Inside The New iPod Shuffle

How Apple gets away with it is beyond me. They've got a bigger monopoly on their market than Microsoft does.

How so? Apple's share of the mp3 market is around 70%. Microsoft's share of the OS market is around 90%.
 
Because the iPod shuffle earbuds that came with the iPod shuffle he just bought last night work perfectly with the iPhone he bought last year, perhaps? They control the audio playback and volume just like the ety hf2 set does on his iPhone, so why won't the hf2 control the shuffle? See how that works?

You look at the 4 conductor plug on both sets of earbuds/IEMs, you figure hey, they both control volume, they both do the click/click-click/click-click-click control thing, they should both work on either device.

"Ehhh... sorry, wrong answer."

Or didn't you get the memo?
 
Thats a little ridiculous. Why on earth would be buy one when it is CLEAR that you can't control it without the OEM earbuds....
I haven't seen a retail package yet... But do you seriously think Apple will stamp "Not compatible with third-party headphones" right on the package? I highly doubt it.

Parents, Grandparents, Uncles and Aunts will all see this on the shelves and buy it. A very slim minority actually do research on stuff they buy.

How so? Apple's share of the mp3 market is around 70%. Microsoft's share of the OS market is around 90%.
What the public wants to buy is different.
People buy Windows because it's widely supported. They aren't being forced to use Microsoft mice and Microsoft keyboards though.
If they don't want Windows, they can either buy a Ubuntu machine from Dell or install Ubuntu after the fact. Having choices is a wonderful thing.
Windows is not tied to the hardware. It's just software, that's all it is. And you can install any other software on that hardware as you see fit.

Apple pretty much just forces people into using iPods again and again. Unless you own all the MP3s, once you have your iTunes setup, you're pretty much locked into it.
Add to this now the third-party accessories that it's apparent Apple wants control over.
 
Apple pretty much just forces people into using iPods again and again.

That's a ludicrous argument. People are free to switch to another media player anytime they want. Just as people are free to switch to another OS anytime they want. You claim people can't transfer some of their music if they switch... well guess what you switch OSes and you can't transfer your software.... Where was your argument again?
 
Because the iPod shuffle earbuds that came with the iPod shuffle he just bought last night work perfectly with the iPhone he bought last year, perhaps?

After reading that... This fits in perfectly with everything else Apple does, I don't know why I'm a little bit surprised at it.

If you want the newest products from Apple, you'll have to spend money on it.

Good example is the original Zunes. Microsoft, when the Zune v2 came out, released a firmware upgrade for all the original Zunes that gave almost all of the functionality of Zune v2.... FOR FREE. Only exceptions is the hardware limitations.

If you want new features with Apple, you're going to have to buy a whole new device.

So it fits along perfectly with their standing philosophy: Cater to the Cult, and they'll keep buying.
 
That's a ludicrous argument. People are free to switch to another media player anytime they want.
And lose all their DRM-infested media that iTunes provides.
Most people I know spend a ton of money on music... Buying just about everything new.

You're telling me they are going to switch to a different device and lose hundreds of dollars in music?

Fat chance.

This is my point. They'll continue buying iPods because they won't lose it, and it's just the easier thing to do.
Which reminds me, that sounds exactly like what people with more money than sense do.

You claim people can't transfer some of their music if they switch... well guess what you switch OSes and you can't transfer your software.... Where was your argument again?
I don't know what planet you're living on, but most documents and data files nowadays are cross-platform.
 
TO add to the point above, if anything using your "argument" Microsoft has a bigger monopoly because it forces people to stay with Windows because that's the platform most software is developed for. If you want to continue using your software, in most cases, you HAVE to use Windows, there is no other option.
 
I don't know what planet you're living on, but most documents and data files nowadays are cross-platform.

Do I really need to explain the difference between data and software to you? Or are you just trying to change your argument? :rolleyes:
 
Do I really need to explain the difference between data and software to you? Or are you just trying to change your argument? :rolleyes:
Apparently I need to explain it to you.

