Army Experience Center Facing Protests Today

Status
Not open for further replies.

Terry Olaes

I Used to be the [H] News Guy
2FA
Joined
Nov 27, 2006
Messages
4,646
GamePolitics is actively following a protest against the Army Experience Center that we told you about last year. Protesters contend that the US Army is using video games to “militarize youth.” What do you think about all this?

Today's protest is scheduled to begin with a 1:00 P.M. rally at a nearby church. Speakers will include veterans of the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan as well as Celeste Zappala of Gold Star Families for Peace and a former State Department official, Col. Anne Wright.
 
I wonder if they'll protest the mandatory service requirements.
 
There's probably some truth to their protest, and maybe even a bit more beyond that.

Without looking at games like America's Army, other of other FPS games seem very military like. Look at Halo for example and how it evolved from Halo 2 and Halo 3. Every version of these games seem to get more patriotic and more robotic solders as far as personality goes. A lot more games today seem to be going in this direction.

Even some popular TV shows that males would typically watch get this treatment. Look at Knight Rider 2008 for example. Ignore the fact that this sucked and that Ford must have paid a huge sum of money. The main characters Micheal Knight and KITT also have that robotic military personality too. Micheal Knight is even an ex Iraq solder. Even the whole operation is run in a secret underground base.

It does seem like in some way that today's youth is being programmed to like war and wanna be exited to fight in one. Rather then teaching them that War sucks and that it should be avoided at all costs.

Maybe if games brought some real elements that really occurs in Wars, like when a solder sees a dead body for the first time and goes nuts or when the pressure gets to some of the solders heads and they freak out. Rather then watching NPCs running gun hoe and spewing nonsense like "eat it baby" or "get some", and then suddenly dying like morons.

Not only would that send a better message about wars, but it'll make for a better game to see NPC solders screaming and firing bullets in the air like a mad man, just cause they saw their friend die.
 
There's probably some truth to their protest, and maybe even a bit more beyond that.

Without looking at games like America's Army, other of other FPS games seem very military like. Look at Halo for example and how it evolved from Halo 2 and Halo 3. Every version of these games seem to get more patriotic and more robotic solders as far as personality goes. A lot more games today seem to be going in this direction.

Even some popular TV shows that males would typically watch get this treatment. Look at Knight Rider 2008 for example. Ignore the fact that this sucked and that Ford must have paid a huge sum of money. The main characters Micheal Knight and KITT also have that robotic military personality too. Micheal Knight is even an ex Iraq solder. Even the whole operation is run in a secret underground base.

It does seem like in some way that today's youth is being programmed to like war and wanna be exited to fight in one. Rather then teaching them that War sucks and that it should be avoided at all costs.

Maybe if games brought some real elements that really occurs in Wars, like when a solder sees a dead body for the first time and goes nuts or when the pressure gets to some of the solders heads and they freak out. Rather then watching NPCs running gun hoe and spewing nonsense like "eat it baby" or "get some", and then suddenly dying like morons.

Not only would that send a better message about wars, but it'll make for a better game to see NPC solders screaming and firing bullets in the air like a mad man, just cause they saw their friend die.


true.. but the US is still one of the few countries that doesnt require anyone over 18 to serve time in the military.. but i think it also brings awareness to kids about the military.. there are just to many horror story time military movies from the Vietnam era style that scare people into thinking the military is this horrible thing where all you do is get yelled at left and right.. and its really not like that at all.. so they have to do something to show kids that things arent that way and peak interest..

not to mention i just find protests a waste of time and resources.. very rarely does anything come out of them and usually theres more lies mixed in with them then truth these days.. but meh.. if people want to protest it.. feel free.. since its not my time being wasted.. but they arent going to get anything done with.. the military and government could care less what a small group of people think if what they are doing is working the way they want it to..

i mean heck America's Army didnt make me join the army.. it was the money.. and i think that goes for a lot of people.. money will always make some one join before patriotism..
 
I find it ironic that they are protesting an organization, who's members over the years, have fought and died to protect their right to protest.
 
I find it ironic that they are protesting an organization, who's members over the years, have fought and died to protect their right to protest.

...and that they're protesting/disagreeing with the military because they think that they've stolen people's free will. Isn't them just being there proof that people are able to decide for themselves?
 
