Top 10 Internet Villains

Terry Olaes

I Used to be the [H] News Guy
2FA
Joined
Nov 27, 2006
Messages
4,646
This list of ten people tech people love to hate is pretty entertaining. From the Hamsterdance creator to Jack Thompson, the article’s authors have some pretty funny quips on why the people on the list belong there.

Some are shrewd businessmen whose tactics have garnered them a long list of enemies. Others are well-meaning individuals whose mistakes earned them the ire of the public, while still others are moral crusaders who don't mind being seen as a heel by the unwashed masses.
 
Well,at least they got it right with the RIAA/MPAA. Thompson's antics though have demoted him from villain to complete joke.
 
Gary Thuerk? Because he sent a mass email, i.e. he CC'd to a ton of people, before the internet was called the internet? This is the sole reason for spam today?? Really trying to throw names around to prove how much of an internet knowledge-dork they are.

How about these two tools who made this list? Or why not the first person who ever made a top10 list on the internet?
 
I could hardly get halfway through this article. It just seemed very poorly written and organized. It hurt my head, :(
 
  1. RIAA/MPAA
  2. Bill Gates
  3. SCO
  4. Gary Thuerk
  5. ECHELON
  6. Jack Thompson
  7. Zango
  8. Mark Zuckerberg
  9. Steve Jobs
  10. Sony BMG

Honorable Mentions
  • Deidre LaCarte
  • Ted "The Tubes" Stevens

Strangely missing from either list is/are the creator(s) of Vundo, Claria Corporation (formerly GATOR), and EA. Oh, and Tom Anderson :D
 
^^^ Damn, forgot to mention that I posted that there for anyone who hates those multi-page lists.
 
^^^ Damn, forgot to mention that I posted that there for anyone who hates those multi-page lists.

Printable version, all on one page, but may prompt to print after it's loaded. Just hit cancel and read:

http://www.vnunet.com/articles/print/2239392

The article has a response/comments section but I don't see any links to see comments that have been posted or approved... so I'm throwing in what I wrote them here:

---

I'd probably arrange the list slightly differently myself, but that nit pick goes ignored for what I consider to be a bit of a fatal flaw in the comments made at the end for the RIAA/MPAA selection at the end.

Quoted: "Let me say right off the bat that theft is wrong. You can't walk into a store and start helping yourself to CDs and DVDs without paying by saying that you have a fast internet connection and so you're entitled to get stuff for free."

Your own argument against the RIAA/MPAA's actions would be strengthened even further if you could distinguish the difference between copyright infringement and theft.

Copyright infringement is not theft. To waltz into a store and steal copies sitting on the shelf, you are removing a physical product from the property of the store itself, if you were to succeed in this moment of criminality. Something is physically lost and has to be manufactured, shipped and restocked again to be replaced.

However, when it comes to copyright infringement... making a copy of an object, or in this case, the data that exists on a physical slab of plastic... that slab of plastic still remains in the hands of whoever made a copy of it. When they send a copy of the data on that slab of plastic, there becomes two copies of it... and again, that slab of plastic STILL remains in the hands of whoever made that first copy of it. When you download, copies do not go missing from store shelves... nor can you directly say that it means that those copies will go unsold because of a download. The culture that we live in today dates further back than people realise: Try before you buy. Reader's Digest. Shareware. In-store demo displays.

When the fat cats running these organizations as a proxy for lawsuits on behalf of the member labels say that each download equals a lost sale, I can easily argue that anyone who downloads an album from The Pirate Bay likely never intended to buy it from the store in the first place. I can also say, albiet only from my own experience and of those I know, that being able to download tracks "for free" has led myself, and others, to go out and purchase legit copies of these releases because we enjoyed them so much. Artists are recognizing the potential for publicity and exposure due to "piracy" and have begun to use it to their advantage. For every Nine Inch Nails, where there is a built in fanbase already well aware of the act, there are hundreds of unknowns who crave this kind of exposure... and have gotten some, due to their open policy of allowing people to sample their works without being called criminals.

Copyright infringement is not theft. If it were, people who have been caught downloading could be arrested. But they can't. Copyright infringement is a civil issue, not a criminal one. Being a pirate, or a mere downloader, two sides of the same coin in all intents and purposes... is not a criminal act no matter how much the RIAA and the MPAA want to make it so.

However, when it comes to the RIAA and MPAA for the type of actions they have taken against their very own customer base... the brief summary of why they're hated is apt, but incomplete. I think it is definitely worth mentioning that the actions that they have taken in the legal system blatantly reeks of extortion. So much that motions and counter claims accusing them of violating the RICO Act has actually gotten serious attention. The real criminals are the fronts, called the RIAA and MPAA, for how they have abused the legal system and their very own customers.
 
Some of the articles sound like envy and more FUD feeding than anything. Regarding Bill Gates:

Iain Thomson said:
Bill's charitable work is redeeming his reputation in my eyes, but his sins are many.

Leaving aside the dog that is Windows Vista, Bill's tactics have caused some serious harm to certain areas of the industry. Browser development is a case in point. Once Internet Explorer had achieved a near monopoly it stopped being something Microsoft concentrated on and languished for years. This allowed malware writers to target it with great effect.

The dog that is Vista? They're still writing articles against Vista on tech sites? Browser monopoly?
 
Some of the articles sound like envy and more FUD feeding than anything. Regarding Bill Gates:



The dog that is Vista? They're still writing articles against Vista on tech sites? Browser monopoly?

The whole article was obviously written by Linux fanatics.

I'm pretty sure when they do their follow up "heroes" list Torvalds is number 1
 
Back
Top