Just how safe/reliable is WHS?

MrCrispy

2[H]4U
Joined
May 14, 2007
Messages
4,001
I keep thinking about WHS for my growing storage needs, but every time I read stuff on the various forums about how you can't trust folder duplication to keep your data safe, and that backing up WHS shares to external media is essential. Even MS recommend this.

If that's true, then WHS becomes just another high availability solution, like RAID+JBOD, and not a substitute for backups (ignoring stuff like remote access and pc backups for the time being).

Do you agree?
 
I don't think RAID nor WHS was ever intended as a backup... That is, in a practical sense. RAID surely was never intended to be a true backup.
 
I agree. I'm asking if people who have experience with WHS recommend turning on folder duplication. If it doesn't keep data safe then I don't see the point in it, and its the biggest feature of WHS.
 
I do run a 4TB WHS box but I don't use duplication. Most of what I use it for is media which to me isn't life ending if I lose it.

At the end of the day though, if you want some piece of mind you might as well turn it on. Its better than nothing.
 
My 12tb WHS has duplication on for all my important stuff, and off for my digitized DVD collection. If it disapears, I can always re-create it.

I have had a HD fail (yay Seagate) but did not loose anything as only dupicated shares were stored on it.


Edit:
I forgot - In addition to the duplication being turned on for the imporant stuff, I also sync the important stuff offsite. It goes without saying that RAID is no replacement for offsite or unattached duplication, which is why I failed to mention it previously.
 
Hmm, I've always looked at WHS, and in fact any file server running RAID, as being for high availability of data and not backup. Backup, to me at least, is storing critical data on a different medium and preferrably in a different location. That is coming from someone working as a systems admin. I don't consider any of our data backed up until it is on tape and at an off-site location.

Of course, our company has recently decided to move to a SAN storage for "backup" and I keep trying to tell them that the data isn't really safe until it leaves the site :rolleyes: Everyone just looks at it and says "as long as it is backed up on another storage/server it is a backup" even though it is in the same server room and subject to the same loss if we have a fire or the sprinklers go off...

Personally, I use my WHS system to store all my data and turn duplication on for the important stuff. Documents/photos/home videos etc. are backed up nightly to an external USB drive and weekly to a DLT 80 GB tape drive on Sunday night and take the tapes with me to work on Monday for the week. Once a month I try to burn the document files to DVD and store them in a fire safe... I'm just waiting for Blue-ray to get to a price point that I feel I can afford to upgrade. My wife also uploads all the photos to some photo site (she used to use Photoworks, not sure what she uses now). That may be a little overboard, but after losing photos not once but twice (and having to download them one at a time from Photoworks) I'm a little paranoid :)
 
I keep thinking about WHS for my growing storage needs, but every time I read stuff on the various forums about how you can't trust folder duplication to keep your data safe

Where are you reading this?

Is this purely in the context of RAID vs. WHS's DE and are they "backups", or are you aware of an actual issue?
 
[LYL]Homer;1033828343 said:
Where are you reading this?

Is this purely in the context of RAID vs. WHS's DE and are they "backups", or are you aware of an actual issue?

I believe it's just the way everyone thought before they actually experienced WHS, that there's no software solution that can replace a $1000 hardware raid card. I know I was guilty of thinking that before I decided to give WHS a shot.
 
I should clarify my situation - right now I backup my data to external disks which are only connected to do a sync and then stored separately. The data is on 2 different pc's and of course multiple disks.

Now the way I see it, if I go with WHS I will still have to backup to external media to keep it safe. So then why would I want to turn on folder duplication and thus need 3x the storage space (original, backup, duplicates)? FD seems like a waste of space if the data is backed up anyway (and it should be). Does that make sense?
 
you raise an interesting point but surely the aim of FD is a form of laymans backup should one HDD fail

im personallly a little worried that all my data is on one box atm (even if the majority is duplicated) my next task is to build a Ubuntu box and stick it in the garage (seperate building) then throw everything i have onto that once a month.
 
IMO, from my experience, a lot of people who don't have WHS talk out of their ass about a lot of these WHS claims.

WHS is a great, stable, and solid solution... not to mention cheap and super effective.
 
I know everybody values their data differently, but lately I've found myself going a bit overboard on backups. Right now I have folder duplication turned on for all shares on my WHS box. Honestly, extra hard drives are cheaper than the time it would take me to re-rip all of my dvd's. In addition to full duplication, I'm also looking at backing up my shares to external media. Yes, I realize this will result in 3 full copies all in the same location. There are some other side benefits to having my media backed up externally, but really with hard drives so cheap, why not.

So that's how I've got things set up right now. To answer the OP's question: If you're doing external backups regularly then you probably don't need full duplication. I don't think that argument goes the other way. If you are doing full duplication then it still would be a good idea to do external backups. The whole point is if your entire server frys (power supply failure, fire, etc.) then duplication or RAID isn't going to help.
 
I have duplication turned on selectively, and then backup all duped folders to an external drive that is then taken off-site (to my office). That's not 3x the hard drive space, not even 2x, more like 0.2x.
 
I don't use WHS but I agree with the points that have been made about it not being a true backup until it is off site or on another form of media.

I run an OS called unRAID that uses a dedicated parity drive to keep the data protected (parity drive has to be the largest drive). I do not get the performance (especially writes) that a RAID5 would. The one big thing i like about unRAID is that each data disk is its own independent drive. If i lose one drive i can restore the data; if i lose 2 drives i lose all the data but none of the data that is on the other drive; with a RAID5 if i lost 2 disks i would lose all data.
 
WHS was never intended to be a subsitute for a backup.
Nothing besides a true backup can be a subsitute.

Whs is a subsitute for raid, and was created to do 3 things
1) Backup peoples home computers.
2) Provide a central storage place for the consumers growing storage needs, and provide some added data security/ redundancy
3)Provide remote access to that data and computers.

I run an 11tb whs box with duplication turned on. I trust it.
I have been running whs since it was a beta and I haven't looked back.
 
I agree, it's not a substitute for a backup but it does seem like a substitute for RAID. Having been rationalizing the process, what I've concluded thus far:

Advantages vs. RAID:
- works well with heterogeneous disks (disks can be different speeds, sizes, interfaces, generations)
- redundancy specified at the folder level confers some flexibility
- software-only solution eliminates the need for a RAID controller, period
- very easy recovery in the event of total server failure - simply move the disks to another PC and copy off the files, whereas a RAID controller failure requires replacing the controller
- inexpensive scalability across a large number of spindles
- very low learning curve

Disadvantages vs. RAID
- potentially much less local throughput / not intended for high local performance
- inflexible redundancy levels (basically "on" vs "off") versus RAID5, RAID6, etc.
- dedicates a computer to running WHS and serving out files vs. say Windows Server + RAID controller sharing volumes out but also allowing the computer to act as a high performance workstation.
 
Back
Top