Intel CEO Comments on NVIDIA, Economy, Flash

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Intel’s CEO Paul Otellini, while speaking at the 2009 Goldman Sachs Technology and Internet Conference, had a few things to say about NVIDIA, the economy and the Flash market.

Otellini said that Nvidia is not in a strong competitive position. "If you don't have a microprocessor, what else do you have to sell?" he said, countering Nvidia's claims that the industry is becoming more centered on graphics chips. "The graphics subsystem for most machines will be subsumed into the microprocessor. So what Nvidia is doing is making an argument to defend the status quo," he said. He said if you want higher performance you can buy a discrete graphics chip. "You can buy it from them or you can buy it from us," he said, referring to Intel's upcoming Larrabee graphics chip.
 
Yeah, but is Intel really going to be able to add graphics speed that is equal to nvidia's to their CPUs? I mean, I don't exactly think of Intel when I think of 3d graphics. Seems more like a lot of posturing to me.
 
I think it's funny watching these two companies going back and forth going "Ooo, It's all about the CPU, It's all about the CPU" / "Ooo, It's all about the GPU, It's all about the GPU", just cause that's what each one of them makes. Honestly I think that of the while group, that AMD/ATI is actually the one that has the best bet on future trends with their hybrid CPU/GPU chip plans. However, there will ALWAYS be a market for BOTH a dedicated CPU AND a dedicated GPU.

 
Yeah, but is Intel really going to be able to add graphics speed that is equal to nvidia's to their CPUs? I mean, I don't exactly think of Intel when I think of 3d graphics. Seems more like a lot of posturing to me.

Remember Weitek? Let me take you back a couple decades...

Is Intel really going to be able to integrate a floating point math co-processor that's equal to Weitek's speed into their CPU's? I mean, Intel isn't exactly the name you think of when it comes to floating point math co-processors. Seems like posturing to me.

Or so Weitek thought....
 
Remember Weitek? Let me take you back a couple decades...

Is Intel really going to be able to integrate a floating point math co-processor that's equal to Weitek's speed into their CPU's? I mean, Intel isn't exactly the name you think of when it comes to floating point math co-processors. Seems like posturing to me.

Or so Weitek thought....

QFT.
 
Yeah, but is Intel really going to be able to add graphics speed that is equal to nvidia's to their CPUs? I mean, I don't exactly think of Intel when I think of 3d graphics. Seems more like a lot of posturing to me.

Silly lil Wabbit :p
 
"You can buy it from them or you can buy it from us,"
Really? Larrabee? Today? Can I? No, I cant, Paul.... No, I can't...

These two are like little 3rd graders throwing mud in the playground. And until I see a finished chip, Larrabee is nothing but theoretical fud.
 
Until Intel produces a GPU that doesn't suck, they can have a nice big warm glass of STFU.
 
The intresting part of this statement isn't what he said about nVidia, its what he said about Intel and Windows 7:

About Netbooks he said: "We lit a fuse. It's the only bright spot in the PC industry at this point in time." But he added: "Atom is still less than half the performance of our entry-level Celeron product. It wasn't designed to be a notebook replacement part." He added the Microsoft will limit the starter edition of Windows 7--that will be used for future Netbooks--to three applications running at once. "You'll be underwhelmed," he said, relative to mainstream notebooks

See the problem? Windows 7 Starter edition being limited to three apps is completely artificial. My Eee PC running Windows 7 continues to impress me. Windows 7 even in beta form simply runs perfectly. Even hi def content in Windows Media Center plays fine it overall, some slow downs here and there but perfectly fine for small screen device that you'd take on trips, you're not going to hook it up to an HDTV.

So the Atom is just half the power of the crappiest Celeron and is running the latest and greatest Windows like nobody's business. Maybe I don't need all that much CPU either Mr. Otellini.

