120 Hz Monitors

In stock today at Tiger Direct. I pulled the trigger. The price is steep because you have to order the 'bundle' which includes the $200 3D Vision glasses on top of the $400 monitor.

http://www.tigerdirect.com/applications/searchtools/item-details.asp?EdpNo=4386904

I'll post my impressions once it arrives and I've had a chance to play with it. As an avid FPS gamer, I've been waiting years for a high refresh LCD to hit the market. Will this be the week that I can finally put my gaming CRT to rest? We shall see...
 
great news, I'm looking forward to what you have to say. I've waited a long time for a decent LCD and I'm hoping the wait is finally over. If you could test the input lag vs the crt that would be great, and please let me how bad the blur is and if you can still see tearing at 120 lcd hz with the vsync off.
 

Hmm that looks like a con.
Note that the glasses are not LCD shutter but are polarity glasses
From the included pictures it seems that the TVs polarity changes on each horizontal line.
ie odd lines for right eye, even line for left eye.
This is the old Scan Line Interleave method of obtaining 3D by presenting 1/2 the resolution to each eye and is thus not a 120Hz input TV but 60Hz half resolution.
This wont give as good an image as the NVidia solution.

There is one positive side, as the light is already polarity filtered, the brightness you see when wearing glasses is practically as bright as when not wearing them.
So no need to turn the brightness up with the glasses on :)

Edit: Ah, should have read further.
for the 3D effect, a polariser is placed over the screen so you will need to turn the brightness up.
Therefore it has no advantages :p
 
Therefore it has no advantages :p

Doesn't flicker like when using shutter glasses so you will be able to use it for more than 30 minutes without getting a headache. When interested in 3D the iZ3D stuff looks the most interesting to me (polarized but full resolution through the use of two LCD matrix in the monitor)
 
Doesn't flicker like when using shutter glasses so you will be able to use it for more than 30 minutes without getting a headache. When interested in 3D the iZ3D stuff looks the most interesting to me (polarized but full resolution through the use of two LCD matrix in the monitor)

Thats true (about potentially having flicker induced issues - note that your 30 mins is a guess and most people dont get headaches :)) but at half vertical resolution per eye on that TV, its no longer hi-def gaming.
It will also need to have the brightness turned up a LOT due to 50% brightness loss receiving an image that is only from half the screen - and another 50% loss due to each eye being polarity filtered by the polarity glass fitted over the LCD.
There is another loss from the glasses but thats not as big.

Its worth noting previous reports that fatigue has been dramatically reduced with the new glasses from NVidia.
 
Thats true (about potentially having flicker induced issues - note that your 30 mins is a guess and most people dont get headaches :)) but at half vertical resolution per eye on that TV, its no longer hi-def gaming.
It will also need to have the brightness turned up a LOT due to 50% brightness loss receiving an image that is only from half the screen - and another 50% loss due to each eye being polarity filtered by the polarity glass fitted over the LCD.
There is another loss from the glasses but thats not as big.

Its worth noting previous reports that fatigue has been dramatically reduced with the new glasses from NVidia.

It's been a while since I've used shutter glasses so you're probably right about extended use not being such an issue anymore :).
I'd still prefer a polarizer though. But not with half resolution like it's used by hyundai or zalman... More like the one by these guys http://www.iz3d.com/t-22monitor.aspx but I'm waiting for the new model and drivers with wider software support.
 
It's been a while since I've used shutter glasses so you're probably right about extended use not being such an issue anymore :).
I'd still prefer a polarizer though. But not with half resolution like it's used by hyundai or zalman... More like the one by these guys http://www.iz3d.com/t-22monitor.aspx but I'm waiting for the new model and drivers with wider software support.

I toyed with making a similar 3D projector using 2 opposing polarity LCD panels a few years ago but didnt get the incentive as PCs were always too slow to use it at high res...

The iZ3D doesnt look bad, I checked out a few reviews, this is one of the most helpful
http://www.fpslabs.com/reviews/monitors/iz3d-22-review
The downside is the support needed for new games which also begs the question, how long will this display be supported with 3D game updates?

