Student Arrested For Classroom Texting

Oh yes, ignore her. It is her own fault she fails.

This is why American's public school standards go down every damn generation.
 
And again she wasn't arrested for texting in class, do you think if she would have told the principal when she was asked for her phone, I'm sorry sir, here is my phone may I pick it up after school? that she would have been arrested?

It seems like you haven't read the article...

She was escorted willingly from class, and then later arrested after lying about not having a phone on her.

It's one thing to kick a student out of class for being disruptive, and this was done, which indeed resolved the situation. It's another thing to arrest the student after they've been removed from class and are no longer creating disruption.

Arrest is an extreme course of action, especially when the situation is resolved by simply removing the student from the classroom (as was done in this scenario). Kicking a student out of class is a simple and effective method for keeping order in a classroom. Explain to me why, in addition to this, arresting the student was necessary?

Furthermore, are we really going to arrest students for giggling in class as you would suggest?


Finally, before anyone suggests otherwise, I'm not suggesting that the student didn't deserve some form of discipline. I'm suggesting that arresting the student was an extremely disproportionate course of action considering what she was actually doing (texting in class).
 
And after I hit him back in "self defence", I would sue him personally to ruin his life and sue the school to get them bad publicity for hiring a moron. Yes, I know I'm taking advantage of the legal system, but I'd do it anyway to make a point.

That is the stupid option. The other option is, you can stop, think about the situation, and use logic to figure out what to do. Logic does not mean impulsive actions that escalate to full-fledged conflict. Logic means you absorb your pride and butthurt, do the right thing, and complain to more effective channels. Attacking a teacher is not an effective channel. You get nothing out of it except for revenge. It does the system no good, and does you no good in the long run.

Come on, man. I thought you were logical.
 
Come on, man. I thought you were logical.

he doesn't need to be logical, hes an Artiste you should be thankful hes taking time out of his day to speak to us mere mortals, when he could be making 2000,000$ a second sucking on his God like teachers piano schlong.
 
It seems like you haven't read the article...

She was escorted willingly from class, and then later arrested after lying about not having a phone on her.

It's one thing to kick a student out of class for being disruptive, and this was done, which indeed resolved the situation. It's another thing to arrest the student after they've been removed from class and are no longer creating disruption.

Arrest is an extreme course of action, especially when the situation is resolved by simply removing the student from the classroom (as was done in this scenario). Kicking a student out of class is a simple and effective method for keeping order in a classroom. Explain to me why, in addition to this, arresting the student was necessary?

Furthermore, are we really going to arrest students for giggling in class as you would suggest?


Finally, before anyone suggests otherwise, I'm not suggesting that the student didn't deserve some form of discipline. I'm suggesting that arresting the student was an extremely disproportionate course of action considering what she was actually doing (texting in class).

My kids had Cell phones in High School. They were afraid to let any teacher have their cell phone because they seem to dissapear when they are confiscated, an expensive affair. Me and the Principal had a lovely conversation about that, never did get that razor back, but it was phone yelling at the principal and getting away with it for a change,
 
My kids had Cell phones in High School. They were afraid to let any teacher have their cell phone because they seem to dissapear when they are confiscated, an expensive affair. Me and the Principal had a lovely conversation about that, never did get that razor back, but it was phone yelling at the principal and getting away with it for a change,

but it was fun yelling at the principal and getting away with it for a change.

Jeese, guess I should go back to school.
 
It seems like you haven't read the article...

I'm guessing you haven't read the article.

She was escorted willingly from class, and then later arrested after lying about not having a phone on her.

She was arrested for Disorderly Conduct after she escalated the situation to the point where a female probation officer had to come in and basically do a strip search. Again do you honestly think we would be here talking about this if she simply sacked up, did the right thing and said I'm sorry here is my phone, can either myself or my parents pick it up after school?

It's one thing to kick a student out of class for being disruptive, and this was done, which indeed resolved the situation. It's another thing to arrest the student after they've been removed from class and are no longer creating disruption.

Again, I don't think you read the article, because she was indeed still creating a disturbance, now whether or not you think that disturbance warranted a female probation officer to be called is another story. School administrators thought it necessary and from reading the article, it was indeed necessary.

Arrest is an extreme course of action, especially when the situation is resolved by simply removing the student from the classroom (as was done in this scenario). Kicking a student out of class is a simple and effective method for keeping order in a classroom.

it is, I agree with you there. Are you a teacher though? Do you have to deal with this on a daily basis? Because if you do then you also realize that there is only so many times you can remove someone from your classroom and each time you do it hinders the teacher from doing their job which is teaching our kids, not babysitting attitude ridden kids who feel they're entitled to do whatever they want while in school.

Explain to me why, in addition to this, arresting the student was necessary?