What did I say? I noted two things: documents and data files.

That's data.

Photoshop, is a program.

You mentioned switching OS and transferring your software. If you had half a shits knowledge about anything in the OS world, you know you can't do that. Even going from XP to XP, you can't just copy the damn program over.
You look at a reinstall each time you assign software to a new system. You're whole point there is invalid.

As I said, Documents and Data files are cross-platform. Let me give you two examples of programs:
Microsoft Office
Adobe CS4

Both exist on Mac. Both exist on PC.
And guess what? The data files created by each of them... ARE COMPATIBLE!!!


Your argument is rather null in the fact that if you switch platforms or machines, your data is able to follow you around.


And note, I am not talking about propriety business applications or any other propriety application. I'm talking about Average Joe end-user here.

Add to this, guess what??? Most of the time, alternative software exists for each platform!

TO add to the point above, if anything using your "argument" Microsoft has a bigger monopoly because it forces people to stay with Windows because that's the platform most software is developed for.
The difference is that Microsoft doesn't have a piece of DRM software inside Windows that says you can only run Microsoft software.
THAT'S THE DIFFERENCE. I really don't understand how such a simple concept can be so hard to grasp.
 
The difference is that Microsoft doesn't have a piece of DRM software inside Windows that says you can only run Microsoft software.

Funny enough... that's why Microsoft was getting sued, because they were trying to do just that, it just wasn't called DRM.

The rest of your points are moot. 90% of software is Windows only. No company is going spend thousands of dollars retraining it's employees to use software alternatives.
 
If you want new features with Apple, you're going to have to buy a whole new device.
Like the iPod touch 2.0 update, right? iPod touch users only had to pay $10 to update to the new 2.0 touch OS. The same applies to the current version (2.2). New features -- no new hardware.

And lose all their DRM-infested media that iTunes provides.
Frankly, if you don't know how to strip FairPlay from your media files, you probably don't need to be buying $200+ iPods.
 
Been doing that kind of stuff for decades... simple swap job, not a big hassle. No not everyone can do it, but that's why people that can't know people like me that can. ;)
 
As has been noted, there are better DAPs for the cost, seriously better ones, in all possible ways. Just because it's small doesn't mean it's a good thing... :)

I went back and re-read that review iLounge did and they're just spot on about it. Damned shame I suppose, but... too late now, Apple. And yes, we all know they're selling these shuffles like they're going outta style.

So much for brains... ;)
 
iPod touch users only had to pay $10 to update to the new 2.0 touch OS.
$10 or free..... hmmmm... I'll take the free one, thank you very much.
It's a freaking asinine thing to do in this economy to suggest that spending $10 on firmware is better than free. Especially when it costs the company nothing to do it because they've already gotten it written for other products!
Hell, there's even a thing called Consumer Goodwill that Apple apparently threw out the window a long time ago.

Frankly, if you don't know how to strip FairPlay from your media files, you probably don't need to be buying $200+ iPods.
Frankly, the iPod is known and marketed for its easy-to-use package.
So now you're saying the iPod is aimed at a different market?


Funny enough... that's why Microsoft was getting sued, because they were trying to do just that, it just wasn't called DRM.
Microsoft is getting sued for INCLUDING Internet Explorer. It's no different than them getting sued for INCLUDING Task Manager. It's just frivolous.

Apple goes a huge step beyond that and outright ELIMINATES THE POSSIBILITY of third-parties.

A gradeschooler could grasp this concept, honestly.

The rest of your points are moot. 90% of software is Windows only. No company is going spend thousands of dollars retraining it's employees to use software alternatives.
How the hell daft are you? Did you not miss not only my note here:
I am not talking about propriety business applications
And also happened to miss the one here:
I'm talking about Average Joe end-user here.
????
A gradeschooler would have better reading comprehension.

And until businesses start issuing iPods as standard equipment across the board like they do Windows machines, you're argument is in two totally different realms. Business does not equal Average Joe Consumer.
 