It also looks like framerate is still an issue sadly (and may be for NVidia too) requiring reduced quality which negates the 3D effects somewhat.
There was talk that the NVidia setup loses less fps in stereo mode but I need to see confirmation.
It would be nice to see SLI/Crossfire setups used to render 3D for each eye independently so there could be almost no framerate drop (compared to single card 2D), fingers crossed.
The iZ3D looks to be easier to translate to this method as both panels can be connected to different cards.
The NVidia kit has to pass all video out of one card.


Its true to say that not all new games will function straight off the bat with the NVidia setup either as the stereo driver needs to be matched to the display driver version and the stereo drivers dont get updated often (so far).
Newer games often need a beta driver to get decent performance/fix bugs which will force 3D gamers to wait a bit to play some games unless NVidia address this.
The price of progress :)

So early days still for both methods but its great to see the technology becoming wider spread and getting much needed exposure.
 
In stock today at Tiger Direct. I pulled the trigger. The price is steep because you have to order the 'bundle' which includes the $200 3D Vision glasses on top of the $400 monitor.

http://www.tigerdirect.com/applications/searchtools/item-details.asp?EdpNo=4386904

I'll post my impressions once it arrives and I've had a chance to play with it. As an avid FPS gamer, I've been waiting years for a high refresh LCD to hit the market. Will this be the week that I can finally put my gaming CRT to rest? We shall see...

thanks, keep us posted
 
Well I've been playing with the new 3Dvision, didnt have to pay for the monitor. I have some old shutter glasses and the new Nvidia ones are so much better. There is no such thing as flickering lol.. cant tell at all. Only one game where the glasses started to flicker every now and then was WOW but that was in the main city other than that never.

I played with the IZ3d monitor and Nvidia wins hands down. See IZ3d's has awful ghosting and the 2d text is kind of fuzzy because of the two screens. Iz3d is lighter but you have to really turn up bright/contrast to get rid of ghosting. Where as Nvidia is darker but ALOT better than it use to be. Now sure what the other post was talking about when said %50 darker.. but thats not the new NV. Also I have NOT.. NOT had to turn ANYTHING down becaues of FPS. Only had to turn some stuff down because of 3D looked funny. Like Crysis.. to get the 3d effect not because it made it go slower. Was it worth it? LOL man to play these games in 3D and not see ghosting.. yes very worth it.

But IZ3D is coming out with a new 24" so if your looking to buy you might want to wait to see how that turns out.

Had to add: Hyunda w240s says this: For seeing a list of further supported games and the possibility of buying additional 3D-game drivers please visit the following home page: http://www.tridef.com/3dgames/3d-games.html.:

Just go look.. this is just awful. The list of games is very very very small and if you want to have that game in 3d it cost $5 a game lol.. For $1300 its not worth it
 
I'm a diehard CRT user (I play only FPS games, and quite competitively so I usually run 800x600 for 160hz refresh rate). You can blindfold me and set my monitor to 120 or 160hz and I'll tell you which it is, I apparently have very sensitive eyes as I argue with my friends over this all the time. My monitor is starting to die and so I've been looking into LCD's for months now, and it always seems like the next best thing is just around the corner, and now we have the Viewsonic 120hz and the Samsung nvidia bundle thing, but is it really 120hz if you don't use those glasses?

I've been reading a lot about these new monitors with dual link dvi claiming 120hz with the stereoscopic technology. Now, all of these come with these glasses, does this mean you are only seeing the 120 refresh while using the glasses, or does it use the 2 dvi cables to render opposite frames each @ 60hz thus making it 120hz when combined?

If anybody could clear this up for me that would be great, gaming with glasses on aint my cup of tea.
 