So these tards are gong to protest military recruitment? I suppose they think the US doesn't need a military. :rolleyes: Hell, let's have conscription and establish mandatory service, maybe then they wouldn't find it so objectionable.
 
Meh... after the movie The Fast and the Furious (the original one) there were so many races that went on right after they got out of the movie it wasn't funny.

Kids and young adults are impressionable, it's why commercials work, this is not a state secret, having a game to lure in fresh recruits is no different than the Marine commercial showing the knight fighting and looking all bad ass...

If anything the part that pisses me off about this is that the US Military is actively spending serious bucks to get recruits, i.e. my tax dollars hard at work *sigh*
 
true.. but the US is still one of the few countries that doesnt require anyone over 18 to serve time in the military.

That's not true. Israel and Switzerland, and South Korea are pretty much the only countries that require mandatory military service (and Switzerland's is a joke).
 
There's probably some truth to their protest, and maybe even a bit more beyond that.

Without looking at games like America's Army, other of other FPS games seem very military like. Look at Halo for example and how it evolved from Halo 2 and Halo 3. Every version of these games seem to get more patriotic and more robotic solders as far as personality goes. A lot more games today seem to be going in this direction.

Even some popular TV shows that males would typically watch get this treatment. Look at Knight Rider 2008 for example. Ignore the fact that this sucked and that Ford must have paid a huge sum of money. The main characters Micheal Knight and KITT also have that robotic military personality too. Micheal Knight is even an ex Iraq solder. Even the whole operation is run in a secret underground base.

It does seem like in some way that today's youth is being programmed to like war and wanna be exited to fight in one. Rather then teaching them that War sucks and that it should be avoided at all costs.

Maybe if games brought some real elements that really occurs in Wars, like when a solder sees a dead body for the first time and goes nuts or when the pressure gets to some of the solders heads and they freak out. Rather then watching NPCs running gun hoe and spewing nonsense like "eat it baby" or "get some", and then suddenly dying like morons.

Not only would that send a better message about wars, but it'll make for a better game to see NPC solders screaming and firing bullets in the air like a mad man, just cause they saw their friend die.
What's your name again?

EA, NBC and the Pentagon are colluding to corrupt America's youth! You foiled their uber conspiracy.

Current entertainment is hell bent on reality. The media corps don't have to do pay for any novel creations so it's cheap to produce and people seem to like it. Therefore you get a bunch of games and TV based on wars and crime fighting departments.

This article is directly about the US government using consoles in recruiting centers. Stay on target...
 
You see these types of tards all the time today. Idiots from middle/upper middle/high class, never seen war, thinks no country is an enemy (Hell, they think the terrorists are freedom fighters fighting infiltrators to their country).

They sit around, making up the most retarded conspiracy theories about 9/11, but in all honesty, they have no balls and are led around by anyone. If war actually broke out, they'd be the first to die.
 
my friends in highschool didn't sign up for their respective military service completely out of a sense of patriotism, but they didn't sign up because of video games either. they went in because they needed money for college and at the time, that was the big promise - serve in the military, get money for college.

out of the ten that I know that went, one went in with aspirations to become a Navy SEAL. Barring that from happening, he'd settle for college money to learn how to fly.

Another one went because he literally felt he had nothing else to live for, and if he does, he'd find it in the military or he'd find it overseas. haven't heard from him since he left for boot camp in 2001/2002. whatever he's looking for, I hope he found it.

instead of protesting, maybe these people should ask why people sign up. they'd probably find video games have little to no pull on that. they'd find legitimate and valid reasoning behind why people sign up to face an opportunity that will change them forever. they'd find that video games/simulators are but a tool at best to get people to understand how far we have come in terms of training the soldiers of tomorrow, today.
Posted via [H] Mobile Device
 
Wow just wow. You don't want your kids influenced by the military? Used to be parents would pay lots of money to send kids to a military academy. Wow, pussification at it's flaming highest. Maybe we should use the pussified people as cannon fodder? They will be too weak and scared to fight back that's for sure. Pathetic.
 
...and that they're protesting/disagreeing with the military because they think that they've stolen people's free will. Isn't them just being there proof that people are able to decide for themselves?

I like this one. Their own existence as a group, and their own actions, disprove their own allegations.