Because she continued to lie repeatedly to administrators and staff, laughed about the whole situation, and escalated the situation until a female P.O. was called. You continually make it seem like she was escorted from class into the waiting arms of a swat team which is so far from the truth it is becoming almost asinine. The only thing I find somewhat perturbing about the whole situation is that the school didn't have any contact numbers for her parents and was forced to continually ask the lying child on how to reach them.


Furthermore, are we really going to arrest students for giggling in class as you would suggest?

I suggested this? I really don't think reading is your forte, but that is about par for the course. You suggested that the loud noise from texting was disruptive in your so so sarcastic manner suggesting that is what warranted her arrest. I addressed the disruptive part since you failed to grasp that yes, texting in class is disruptive. and then addressed the fact that she wasn't arrested for the texting which you continually fail to grasp as well, again due to a poor lack of reading comprehension or perhaps you just enjoy playing the devil's advocate.


Finally, before anyone suggests otherwise, I'm not suggesting that the student didn't deserve some form of discipline. I'm suggesting that arresting the student was an extremely disproportionate course of action considering what she was actually doing (lying to administrators, staff, and law enforcement continually without remorse).

Fixed.

I'm just really thinking your missing the point. She knew what she did was wrong, as suggested by the fact that she tried to illicit help from her friends in taking the phone for her, the fact that she hid the phone in her pants between her buttocks, and the fact that she continually lied to everyone involved and went as far as giving the wrong number to staff so they couldn't call her parents. Then again, there is something else wrong here with the suspect as well, especially after the situation in which she continually defied their request to remain off campus. Arrest in this situation seems to have been a good start to hopefully nip this attitude and problem child in the bud before she gets too far out of hand.
 
As a graduate lab instructor at a university, and a product of Wisconsin public education, I'm appalled at the outcome of this situation. This kind of punishment is utterly ridiculous. The girl did not do anything illegal. Yes, she was disruptive, but so is someone sleeping in class. You're going to tell me THAT'S illegal too!? Last I checked, we had SOME semblance of being a free country.

I remember when I was in high school (in nearby Madison, WI), I was suspended for 3 days for posting a letter of protest on the wall for the return of trash cans in a certain area of the school. (They took them away for some stupid reason.. can't remember). The mentality of many school officials is overly punitive. Many of them are the typical authoritarian type, probably made that way because of their own insecurities during high school. They are incapable of "backing down" when a 14 year old tries to escalate a, quite frankly, ridiculous scenario. They are incabaple of seeing the ridiculousness of the offense, and instead concentrate on the fact that someone DARE to challenge their rules. This wasn't about a cell phone, people.

If they REALLY wanted to bust her THAT badly, the school could have just talked to the girl's friend, or parents, and gotten her cell phone number. They then could have tried calling her phone, and when she rings, she's busted. No police involved. Then, she should be punished at school, NOT with the law.

Why didn't the teacher just kick her out of class? That's what I do to college students who decide they'd rather eff off in my class. Ugh. Ridiculous.
 
Not to mention the fact that the 4th Amendment makes it illegal to search a non-consenting individual for anything other than a weapon. If she did not consent to a search, then they had no legal right to locate the cell phone.
 
Why didn't the teacher just kick her out of class? That's what I do to college students who decide they'd rather eff off in my class. Ugh. Ridiculous.

I would think a college teacher would know the difference between voluntary college education and involuntary public high school.
 
Minors do not rate libertys. That is the problem now everyone thinks they rate somthing they do not. The parents should be flogged for raising such a little bitch at that. Glad you went to a prep school richie rich but most of us did not. Oh noes the 14 year had her rights violated, oh wait she shouldnt have any. Any ways her parents are to balme.

not rich, i was the poor kid in school.

Last time i checked we are supposed to have rights from birth... you want a free republic then you can't play the buffet game. Shit if a 14 yr shouldn't have any rights then the abortion thing is automatically an invalid arguement too by that logic. since afterall we aren't human until 18.

yeah she's a bitch.. oh well, lots of people are, again this is a non issue. you are a bitch you yell back and toss her out of her class, cops is seriously messed up and completely making mountains out of molehills. Part of the problem is the education system itself but that is out of the scope of this discussion.
 
I would think a college teacher would know the difference between voluntary college education and involuntary public high school.


That's true, but my main point is that this situation could have been resolved without involving police.
 
Not to mention the fact that the 4th Amendment makes it illegal to search a non-consenting individual for anything other than a weapon. If she did not consent to a search, then they had no legal right to locate the cell phone.

lol you need to go back to criminal law 101

oh wait i doubt you ever went.

4th amendment has nothing to do about weapons. Again this country thinks it has way more rights then it does.