I'm a diehard CRT user (I play only FPS games, and quite competitively so I usually run 800x600 for 160hz refresh rate). You can blindfold me and set my monitor to 120 or 160hz and I'll tell you which it is, I apparently have very sensitive eyes as I argue with my friends over this all the time. My monitor is starting to die and so I've been looking into LCD's for months now, and it always seems like the next best thing is just around the corner, and now we have the Viewsonic 120hz and the Samsung nvidia bundle thing, but is it really 120hz if you don't use those glasses?

I've been reading a lot about these new monitors with dual link dvi claiming 120hz with the stereoscopic technology. Now, all of these come with these glasses, does this mean you are only seeing the 120 refresh while using the glasses, or does it use the 2 dvi cables to render opposite frames each @ 60hz thus making it 120hz when combined?

If anybody could clear this up for me that would be great, gaming with glasses on aint my cup of tea.
apparently the monitor can display a true 120hz output from the video card, there is a screenshot of the Nvidia Control panel on the Samsung and it says 1680x1050@120hz. When you use the glasses 60hz goes to each eye, but like you I'm a diehard crt user who loves high refresh rates so screw the glasses just gimme 120hz with no input lag, and hopefully the lcd blur isn't a dealbreaker.
 
Yep I agree, the panel has to be 120Hz capable for 3D so it makes no sense to limit the panel when not used for 3D.
Those 120Hz TVs that can be used with shutter glasses for 3D will be true native 120Hz.
 
FYI I just got the Viewsonic VX2265WM yesterday, and it OWNS. I've never owned an LCD in my life cuz I'm so picky about refresh rates, swapped out my 120hz CRT for this badboy and I haven't looked back.

The side to side viewing angles actually are quite acceptable, moving your head up and down causes the top part of the monitor to go dim, but I guess as long as you don't nod your head while you use it it's fine hehe. Even my old games like unreal tournament (original) work fine, and I don't notice any lag at all compared to 120hz on my CRT. I've never had a CRT that could do a high res and look nice anyway so this is actually a step up in my mind.
 
Yep I agree, the panel has to be 120Hz capable for 3D so it makes no sense to limit the panel when not used for 3D.
Those 120Hz TVs that can be used with shutter glasses for 3D will be true native 120Hz.
except they have no input that will take a dual link dvi signal and they will do 3d a different way. I wanted to buy one to use as a monitor but I beat the horse to death and they can't be used as 120hz monitors.
 
FYI I just got the Viewsonic VX2265WM yesterday, and it OWNS. I've never owned an LCD in my life cuz I'm so picky about refresh rates, swapped out my 120hz CRT for this badboy and I haven't looked back.

The side to side viewing angles actually are quite acceptable, moving your head up and down causes the top part of the monitor to go dim, but I guess as long as you don't nod your head while you use it it's fine hehe. Even my old games like unreal tournament (original) work fine, and I don't notice any lag at all compared to 120hz on my CRT. I've never had a CRT that could do a high res and look nice anyway so this is actually a step up in my mind.
awesome, mind testing input lag?
 
except they have no input that will take a dual link dvi signal and they will do 3d a different way. I wanted to buy one to use as a monitor but I beat the horse to death and they can't be used as 120hz monitors.

Can you provide evidence?
To get a stereo 1680 res picture, it must use dual link, so it must support it.
Having used the NVidia driver for 3D glasses, it does indeed generate 2 images per frame and requires 100Hz+ to look any good.
 
Can you provide evidence?
To get a stereo 1680 res picture, it must use dual link, so it must support it.
Having used the NVidia driver for 3D glasses, it does indeed generate 2 images per frame and requires 100Hz+ to look any good.
I was talking about TVs that support 3d. I was gonna buy one to use as a 120hz monitor (using the same logic you just said) so I asked here http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/showthread.php?t=1112595 and the responses I got were very interesting.
 
So was I.
They still need to receive the signal an NVidia card sends out which is 2 images per frame.
That will not fit down single DVI.
there is some trickery involved with sub-fields and other crap that I don't understand but I assure you there is no tv out right now that can be used as a 120hz monitor. Even if you get a dual-link dvi to hdmi cable, the second link on the dvi side isn't connected to any pins on the hdmi side so there is no way to get a true 120hz signal into it, afaik the 3d TVs do it using a 60hz signal (I know it's counter to what it says but that's the only explanation).
 
awesome, mind testing input lag?

