Need advice on a i7 940

TheQuestor

Limp Gawd
Joined
Aug 5, 2004
Messages
130
I currently have a i7 920 running rock solid @ 4.0Ghz, it is amazing, but I just got an offer to get a 940 for 200 bucks. What I want to know is if it is worth it. I need to hear from people who actuallly HAVE [no "i heard, or I read crap] one and what they are getting for overclocking. If I can't get at least 4.4Ghz it is simply not worth it to me. Now if you own one and get above 4.4 Stable every day no crashes let me know as I may just upgade today, but if nobody has had nearly as much luck overclocking the 940 as we can our 920's than I'll just keep my known entity and wait a while for the upgrade.

TIa
 
Overclocking should end up around the same point. Another consideration is the cost of the 920 --- if you buy the 940 at $200, what's keeping you from selling the 920 at (throwing this out) $240 and walking away profitable?
 
Overclocking should end up around the same point. Another consideration is the cost of the 920 --- if you buy the 940 at $200, what's keeping you from selling the 920 at (throwing this out) $240 and walking away profitable?

Actually that IS selling the 920 for nearly what I paid for it and getting the 940, but if they end up being about the same then it is not worth my effort. the 920 is working awesome, but I've had it for about 6 months now and I was just hoping the 940 would be a worthy upgrade. May wait now for the 950.
 
The 940 will not help you since you are heat limited, if u had phase or another extreme cooling solution the higher multiplier may come in handy other than that is the same cpu with a higher factory multi and same fabrication process.
 
If all you have to spend is time & effort to remove your current i7 920 and put in the 940, then it's really up to you. The main difference between them is the higher multiplier (22) and 300 MHz more of clock speed.
 
The 940 will not help you since you are heat limited, if u had phase or another extreme cooling solution the higher multiplier may come in handy other than that is the same cpu with a higher factory multi and same fabrication process.

Its water cooled. But I have read too many places where they both top out about the same so it is not worth 200 bucks to me to get the same performance I get now. Now if we were talking the 965 that would be another story all together. But I've only once spent a grand on a cpu [the old 965 EE] and while I was happy with it, I was not happy about the price paid :( So I'll hold on to my old 920 and wait for the next tick instead of the tock.
 
You would be best off getting an i7 920 D0. With water you should easily reach your 4.4GHz goal, possibly even 4.6. If you can hold off a while longer, a 950 would be ideal but it's going to cost $500ish.
 
You would be best off getting an i7 920 D0. With water you should easily reach your 4.4GHz goal, possibly even 4.6. If you can hold off a while longer, a 950 would be ideal but it's going to cost $500ish.

I kind of doubt the D0 will be that much better than my C0. It's not a die shrink or anything, just some un-named optimizations, even if Intel says there are NO changes from C0 to D0 except versioning.
 
I kind of doubt the D0 will be that much better than my C0. It's not a die shrink or anything, just some un-named optimizations, even if Intel says there are NO changes from C0 to D0 except versioning.

Just out of curiosity, what voltage is your 920 set to?
 
If you didn't overclock I would say hell yeah and buy it, but if the i7 940 offers no additional headroom over your current 920 I'd pass and wait for the D0 stepping chips to hit en masse if they offer higher OCs.
 
Just out of curiosity, what voltage is your 920 set to?
my920.jpg

my920-memory.jpg


I left everything stock in the bios except the QPI speeds. The motherboard seems to do the rest quite well on it's own :)
 
I bet there's a reason he's selling so cheap. It's probably a bad chip that won't clock past 3.6-3.8GHz or something.

Plus if it did clock slightly better, I wouldn't pay $200 more just for that. You'd be better off spending that money in the GPU area.
 
Ya, but how much voltage is it giving to your 920. The 940 -might- allow you to run at a lower voltage. But if its 200 + your 920, then no its not worth it. If its 200 and you get to sell your 920, i'd say go for it. I just picked up a new 920 today to replace my dead one. Hopefully it overclocks as well as my last one. Was running at 4.2ghz before.
 
Ya, but how much voltage is it giving to your 920. The 940 -might- allow you to run at a lower voltage. But if its 200 + your 920, then no its not worth it. If its 200 and you get to sell your 920, i'd say go for it. I just picked up a new 920 today to replace my dead one. Hopefully it overclocks as well as my last one. Was running at 4.2ghz before.

I'd be buying the chip new from the Egg, $5xx but selling my 6 month old 940 for about 300 which is what I paid for it. Hence the 200 for the new chip. But I already orded the parts and the 940 wasnt on the list. sigh
 
at 20x it wasn't stable long, so I backed it down to 19x and pumped up the qpi to 210 and it has been a rock every since.

I see. Most people have problems getting their i7 920 stable at 20x. Same CPU frequency but 19x (high BCLK, of course) works fine. I had mine running stable at 4 GHz (20 x 200) for 2 weeks but it required that Hyper-Threading be turned off and needed a CPU Vcore voltage of 1.344v. I lowered it to 3.8 GHz with HT on and it runs at 1.25v. I'd rather have the HT and lower voltage over an added 200 MHz.
 
I was running 21x200 (watercooled) at 1.4v on mine until i killed it last weekend. Not sure how good this new chip is going to clock though. Where do you find the "VID" on these new chips anyway.
 
Back
Top