitely an asus. but if you look at the specs carefully, the other choice is a gigabyte!!! you will be able to tell, because it is blue-ish, and it wont work correctly. and bios updates cause problems, not fix them.

Have some proof of that? While not perfect I've had great experiences with Gigabyte motherboards over the last three years. Now prior to that is another story, but Gigabyte really has stepped up their game quite a bit. Though I do still hear a ton of bad things about their lowest tier boards. Especially those in the sub $150 price point.
 
You have two excellent choices there.

I have used the EVGA X58 SLI boards and they are great.you will be able to SLi and use a sound card, no problem.

The "plain" X58 has two versions, the A1 and the TR, these are identical across the board except the A1 has lifetime warranty and is available to Step-up.

What I like about EVGA is service. Plus they have a great forum that their techs pour over and will often give you help without needing to contact support.



most affirmative, matey.

and i have proof about gigabyte. every one i have ever seen has been blue-ish.
and i am just kidding about the gigabyte thing. everybody knows they are simply dandy, almost as fine as an anus.


edit i mean asus.
 
Last edited:
well, that first one is definitely an asus. but if you look at the specs carefully, the other choice is a gigabyte!!! you will be able to tell, because it is blue-ish, and it wont work correctly. and bios updates cause problems, not fix them.

windmillinmybeard.jpg
 




cabbages, knickers, its not got a beak. ice cream has no bones. bell bottom shorts. also, it's crackers to slip a rosin dropsy in snide. dont lean too far towards the dfi, you will tip over, but dfi makes good stuff. almost as good as


edit sorry to go ot but bee biddly opum bopum bobo skideeton dottun waddah shiddam. hibby bobby booby baby hibby dibby sip. (everybody knows the bird is the word)
 
Last edited:
cabbages, knickers, its not got a beak. ice cream has no bones. bell bottom shorts. also, it's crackers to slip a rosin dropsy in snide. dont lean too far towards the dfi, you will tip over, but dfi makes good stuff. almost as good as


edit sorry to go ot but bee biddly opum bopum bobo skideeton dottun waddah shiddam. hibby bobby booby baby hibby dibby sip. (everybody knows the bird is the word)

Can you believe that there are actually people who think (and say) that your posts don't make any sense? What do they know (besides the truth)?

CB
 
Can you believe that there are actually people who think (and say) that your posts don't make any sense? What do they know (besides the truth)?

CB

can you believe there are people that think and say you are an? what do they know (besides you?)

back ot
i am starting a secondary build with the lp ut x58. i had several of their p35/45 and x38/48 boards and most of them were just meh. but this one looks like a winner. unless you have very specific configuration needs.
 
The DFI looks promising. Should have lots of tweaks in the BIOS.
 
I think the point is that just like every other component, you're going to find people who love and hate each brand. The good news is that all the X58 boards seem to be pretty good overall. Find one with a layout that you like, by a company you trust, and you'll most likely be just fine.


the truth is relative.
Relatives? Like incest?
 
I've had the opportunity to use both boards in the end I opted for the Asus P6T Deluxe, because my final cost was $215 shipped new vs $322 for the eVGA board but had they both been $215 or $322 new and shipped I would have definitely stayed with the eVGA board as their customer service is unparalleled to any other company not to mention the Step-up program they have is great.

As for lifetime warranty I personally don't use a board for more than 1YR at best so that is a great selling point for companies that offer that option, although for some that plan on using eVGA products for more than 3-4 years or more it really is a plus.

As far as performance goes in all the reviews I've personally read the Evga X58 board came in behind the Asus P6T Deluxe when it came to performance. During my experience with the eVGA X58 board it was a great solid board that performed very well and overclocked my chip to 3.8GHz with very good temps as the Asus board is and does.

In the end it's really about what suites you best in a boards features; bells n whistles, layout, aesthetics, warranty, and whatever else you may find important to you. Truthfully IMHO you can't go wrong with either board performance wise and I believe most of the current X58 boards are good performers and overclock great but the eVGA warranty/service/customer support goes a long way.
 
On factor you have to consider is the processor layout socket of the board. The EVGA board's socket is at the edge of the board.. This means a large cooler will likely overhang to edge of the motherboard. So if you plan to put a aftermarket cooler on it. Do your homework and make sure the motherboard/Cooler/Case combo fits together properly.

For ASUS and Gigabyte boards, the CPU socket is closer to the center compared with the previous generation P45/X48 boards.. You can mount a Thermal right IFX-14 on it and it will not overhang the edge.

X58 boards with CPU sockets on the edge include.
-DFI
-EVGA
-MSI
 
On factor you have to consider is the processor layout socket of the board. The EVGA board's socket is at the edge of the board.. This means a large cooler will likely overhang to edge of the motherboard. So if you plan to put a aftermarket cooler on it. Do your homework and make sure the motherboard/Cooler/Case combo fits together properly.

For ASUS and Gigabyte boards, the CPU socket is closer to the center compared with the previous generation P45/X48 boards.. You can mount a Thermal right IFX-14 on it and it will not overhang the edge.

This is a good point.
 
get the least expensive board that has the slot config that you need. because they all overclock pretty much the same. i mean there may be 1 or 2 that overclock 4% more betterer, or a couple that oc 4% worserer. just make sure that you dont buy a
 
get the least expensive board that has the slot config that you need. because they all overclock pretty much the same. i mean there may be 1 or 2 that overclock 4% more betterer, or a couple that oc 4% worserer. just make sure that you dont buy a

Well, like AMD CPUs, moving the memory controller into the CPU die limits the variance in performance that a motherboard can generate. Overclock wise they all pretty much overclock in the same range with a few individual exceptions of each model.
 
On factor you have to consider is the processor layout socket of the board. The EVGA board's socket is at the edge of the board.. This means a large cooler will likely overhang to edge of the motherboard. So if you plan to put a aftermarket cooler on it. Do your homework and make sure the motherboard/Cooler/Case combo fits together properly.

For ASUS and Gigabyte boards, the CPU socket is closer to the center compared with the previous generation P45/X48 boards.. You can mount a Thermal right IFX-14 on it and it will not overhang the edge.

X58 boards with CPU sockets on the edge include.
-DFI
-EVGA
-MSI

this really annoys me about my Classified / ATCS 840 combo, the CPU socket is moved over so i can only undo 2 bolts unless i take off the whole motherboard.
 
Back
Top