Besides instilling patriotism in US citizens is not a bad thing. Unless you happen to not be an American. In which case, things that have a tendency to unite the American people can sometimes be problematic for you.
Is this group funded by China or the EU? Just kidding...............
 
So these tards are gong to protest military recruitment?

Protest using games as a means to recruit...though I have a feeling its more of just an anti-war protest than anything else. It bothers me that they would use games as a way to do it..."Hey kid, wanna blow shit up just like this?" Sure that is more generalized, but lure the kids in with the benefits, GI Bill, and such. I know when I went in to talk to the Army and AF about a career a couple of years ago it was serious and not using some stupid ass "Experience" center which has NOTHING to do with "Experience". And this gets into another topic on how some recruiters fill you with nothing but bullshit which creates false expectations but thats another argument for another time.
 
What's your name again?

EA, NBC and the Pentagon are colluding to corrupt America's youth! You foiled their uber conspiracy.

Current entertainment is hell bent on reality. The media corps don't have to do pay for any novel creations so it's cheap to produce and people seem to like it. Therefore you get a bunch of games and TV based on wars and crime fighting departments.

This article is directly about the US government using consoles in recruiting centers. Stay on target...
You don't think the US government doesn't influence the entertainment industry? You want them to put the US government in the credits?

If you don't believe me ask the people who served in Iraq. Plenty of teenagers who think that War is like Counter Strike for them, and are dying to see action. Except that when they leave they're messed up in the head, and suicide is something their family has to be careful of.

It's not like this is the first time the US government used entertainment for propaganda purposes. Remember how they produced fake footage of Iraq?

The US government is corrupt and I don't care if you're Republican, Democrat, or even part of the Green party. Also, thanks for being an ass hole.
 
"Children are a perpetual, self-renewing underclass, helpless to escape from the decisions of adults until they become adults themselves."

"Thank you! Let me begin with some sentimental appeals to our national myths; assorted clichés coined by the state; the ideological shorthand meant to sweep your private doubts [away] of this virtual training course. This portal; this Trojan Horse that you living idiots paid for and actually rolled into your own kids’ rooms."
 
sleepeeg, what duke said was perfectly relevant. he was talking about the protesters justifications in a perfectly level-headed way. what YOU said, however, is trolling bs. current entertainment is LABELED with reality-this, reality-that, when IN reality, these things dont depict anything close to realism. really. what duke was saying was that entertainment today is using extremes and stark misrepresentation as a pithy lure to impressionable idiots, and some people disagree with the militarys attempt to "cash in".

they have a right to protest; im surprised that so many of you are so hostile, attempting to discredit them with exaggeration and misrepresentations of your own, when really, all they're trying to do is what they think is right. sure people are stupid.. but sometimes you gotta let things go.
 
I wonder if they'll protest the mandatory service requirements.

Considering our record over the past few decades of unjust or unwarranted wars, I'd hope so.

I think that the protesters are stupid.

I think this is ironic gold.

Not so.

I have many relatives that gave up allot to join up and fight for their country.
Always? Is that why Pat Tillman left the NFL for the Army? Money?

You both completely misunderstood his sentence and took it out of context. His entire point with that sentence you quoted was that most people join for the money. Please use context clues.

He said that a person would choose to join for money before they would join for patriotism, not that a person would ONLY join for money. Essentially what he is saying that most of the armed service joined because they either wanted the money or needed it.

No where in there did he ever even suggest that no one would join the military if they already had the money.

Sorry to be so blunt, but I'm getting sick and tired of people on forums not reading other people's posts and arguing with them because they got offended or indignant about something they stupidly misunderstood.

Also, Pat Tillman died vainly in an unjust war. - "Hurr Iraq has WMDs trust us! Hurrr!!!"

I find it ironic that they are protesting an organization, who's members over the years, have fought and died to protect their right to protest.

That isn't ironic at all unless you look at it in the most simplistic terms. They are protesting 1)the idea that war is a game and 2)the fact that we are in wars and have been in wars we had no reason to be in.

There is nothing wrong with protesting that the military and wars should only be used when absolutely necessary.

If you want to know true irony, look at how our grandfathers who were the "Greatest Men" fought the "Greatest War" that was to end all wars and how they suffered more than you or our current soldiers will ever know, yet our current soldiers and citizens tend to take it all for granted and act as if war being common is completely OK. Now, that is fucking irony and spitting on graves.