You dont think she broke the law huh you got that cities ordinance book handy ? there are federal, state, and city laws that vary widely. You can be arrested in most cities for almost anything due to ordinances.. swearing.. lieing.. etc etc you be surprised. Officer can search you anytime they got enough probale cause to warrant any crime not just weapons. Hell even less then probable cause is needed in some situatations reasonable suspicion is enough.


god the sheer ignorance of the law by some people dragged me back into this.
 
As a graduate lab instructor at a university, and a product of Wisconsin public education, I'm appalled at the outcome of this situation. This kind of punishment is utterly ridiculous. The girl did not do anything illegal. Yes, she was disruptive, but so is someone sleeping in class. You're going to tell me THAT'S illegal too!? Last I checked, we had SOME semblance of being a free country.

I remember when I was in high school (in nearby Madison, WI), I was suspended for 3 days for posting a letter of protest on the wall for the return of trash cans in a certain area of the school. (They took them away for some stupid reason.. can't remember). The mentality of many school officials is overly punitive. Many of them are the typical authoritarian type, probably made that way because of their own insecurities during high school. They are incapable of "backing down" when a 14 year old tries to escalate a, quite frankly, ridiculous scenario. They are incabaple of seeing the ridiculousness of the offense, and instead concentrate on the fact that someone DARE to challenge their rules. This wasn't about a cell phone, people.

If they REALLY wanted to bust her THAT badly, the school could have just talked to the girl's friend, or parents, and gotten her cell phone number. They then could have tried calling her phone, and when she rings, she's busted. No police involved. Then, she should be punished at school, NOT with the law.

Why didn't the teacher just kick her out of class? That's what I do to college students who decide they'd rather eff off in my class. Ugh. Ridiculous.

why dont you go be a cop in the big city or hell even small towns somtimes and then try out all your citizen why didnt you do this scenarios and then apologize for the ignorance to the situations you tried to monday morning quarterback about.
 
dajet, if you specifically decline from unwarranted searches, you can not be physically padded down and searched for any object besides a weapon without a warrant. If you decline from a search, you may still be apprehended, though. If a police officer seaches your body for an object they will ALYWAYS ask you "What is this?" looking for you to accidentally give either consent or probable cause to further the search. In this case, the possession of a cell phone is not a CRIME (like you admit a police officer needs to suspect has occured in order to have probable cause!), so probable cause to search for one cannot be established.

However, in certain circumstances, authorities are permitted to conduct a limited warrantless search on a level of suspicion less than probable cause. In Terry v. Ohio 392 U.S. 1 (1968), the Supreme Court decided that when a policeman "observes unusual conduct" that leads him to reasonably believe "that criminal activity may be afoot" and that the suspicious person has a weapon and is presently dangerous to the policeman or others, he may conduct a "pat-down search" (or "frisk"), to determine whether the person is in fact carrying a weapon. To conduct a frisk, the policeman must be able to point to specific and articulable facts which, taken together with rational inferences from those facts, reasonably warrant his actions.[22] A vague hunch will not do. Such a search must be temporary and questioning must be limited to the purpose of the stop (i.e., if the policeman stopped you because he had reasonable suspicion to believe that you were driving a stolen car, after confirming that it is not stolen, he cannot force you to answer questions about anything else, such as the possession of contraband).[23]

City ordinances cannot circumvent the constitution. Where they do, they are overturned in court.
 
dajet, if you specifically decline from unwarranted searches, you can not be physically padded down and searched for any object besides a weapon without a warrant. If you decline from a search, you may still be apprehended, though. If a police officer seaches your body for an object they will ALYWAYS ask you "What is this?" looking for you to accidentally give either consent or probable cause to further the search. In this case, the possession of a cell phone is not a CRIME (like you admit a police officer needs to suspect has occured in order to have probable cause!), so probable cause to search for one cannot be established.



City ordinances cannot circumvent the constitution. Where they do, they are overturned in court.

You realize that terry frisk is the first thing the academy talks about .. and it applies to traffic stops normaly when used in arguments. though any stop can involve a terry frisk. Terry frisk is based on officer safety regarding weapons but a normal search can be done with any Probable cause or susupician that a crime has occured or will occur soon.

All the police need is a reasonable suspicion that the individual has committed or is about to commit a crime.

www.officer.com go post you thoughts on there forum and lets see what you come up with.

again you have no idea what your really talking about.
 
You still don't understand. In this case, no crime was commited, so no search could have been legally performed!
 
4th amendment text

The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated, and no Warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause, supported by Oath or affirmation, and particularly describing the place to be searched, and the persons or things to be seized.


dont see anythign about weapons there. The probable cause based on the officers past experience with this girl along with the facts presented along with how she is presenting herself gave more then enough probable cause for this search. and again on school grounds you have no expectency of privacy.