How do i test input lag. The only buttons on this monitor are brightness up and down, and volume up and down for the speakers. No advanced options or anything.

I could tell the difference between 100hz and 120 and 160hz on my CRT, and I've been gaming on standard LCDs before. I have a razer deathadder mouse 1800dpi and generally I can tell if the monitor is good or not just by moving my mouse cursor around in windows, but I tested all my games last night and I had no issues at all doing 180 spin shots etc, I use EXTREMELY fast sensitivity so I would notice if there any input lag.
 
How do i test input lag. The only buttons on this monitor are brightness up and down, and volume up and down for the speakers. No advanced options or anything.

I could tell the difference between 100hz and 120 and 160hz on my CRT, and I've been gaming on standard LCDs before. I have a razer deathadder mouse 1800dpi and generally I can tell if the monitor is good or not just by moving my mouse cursor around in windows, but I tested all my games last night and I had no issues at all doing 180 spin shots etc, I use EXTREMELY fast sensitivity so I would notice if there any input lag.
plug the lcd and your crt in at the same time in clone mode, run a digital stopwatch program and take pictures :).
 
there is some trickery involved with sub-fields and other crap that I don't understand but I assure you there is no tv out right now that can be used as a 120hz monitor. Even if you get a dual-link dvi to hdmi cable, the second link on the dvi side isn't connected to any pins on the hdmi side so there is no way to get a true 120hz signal into it, afaik the 3d TVs do it using a 60hz signal (I know it's counter to what it says but that's the only explanation).

Seriously, you havent been researching recent products, they are true 120Hz.
Take for example this advert
http://www.tigerdirect.com/applications/searchtools/item-details.asp?EdpNo=4386851
http://images.tigerdirect.com/itemdetails/S203-2336/S203-2336-outbx-am.jpg
optimum resolution of 1680x1050 @ 120Hz

Or

http://www.displayblog.com/2008/08/27/viewsonic-vx2265wm-22-lcd-monitor-with-120hz/
the 120Hz frequency is supported by a very fast 3ms response time. The dual-link DVI input is for its stereoscopic 3D capabilities.

Note the @ 120Hz and dual-link DVI
 
for the third time, I am talking about 3D-compatible TVs, not those 2 lcd monitors we already know about.

you originally said that 3d compatible TVs will be true native 120hz, they are not, at least not in any way that we could use as a 120hz monitor. look:

Those 120Hz TVs that can be used with shutter glasses for 3D will be true native 120Hz.

this has nothing to do with those 2 monitors.
 
for the third time, I am talking about 3D-compatible TVs, not those 2 lcd monitors we already know about.

you originally said that 3d compatible TVs will be true native 120hz, they are not, at least not in any way that we could use as a 120hz monitor. look:

this has nothing to do with those 2 monitors.

Its the same thing, older 120Hz TVs use interpolation etc, newer ones are 120hz.
ie this 42" TV
http://www.tigerdirect.com/applications/SearchTools/item-details.asp?EdpNo=4337304&Sku=V25-4240
120Hz, Full HD 1920 x 1080 native Resolution LCD - 120Hz refresh rate coupled with 1920x1080 resolution provides only the smoothest-motion imagery. Enjoy DVD movies, gaming, or High Definition television with astounding clarity. Add 1080p processing power for Full High Definition viewing and the VIZIO SV420XVT is the new home theatre solution!
 
and how do you expect to feed it a 120hz signal? besides, that isn't even one of the 3D-compatible TVs I was referring to and originally thought could be used as a 120hz monitor.
 