For anyone interested in some great new (and future) alternatives...

Cowon S9 is a great touch-based player. Sound player is vastly superior to Apple (although that isn't saying much), but it does lack WiFi/Web Browsing.
The AMOLED display on this is AMAZING. Beats the pants off the iPhone/iPod. Battery life is great too.

Samsung P3 is another great one. Fantastic device with haptic feedback, bluetooth, and flash. Lacks an accelerometer but has an on-board speaker.

While I haven't seen much info on the Sony X1000 yet, it sounds like a high quality player that'll come out later this year... That has just about everything the iPod Touch does, but higher quality sound (That's one thing Sony can still do correctly... audio).
 
Samsung P3 is another great one. Fantastic device with haptic feedback, bluetooth, and flash. Lacks an accelerometer but has an on-board speaker.

The P3 looks interesting, I have been looking for a player with a speaker for work.

Why would anyone in the tech fields buy anything from Apple? They pull this proprietary crap all the time.

I can see the non-techie sheep buying in but I always go for substance over style any day.
 
Microsoft is getting sued for INCLUDING Internet Explorer. It's no different than them getting sued for INCLUDING Task Manager. It's just frivolous.

Uh no. They were violating anti-trust laws by trying to stifle competition by heavily integrating THEIR browser into Windows.


I am not talking about propriety business applications

I'm talking about Average Joe end-user here.

Oh I get it, so when you're concluding which has a bigger monopoly over their market, you included the majority of Apple's market but only half of Microsofts'. Yeah, that makes complete sense... :rolleyes:
 
Uh no. They were violating anti-trust laws by trying to stifle competition by heavily integrating THEIR browser into Windows.






Oh I get it, so when you're concluding which has a bigger monopoly over their market, you included the majority of Apple's market but only half of Microsofts'. Yeah, that makes complete sense... :rolleyes:

And how are the supposed to operate? Not include a browser so you can't go online?

People like you who bitch and moan over the littlest things annoy me. Go bitch at Apple for only including Safari and Linux for only including Firefox.

Or grow balls, quit whining, and download another browser.
 
And how are the supposed to operate? Not include a browser so you can't go online?

There's a huge difference between including a browser and integrating a browser into the OS shell. Try to know what you're talking about before you speak next time.
 
There's a huge difference between including a browser and integrating a browser into the OS shell. Try to know what you're talking about before you speak next time.

It's THEIR OS. It doesn't stiffle competition. BROWSERS ARE FREE. What is the problem again?
 
Uh no. They were violating anti-trust laws by trying to stifle competition by heavily integrating THEIR browser into Windows.
That's exactly what I said. You're just splitting hairs here... They were sued for including IE. No matter what way you word it, that's what it comes down to.


Oh I get it, so when you're concluding which has a bigger monopoly over their market, you included the majority of Apple's market but only half of Microsofts'. Yeah, that makes complete sense... :rolleyes:
You're comparing a fucking PERSONAL market (MP3 Players) to a business market with Windows.
Yea... that makes sense :rolleyes:

Neither am I.
Bullshit.
No company is going spend thousands of dollars retraining it's employees to use software alternatives.
I don't know what the hell version of English you're using, but "Company" pretty much is parallel to "Business" in my world.

There's a huge difference between including a browser and integrating a browser into the OS shell. Try to know what you're talking about before you speak next time.
IE hasn't been integrated with the "shell" since IE7 in XP.
Try to know what you're talking about before you speak next time.
 
That's exactly what I said. You're just splitting hairs here... They were sued for including IE. No matter what way you word it, that's what it comes down to.

No it's not. They weren't sued for including IE, they were sued for the intergration of IE into Windows. HUGE difference and it's the reason why they were forced to unlace it from Windows.

I don't know what the hell version of English you're using, but "Company" pretty much is parallel to "Business" in my world.

I'm not talking about proprietary software. I'm talking about consumer level software. 90% of it is Windows only, which forces you to stay on Windows unless you want to spend the time relearn new software or spending money training your employees to relearn it. Makes no difference, if it's personal or business, the concept is the same.