Otellini may wish he hadn't slammed Vista so hard cause maybe that "resource hog" would have gotten people to buy pricier CPU's. As it stands there are going to tons of people pleased as punch with Windows 7 on a $300 netbook running the latest stuff with no sweat that Intel might have its own problems.
 
yeah but FPU has what 16 registers, and modern GPUs 512MB to 2GB dedicated.

at least right now you can upgrade your graphics card once or twice before needing a new machine.

with the integrated future, your machine will be a doorstop in 8 months. imagine having to shell out for the XE twice, just to get the updated GPU part of the chip.
 
yeah but FPU has what 16 registers, and modern GPUs 512MB to 2GB dedicated.

at least right now you can upgrade your graphics card once or twice before needing a new machine.

with the integrated future, your machine will be a doorstop in 8 months. imagine having to shell out for the XE twice, just to get the updated GPU part of the chip.


The integrated solutions would be on the mainstream side. It will be a long time before high-end CPU's would have integrated graphics in them, or that graphics that anyone buying a high-end CPU would actually care about.

For now the integrated CPU/GPU is all about the mainstream and keeping the platform all in Intel's hands and the money in only its pocket. No third party anything.
 
the day intel makes a decent graphics chip is the day macs become good for gaming
 
It's an interesting play from Intel, they've publicly hammered nVidia pretty hard during a very difficult period for nVidia. That falling share price might get nVidia into vulnerable territory. Should that happen, it's unlikely nVidia will be taken over by ATI. So, who can, and who might be interested?
 
Melons this isn't a war, you don't just conquer companies then take them over.
 
I just see FUD. Intel launched Atom to great and deserved fanfare. Then NVIDIA showed them how to really make it shine and it just magnified the degree to which Intel just doesn't compete in that space. Their CPUs are great. But they just SUCK at graphics. Now, maybe they can change that, but FUD isn't going to change the fact that the GMA 945/950 is a steaming POS. IMHO Intel merely sees Atom as a way to unload older high margin chipsets and make a few more bucks off a dead product line.
 
Remember Weitek? Let me take you back a couple decades...

Is Intel really going to be able to integrate a floating point math co-processor that's equal to Weitek's speed into their CPU's? I mean, Intel isn't exactly the name you think of when it comes to floating point math co-processors. Seems like posturing to me.

Or so Weitek thought....

Yes but math co-processors were small add-on chips.. and pretty much ever since then, CPUs melt without fans. :D

But seriously, GPUs are a lot more complex... and what about memory speed? Even if they made a GPU/CPU combination with an innate speed equal to an nvidia card, the difference of speed of the RAM would strangle it!
 
Yes but math co-processors were small add-on chips.. and pretty much ever since then, CPUs melt without fans. :D

But seriously, GPUs are a lot more complex... and what about memory speed? Even if they made a GPU/CPU combination with an innate speed equal to an nvidia card, the difference of speed of the RAM would strangle it!

If you think a GPU is more complex than a CPU, you really need to do some reading up...
 
Agreed, CPUs are more complex. People may be misleaded by the transistor count ^^.
 
It's an interesting play from Intel, they've publicly hammered nVidia pretty hard during a very difficult period for nVidia. That falling share price might get nVidia into vulnerable territory. Should that happen, it's unlikely nVidia will be taken over by ATI. So, who can, and who might be interested?

Eh? NVIDIA being taken by ATI ? You mean bought ?! That's not unlikely, that's impossible. I think you need to read more about the economic status of each company. NVIDIA alone is worth almost 4 times what AMD is worth. ATI isn't worth much.

As for their share price, they're no where near vulnerable territory.
 
Eh? NVIDIA being taken by ATI ? You mean bought ?! That's not unlikely, that's impossible. I think you need to read more about the economic status of each company. NVIDIA alone is worth almost 4 times what AMD is worth. ATI isn't worth much.

As for their share price, they're no where near vulnerable territory.

He did not imply AMD would buy nVidia. More like Intel would.
 
I don't think things look too well for Nvidia. I think they hit a brick wall and they are looking to rename their gpu line once again to save face.