Would it surprise you that many, if not almost all, war vets of the past are also anti-war advocates because they know that war is a horrible thing and should only be used as a last resort because it can destroy entire generations?

...and that they're protesting/disagreeing with the military because they think that they've stolen people's free will. Isn't them just being there proof that people are able to decide for themselves?

No they aren't, stop this shit. They are protesting brainwashing and associating techniques that this kind of advertisement is built on. Both of which are very real and used historically and today by anyone with an agenda to push, with varying degrees of maliciousness.

So these tards are gong to protest military recruitment? I suppose they think the US doesn't need a military. :rolleyes: Hell, let's have conscription and establish mandatory service, maybe then they wouldn't find it so objectionable.

They are protesting manipulative recruitment that involves making war cool and awesome and hell yea lets go shoot some shit!

Meh... after the movie The Fast and the Furious (the original one) there were so many races that went on right after they got out of the movie it wasn't funny.

Kids and young adults are impressionable, it's why commercials work, this is not a state secret, having a game to lure in fresh recruits is no different than the Marine commercial showing the knight fighting and looking all bad ass...

If anything the part that pisses me off about this is that the US Military is actively spending serious bucks to get recruits, i.e. my tax dollars hard at work *sigh*

Thank you for having an actual IQ high enough to know what is actually being protested.

That's not true. Israel and Switzerland, and South Korea are pretty much the only countries that require mandatory military service (and Switzerland's is a joke).

A joke? Seriously? Switzerland (or was it Finland?) is a place where it isn't uncommon to see a guy who just left post and is stopping by the store on the way home to have his machine gun still strapped to his back. They actually respect guns there and don't have irrational fears about them like we do here.

If the U.S. wasn't so shitty when it comes to starting wars of aggression, I'd support drafts in the case of lack of troops during justified and unprovoked wars, if not actual mandatory service during peace time.

You see these types of tards all the time today. Idiots from middle/upper middle/high class, never seen war, thinks no country is an enemy (Hell, they think the terrorists are freedom fighters fighting infiltrators to their country).

They sit around, making up the most retarded conspiracy theories about 9/11, but in all honesty, they have no balls and are led around by anyone. If war actually broke out, they'd be the first to die.

You're pretty ignorant to talk so pointedly. Tell me about how Iraq had WMDs, please?

instead of protesting, maybe these people should ask why people sign up. they'd probably find video games have little to no pull on that. they'd find legitimate and valid reasoning behind why people sign up to face an opportunity that will change them forever. they'd find that video games/simulators are but a tool at best to get people to understand how far we have come in terms of training the soldiers of tomorrow, today.
Posted via [H] Mobile Device

They aren't protesting that people sign up for those reasons. They are ONLY protesting about the use of games and the trivializing of war in order to recruit impressionable or naive teenagers/young adults.

Your argument is misplaced.

Wow just wow. You don't want your kids influenced by the military? Used to be parents would pay lots of money to send kids to a military academy. Wow, pussification at it's flaming highest. Maybe we should use the pussified people as cannon fodder? They will be too weak and scared to fight back that's for sure. Pathetic.

You talk a lot of shit for someone who is undoubtedly not in the military :rolleyes:.

I like this one. Their own existence as a group, and their own actions, disprove their own allegations.


Besides instilling patriotism in US citizens is not a bad thing. Unless you happen to not be an American. In which case, things that have a tendency to unite the American people can sometimes be problematic for you.
Is this group funded by China or the EU? Just kidding...............

Its pretty telling of you to latch onto an argument of accusation of a group of people that has no bearing in reality. Its even more telling that you tried to compare Patriotism to Xenophobia and felt so proud of yourself for doing it.

I also don't expect you to comprehend this reply and expect you to rebut it out of context.
 
You see these types of tards all the time today. Idiots from middle/upper middle/high class, never seen war, thinks no country is an enemy (Hell, they think the terrorists are freedom fighters fighting infiltrators to their country).
See that's the kinda shit that pisses me off. People like you think it's segregated between hippies who want peace of love, and people who think they're realistic about their views of the world.

You ever see the movie Grand Torino? The movie makes a very good point. War sucks, and you don't know what it's like to take another human beings life.