Nothing wrong with the search. not to mention if he had already decided in his mind he was giving her a arrest citation she is subject to search by arrest.. even if she isnt going to jail the citation = arrest for legal purposes.
 
You still don't understand. In this case, no crime was commited, so no search could have been legally performed!

the crime of disorderly conduct was committed we dont write citations when no crime has occured.

you just accused this officer of making a false arrest.

Again you have no idea if a crime was committed because u dont know the cities ordicnances.

even withotu the cities ordiances iams ure it falls undet the state definition. You just dont think a crime happeend because you dont agree with it. I arrest people everyday for crimes i may not agree with but its still a crime.
Just because you dont like it dont make it anyless illegal.
 
i hate case law as i feel one case should not affect all as each should be case by case but anyways

New Jersey v. T. L. O., 469 U.S. 325 (1985), held that searches in public schools do not require warrants, as long as the searching officers have reasonable grounds for believing that the search will result in the finding of evidence of illegal activity.

the officer stated numerous times in the report he saw her trying to hide somthing in her sleeve and moved it around her body under her shirt. so he had grounds to belive the item in question being contraband in the school and being directly related tot he disturbance would be found with said search.
 
Being able to be searched for a cell phone for disorderly conduct is like being able to have your house searched without consent or probable cause for drugs for throwing a noisy party. It just isn't legal. Period.

I'm saying that the girl probably gave consent. Had she respectfully declined consent, no police officer could have legally searched her body for a cell phone without a warrant.

I never said she was arrested illegally, I said that had she not consented to a search, she was frisked illegally. You can be arrested legally much easier than you can be searched legally, without consent.

You are continuing to prove to me that most police officers can be individuals with chips on their shoulder, a bad attitude, and limited understanding of the extent of their power.... I was never trying to be rude, and yet you continue to insult me and use ad hominem arguments against me.
 
thing is that law is REALLY being stretched here.

cell phone use is NOT illegal. Disruption of class, also not illegal, lying... well thats a state by state issue but usually not illegal, lying to police IS usually illegal. But still a non consensual search is unwarranted simply due to the fact that the activity in question and the item is not illegal by state/federal law. a school rule/policy such as no cell phones or no cell usage is in place that is a local rule policy, NOT a state/federal upheld law which would allow the use of law enforcement.

so yes warrants are not necessary but the search was illegal due to no illegal activity or items being involved. and furthmore as i brought up before, disturbing class is NOT a case of public disturbance, not to the level of law enforcement.

again this whole thing is bullshit and just more destruction of America. Stay tuned, we'll be tazed for accidental littering or cursing next.
 
Honestly, I agree that she shouldn't have been texting but, was this really called for? An arrest with criminal charges? Whatever happened to detention or ISS? Did she harass or assault the teacher in anyway? Besides she is only 14 I mean damn, this seems a bit extreme.
 
It pisses me off how much power public schools have. The young lady's parents would get jail time, just like everyone else, if they didn't let the government steal their money. Schools shouldn't even be able to "confiscate" someone's phone. That's stealing. You can suspend someone for using such devices during class (although if I were a teacher I would just order the rest of the class to ignore, so I wouldn't have to waste the time and not have to disrupt the lesson by writing up a referral form and sending the student to the office). I seriously hope the ACLU sooner takes more schools to court
over all the civil liberties that school boards violate, such as mid-thigh rules, and beating the shit out of students, just because the teacher is feeling aggressive. On average, I must have seen ~1.3 incidents per year (from 2nd grade, 1995, to 12th grade, 2005) where teachers used unnecessary force. They could even hit a student back AFTER a student quit hitting them, and could also sue that student, even if they punched the teacher light as shit.

Don't get me wrong about the ACLU, as I don't believe in advocating government-forced integration on private property, but the ACLU is needed a LOT more than the majority of people allow.

The punishments just keep getting more numerous and more fucked up. The Constitution intended for people to only get punished if they deprived someone of life, liberty, or property and caused the victim harm.
 
Did anybody happen to go to the school websit mentioned in the article?
Head on over to the school website and read the Student Handbook for the school mentioned in the article?
In the handbook there is this:
ELECTRONIC DEVICES (WISCONSIN STATE STATUTE 118.258)/MUSIC
AND MEDIA DEVICES
It is illegal for students to possess or use any beepers, electronic paging or two
way communication devices while on premises owned, rented, or under the
control of a school. This includes cellular phones and recording devices. In
addition to being illegal, as outlined above, Electronic/Music/Media devices may
be disruptive to the educational process. Students are entitled to a safe
atmosphere, free from noise and distractions.
and elsewhere in the handbook:
Such behavior may, in the determination of the teacher, warrant removal because of its interference with the ability of others to learn effectively.
and this:
The expectations for student behavior as outlined in the school’s student
handbook will be explained and discussed with the students at the
beginning of each school year. Administrators will review the handbook
requirements with students. Students will initial that they have received
their handbook.
The student violated the rules as set by the school and the school board of that district. You may not like it and think it sucks but the school made these rules for a reason.
It even states that the student is given a copy of said handbook and had to put their initials to signify they received it. The point is that it was made available to the students.

