Battery That 'Charges in Seconds'


[prick]The energy released through nuclear fission (or even simply burning gasoline) was stored in that form at an earlier time. It ultimately took more energy to create the fissionable material (or, in my example, gasoline) than you actually get out of it.[/prick]

He obviously just means that you can't have a perpetual motion machine.
 
You're absolutely correct. It's yet to be performed by us in a controlled manner. Like you said, it takes more energy than it outputs...

However many recent advances have us coming closer to that goal though.

I'm also not as convinced as you are that he wasn't literal that ANYTHING can't output more than what puts into it.
 
Meantime, back in reality land.

To fullfill the desire to make a practical electric car, that performs and behaves like a car will require ....

200 KWH's of power

... to achieve a 400 mile range, and further it needs to at a maximum be chargable in 10 minutes to come close to satisfying the average consumer.
Just to continue on this train, the Tesla Roadster apparently has a capacity of 53 kWh and a range of 244 miles.

Now if you want to continue with the american way of life and have his behemoth of a SUV that's all electric, then yeah you'd probably need more juice to get the range you want.
 
You're absolutely correct. It's yet to be performed by us in a controlled manner. Like you said, it takes more energy than it outputs...
Is sounds like you're referring to nuclear fusion. The same issue applies, during fusion two atoms form a larger atom of lighter mass and the leftover matter is released as energy. The energy doesn't come out of nowhere, it was "stored" as matter.
 
Why go here? Why don't you just go to the wiki page for a piece of wood? I mean there's no energy there right? You put a small match to it and you get so much more energy out of it than you put in!!
The guy's a moron. I just had to post something, so I posted the most extreme example I could think of.
Wood eventually burns out, a Fission Reactor is a self-sustaining chain reaction.

Is sounds like you're referring to nuclear fusion. The same issue applies, during fusion two atoms form a larger atom of lighter mass and the leftover matter is released as energy. The energy doesn't come out of nowhere, it was "stored" as matter.

I'm not a nuclear chemist smart enough to know all the minor details, but I do know they are close enough related that they are both in play with what I'm referencing.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Natural_nuclear_fission_reactor
 
Look, this is stupid. YOU CAN'T GENERATE MORE ENERGY THAN YOU PUT IN. IT IS IMPOSSIBLE. WE LIVE IN AN IMPERFECT WORLD WITH FRICTION.

Yes, you can make things very efficient, but you CANNOT make something that perpetually recharges itself.

YES YUO CAN!! I patented a spankterbation engine that gets 20 mile per porno. Whee!!

[/throws gas on fire]
 
The guy's a moron. I just had to post something, so I posted the most extreme example I could think of.
Wood eventually burns out, a Fission Reactor is a self-sustaining chain reaction.

Until you run out of fissionable material. Its self sustaining, but not limitless. The wood argument is correct.

In theory with the right conditions you could build a system that ran perpetually, but in reality you're always going to lose some energy because we can't transmit energy without resistance.
 
hydrogen fuel cells is what we will be using. yeah yeah yeah i know it takes energy to isolate hydrogen so in essence its not a fuel source its more like a battery but so what? theyre going to work, we will find ways to isolate hydrogen efficiently on massive scales, and unless battery technology can increase dramatically i dont think you can do any better then a hydrogen fuel cell
 
Until you run out of fissionable material. Its self sustaining, but not limitless. The wood argument is correct.

In theory with the right conditions you could build a system that ran perpetually, but in reality you're always going to lose some energy because we can't transmit energy without resistance.

True, like I said, we haven't perfected it yet.
A hundred years ago people would never have thought we'd be on the moon, either.
Never say never.
 
sf, like I said, "the average consumer" wants. They dont want a 1400 lb 2 seat sports zippy. They want a minivan/suv/passenger car that carries the kids and the groceries, etc.

To know how much energy is needed as a starting point, take the BTU content of a gallon of 87 octane gas, and see how much a 20 MPG vehicle uses going 400 miles (ie: 20 gallons of gasoline contains).

