Apple Sued for iMac Display Vertical Line Problem

Terry Olaes

I Used to be the [H] News Guy
2FA
Joined
Nov 27, 2006
Messages
4,646
Apple has been busy in courts this past week. On the same day the iPod Touch suit was filed, another lawsuit was submitted alleging that Apple defrauded iMac purchasers by knowingly selling defective systems. This suit revolves around the infamous iMac LCD vertical line issue and is seeking class-action status.

Apple is not only said to have been violating California's Business & Professional and Commercial Codes by failing to properly test the displays, and therefore knowingly selling defective systems, but of unfairly skewing its warranty terms to evade repairing or replacing the iMacs out of its own pocket.
 
I checked out that vertical line problem, and if that is truly common, then I definitely hope Apple looses the case.
 
How can this be?
Problems with Apple products?
Tell me it can't be so.
The end of the world is nigh!
[/end sarcasm]

So I guess this means there might be some flaw in the thinking of "Apple, it just works", huh?

:cool:
 
You'd think Apple would eventually realize that dumping whatever money they need to into fixing these issues would benefit them in the long term. If they can avoid lawsuits and bad press over what is seemingly a "minor" issue by investing more resources into quality control and by honoring system warranties, why wouldn't they do it? It just seems like good business to me.

I've always felt like these types of incidents have the potential to severely damage Apple's image, and since a good part of Apple's business seems to revolve around the company's "shining" image, letting this stuff slip through the cracks just doesn't make any sense. If people lose faith in Apple's ability to ship good products, what then?
 
How can this be?
Problems with Apple products?
Tell me it can't be so.
The end of the world is nigh!
[/end sarcasm]

So I guess this means there might be some flaw in the thinking of "Apple, it just works", huh?

:cool:

This. I hope apple looses :D
 
I checked out that vertical line problem, and if that is truly common, then I definitely hope Apple looses the case.

More than just common: Expected. It's been an issue plaguing their various Powermacs, iBooks, MacBooks and such. Apple just can't seem to make a system build that doesn't involve the display fucking up some time down the line.
 
I find it interesting that according to Consumer Reports and PC Magazine etc Apple users are the happiest with reliability and service. I have one of these exact models sitting on my desk at work that I use for video editing. If the screen did this and then Apple told me to screw off I would not be rating them top notch on any survey. In their defense, my screen works fine after a couple years and literally everyone that walks by my area comments on how amazing the screen looks on the IMac.
 
You'd think Apple would eventually realize that dumping whatever money they need to into fixing these issues would benefit them in the long term. If they can avoid lawsuits and bad press over what is seemingly a "minor" issue by investing more resources into quality control and by honoring system warranties, why wouldn't they do it? It just seems like good business to me.

I've always felt like these types of incidents have the potential to severely damage Apple's image, and since a good part of Apple's business seems to revolve around the company's "shining" image, letting this stuff slip through the cracks just doesn't make any sense. If people lose faith in Apple's ability to ship good products, what then?



Yeah I agree with you, if Apple doesn't start to deal with this head on it will catch up to them and cost them dearly down the road.
 
So many problems, design flaws and just plain defective hardware yet iDiots around the world still claim that Apple hardware is of much better quality than the competition :confused:

Never had any lines, visual artifacts, explosions etc. from my noname mp3 players, BenQ and Samsung LCDs, home built PCs, Acer and HP laptops etc... ;)
 
was there a class action suit against nvidia for the 8400/8600 mobile gpus?
 
Is it me or is Apple users sue happy? As far as users go it seems to me that Apple users are the most sue happy bunch of any user base out there? Some of the lawsuits are warrented, but it also seems alot of them are not. Sueing because the price of something drops after you purchased it, You dont see Xbox users sueing because the price of the Xbox has dropped to 1/2 its original price, price drops in electronics are expected, or at least they should be.

Now this lawsuit because of defective screens seems legit to me.
 
Is it me or is Apple users sue happy? As far as users go it seems to me that Apple users are the most sue happy bunch of any user base out there? Some of the lawsuits are warrented, but it also seems alot of them are not. Sueing because the price of something drops after you purchased it, You dont see Xbox users sueing because the price of the Xbox has dropped to 1/2 its original price, price drops in electronics are expected, or at least they should be.

Now this lawsuit because of defective screens seems legit to me.

Not anymore sue happy than the rest of the American population is. :p
 
I find it interesting that according to Consumer Reports and PC Magazine etc Apple users are the happiest with reliability and service*

* Of those who responded.

We're already well of the very vocal minority of obnoxious fanboys.
 
Read the article since I was worried that it was an issue with my model. Apparently it is an issue with the old 17" G5 iMacs, so mine is way in the clear. Either way, Apple really needs to take care of this, especially if these cases were reported within the warranty period and the customer was told to screw off.

In their defense, my screen works fine after a couple years and literally everyone that walks by my area comments on how amazing the screen looks on the IMac.

Yeah, I had a 23" ACD for five years and it was perfect the whole time I had it. The display on my current 24" iMac is awesome, beaten only by the $1100 24" NEC 2490WUXi I have sitting next to it.
 
Yeah I agree with you, if Apple doesn't start to deal with this head on it will catch up to them and cost them dearly down the road.

As long as Apple is the under dog, these issues will not affect their sales and overall "coolness" Apple in the "little guy" we all want to see win. Once they get there, people will jump ship quick.
Most of the Mac users I had to deal with at my last job, liked Macs because they were "unique" and it made the user "stand out".
 
Back
Top