Valve: Pirates Are Just Underserved Customers

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Speaking at the Game Business Law summit, Valve’s Jason Holtman said that his company sees pirates as underserved customers. Yes, you read that correctly….”underserved customers.” Thanks to Oldie for this one!

The final sacred cow that Holtman took a stab at was the issue of piracy. "There's a big business feeling that there's piracy," he says. But the truth is: "Pirates are underserved customers."
 
He didn't mention piracy in the States though. He made the statement that in Russia, they had to wait at least 6 months for a game that is released in the US, so because people are watching commercials and reading about this game, instead of waiting 6 months, they just pirate it.

Now since they have made sure they release the game at the same time there as in the US, as well as releasing it via digital distribution, the piracy rate in that country has dropped.
 
Are there that many games that we in the states have to wait for? The only games I can really think of off the top of my head is the Final Fantasy series, or other japanese games.
 
i can't comment for foreigners, but speaking as an american, and for americans, a pirate is usually simply someone that wants a new game without paying for it..

*used to pirate games like crazy before i graduated college....

that is all
 
is that the fat guy that works at valve?
Hah. No, that's Gabe Newell, who I refer to as the Anti-Steve Jobs (Jobs gets thinner, Newell gets heavier, etc.). Newell is one of Valve's co-founders.
 
Correct me if I am wrong, but the biggest pirates are Russia and China. I can see them pirating games just for the fact they can not get them, just like the aussie's do with banned or censored games in their country.

Those who give up freedom for temporary safety deserve neither.
 
Remember Doom 3?

One week (or was it two?) between US and EU releases. Would have been far less arr mateying going on if it had been a couple of days and not a week.

See console games. We gotta wait forever for most games to get released here just because Germany Spain and France are too proud of themselves to learn English. Another world war might set them right.
 
At least one company has realized that rather than attacking pirates they should attempt to get them to pay something, anything, for their game. Steam is rather marketing savvy using price discrimination, demos, ddl, and concurrent releases to encourage pirates to purchase. I figure if Steam can work in some excellent downloadable content and offer it over Steam they could add even more reasons to buy your games via Steam.

Add value and you get pirates to purchase, attack pirates and you make them feel defensive. At least Valve gets it.
 
i can't comment for foreigners, but speaking as an american, and for americans, a pirate is usually simply someone that wants a new game without paying for it..

*used to pirate games like crazy before i graduated college....

that is all

Like mentioned by someone else though, for many PC gamers, it's just plain difficult to purchase games locally. I don't live in the US or Canada, and the only place I can buy PC games is one or two department stores for the most part... they sell them for a decent price, but for the last 6 months the only games that have been available are Mass Effect, Assassin's Creed for a while... Turok, and a few other games I would never play.

If it wasn't for things like Steam and Direct2Download, the only choice for many would be to pirate just to PLAY the games they want to play on PC.
 
yup, thats why i speak generally for american consumers.... no comment for others....

once steam/other direct download services become ubiquitous, even this excuse (however valid/invalid) will fall by the wayside.....
 
I think Steam has done leaps and bounds against piracy, if solely for the fact it provides a way to play whatever you buy anywhere you want to and not have to wait, worry about discs or DRM or what not.
 
Honestly steam is one of the best ways to combat piracy and more distributors should follow suit.
 
At least one company has realized that rather than attacking pirates they should attempt to get them to pay something, anything, for their game. Steam is rather marketing savvy using price discrimination, demos, ddl, and concurrent releases to encourage pirates to purchase. I figure if Steam can work in some excellent downloadable content and offer it over Steam they could add even more reasons to buy your games via Steam.

Add value and you get pirates to purchase, attack pirates and you make them feel defensive. At least Valve gets it.

This.
 
Too bad they actions is exactly the opposite of this article. Steam is right now the most expensive game store in Europe. And no, i don't talk about 1-2 euros (yes, Steam in non-UK europe uses Euros). I talk about much higher numbers.

For example, Red Alert 3, Mass Effect and Dead Space together :
1) local store 1 - 105-115 euros total depending which version of Red Alert 3 is choosen (localised Czech is 10 euros cheaper than the english version)
2) local store 2 - 124 euros
3) Steam - 139 euros

So it is more expensive than the damn retail. And we even didn't started to talk about comparison to US Steam :
1) US Steam without VAT - $99.98
2) Euro Steam without our local VAT (19%) converted to USD using current exchange ratio - $150.