Use one of these: HDMI to DVI Dual Link Cable, 10 ft
http://sewelldirect.com/hdmi-to-dvi-dual-link-cable-10-ft.asp
and we come full circle

We're often asked why there isn't a DVI-I to HDMI cable or a DVI-D Dual Link to HDMI cable; the reason is that HDMI (at least, the 19-pin version of HDMI implemented on all consumer HDMI devices) is a single-link, digital-only standard, so there's no way to hook it up either to a DVI analog or Dual-Link signal; one could put the DVI-I or Dual-Link type connector on the cable, but the additional pins at the DVI end wouldn't actually be hooked up to anything.
http://bluejeanscable.com/store/hdmi-cables/index.htm

it won't work.
 

HDMI supports dual link, and has for a long while...
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HDMI#Connectors
The Type B connector has 29 pins (21.2 mm by 4.45 mm) and can carry double the video bandwidth of Type A for use with very high-resolution future displays such as WQUXGA (3840x2400).[51][50] Type B is electrically compatible with dual link DVI-D but has not yet been used in any products.[50][52]

The sources for the last statement are quite old. But still, I don't think there is any TV supporting a 120Hz source.
 
You are right about Nvidias recommended TVs for 3D, I actually found how it works!
The TVs that support 3D glasses are DLPs from Mitsubishi (according to NVidia) and they use an algorithm to fit stereo down single link DVI.

http://dlp.com/downloads/Introducing DLP 3D HDTV Whitepaper.pdf
DLP® 3-D Image Format
The DLP® 3-D Image format makes use of how the DLP® SmoothPicture™ algorithm displays an image onto the screen. The left and right images are sampled using the native offset diagonal sampling format of the DMD. The two views are then overlaid and appear as a left and right checkerboard pattern in a conventional orthogonal sampled image....

3-D Content
One of the advantages of the DLP® Technology is that the data signal uses the same bandwidth as a traditional HD Video Signal. As such, this format can be transferred over current DVI and HDMI interfaces.

I'm still not sure that there arent any 120Hz TV's still though :)
I havent got the time to research this further atm but here is something that might change the landscape
http://www.allpinouts.org/index.php/HDMI_to_DVI_cable_scheme
The standard Type A HDMI connector has 19 pins, and a higher resolution version called Type B, has been defined, although it is not yet in common use. Type B has 29 pins, allowing it to carry an expanded video channel for use with high-resolution displays. Type-B is designed to support resolutions higher than 1080p.
The extra video channels could be used for Dual Link DVI...

Edit: I see brumwald mentioned the same thing (took me ages to make this post :))
 
Its the same thing, older 120Hz TVs use interpolation etc, newer ones are 120hz.
ie this 42" TV
http://www.tigerdirect.com/applications/SearchTools/item-details.asp?EdpNo=4337304&Sku=V25-4240

From the page you linked:
VIZIO_SV420XVT1A_Manual.pdf
Now, consult the manual, particularly pages 30 and 31, and you will find that the monitor takes a maximum of 60Hz. Furthermore, in the specs on page 81, you'll see in the Feature list "HDMI V.1.3, 120 Hz Motion Estimation and Motion Compensation". Nowhere in the manual is there mention of HDMI Type B, which would be a serious omission since Type B plugs are a different size than Type A.

To quote this hdmi cable buying guide (dated 2009):

There are currently two different types of HDMI cables; Type A and Type B. Type A is the mainstream consumer type of HDMI cable, consisting of 19 interwoven wires within the cable to produce both HD audio and video. Type B is similar, but differs in size of the plug itself and the amount of internal wiring within the cable. While Type A has 19 wires, Type B has 29, meaning higher quality. Most normal users will never be able to tell the difference, and most of today’s components only support Type A HDMI plugins. Type B is designed for the motion picture industry and other extra-high-quality professional applications such as HD camcorders, etc.

I am unable to find any consumer TVs with HDMI B inputs; as I said before, this would have be very clearly stated even in the marketing since you can't plug a type A cord into a type B socket.

You've been fooled by the marketing of 120Hz TVs. 120Hz TVs are not true 120Hz. They display 120Hz, but only by taking 60Hz or less input and duplicating and interpolating frames.
 
Yep, already conceded that the TVs being used for 3D are not true 120Hz, see post #73
 
Back
Top