From there, start working out how much energy can be reclaimed by true regenerative braking (ELECTRIC BRAKES) and the fact that electric motor to mechanical energy conversion is also more efficient than gas-to-mechanical conversion in our cars.

So it is somewhere between 100 and 200 KWH's of energy stored and accessible to get the job done. And it will require something that can be charged in 10 minutes from 0 to 200 KWHs of energy storage.

The weight and size of the cars/etc is dictated more by safety systems and the uses people put the vehicle to, than what we might wish we could build. Though mass production carbon fiber, pioneered by GM with the ZR1 may get significant weight out without compromise down the road.

*****

On the nuclear fusion issue. The next breakthrough is how to make the laser fired reaction continuous. There may be a way, using geometry, and a combustion chamber that is an elipsoid, the inner surface of which reflects xrays and gammarays.

The fuel pellet is injected and zapped from a high power laser, but the xray/gammaray output is then reflected inside the chamber, and as math wizzes know 100% of the enrgy bounces around and passes through the FOCII of the elipsoid. By injecting fuel at the focii, the high energy of the ongoing fusion reaction, will be concentrated to ignite the next particle of fuel, rinse/repeat. It may be possible to sustain a continuous reaction that feeds off its own energy that way.

The containment would reflect the xrays and gammarays, but allow the infrared and other radiationand particles from the reaction to be absorbed by the material which is then cooled by liquid sodium circulating around the outside of the containment, which in turn heats water to steam and viola... useful electricity can be produced.

You have a continuous stream of dueturium/tritium plasma being fired into the target focii, and as the energy focused at the focii ignites it, burn baby burn.

WORSE... now design the containment so that one of the focii is on the surface of the ellipsoid, with a shutter, and if opened, the xray/gammaray energy of the ongoing fusion reaction is allowed to leave..... and a PHASER is born. :eek::rolleyes::p

Just remember you heard it hear first. :cool:
 
True, like I said, we haven't perfected it yet.
A hundred years ago people would never have thought we'd be on the moon, either.
Never say never.

The universe disagrees with you, stars have been making energy via fusion for longer than Earth has been a planet, they don't last forever. Fission doesn't last forever for the same reason, you get energy out of fission by things splitting up into smaller things, eventually you'll run out of things that give energy when they split up.
 
The universe disagrees with you, stars have been making energy via fusion for longer than Earth has been a planet, they don't last forever. Fission doesn't last forever for the same reason, you get energy out of fission by things splitting up into smaller things, eventually you'll run out of things that give energy when they split up.

Thank goodness we can build multiple reactors :rolleyes:
 
To know how much energy is needed as a starting point, take the BTU content of a gallon of 87 octane gas, and see how much a 20 MPG vehicle uses going 400 miles (ie: 20 gallons of gasoline contains).
114100 BTU/gallon http://www.nafa.org/Content/Navigat...els/Energy_Equivalents/Energy_Equivalents.htm

So it is somewhere between 100 and 200 KWH's of energy stored and accessible to get the job done. And it will require something that can be charged in 10 minutes from 0 to 200 KWHs of energy storage.
20 Gallons x 114100BTU/Gallon / 3140BTU/kWh = 726.8kWh

I don't have credible figures for the actual efficiencies of gas cars vs electric cars, and I don't like to use speculative figures, so I can't correct that figure for the difference in mechanical efficiencies between gas and electric cars, but I'd expect your figure of 100 to 200 to be a little higher than necessary, assuming the electric powertrain was replacing a gasoline one capable of 20MPG on 20 gallons. If someone can correct that, I look forward to that info.

Where does your "must charge in 10 minutes" figure come from? Going with the 200kWh battery figure, in ten minutes, that's a 1200kW rate of charge. That's an insane rate of charge. Even if a battery can take it, where's that charge going to come from, that fast?
 
114100 BTU/gallon http://www.nafa.org/Content/Navigat...els/Energy_Equivalents/Energy_Equivalents.htm


20 Gallons x 114100BTU/Gallon / 3140BTU/kWh = 726.8kWh

I don't have credible figures for the actual efficiencies of gas cars vs electric cars, and I don't like to use speculative figures, so I can't correct that figure for the difference in mechanical efficiencies between gas and electric cars, but I'd expect your figure of 100 to 200 to be a little higher than necessary, assuming the electric powertrain was replacing a gasoline one capable of 20MPG on 20 gallons. If someone can correct that, I look forward to that info.