So yes, let's pay 50% more than US, yes let's pay 12-30% more than retail - that is the way Valve and Steam fights piracy.

And best is that he says this :
From the outset, we knew we had customers worldwide," says Holtman.

Yes, they had customers worldwide. But in Europe, they lost many customers. Heck, even their own games are cheaper in retail, so i will buy HL2E3 or their next game in retail store and activate it on Steam.
 
At least one company has realized that rather than attacking pirates they should attempt to get them to pay something, anything, for their game. Steam is rather marketing savvy using price discrimination, demos, ddl, and concurrent releases to encourage pirates to purchase. I figure if Steam can work in some excellent downloadable content and offer it over Steam they could add even more reasons to buy your games via Steam.

Add value and you get pirates to purchase, attack pirates and you make them feel defensive. At least Valve gets it.
true
 
Too bad they actions is exactly the opposite of this article. Steam is right now the most expensive game store in Europe. And no, i don't talk about 1-2 euros (yes, Steam in non-UK europe uses Euros). I talk about much higher numbers.

For example, Red Alert 3, Mass Effect and Dead Space together :
1) local store 1 - 105-115 euros total depending which version of Red Alert 3 is choosen (localised Czech is 10 euros cheaper than the english version)
2) local store 2 - 124 euros
3) Steam - 139 euros

So it is more expensive than the damn retail. And we even didn't started to talk about comparison to US Steam :
1) US Steam without VAT - $99.98
2) Euro Steam without our local VAT (19%) converted to USD using current exchange ratio - $150.

So yes, let's pay 50% more than US, yes let's pay 12-30% more than retail - that is the way Valve and Steam fights piracy.

And best is that he says this :
From the outset, we knew we had customers worldwide," says Holtman.

Yes, they had customers worldwide. But in Europe, they lost many customers. Heck, even their own games are cheaper in retail, so i will buy HL2E3 or their next game in retail store and activate it on Steam.

They're probably caving under pressure by your local retailers or some stupid law if they're doing that. It wouldn't make sense that they do reasonable pricing everywhere else, if not the same as retail shelf price at worst, but where you're at, they jack things up above retail shelf pricing.
 
They're probably caving under pressure by your local retailers or some stupid law if they're doing that. It wouldn't make sense that they do reasonable pricing everywhere else, if not the same as retail shelf price at worst, but where you're at, they jack things up above retail shelf pricing.

Local retailers have no influence and they are not forced to do this by any law. They are now breaking law by not allowing us to use GB version of their store (which have much better prices) and as a result they might get pretty high fine from EU - not nearly as high as MS but enough to hurt them....

 
Another example of stupid Steam prices

FlatOut: Ultimate Carnage
US: 20$
EU: 40€ (~55$)

 
Another example of stupid Steam prices

FlatOut: Ultimate Carnage
US: 20$
EU: 40€ (~55$)


Ouch, that's too bad... most of the rest of the world just has to pay the conversion to dollars. Unfortunately for me the Peso is almost 14 to the dollar right now :mad:
 
Ouch, that's too bad... most of the rest of the world just has to pay the conversion to dollars. Unfortunately for me the Peso is almost 14 to the dollar right now :mad:

Yeah and this is not just here - these prices are for entire EU except GB :mad::rolleyes:.

 
They're probably caving under pressure by your local retailers or some stupid law if they're doing that. It wouldn't make sense that they do reasonable pricing everywhere else, if not the same as retail shelf price at worst, but where you're at, they jack things up above retail shelf pricing.

No laws involved. As someone noted, they are actually breaking a EU law by not allowing us to buy in UK store. Apple (iTunes) learned this hard way, maybe Valve needs to be kicked too to wake up.
 
No laws involved. As someone noted, they are actually breaking a EU law by not allowing us to buy in UK store. Apple (iTunes) learned this hard way, maybe Valve needs to be kicked too to wake up.

You can buy from a UK store... Get in your car, and go to a game store in the UK. :p
 
Sorry I didn't look at his profile to see he lived in Slovakia until he posted that. Maybe they are charging you smug bastards for making fun of Americans so much?

lol I meant I didn't look at his profile until you posted that. No edit FTW?
 
Another example of stupid Steam prices

FlatOut: Ultimate Carnage
US: 20$
EU: 40€ (~55$)


please correct me if this is a stupid question...

but can the EU customers just register as american customers? hmm... on second thought, maybe not.... considering during payment you have to put your residential details in for CC authentication....

what about gift cards?