According to the report, it sounds like if the student had confessed to having the phone in the first place, then everything might have been fine.
Since the student persisted in lying repeatedly and the Officer sounded like he had reason for suspicion (as stated in the report), then it escalated.

Now, before the flames start in my direction, I am neither for nor against the action taken in this case.
This information is posted to provide some factual data so that all sides may be properly informed as to the reasons things happened the way they did in that incident.

Ok, I'm off to don my Nomex suit... :cool:
 
Texting in class is no more disorderly than taking notes in class. Hell, taking notes is probably noisier.

The teacher, school principal, and police officers should all be shitcanned.
 
The student violated the rules as set by the school and the school board of that district. You may not like it and think it sucks but the school made these rules for a reason.
It even states that the student is given a copy of said handbook and had to put their initials to signify they received it. The point is that it was made available to the students.

The rules were clearly designed so that students would not be disruptive in class by using noisy electronics. Texting can be done quietly and without disturbing fellow students. Anyone who says texting in class is any more disturbing than whispering to the student next to you, or even doodling on one's notebook, is a bit confused.

The sanity check for any law is to compare it to common fucking sense. Was the student impairing anyone elses ability to learn? Nope. On the other hand, the overreaction by school officials probably caused more disruption than anything.
 
The rules were clearly designed so that students would not be disruptive in class by using noisy electronics. Texting can be done quietly and without disturbing fellow students. Anyone who says texting in class is any more disturbing than whispering to the student next to you, or even doodling on one's notebook, is a bit confused.

The sanity check for any law is to compare it to common fucking sense. Was the student impairing anyone elses ability to learn? Nope. On the other hand, the overreaction by school officials probably caused more disruption than anything.

Then why go to school in the first place? They removed her from the class and the police got involved because of her attitude.

You live by the rules or you leave making your own rules. She wanted to live but without the rules.
 
Being able to be searched for a cell phone for disorderly conduct is like being able to have your house searched without consent or probable cause for drugs for throwing a noisy party. It just isn't legal. Period.

I'm saying that the girl probably gave consent. Had she respectfully declined consent, no police officer could have legally searched her body for a cell phone without a warrant.

I never said she was arrested illegally, I said that had she not consented to a search, she was frisked illegally. You can be arrested legally much easier than you can be searched legally, without consent.

You are continuing to prove to me that most police officers can be individuals with chips on their shoulder, a bad attitude, and limited understanding of the extent of their power.... I was never trying to be rude, and yet you continue to insult me and use ad hominem arguments against me.

She wasn't on her private property, the analogy to a house is complete nonsense. There are signs all over every public school out there "anyone on this premises is subject to search at any time." If you don't like it, pay for your own schooling at a private school.

There is no consent needed, she was on public property, and (probably) lying to a police officer.

I think you're the one with the chip on your shoulder. I'm not an Officer, just a college student, and I agree with dajet24. Where is there an ad hominem in his post, do you even know what that means? I see nothing insulting your person in his posts, he's just disagreeing with you. In fact, calling most officers of the law "individuals with chips on their shoulder, a bad attitude, and limited understanding of the extent of their power" seems more personally insulting to his/their line of work than anything in his posts was to you.

On the subject of the OP:
There are far too many asshole students in public schools now, who know they can do whatever they want and essentially get away with it. However, the system has something to do with it, forcing 100% of all kids to go to school until a certain age. Obviously there are going to be bad apples everywhere, so why force them to mix in the exact same classrooms as people who actually feel like learning?
 
Then why go to school in the first place? They removed her from the class and the police got involved because of her attitude.

You live by the rules or you leave making your own rules. She wanted to live but without the rules.

if i recall correctly without parental consent it is in fact illegal to skip school. I'm not sure why something that should be considered a privilege is made mandatory, definitely a law that needs a hard look (like school is not mandatory but without school you lose certain benefits etc). As for attitude, still not a police level offense, never should be under any circumstance, if i tell someone to **** off and suck my **** you piece of ****, its crude, but not illegal, or should not be. if i strike, or otherwise harm then you enter into possible law territory.

as for the second part. I have spent my life making my own rules. Thats not to sound badass or anything, because i'm definitely not...but I have always felt that no one should have any control over me except for myself, and just stuck to that. So yeah, i've left places, included decent paying jobs because they could not align themselves with my own rules for living. I think it should be perfectly acceptable to choose not to follow the rules. You may miss some benefits but gain others.
 
