Top 7 Reasons People Quit Linux

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Some guy wrote a list of the Top 7 Reasons People Quit Linux. Personally, I think that lists like this are, by themselves, one of the reason people quit Linux. We have a great deal of readers that are Linux users and we’ve even spent some time with Linux ourselves. We find that people usually respond to Linux help better when people aren’t making fun of you the whole way. OMG!!! Really? Yup.

OMG!!! Really? But seriously. So what? Are you scared of the keyboard? This is usually related to point #2 above, and it's usually a one-off manoeuvre designed to get something working. For example, to get DVD playback on Ubuntu, you have to type a certain command after downloading software. Once done, however, DVDs will play back automatically forever and ever.
 
Am I wrong? I could feel the sarcasm dripping off the article and I don't think that helps when you are trying to prove Linux users AREN'T that way.
 
No, you're not wrong, Steve. I felt so belittled just reading that article I would be put off even trying it.
 
The only thing that keeps me from using linux full time is games.....

I use it on my laptop full time however, just not on my desktop.
 
I stopped reading after # 3. That guy is a tool, the very reason non-Linux users think Linux users are elitist jerks.
 
#5 on that list is pretty dead on. Not *every* Linux forum in the universe is bad or full of mean people, but quite a few I have been to, the people were pretty ugly. I had some intermediate questions that normal FAQ's and searches couldn't answer and I got treated with a "if you can't compile a kernel, don't be asking questions here" attitude. Wow. I've since then made some local Linux guru friends who pretty much answer my questions now.
 
Am I wrong? I could feel the sarcasm dripping off the article and I don't think that helps when you are trying to prove Linux users AREN'T that way.

it doesn't help that most linux nerds' solutions to anyone's problem is "install linux", instead of things that actually might be helpful. its bound to stay niche as long as they keep behaving like that.

I think of linux as the kid in every one of my engineering classes who sits in the front with a large yellow legal pad, insisting violenty on doing every integral and calculation by hand, and scoffing at me as I plug things into my ti-89. the 89 isn't perfect...but its so *easy*.
 
ROFL boy he's a flat out liar.

In #5, he puts the blame solely on the original poster. "You need to keep your temper in check", "we know it's frustrating using Linux sometimes, but try and be civil when asking for help", etc etc..

As if his entire patronizing article didn't clue him in.
 
The wording in that alone sums up what many people have found in the linux community or lack there of. You are in insider or a NOOB, ubuntu forums and a FEW other placed are tolerant of non linux users asking simple questions but it seems like few.

Windows and Mac OS are designed for Desktop use, Linux is missing the design part, it is a collection of projects that provide similar desktop functions to Windows and Mac OS but hardly offer a unified desktop experience.

I admit Ubuntu is trying really hard to glue those parts together and provide a unified experience, along with some other distos.

I keep TRYING linux as a desktop OS every few years and always find it lacking, it is a great server and EXPERT OS, but not a average user desktop.
 
whew, at least it wasn't just me that objected to the tone of the article.

I really, really HATE taking someone to task for being a dick because I am a CLASS A DICK a lot of the time too and I ocassionally write some fairly dick-ish things as well but...when I do, I am prepared to have someone call me on it. :D
 
:p

the article itself is the very reason why people don't use *nix as a desk-TOP.

but for servers, admins should make every effort to know *nix, it can (possibly) save $ if their *nix-fu was onpar.

besides Mac OS X+ is basically unix :eek:
 
His article did nothing to help the Linux community.....it's to bad because it has come a long way from just a couple years ago.
 
#1 for me - So, I installed Linux..now what? I can browse the web, chat, write documents etc. That's cool. I can do that on my $200 netbook too. But my two main interests, creating music and gaming, are off limits in Linux. Sure there's some open source DAW but it isn't as user friendly meaning it gets in the way of creativity. Compatibility with instrument plug ins is accomplished with Wine resulting in a huge performance hit and many problems.
Gaming - well, there's always Tux Racer... :p

After using Linux for a few hours, just fooling around, changing the appearance of the terminal, installing skins, downloading open source apps that really don't "do" anything...I'm just so bored it's a relief to boot back into Windows again so I can actually "do" stuff, not just use the OS for the sake of using it. An OS is only as good as the applications that are available for it. Plus, most decent open source apps are available for Windows too.

That's incredible because I installed Windows the other day and had the exact same experience! My graphics card didn't work, and wifi didn't either.

The difference is that to install a driver in Windows, you double-click an .exe file and click next a few times. In Linux, there isn't even a standardized way to install drivers. It's done differently for every driver - sometimes the process is completely automated, sometimes you have to spend hours googling for information on how to get the driver installed.