(1) purchase gift card
(2) purchase steam game, register as an american, living in america
(3) ????
(4) profit (?)
 
Heh, I bought Orange Box about 3 months ago and still have not played it once. Why? I have no choice in my area to use dial-up 56k. The way Steam tries ever so hard to reduce people pirating has made Episode 1 and 2 100% unplayable for me. I finally gave up trying to update after I nearly broke the disc over the throbbing vein in my forehead.

The game needs an update to play.
I try update, and get an error after about 10 minutes.
I try to play in offline mode.
This game cannot be played it offline mode without updating.

Anyone want a broken Orange Box disc? I guess my broken disc paid for someones pirated version.

Give me a break Valve. I wonder why I haven't bought Left 4 Dead, or any other steam game for that matter.

Thanks for reading.
 
Pretty sure I know people who pirated stuff that is easily attainable on the shelves, just it's a lot cheaper to download something rather than spend gas driving out and buying the game.


What pissed me off was Wrath of the Lich King was only available in stores and you couldn't upgrade your account online. :mad:
 
i can't comment for foreigners, but speaking as an american, and for americans, a pirate is usually simply someone that wants a new game without paying for it..

*used to pirate games like crazy before i graduated college....

that is all


Actually a guy that makes games got feedback in the last issue of PC Gamer, Most people who pirate games want to see how the game works when the demos are either too short or just don't exist, so you can't experience what the game features are like, 1/3 of the responses were just the reason you pointed out, or just did it because they could.
 
i can't comment for foreigners, but speaking as an american, and for americans, a pirate is usually simply someone that wants a new game without paying for it..

*used to pirate games like crazy before i graduated college....

that is all

actually pirates live on the sea's and pirate things... a US judge rules that "pirates" cant be called that official, as they are copyright infringers and most "pirates" have nothing in common with modern day pirates, like those who steal massive oil tanker ships :D


but i will say, pirate sounds a hella-LOT-betta!
 
Too bad they actions is exactly the opposite of this article. Steam is right now the most expensive game store in Europe. And no, i don't talk about 1-2 euros (yes, Steam in non-UK europe uses Euros). I talk about much higher numbers.

For example, Red Alert 3, Mass Effect and Dead Space together :
1) local store 1 - 105-115 euros total depending which version of Red Alert 3 is choosen (localised Czech is 10 euros cheaper than the english version)
2) local store 2 - 124 euros
3) Steam - 139 euros

So it is more expensive than the damn retail. And we even didn't started to talk about comparison to US Steam :
1) US Steam without VAT - $99.98
2) Euro Steam without our local VAT (19%) converted to USD using current exchange ratio - $150.

So yes, let's pay 50% more than US, yes let's pay 12-30% more than retail - that is the way Valve and Steam fights piracy.

And best is that he says this :
From the outset, we knew we had customers worldwide," says Holtman.

Yes, they had customers worldwide. But in Europe, they lost many customers. Heck, even their own games are cheaper in retail, so i will buy HL2E3 or their next game in retail store and activate it on Steam.

you know Steam does not set the prices, so this is not steam's fault, the game maker decides the prices of the games.
 
you know Steam does not set the prices, so this is not steam's fault, the game maker decides the prices of the games.

Ok. Then explain why Valve games are still sometimes more expensive at Steam than at retail ?

Left 4 Dead, Team Fortress 2 - both are more expensive than retail (around 3 euros more expensive). Ok, Orange Box is cheaper on Steam, but still - this is true for us in Slovakia. But how about Norway for example ? They have 0% VAT for digital downloads, yet they have same prices as us (oh, and they don't have Euro of course). So, for me it is 44.99 including 19% VAT. For they it is 44.99 including 0% VAT. Something bad smells here.

Too bad this pricing scheme is valid for most of Steam store, so simply Steam is not a good alternative now. Not in Europe. The only usable way now is to get a reliable UK/US friend, pay him via PayPal and let him gift you the game.
 
Actually a guy that makes games got feedback in the last issue of PC Gamer, Most people who pirate games want to see how the game works when the demos are either too short or just don't exist, so you can't experience what the game features are like, 1/3 of the responses were just the reason you pointed out, or just did it because they could.

eh, i still call bullshit on the people that say they download just to see how it will play.... 99% of the time, someone can get a pretty damn accurate picture of how a game will play if they just wait a day or two after the release of the game and see how the internet community reacts, and how people say a certain game plays on their particular system....

the people that use that excuse are either lying outright or lying to themselves (generally)
 
Back
Top