As for AMD, part of the reason they are sucking is poor marketing. Everyone knows who intel is, and not everyone knows who amd is.
 
He did not imply AMD would buy nVidia. More like Intel would.

lol do you really think that Intel could/will part with 1/8th (~$10B) of it's company's worth to buy them?

I say 1/8th because NVIDIA has roughly 5-7% the market cap of Intel right now (at it's peak in '07 it was about 17%), and to get shareholder approval of something like that you'd have to give them some damn good immediate profits to entice them for the purchase, meaning Intel would have to part with more than NVIDIA's current market cap of ~$5B to get mass approval.
 
Everyone laughed at Intel when AMD dominated them, and then suddenly out came Core 2 Duo.

Until Nvidia can pretty much destroy their competition, I place my bets on Intel coming out on top.
 
And hopefully people will remember Netburst and especially Pentium D. If Intel takes their time, they could dominate on a GPU.
 
I dont know how people can say Intel suck at graphics when they haven't attempted to make a real graphics chip as far as I can remember. The integrated graphics isnt their best attempt, believe me. They know the GMA 945/950 is a pile of sh*t. However, there is a market for it, so they sell it. Larrabee may be a "Core 2 Duo". It may be a "Phenom II". We will see.
 
Everyone laughed at Intel when AMD dominated them, and then suddenly out came Core 2 Duo.

Until Nvidia can pretty much destroy their competition, I place my bets on Intel coming out on top.

Erm similarly, everyone laughed at NVIDIA's GeForce FX, until they came out with 6/7-series, and ultimately the 8-series and took tons of marketshare, dominating the graphics space...

So your point is any company with talent can set their mind to something and dominate the field.. sure. But don't fool yourself into thinking that it is so easy to do so outside of your area of expertise...
 
Erm similarly, everyone laughed at NVIDIA's GeForce FX, until they came out with 6/7-series, and ultimately the 8-series and took tons of marketshare, dominating the graphics space...

So your point is any company with talent can set their mind to something and dominate the field.. sure. But don't fool yourself into thinking that it is so easy to do so outside of your area of expertise...

Looking at Intel's RD, their fabs and the acquisitions and their financial state, I would state Intel is poised to make "Larrabee" a nice midrange GPU.

The high end is not targeted untill "Larrabee2" and if anyone can enter the GPU market..it is Intel.

Underestimate Intel all you want to...but it is very unwise, even more so if you look at Intel's long term chip plans.

To quote Tim Sweeny:
"The GPU is temporay solution to a general computing issue"

Hint: google "terascale"
 
There's not much room for profit in the add-in graphics arena. If Larrabee can compete even in the low-mid range in price/performance, it could hurt Nvidia enough to drive their stock price to a point where a hostile takeover can happen.
 
There's not much room for profit in the add-in graphics arena. If Larrabee can compete even in the low-mid range in price/performance, it could hurt Nvidia enough to drive their stock price to a point where a hostile takeover can happen.

Honestly, at the rate nVidia is going it might not be around much longer past 2012. If Intel can come out with a solid gpu setup and if AMD/ATI can stick around things start to look really really bleak. Then if the cpu/gpu hybrids coming from both (really need both Intel and AMD to both be on the ball with this) AMD and Intel "work as intended" that may be the final nail in the coffin.

Of course nVidia could get smart, reinvent/market itself, and overcome doomsday. Personally I would love the option of having three quality video card makers to choose from.
 
So I can buy an nVidia dedicated graphics card that will run anything without a problem, or the Intel comparison (I use the term loosely), and put up with the game not understanding/not detecting a graphics card that's compatible, crap graphics, and abysmal playback of DVD's (if Intel's last attempt at graphics is anything to go by)?

I'd switch back to ATi/AMD rather than put up with Intel's BS when it comes to graphics and gaming.
 
If they made a GPU socket on their boards it could be interesting to upgrade a GPU chip instead of a GPU card.

But if they try to out due Nvidia in the GPU card game they are probably going to burned at first.
 
Back
Top