3. I tried Linux but I had to type commands!

OMG!!! Really?

But seriously. So what? Are you scared of the keyboard?

It's 2009. I've been using computers since the Commdore 64. Typing commands was OK in 1988. It's not OK today. It's a sign of a poorly designed user interface.Either it's incomplete or too simplified and dumbed down. The terminal should only be a last resort, not the standard way of doing things (unless that's what you want).
 
I enjoy the standard GUI in openSUSE, and some of the features of other Linux distros...but I don't feel like *HAVING* no choice but to learn a whole new command system just to get something simple like sound drivers to work. I really don't have time for it. So while Linux is nice sometimes - I won't use it until it's easily installed, and easily up and running.
 
most internet forums and boards have a certain percentage of elitist pricks that you cant seem to avoid because they practially live on that board and seem to think its there home or something ([H] included) but the Linux crowd is like a bunch of Apple fans on meth or something...aside from that I never bothered with Linux cause I just dont care. I make a living with Windows and enjoy aspects of my downtime with windows...whats wrong with that?
 
Why do people still bitch about the CLI? When I installed Linux Mint, I had to do NOTHING with the CLI to get it working. Wireless, codecs, all working or easily configurable from the GUI.

Ubuntu cuts out the codecs and flash goodies. So installing is necessary, BUT, there is a tool that can be used to download the codecs, or else a GUI message will appear asking if you want to install it the first time you need it.

CLI arguments irritate me. It wasn't too long ago that you needed to issue a CLI command just to start windows. CLI, for me, is easier in both Linux OR Windows.
 
What a tool. What a condescending pile of tripe.

Linux on the desktop is a toy. Fun to play with, but hard to actually get any work done.
 
I skimmed the list till I saw this at #6:

It would be marvellous if people were honest enough to state this as bluntly as I've listed it above. After all, Linux isn't for everybody.

At that point I just laughed a good laugh, felt sorry for anyone that bought that idiot's books, and wondered just what the fuck is up with his apparent inability to spell. What, Linux spellcheckers are that bad? Oh, right, I doubt he uses Linux daily, more likely some Windows or OSX machine for publishing duties... go figure.

Marvelous, I say... or as Billy Crystal might, "Mahvelous..."
 
Why do people still bitch about the CLI? When I installed Linux Mint, I had to do NOTHING with the CLI to get it working. Wireless, codecs, all working or easily configurable from the GUI.

Ubuntu cuts out the codecs and flash goodies. So installing is necessary, BUT, there is a tool that can be used to download the codecs, or else a GUI message will appear asking if you want to install it the first time you need it.

CLI arguments irritate me. It wasn't too long ago that you needed to issue a CLI command just to start windows. CLI, for me, is easier in both Linux OR Windows.

Um, the last time I started Windows using command line interface was Windows 3.1 when you typed win from DOS prompt, which you could get around by putting win.exe at the end of Autoexec.bat

I don't know which version of Windows you were using "not too long ago".
 
The article took a face-first slide down sh!t mountain after point number one.
 
The list is very much spot on folks. Not that all the reasons are valid are even real, as the author points out, things often don't work in Windows as well.

But his missing at least one, "Why bother with Linux, its not doing anything more than Windows." I think this is the biggest reason of all as to why Linux on the desktop just isn't going to be a mass appeal situation.

Windows comes with 90% of all new PC and the vast majority of Windows copies are distributed that way. Yes, you can save some money and better better security and if you didn't have to give up anything then Linux would rule the world. But you do have to give up something usually.

For me I get free legal versions of Windows and I know how to keep my systems safe and stable, though like anything I own from time to time sure there are problems. There's no financial or technical reason for me to use Linux unless I need a Linux machine for something Linux only.

Linux is great, its just not great enough on the desktop/laptop/nettop for the average person to switch.
 
I skimmed the list till I saw this at #6:



At that point I just laughed a good laugh, felt sorry for anyone that bought that idiot's books, and wondered just what the fuck is up with his apparent inability to spell. What, Linux spellcheckers are that bad? Oh, right, I doubt he uses Linux daily, more likely some Windows or OSX machine for publishing duties... go figure.

Marvelous, I say... or as Billy Crystal might, "Mahvelous..."

Actually marvellous is an accepted non-US spelling.
 
I use Ubuntu on my spare PC and I really like it. I enjoy typing in commands and figuring things out when they don't work, but that's because I enjoy computers. It's a challenge to me to figure it out and I'm pleased when I do. Now not everyone is like that, lots of people are just "sheep" if you will and would rather just be able to click and move on. They don't want to diag things they just want the thing to work. I don't recommend Linux to most people because well yeah when things go bad you have to be some what intelligent and honestly people are just scared of computers it seems. I know my parents are, and lots of customers that I deal with, they are scared of always "hitting the wrong button." Sadly enough not enough people know how to use google yet.