you self righteous anti-government types need to shut the fuck up. Typical of your type, trying to shift the attention and the blame from everyone but the girl who was involved.

for the billionth fucking time

SHE WASNT ARRESTED FOR TEXTING, SHE WAS ARRESTED BECAUSE SHE MADE SUCH A BIG FUCKING DEAL ABOUT IT, LIED TO EVERYONE AND WAS DESTROYING THE LEARNING ENVIRONMENT

can we make it any more simple? Did you even READ the article? She broke the school rule about using a phone during class. You can bicker all you want that kids should have the right to use their phones during class, but thats all a crock o shit and you know it. They dont have the right to do that, its not a right, so shut up and learn. Im not paying to provide a place where a bunch of acne riddled teenyboppers can text about who got drunk, who got laid, and who doesnt give a fuck anymore. You're there to learn, learn damnit, or look like you are learning if you want to be a "rebel" and fight the system.

Since she wants to act like shes all grown up, what the fuck do you think would happen if she had an office job some where, was always texting, then the boss came down told her not to, to get to work, she tells the boss to FUCK OFF. what would happen? she'd be fired. You all want to give her the rights of a tax paying adult, then fine, she has to answer up to the rules and laws of society then. She tried to burn the system, dont come crying to me when she gets burned. Rules/Laws are there for a reason, to keep some semblance of order. Are all rules/laws smart or do they make sense? Fuck no, but if we got rid of all rules so you "free souls" can live your free lives away from the man, we'd all be fucked.

Anyways, why does she need to be texting? So what if the school systems are all fucked up, she can learn SOMETHING by paying attention rather than texting, no matter how irrelevant it may seem. And learning anything will help to make you a more well rounded person, even if you forget it, learning things always betters you.

You are quick to blame the gov't or the schools, but think about it. No gov't is perfect, no school system is perfect, and with over 350 MILLION people to cater to, you will never have a perfect anything. IT not possible. The gov't will shit on you sooner or later, its supposed to happen, its going to happen. What they do is keep 350 MILLION people form shitting all over themselves, their neighbors, their country. Yea, the schools are pretty sad right now, but its much better than allowing all the teens in the country to spend all day texting and teaching themselves, we'd be fucked in the future. Does it need reform? Yes, our schools need help, but damnit, until that happens, they are the best alternitive we have and we need to be using them to our best, not letting kids do stupid shit like this. Just because its flawed doesnt mean its not the best option we have to use right now.

And to the chap that says he's sick of how much power our schools have has NO CLUE what the fuck he's talking about. Our schools have no power against a generation of shitty parents that dont want to be parents and when anything goes anything but perfect, they sue just as much as they breed. School's are POWERLESS now adays, face it.

TO all the nut jobs here that are trying to blame the schools or the gov't or what not, I ask you this, will you get into a dialogue with me involving only those involved?

CAST
The 2 or so police officers (we'll use one male one female for this test)
The teacher
The principle
The girl
The girl's parents (who shouldnt even be playing because obviously they havnt done shit to parent this girl, but I know if I dont put this here you'll whine and bitch that this isnt fair)

Pick a role (obviously, anyone but the girl) and tell me what you would have done differently in this scenario and I'll tell you why it wouldnt work.

Try me, I dare ya, and you'll see 3 things
1: The girl is to blame. PERIOD.
2: The cops were a last ditch effort.
3: The schools are POWERLESS

Just fucking try me, this is getting beyond stupid with the shit some of you are spewing, and on a side note, personal thanks from me and my brothers in arms to all the law enforcement or related jobs that have posted here, you keep us going!
 
for the billionth fucking time

SHE WASNT ARRESTED FOR TEXTING, SHE WAS ARRESTED BECAUSE SHE MADE SUCH A BIG FUCKING DEAL ABOUT IT, LIED TO EVERYONE AND WAS DESTROYING THE LEARNING ENVIRONMENT


you are right the right is most certainly at fault. That is not in question. The question is how it was handled. Simply put from a legal standpoint. Destroying a learning environment is not illegal... and a lawyer would have a field day with it. Lying, also in most cases NOT illegal. Making a big deal about things, also not illegal.

so it's not as simple as you want to make it.

You are right the schools have little power, a problem for sure.
This could have been handled with expulsion. BUT because for whatever idiotic reason enrollment is mandatory, they can't just boot her.

the point I think most people are trying to make is a valid one. Simply put, Arrest was not warranted for this type of infraction...period.
 
the point I think most people are trying to make is a valid one. Simply put, Arrest was not warranted for this type of infraction...period.

And as someone who used to work in the educational system, I disagree, strongly.