Too many people today would prefer to call themselves American instead of human. It's getting easier today to spot the difference of the two. If human life had a value on the stock market, it would certainly be a low value.

Human life is above all else. Nothing comes before human life, not even a war.
They sit around, making up the most retarded conspiracy theories about 9/11, but in all honesty, they have no balls and are led around by anyone. If war actually broke out, they'd be the first to die.
Plenty of people have the balls to do what's right. Very few have the power to make it happen.

What business Iraq and 9/11 had together nobody knows. All we know is that it wasn't related, and the government use propaganda to influence Americans to war.

The entire world didn't want us to go to war and doesn't like war, yet somehow we know better then they do.
 
You see these types of tards all the time today. Idiots from middle/upper middle/high class, never seen war, thinks no country is an enemy (Hell, they think the terrorists are freedom fighters fighting infiltrators to their country).

They sit around, making up the most retarded conspiracy theories about 9/11, but in all honesty, they have no balls and are led around by anyone. If war actually broke out, they'd be the first to die.
Wow just wow. You don't want your kids influenced by the military? Used to be parents would pay lots of money to send kids to a military academy. Wow, pussification at it's flaming highest. Maybe we should use the pussified people as cannon fodder? They will be too weak and scared to fight back that's for sure. Pathetic.

Exactly! I am getting tired of people protesting for the rights of the enemies. War is brutal and people die. The simple fact of the matter is that half of the United States does not have the stomach for war. People have lost their sense of patriotism and honor in this country. They think they shouldn't have to work hard or live hard and they protest the very people who defend these freedoms. At least the people going to these recruitment centers know that when you point a gun at somebody and pull the trigger that somebody dies at the other end. At least they have "some" understanding of what happens when they go to war. What are we going to use to prepare them for what to expect? You can drop them into a war zone with basic point and shoot instructions, then see how they do against people who have been living with death and trained to use a gun their whole life. It's a stupid argument from unrealistic idealists.
 
From America's Army own page: "As the Director of OEMA, Colonel Wardynski provides policy analysis and advice to senior Army leaders including the Assistant Secretary of the Army for Manpower and Reserve Affairs, the Army G1 and G3, and Commanders of Major Subordinate Commands of the Army. By applying economic and statistical analysis to time sensitive policy problems, he provides senior leaders with definitive policy advice on issues ranging from Soldier compensation structure to recapitalization of the Army tank fleet. So as to reduce the career information search and assimilation costs associated with learning about Soldiering, Colonel Wardynski developed the concept for the Army Game Project. He serves as the Army manager for the development and operational phases of the project known to the public as America’s Army, a PC game designed to provide civilians with an inside perspective and a virtual role in today’s modern Army."


"Welcome to the offices of Economic and Manpower Analyses here at our historic and sprawling West Point Academy campus! My name is Mindy! It is my distinct pleasure to introduce you to a loving father of three (and a champion of the sanctioned use of armed force in pursuit of policy objectives). Ladies and gentlemen, put your hands together for the project director of our newest recruitment strategy; our mission to staff future combat systems through current technologies. Without any further ado, I give to you Colonel Casey Wardynski!"

"Thank you! Let me begin with some sentimental appeals to our national myths; assorted clichés coined by the state; the ideological shorthand meant to sweep your private doubts [away] of this virtual training course. This portal; this Trojan Horse that you living idiots paid for and actually rolled into your own kids’ rooms."

"Oops, did I just say that out loud? Oh, well, it’s not like it’s something new. It’s just the logical extension of the decades of bilge water that you’ve let us pump into your homes. The pink noise that hums away in the background while you run the gauntlet we force on you everyday. The billowing candy floss that helps to soften the blow. Deep down you’ve always known that your children already belong to us, so why don’t you cut the outraged parent routine, shut your mouth and get back in your seat. Your children already belong to us. What are you? You will pass on. And they won’t know a fucking thing but this 'community,' this real life Ender’s Game. Forget what you think you know.""


So many video games today are propaganda machines that give children profoundly distorted views on the roels of military and the act of murder. The games are made to desensitize us to the atrocities in injustices of warfare, and to entice us into thinking murdering our brothers and sisters across the world is 'honorable' or 'patriotic'.
 