Where does your "must charge in 10 minutes" figure come from? Going with the 200kWh battery figure, in ten minutes, that's a 1200kW rate of charge. That's an insane rate of charge. Even if a battery can take it, where's that charge going to come from, that fast?

The ten minutes is probably from refuling.
On a long trip I can drive 400 miles, pull into a station and about 10 minutes later be back on the road.
With two people driving and not stopping to sleep you could cover 1500+ miles a day without speeding.
 

:rolleyes:
They are trying to get more energy out of the reaction than it takes to maintain it.
That is not the same as you keep saying.

The mass being turned into energy was created at some point by proccesses before we exhisted.
Those procceses required energy.
We didn't have to provide that energy.
That's the only reason we get useful work out of those reactions.
Just like burning wood or gasoline.


Hydrogen fuel cells are considered energy storage, not an energy source.
Why?
Because we have to expend the energy to create the hydrogen.
 
The Dept of Transportation has the figures. Internal combustion engine cars get about 30% efficiency, so about 200 KWH of that 768 KWH is what is actually done as work.

Electric motor conversion is alot more efficient. I did the math once and came out with 186 KWH to make a 3800LB minivan/suv type vehicle, say a RAV4, have a 400 mile range.

Yes, 10 minutes is about the limit of peoples tolerence for a pull in and refuel at the gas station, more than that would be annoying. I'm just pointing out that getting PRACTICAL acceptence of a plug in electric car as THE replacement ultimately will require getting close to certain parameters.... others like acceleration in the 5-10sec 0-60 range, and 100MPH top speed min, and good handling, etc. Nice thing about an electric car is how easy AWD is to do, as well as ABS and traction control.

If it weren't for the charging/output limitations, a correctly made battery today could get close to being realistic. The Tesla uses off the shelf AA batteries, if you think abiout the packaging compromise that results in, in both weight and volumetric efficiency, you can see the same volume of purpose built battery could hold 2X the energy of what they are using now. Think about all that unnessecary AA battery packaging and the weight of it all, instead of a solid battery entirely using that volume with LiION storage.
 
Isn't this the whole point of the GM Volt? Charge overnight for those average 40 miles or less most people drive in a day and a small gas generator under the hood when you need to go further than that. You use the batteries most of the time without having to wait for them to recharge for long trips and no range anxiety.
 
I remember a super engine that was as powerful as the engines used in 18 wheeler trucks a year or so ago, which could be adapted to run on compressed air...that looked amazing too...not seen it since. *sigh* I do wish these technologies always worked their way into the mainstream, life would be much cooler that way :D
 
The ten minutes is probably from refuling.
On a long trip I can drive 400 miles, pull into a station and about 10 minutes later be back on the road.
With two people driving and not stopping to sleep you could cover 1500+ miles a day without speeding.
I get the point of "road-trip refueling", the thing is, that represents a very tiny fraction of vehicle usage. For example, in the past 2 years, I have, twice, traveled beyond the range of a single tank of fuel in a day. If I had an electric vehicle, which required overnight charge, and had 400 mile range, in 2 years I could use it for everything except those two road trips. For the price of electric energy, I could have rented a gas car for those two trips, and still had very substantial savings of driving expenses, IF (recognize, this is big if) the electic car could be sold for a price comparable to it's gasoline counterpart.

xX_Jack_Carver_Xx- Do you have a link to those figures? I'd like to read them, and how they arrived at them. My understanding is that internal combustion engines are, at best, 30% efficient. A gasoline ICE is most efficient at mid to lower rpm, with a wide, but not full throttle opening. Highway crusing conditions do not represent an ICE running at it's maximum efficiency, thus I think the actual energy efficiency of a gasoline engine, as observed in a vehicle, under highway conditions, is actually less than that 30% figure
 
Back
Top