As long as liberal wanker pussies demand that everyone deserves an education, we have to put up with shithead kids like this. If it were up to me, id throw their non-wanting to learn asses out, and they can spend their lives in the coal mine or flipping burgers.
 
you are right the right is most certainly at fault. That is not in question. The question is how it was handled. Simply put from a legal standpoint. Destroying a learning environment is not illegal... and a lawyer would have a field day with it. Lying, also in most cases NOT illegal. Making a big deal about things, also not illegal.

so it's not as simple as you want to make it.

You are right the schools have little power, a problem for sure.
This could have been handled with expulsion. BUT because for whatever idiotic reason enrollment is mandatory, they can't just boot her.

the point I think most people are trying to make is a valid one. Simply put, Arrest was not warranted for this type of infraction...period.

You don't know the girl. Nobody can make the judgment these people made. I'm fairly sure that calling the police isn't the first thing they do when students get out of line, or we'd be hearing about this more often.
 
And as someone who used to work in the educational system, I disagree, strongly.

As long as liberal wanker pussies demand that everyone deserves an education, we have to put up with shithead kids like this. If it were up to me, id throw their non-wanting to learn asses out, and they can spend their lives in the coal mine or flipping burgers.


I still disagree about the arrest, but we are on the same page with the second part. If you don't want to be there why waste the time. I mentioned earlier i didn't particularly learn a lot from some of my classes, but if nothing else it gave me quiet reading time.

what it really boils down to is if someone doesn't want to be in school they shouldn't have to be, and they should also have the ability to lose the privilege if they fuck up.

Then again... arrests over stupid shit like this wouldn't happen.

Oh and just for point of reference at seeing things from different angles. I was also in education for a while, though not in a high school level.
 
I think you're the one with the chip on your shoulder. I'm not an Officer, just a college student, and I agree with dajet24. Where is there an ad hominem in his post, do you even know what that means? I see nothing insulting your person in his posts, he's just disagreeing with you.

Sorry, but Big Brother (police are the tools of the government) cannot search you for "practically anything." If you think that should be the case, then you're wrong, wrong, wrong. Mentalities like this are what America used to stand against. In fact, we became a nation because our people took a stand against unwarranted government intrusion. Now America's just becoming a nation of personal over-regulation.

@DustMite: You totally schooled me. Thanks for the update on the laws. I don't belive that law was put in place in Wisconsin when I attended high school there, so I didn't know about it. I disagree with that law that makes it illegal for students to posses a phone or electronic device at school, and question whether it would really hold up to close scrutiny in a legal case, but this information allows the police officer to have legally searched the girl for the phone.
 
And by the way, Russ, I'm not in the habit of using expressions I do not understand. I'm not sure what your point was there, since you admit he does use ad hominem. :rolleyes:
 
Did anybody happen to go to the school websit mentioned in the article?
Head on over to the school website and read the Student Handbook for the school mentioned in the article?
In the handbook there is this:

and elsewhere in the handbook:
and this:
The student violated the rules as set by the school and the school board of that district. You may not like it and think it sucks but the school made these rules for a reason.
It even states that the student is given a copy of said handbook and had to put their initials to signify they received it. The point is that it was made available to the students.

According to the report, it sounds like if the student had confessed to having the phone in the first place, then everything might have been fine.
Since the student persisted in lying repeatedly and the Officer sounded like he had reason for suspicion (as stated in the report), then it escalated.

Now, before the flames start in my direction, I am neither for nor against the action taken in this case.
This information is posted to provide some factual data so that all sides may be properly informed as to the reasons things happened the way they did in that incident.

Ok, I'm off to don my Nomex suit... :cool:
Those Laws are Unconstitutional and are in blatant, direct violation of the Bill of Rights. I have no fucking clue how public schools get around doing stupid shit like this.

She wasn't on her private property, the analogy to a house is complete nonsense. There are signs all over every public school out there "anyone on this premises is subject to search at any time." If you don't like it, pay for your own schooling at a private school.

There is no consent needed, she was on public property, and (probably) lying to a police officer.

I think you're the one with the chip on your shoulder. I'm not an Officer, just a college student, and I agree with dajet24. Where is there an ad hominem in his post, do you even know what that means? I see nothing insulting your person in his posts, he's just disagreeing with you. In fact, calling most officers of the law "individuals with chips on their shoulder, a bad attitude, and limited understanding of the extent of their power" seems more personally insulting to his/their line of work than anything in his posts was to you.