Considering our record over the past few decades of unjust or unwarranted wars, I'd hope so.
lol, you totally didn't get it. :p But thanks for addressing everyone with a diatribe of epic proportions. We all feel better now that everything is all cleared up. ;)
 
sleepeeg, what duke said was perfectly relevant. he was talking about the protesters justifications in a perfectly level-headed way. what YOU said, however, is trolling bs. current entertainment is LABELED with reality-this, reality-that, when IN reality, these things dont depict anything close to realism. really. what duke was saying was that entertainment today is using extremes and stark misrepresentation as a pithy lure to impressionable idiots, and some people disagree with the militarys attempt to "cash in".

they have a right to protest; im surprised that so many of you are so hostile, attempting to discredit them with exaggeration and misrepresentations of your own, when really, all they're trying to do is what they think is right. sure people are stupid.. but sometimes you gotta let things go.

I don’t recall anyone saying they could not do anything or did not have the right, do you?

That aside they are busy body vacuous morons who earn the contempt and ridicule they so richly deserve. And BTW people here have the right to point out they are vacuous morons.
 
no, nobody said they didnt have the right, but many skirt the line. does this now discredit my point somehow? speaking of using extremes and exaggeration, heres another one^^ im well aware that people here have the right to post whatever they wish (besides what gets them banned), but that doesnt mean everyone who has an opinion makes sense just because they have one at all.
 
See that's the kinda shit that pisses me off. People like you think it's segregated between hippies who want peace of love, and people who think they're realistic about their views of the world.

Actually I didn't. You and Kristoff did this yourselves by attacking anybody who disagreed with you, which turned the topic into two different sides.
 
no, nobody said they didnt have the right, but many skirt the line. does this now discredit my point somehow? speaking of using extremes and exaggeration, heres another one^^ im well aware that people here have the right to post whatever they wish (besides what gets them banned), but that doesnt mean everyone who has an opinion makes sense just because they have one at all.

Double speak. You seem to have had no point other than if you like it that makes it relevant (even when what you like is exaggeration, distortions, and misrepresentation) and if you don’t like it that makes it exaggeration and misrepresentations (even if relevant).

Speaking of Orwell...

We sleep safely in our beds because rough men stand ready in the night to visit violence on those who would do us harm.

George Orwell


Some of you would do well to understant this truth.
 
no, nobody said they didnt have the right, but many skirt the line. does this now discredit my point somehow? speaking of using extremes and exaggeration, heres another one^^ im well aware that people here have the right to post whatever they wish (besides what gets them banned), but that doesnt mean everyone who has an opinion makes sense just because they have one at all.

Being wrong isn't a Democracy.
 
I always love how ignorant people like Kristoff try to make it sound like, if you want to defend your country, your some cowboy who wants to shoot things up.

Tell me, was Vietnam better or worse, when we came, and when we left? Talk to me about death all you want, but the country was not better before, and certainly wasn't better when your type of people wanted us to leave.

It's funny, liberals act like they are the intelligent. There's a game called chess, and it's actually a war simulator to a degree. Alot of times the most logical steps are to kill a few, save tons more.

You guys tell me you think, but the reality is you think with your heart, not your head. You can't see beyond bloodshed to make a logical thought.
 
With this said, the one war I'd probably agree on as being unjustified is the Iraq war. The problem I have is that we already are in it. Again, you guys can't see thru your crying to use your head and realize leaving the damn country will make things worse.
 
My dislike of this protest comes from neither side of anti-war pro-war or video games are influencing are kids but from the side that the Army experience center is basically a free arcade, where all i have to do is give them my information(like any place on the net), and I gave them an email address I barely check and I havent gotten any calls letters and only tournament emails, thenI get to play on high end computers, and full scale simulators with my friends, it's awesome, plus there are 60 PCs so me and my friends can play cod4 lan without having to move any of our computers. You can have your free speech but Don't take away my free entertainment dang it
 
I wonder if they'll protest the mandatory service requirements.
yep.
I think that the protesters are stupid.
yep.
I find it ironic that they are protesting an organization, who's members over the years, have fought and died to protect their right to protest.
Oh yeah.

Somehow these protesters would probably be in worse shape if there was no military, But then We all would be going to hell in a handbag, They'd just be protesting against something else, As usual.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top