Need a UPS. APC or CyberPower?

Status
Not open for further replies.

lodingi

2[H]4U
Joined
Aug 24, 2003
Messages
2,199
Need a UPS for system in my sig. APC & CyberPower are the 2 names I see most. I would appreciate your comments on both brands. I cannot find any comparative reviews. Thanks.
 
If you are looking at line-interactive, simulated sinewave, I'm not sure it really matters that much. Any brand should work fine as long as you get a sufficient real power rating (vs. the apparent power rating they generally advertise). Usually it's about a 55-60% difference. (e.g. a 1500VA UPS can support around 800-900W of power, or a 1000VA can support around 500-600W)

If your going to spend the extra for a good isolating online UPS with full sinewave, then I'd look at spending the extra for the high-end models of APC. But the standard fare low-end you see at staples or whatever aren't much different than any other in my (limited) experience.
 
Last edited:
Thanks for the info. I don't think I need full sinewave. I just want surge protection, AVR & the ability to shut down when the power goes out. Microcenter has several units from both APC & Cyberpower. The Cyberpower is less expensive than the APC but isn't a consideration if the quality is not up to task.
 
You should be able to find a 750VA for around $70. APC Back-UPS or Cyberpower work fine.
 
Go for the APC, I had a Cyberpower and it was crap. It lasted about 2 years. I replaced it with an APC 650 I picked up at Circuit City for about 60 bux over 2 years ago and it shows no signs of slowing down and seems to be underrated powerwise. I have seen people say that they have had their APC for 6-8 years without a battery change. I can virtually guarantee you will not find anyone saying the same for Cybercrapola.
 
APC's consumer UPS units have minimal surge protection. Like a few hundred joules. That's why I went with CyberPower.
 
Have used a Cyberpower 1500VA for two years now. Been through several power outages, set to run 10 min then shuts down PC. Never had a problem with it, and has shown no sign of wear.
 
Go for the APC, I had a Cyberpower and it was crap. It lasted about 2 years. I replaced it with an APC 650 I picked up at Circuit City for about 60 bux over 2 years ago and it shows no signs of slowing down and seems to be underrated powerwise. I have seen people say that they have had their APC for 6-8 years without a battery change. I can virtually guarantee you will not find anyone saying the same for Cybercrapola.
I agree!

I have been using APC almost exclusively for 15yrs+ & with customers & friends have "used" several hundred various BackUps, BackUp-Pro's & Smart BackUps with only about a dozen or so DOA's & ELF's.

Now, Paul is correct, the APC label does appear IMO on some real low-end stuff, but if you stick to the higher-end models, those with at least AVR, you will be very satisfied with your new APC UPS.

Make sure that the UPS's wattage rating is higher than the actual wattage your system uses including monitor(s), modems, routers, etc. anything that you are going to plug in to the battery backed-up outlets. Wattage is important! (Forget about V/A for consumer units.)

If you just want enough time for a controlled shutdown then a "pure sine wave" output is not required, but if you need more time invest in a Smart Back-Up with "pure sine wave" you will thank yourself for years.
 
I had a pcpowercooling 510sli pop on me the other day and when I RMA'd it I told them I had it running on a UPS ( a APC bx1500 865w). They stated that Active PFC power supplys need a pure sine wave output other wise the PSU is going work harder since it thinks the incoming voltage is going up and down a lot and that since the 510sli can take 90-264 volts the avr function is kinda moot.

I hadn't considered the difference when I bought the UPS but I'd either get a pure since wave one in the future or just get a decent line conditioner cause for the money the UPS cost me versus the amount of time I've need it to stay on during a power outage I could have bought more ram or a video card.

Don't get me wrong, if you need to run the system in a power outage or you get a lot of power issues a UPS is great, it is just if you do run on battery a lot you shold get a good one or it can cause premature failure of a PSU.
 