On the subject of the OP:
There are far too many asshole students in public schools now, who know they can do whatever they want and essentially get away with it. However, the system has something to do with it, forcing 100% of all kids to go to school until a certain age. Obviously there are going to be bad apples everywhere, so why force them to mix in the exact same classrooms as people who actually feel like learning?
Public school isn't free. Her parents paid to send her there through both state AND federal taxes. And most (as in >50%) of cops DO have bad attitudes and do far more bad than good.

if i recall correctly without parental consent it is in fact illegal to skip school. I'm not sure why something that should be considered a privilege is made mandatory, definitely a law that needs a hard look (like school is not mandatory but without school you lose certain benefits etc). As for attitude, still not a police level offense, never should be under any circumstance, if i tell someone to **** off and suck my **** you piece of ****, its crude, but not illegal, or should not be. if i strike, or otherwise harm then you enter into possible law territory.

as for the second part. I have spent my life making my own rules. Thats not to sound badass or anything, because i'm definitely not...but I have always felt that no one should have any control over me except for myself, and just stuck to that. So yeah, i've left places, included decent paying jobs because they could not align themselves with my own rules for living. I think it should be perfectly acceptable to choose not to follow the rules. You may miss some benefits but gain others.
I agree 100%. She didn't harm a damn soul.
you self righteous anti-government types need to shut the fuck up. Typical of your type, trying to shift the attention and the blame from everyone but the girl who was involved.

for the billionth fucking time

SHE WASNT ARRESTED FOR TEXTING, SHE WAS ARRESTED BECAUSE SHE MADE SUCH A BIG FUCKING DEAL ABOUT IT, LIED TO EVERYONE AND WAS DESTROYING THE LEARNING ENVIRONMENT

can we make it any more simple? Did you even READ the article? She broke the school rule about using a phone during class. You can bicker all you want that kids should have the right to use their phones during class, but thats all a crock o shit and you know it. They dont have the right to do that, its not a right, so shut up and learn. Im not paying to provide a place where a bunch of acne riddled teenyboppers can text about who got drunk, who got laid, and who doesnt give a fuck anymore. You're there to learn, learn damnit, or look like you are learning if you want to be a "rebel" and fight the system.

Since she wants to act like shes all grown up, what the fuck do you think would happen if she had an office job some where, was always texting, then the boss came down told her not to, to get to work, she tells the boss to FUCK OFF. what would happen? she'd be fired. You all want to give her the rights of a tax paying adult, then fine, she has to answer up to the rules and laws of society then. She tried to burn the system, dont come crying to me when she gets burned. Rules/Laws are there for a reason, to keep some semblance of order. Are all rules/laws smart or do they make sense? Fuck no, but if we got rid of all rules so you "free souls" can live your free lives away from the man, we'd all be fucked.

Anyways, why does she need to be texting? So what if the school systems are all fucked up, she can learn SOMETHING by paying attention rather than texting, no matter how irrelevant it may seem. And learning anything will help to make you a more well rounded person, even if you forget it, learning things always betters you.

You are quick to blame the gov't or the schools, but think about it. No gov't is perfect, no school system is perfect, and with over 350 MILLION people to cater to, you will never have a perfect anything. IT not possible. The gov't will shit on you sooner or later, its supposed to happen, its going to happen. What they do is keep 350 MILLION people form shitting all over themselves, their neighbors, their country. Yea, the schools are pretty sad right now, but its much better than allowing all the teens in the country to spend all day texting and teaching themselves, we'd be fucked in the future. Does it need reform? Yes, our schools need help, but damnit, until that happens, they are the best alternitive we have and we need to be using them to our best, not letting kids do stupid shit like this. Just because its flawed doesnt mean its not the best option we have to use right now.

And to the chap that says he's sick of how much power our schools have has NO CLUE what the fuck he's talking about. Our schools have no power against a generation of shitty parents that dont want to be parents and when anything goes anything but perfect, they sue just as much as they breed. School's are POWERLESS now adays, face it.

TO all the nut jobs here that are trying to blame the schools or the gov't or what not, I ask you this, will you get into a dialogue with me involving only those involved?

CAST
The 2 or so police officers (we'll use one male one female for this test)
The teacher
The principle
The girl
The girl's parents (who shouldnt even be playing because obviously they havnt done shit to parent this girl, but I know if I dont put this here you'll whine and bitch that this isnt fair)

Pick a role (obviously, anyone but the girl) and tell me what you would have done differently in this scenario and I'll tell you why it wouldnt work.

Try me, I dare ya, and you'll see 3 things
1: The girl is to blame. PERIOD.
2: The cops were a last ditch effort.
3: The schools are POWERLESS

Just fucking try me, this is getting beyond stupid with the shit some of you are spewing, and on a side note, personal thanks from me and my brothers in arms to all the law enforcement or related jobs that have posted here, you keep us going!
Um, you're f-bombing like this and you're criticizing anti-government people, like myself, who support your inalienable right to do so 100%.
 
Back
Top