IE hasn't been integrated with the "shell" since IE7 in XP.

Which is the result of the case I've been talking about.
 
It's a freaking asinine thing to do in this economy to suggest that spending $10 on firmware is better than free.
Who suggested that? Putting words in my mouth, are we? Tisk, tisk.

All I did was merely inform you that Apple doesn't always make you purchase new hardware to gain new features, which is precisely what you suggested (erroneously) that they do. That's all I did.

Frankly, the iPod is known and marketed for its easy-to-use package. So now you're saying the iPod is aimed at a different market?
I'm saying that if you, as an iPod owner, can't figure out how to strip FairPlay from your protected files, you're a fuckin' idiot. That's what I'm saying :)

Even if you're too inept figure out that crazy Google voodoo magic, Jobs himself has described a way in which you can remove the copy protection by burning CDs and then re-ripping them in one of his open letters posted to apple.com. Suffice to say you never have to lose any of your protected files if you don't want to.
 
No it's not. They weren't sued for including IE, they were sued for the intergration of IE into Windows. HUGE difference and it's the reason why they were forced to unlace it from Windows.
Which is the result of the case I've been talking about.
It'd really be one thing if you would've said that from the beginning, however it's not such a case.
You blatantly made the statement that IE is still tied to the "shell".


I'm not talking about proprietary software. I'm talking about consumer level software. 90% of it is Windows only, which forces you to stay on Windows unless you want to spend the time relearn new software or spending money training your employees to relearn it. Makes no difference, if it's personal or business, the concept is the same.
80% of the MP3 player market is iPod only, which forces you to stay on iTunes unless you want to spend the time to relearn new software or spending money training your employees to relearn it.


Works both ways, bub.

The difference (AGAIN!!!) is that Apple takes it a step further and dictates the hardware as well as the software.






Who suggested that? Putting words in my mouth, are we? Tisk, tisk.

All I did was merely inform you that Apple doesn't always make you purchase new hardware to gain new features, which is precisely what you suggested (erroneously) that they do. That's all I did.


I'm saying that if you, as an iPod owner, can't figure out how to strip FairPlay from your protected files, you're a fuckin' idiot. That's what I'm saying :)

Even if you're too inept figure out that crazy Google voodoo magic, Jobs himself has described a way in which you can remove the copy protection by burning CDs and then re-ripping them in one of his open letters posted to apple.com. Suffice to say you never have to lose any of your protected files if you don't want to.

Like the iPod touch 2.0 update, right? iPod touch users only had to pay $10 to update to the new 2.0 touch OS. The same applies to the current version (2.2). New features -- no new hardware.


Frankly, if you don't know how to strip FairPlay from your media files, you probably don't need to be buying $200+ iPods.
 
Darn lack of edit...
All I did was merely inform you that Apple doesn't always make you purchase new hardware to gain new features, which is precisely what you suggested (erroneously) that they do. That's all I did.
OK, fair enough.
I think my point is still valid by a bit though. Microsoft automatically gave everyone new features, and Apple isn't showing such goodwill.

I'm saying that if you, as an iPod owner, can't figure out how to strip FairPlay from your protected files, you're a fuckin' idiot. That's what I'm saying :)
According to your prior post, you said you shouldn't get an iPod in the first place:
Frankly, if you don't know how to strip FairPlay from your media files, you probably don't need to be buying $200+ iPods.
 
You're taking being pedantic to an entirely new level. Kudos. (why isn't "pedanticism" a word?)

Well, fair enough then. I'll "officially" retract my first statement and put forth a newly-reworded statement so you can get your hard-on back:
Frankly, if you don't know how to strip FairPlay from your media files, you're a fuckin' idiot, and you probably don't need to be buying $200+ iPods.

I actually thought I implied something fairly obvious there the first time, but I guess obvious things are sometimes not so obvious to certain folk. My mistake :)
 
Back
Top