Plus you can't fix stupid people, just let them be.
 
Here are my top 7 reasons:

1)I have to compile the kernel!?

2)There was an update, I have to compile the kernel again!?

3)Damnit program x isnt precompiled for this distribution I need to compile it, but it needs kernel sources for newer libraries, so I have to fuckin compile the kernel again!!!

4)For fucksakes program x and program y want different versions of libraries and they they wont compile without me learning how to fix a fucking gcc makefile.

5)My head hurts I take a Tylenol.

6)So the driver for hardware x is faster and more stable under windows but under this awesome linux it's half assed. Open source is so awesome they let politics stop development.

7)Windows is cheaper then 100 bottles of Tylenol.

#!/bin/bash
echo "As the AVGN says... I'd rather have a buffalo take a diarrhea dump in my ear."
 
Now not everyone is like that, lots of people are just "sheep" if you will and would rather just be able to click and move on. They don't want to diag things they just want the thing to work.

Just because a person doesn't want to spend hours and hours learning about Linux doesn't mean they are sheep, perhaps they have more important things to do, like earn a living, take care of their children, that sort of thing.

Remember, the MAIN selling point that Apple uses for Macs is that they are easier and just work, and while I think that its a bogus argument coming from Apple in relation to Macs overall it is nonetheless compelling. Try selling a computer with the tag line "But you'll enjoy spending endless hours just to make it print a document?"
 
I use Ubuntu on my spare PC and I really like it. I enjoy typing in commands and figuring things out when they don't work, but that's because I enjoy computers. It's a challenge to me to figure it out and I'm pleased when I do. Now not everyone is like that, lots of people are just "sheep" if you will and would rather just be able to click and move on. They don't want to diag things they just want the thing to work. I don't recommend Linux to most people because well yeah when things go bad you have to be some what intelligent and honestly people are just scared of computers it seems. I know my parents are, and lots of customers that I deal with, they are scared of always "hitting the wrong button." Sadly enough not enough people know how to use google yet.

Plus you can't fix stupid people, just let them be.

I agree 100%. But then I am actualy a PC enthusiast.
 
Why people don't use linux: linux users are tools and nobody wants to be a tool.

Linux users are the Simpson's Comicbook Guy. They think they're cool. But they are not. We mock them.

Back in the mid 90s I remember people telling me that Linux would destroy Windows. At that time you can to edit the source and rebuild the kernel to get audio working. That is how out of touch they were and still are.

I see this all the time in any tech business: the people doing the tech work think they are the norm when in fact they are the outlier.

Oh, and this article was a load of shit. Graphics didn't work? Bullshit. Download driver and install it. And the process is standardized rather than the design by committee cluster-fuck that is Linux. Same goes for netowkring and wifi.

Having to edit text config files in 2009 for common things is a sign of epic OS design FAIL.
 
lol, yeah i think most pragmatic computer enthusiasts will realize that it isn't for the lack of technical reason that technical users don't want to use *nix, it's because of TIME!!!! that is one limited resource that most users don't have much of equally no matter how l337 u r.

but if u do happen to have a lot of time and enjoy it, sure why not. in fact, there is no reason not to BE BOTH when you can.

i have a feeling that there are many computer enthusiasts who game/surf/email/etc. on their windoze box but also keep a spare 486 or el cheapo somewhere so they can try *nix on it and play around with it. it's a nyce toy and excellent learning/training mechanism if u really want to understand how an OS really works or operate a server.
 
Did any of you actually read the article? He's just not "some guy", the man has done more for linux than any of you tools will ever do.
 
Just because a person doesn't want to spend hours and hours learning about Linux doesn't mean they are sheep, perhaps they have more important things to do, like earn a living, take care of their children, that sort of thing.

Remember, the MAIN selling point that Apple uses for Macs is that they are easier and just work, and while I think that its a bogus argument coming from Apple in relation to Macs overall it is nonetheless compelling. Try selling a computer with the tag line "But you'll enjoy spending endless hours just to make it print a document?"


Sorry to be brief, my main reason for saying that is I get computers all the time to work on to where it seems people spend about 5 seconds of trying something and if they can't figure it out in that time they just give up. It bothers me that we are getting that lazy now of days instead of actually tying to do some research and better your knowledge as a person.

Yes I agree with if you have kids and you just want something to work, because you have a very busy day. Maybe I just expect too much from people, but I just look at my history of buying anything or dealing with anything and the very last thing I do is just give up and switch I like to research things because I always feel that it's something that I'm doing wrong and not the application.