I picked up my refurb SUA750 for $169.99 + ~$30 shipping from ExcessUPS.

About $100 less than new, through newegg.

Arrived in excellent condition, of course new batteries had been installed, and the unit was packed extremely well. I traded e-mails with one of their CS reps before purchase, and he was very helpful in answering a multitude of questions, and was even honest enough to say that the unit in question was probably a bit more than I needed.

I went with it anyway, as 1) I really felt they'd earned the sale, and 2) that price for a true sine unit, with AVR, and USB connectivity, seemed to be a great deal.

It has been in service for a few months now, and has performed perfectly. Where I live, the slightest wind from an approaching storm will have the power flickering every few minutes...not really any significant outages to speak of, just really unstable power in windy weather. That fact alone means I probably didn't need a true sine unit, but, wth, I get about 30 min of runtime out of it while idle or near idle (as of last runtime calibration), and I don't have to worry about actually using it that way should the need ever arise.

This is my first UPS, so I have no way to contrast this unit against any others, all I can say is that it does it's job, and does it well. I didn't buy it for anything operationally critical, just for peace of mind, and I am, so far, completely satisfied.
 
Last edited:
I had a pcpowercooling 510sli pop on me the other day and when I RMA'd it I told them I had it running on a UPS ( a APC bx1500 865w). They stated that Active PFC power supplys need a pure sine wave output other wise the PSU is going work harder since it thinks the incoming voltage is going up and down a lot and that since the 510sli can take 90-264 volts the avr function is kinda moot.

I hadn't considered the difference when I bought the UPS but I'd either get a pure since wave one in the future or just get a decent line conditioner cause for the money the UPS cost me versus the amount of time I've need it to stay on during a power outage I could have bought more ram or a video card.

Don't get me wrong, if you need to run the system in a power outage or you get a lot of power issues a UPS is great, it is just if you do run on battery a lot you shold get a good one or it can cause premature failure of a PSU.
If all you need as long enough for a controlled shutdown, stepped wave/modified sine wave is fine, but if you are going to run on batteries for extended periods of time then you NEED a "pure sine wave" output like the APC Smart BackUps.
 
3 out of 4 of my APC UPS units failed over the last 6 years for problems unrelated to the batteries. The most recent case is an APC Smart UPS 1000 that got a fault and periodically started self testing and bringing the network down. I don't see how Cyberpower could be any worse. If they are then we need a 3rd option.
 
From what I've read over the years in multiple computer and electronic forums, for a computer PSU with an active PFC (which is most any of them except the cheapos) it doesn't matter about pure sine wave versus simulated sinewave. For which either UPS should be fine. If you are going to run something with a traditional electric motor on it you need to consider a true sine wave output device like the Smart APC UPS series. A simulated sine wave will burn up an electric motor (IE sump pump or something), but will be fine for TVs, and computers.

I know two people who bought the 1000 - 1500VA power supplies from CyberPower. The CyberPower units ALL use simulated sine wave. Both CyberPower owners are exceptionally happy. I personally have only used PowerWare, Smart APC, and Belkin UPS units. I'd rate them in that order. I've not had problems with my PowerWare nor Smart APC, but I did have issues with the cheapo Belkin I bought. The PowerWare was definately the best quality and most expensive. Smart APC is APC's upper tier, but it cannot handle as much as the PowerWare even with the nearly the same VA rating. The Belkin I have is a junk model, and constantly overloads, beeps, shuts down etc with even the most basic of PCs.
 
I have only once bought other than APC and ended up very disappointed. Since they have become part of Schneider Electric it seems they have continued with the high quality, but that can always change.
 
I have 2 APC units here. A Back-UPS 500VA that I must have bought at least 6 years ago, and a more expensive ($400 at the time of purchase) Smart-UPS 750VA pure sine wave unit. Both work perfectly. The former has required a few battery changes as you might expect for a UPS that old but the unit itself still functions perfectly during a power outage.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top