MacBook - Proprietary Hard Drive?

LithiumRage158

Limp Gawd
Joined
Jan 18, 2006
Messages
273
Exactly as the thread name says - Does the MacBook use a proprietary Hard Drive? This is probably a stupid question, but I'd rather be safe than sorry. I can't find the answer anywhere else. I've been thinking about upgrading the existing Hard Drive in the computer to a 500 gig, and wanted to know before I drop $100 on it.

Thanks!
 
those are only on pre order right now, only n option if you're not looking for an upgrade sooner.
 
not sure if its still true, but the hd in my old g4 ibook had pegs on the side. These made it so I couldn't use the hd in anything else, but, I could use any hard drive in it's place in the ibook.
 
Version 3: Those pegs can be taken of with a standard Hex screwdriver... :D
 
I'm more of a Maxtor/Seagate fan myself, as I've had some bad dealings with Western Digital... However, I never even took the whole power consumption/performance thing into consideration... Didn't even think about it :p

Thank you all for the help... I'll probably go for a 5200 RPM Seagate. Would I really tell much of a difference between 5400 and 7200 RPM? I don't play alot of games, just World of Warcraft really... I don't run any applications that would need it, but it'd be nice to have.
 
That's kind of the point? You can either go for higher performance or better battery life. I'm confused by your statement :confused:
Or get a SSD, for both.

(As an aside, when writing acronyms in english, should you use "an" vs "a" according to the pronunciation of the first letter of the acronym, or the pronunciation of the word being abbreviated?)
 
That's kind of the point? You can either go for higher performance or better battery life. I'm confused by your statement :confused:

The 7200.4 uses less power at both seek and idle when compared to the WD Scorpio Blue.

7200.4
Power (W)
Seek, Typical 1.554
Idle, Typical 0.67

WD SB
Power Dissipation
Read/Write 2.50 Watts
Idle 0.85 Watts
Standby 0.25 Watts
Sleep 0.10 Watts
 
The 7200.4 uses less power at both seek and idle when compared to the WD Scorpio Blue.

7200.4
Power (W)
Seek, Typical 1.554
Idle, Typical 0.67

WD SB
Power Dissipation
Read/Write 2.50 Watts
Idle 0.85 Watts
Standby 0.25 Watts
Sleep 0.10 Watts

I find it incredibly hard to believe that a 7200RPM drive has better power consumption stats than a 5400RPM drive considering they're both two platter drives. Mark me down in the "skeptical" column.

WD 500GB Blue (WD5000BEVT):
claimed idle = 0.85W, actual idle = 0.78W
claimed max = 2.50W, actual max = 2.62W

Seagate 5400.4 250GB (ST9250827AS):
claimed idle = 0.60W, actual idle = 1.00W
claimed max = 2.00W, actual max = 3.70W

Seagate 7200.3 320GB (ST9320421AS):
claimed idle = 0.75, actual idle = 0.95W
claimed max = 2.3W, actual max = 3.03W

I realize that the 5400.4 is not the 7200.4, but imo, it shows Seagate has a bit of an issue with calculating their power consumption stats. I mean, for god's sake, the actual values are almost TWO TIMES what Seagate claims it to be. It's shady stuff like this that fuck over the people who just believe the manufacturer and don't do any research beyond that.

Sources are wd.com, seagate.com, and tomshardware.com (the 2.5" hard drive charts).
 
not sure if its still true, but the hd in my old g4 ibook had pegs on the side. These made it so I couldn't use the hd in anything else, but, I could use any hard drive in it's place in the ibook.

Those pegs came off so you could put them on the replacement drive.

I've done it at least a 100 times(was a laptop tech).

OP yea any standard 2.5 inch sata drive.
 
if only the seagate drive is actually available... I'd probably still go for the wd blue, if I was going to play the waiting game for a 7200rpm drive, I'd wait for a 500GB scorpio black from WD
 
I have a question.

The Macbook hard drive has a sudden motion sensor that is controlled by the OS. Do replacement drives continue this functionality? I know some drives have SMS, but do they work with the OS?
 
I have a question.

The Macbook hard drive has a sudden motion sensor that is controlled by the OS. Do replacement drives continue this functionality? I know some drives have SMS, but do they work with the OS?

The sensor should be built into the notebook and really have nothing to do with the drive other than it telling the board to turn the drive off.
 
(As an aside, when writing acronyms in english, should you use "an" vs "a" according to the pronunciation of the first letter of the acronym, or the pronunciation of the word being abbreviated?)

In English as far as I know you us "an" whenever the following word begins with a vowel, an h that is not pronounced. As far as acronyms its based off of how it sounds like you suggested. If when you say it it sounds like a vowel starts it then yes you use "an" so let say you MRI well you would use AN MRI because MRI is pronounced like "em ar eye" for SSD you would probably use an SSD because "es es dee"
 
In English as far as I know you us "an" whenever the following word begins with a vowel, an h that is not pronounced. As far as acronyms its based off of how it sounds like you suggested. If when you say it it sounds like a vowel starts it then yes you use "an" so let say you MRI well you would use AN MRI because MRI is pronounced like "em ar eye" for SSD you would probably use an SSD because "es es dee"

QFT. It's phoenetic - if it sounds like a vowel, then you use "an."
 
In English as far as I know you us "an" whenever the following word begins with a vowel, an h that is not pronounced. As far as acronyms its based off of how it sounds like you suggested. If when you say it it sounds like a vowel starts it then yes you use "an" so let say you MRI well you would use AN MRI because MRI is pronounced like "em ar eye" for SSD you would probably use an SSD because "es es dee"
Well, that's the thing:♥do you say Ess Ess Dee, or do you write SSD and say Solid State Drive? If I'm talking and I say Ess Ess Dee, it would obviously be an, but in writing you have no way of knowing the reader will "expand" the acronym or not.
 
The sensor should be built into the notebook and really have nothing to do with the drive other than it telling the board to turn the drive off.

It is in the HDD actually. But if the drive has it the Mac will most likely support it. I replaced my 7k200 with a 7k320 and it worked fine.
 
hard drives are standard in all computers, you can use any hard drive in any computer as long as you have compatible hardware.
 
Back
Top