Plus computers are a luxury, we should be happy every time that they work and make our life better. Maybe I just don't get so upset as the normal person I just go try to fix the issue the best that I can.
 
Just because a person doesn't want to spend hours and hours learning about Linux doesn't mean they are sheep, perhaps they have more important things to do, like earn a living, take care of their children, that sort of thing.

This.

I use both Operating Systems but Windows is still more easy to get working. The hardware situation with Linux hasn't improved much. Getting the best graphics drivers with 3D acceleration and Wireless to work is more time-consuming and challenging ... if it ends up working for you at all.

My big problem with this article is that the author and the more vocal Linux apologists blame everything but themselves.

So the "users are stupid." Well, that's not a very nice thing to say, but when it comes to computer literacy this is indeed the case (on a side note, i'd love to see the people who say these things do the actual career function of the 'idiot' in front of the keyboard -- odds are, they'd fall flat on their face.) What they refuse to accept is that they must accomodate these kinds of people if Linux is to succeed, not the other way around! Instead, user unfriendliness hasn't improved much which indicates either inability or unwillingness to achieve those goals -- neither is excusable if they want Linux to be adopted as quickly as they hope it will be. This is unfortunate, but that is the reality.

Also, user unfriendliness affects advanced users as well as beginners. If something takes less time to do in Windows than it does in Linux -- regardless of whether the task is achievable or not, it will be rejected unless absolutely necessary by technical people who need to make a living off of the technology they use.

Furthermore, device drivers for every piece of hardware exist in Windows and can be installed relatively easily if they are not detected automatically. It isn't always this straightforward in Linux, due to restrictive licensing. There is no point in getting bent out of shape about this if someone doesn't use the OS because the hardware isn't supported (or isn't well-supported, or difficult to install.) Maybe the hardware licensing IS restrictive and the drivers are not open, but that doesn't matter to the end-user. To them, it just doesn't work. Why do certain Linux community members get upset at people for giving up on the OS if it doesn't work for them?
 
That guy is a tool, the very reason non-Linux users think Linux users are elitist jerks.
I have to agree. I don't think that article is going to make anyone try linux.
 
Back in late 1994 early 1995 I learned to tweak the heck out of windows 3.1. I played around with multiple memory managers and changed order of TSR loading and such until my system was so tweaked out I had 636k free conventional memory in DOS mode, WITH every single driver and TSR I needed loaded into high memory. It was a lot of fun but frankly I never want to do it again. I proved to myself I was capable of it and I know if I had to I could I just don't want to any more, I've moved on.

Back around the same timeframe I also learned the Linux Slackware distro, not even sure if that's still maintained these days, pretty sure kernel version was 1.4 or 1.6, it's been a while. I got that system all tweaked out too, x-windows, pretty much every app I needed, didn't game a lot back then, and I generally used Linux more than windows.

Fast forward 15 years.

Win7 is on the horizon and with its 64-bit goodness memory management issues are ancient history, I don't care how much "conventional memory" my computer has free any more and neither do any of my apps.

Can any Linux fanboy out there honestly tell me if I switched to any linux distro that I'd NEVER have to touch a text editor to change any settings for anything OS related? This includes the GUI, networking, drivers, anything related to just making the computer work.

Microsoft has thousands of nerds who are paid to study and figure out how to make the overall system easier to use for everybody, even people who don't want to get their hands dirty in obscure configs.

Linux has thousands of nerds who volunteer to make things and generally work on making things easier for themselves and other nerds. Since the vast majority of these developers feel people should spend more time studying to learn to use their computer better instead of making them spend thousands of hours making the computer easier to learn, then while things may LOOK cool and fast, they require much more complex and convoluted setup. Their answer to improving the end user experience is make the end user more nerdy.

The Linux motto should be "By nerds, for nerds"
 
What drives people away from Linux Desktop is that anyone who sits down and seriously uses it for a week will run into an alarming number of bugs and hard things that shouldn't be difficult.

I don't know who runs QA and Usability at the likes of Fedora / Ubuntu / Mandriva but they all need a lot of improvement after all these years still.
 
I didn't read the meat of the article, but most of the main points made sense. Point #5 can vary wildly though, so it doesn't carry much weight. Other points also vary, but to a lesser extent. Some people may get lucky and get everything working right out of the gate. The rest of the points *are* believable reasons as to why people would just quit using Linux.

Personally, I've checked out Ubuntu a few times over the year, and all I can say is that it "just works." Then I say to myself "Well, that was something different." After that, I go back to Windows. No point in learning a new OS if I won't gain much out of it.
 
Back
Top