What strategy for external Hard Drive purchase?

Joined
Nov 15, 2003
Messages
35
Hi. I want to get an internal SATA hard drive for my external enclosure. For backup mainly. I need help with my two minds about it.

Thought 1: Since I'll be using it as a backup drive, space and reliability are the primary considerations. I don't want to 'over buy' for this drive but I want peace of mind.

Thought 2: On the other hand, it seems like the difference between a 250 GB drive and a 750 GB drive can be $25. And why should I go with a smaller drive when a larger, faster drive will have a longer useful life? Or will it? I was looking at newegg's deal on the SAMSUNG Spinpoint F1 HD753LJ 750GB 7200 RPM 32MB Cache SATA 3.0Gb/s Hard Drive - OEM and it seems like the larger drives may be less stable. This one anyway.

Any thoughts on the best course to take? Recommendations appreciated.
 
You know that the overall performance of your internal hard drive will be limited by the connection used by your external enclosure, right? Unless you have an enclosure that uses eSATA, expect to see some (comparative) slowdown.

Why do you believe that the Samsung HD753LJ is going to be less stable? If it's from reading the NewEgg reviews, take those with a grain of salt. Oftentimes those who write the reviews either don't know what they're talking about or don't say enough to justify their point (or both).

As long as you take care of the hard drive, you shouldn't have any longevity issues. With that said, get the amount that you feel like you need. For the purposes of simply backing up your data, though, you could get away with using a smaller capacity or slower hard drive (if it's cheaper).
 
eSata ftw. Basically, any drive over 640MB is going to max out USB 2.0 in xfer speeds.
 
usb2 is fast enough for pretty much everything except maybe taking a backup image of entire hard drive, but in that case everything but raid0 is slow. If you're only using it as backup storage, no need to fear usb is too slow.

Because usb is limiting the top speed anyway you don't need the fastest, noisiest and hottest drive, like Samsung F1. I have two WD Elemrnts 1TB usb hdds and they have this WD green power hd inside, and I must say, they run very cool. If I'd put my system drive (barracuda 7200.11) inside that case it would cook itself without cooling.

So I suggest to look for some "energy saving" hdd for that usb enclosure. They are slower, but usually for a reason.

E: manufacturer pages.
http://www.wdc.com/en/products/Products.asp?DriveID=498
http://www.wdc.com/en/products/Products.asp?DriveID=336
 
First batches of HDDs are always full of problematic drives, so I'd wait a while before buying any newly released drives. Therefore, go with a drive thats been on the market for at least a few months, since reliability is your main concern -- which should rule out the 1.5TB drives.

usb2 is fast enough for pretty much everything except maybe taking a backup image of entire hard drive, but in that case everything but raid0 is slow. If you're only using it as backup storage, no need to fear usb is too slow....
eSATA would be just as fast as an internal drive, whereas USB2.0 is much, much slower. Even if you're backing up large data files (gigabytes in size), USB2.0 is slow, IMO.

eSATA: up to 300MB/s, avg around 90MB/s (for newer drives) or 60MB/s (older/slower drives), depending on drive
USB2.0: up to 60MB/s, avg around 30MB/s (for both newer and older drives)

If you're backing up small amounts of data, USB2.0 is fine. If your enclosure is USB2.0 w/ passive cooling, I agree with novemberrain... get a Green Power WD drive.
 
Thought 2: On the other hand, it seems like the difference between a 250 GB drive and a 750 GB drive can be $25.

To answer this thought, I will say that there's always a "sweet spot" for hard drive purchases. Any drive smaller than the sweet spot will tend to be more expensive, and any drive larger than the sweet spot will also be more expensive since these are newer models.

Right now, the sweet spot is at the 1TB mark where prices are approximately 9cents/GB. A 250GB HDD for $50, by comparison, is more than twice as expensive per GB.

I wouldn't buy anything less than a 1TB drive right now, anything less is a waste of your money unless you are getting a spectacular deal.

As others have said, get a WD Green Power drive if your enclosure is USB, if your enclosure is eSATA then you should at least consider faster drives, although I'd still recommend the GP.
 
Thanks for the replies, everybody. I'll go with a WD green. I'm looking at the 640GB and the 1TB. How's that for sweet spot? At $70 (9.1 cents/GB) vs $120 (8.3 cents/GB), I'm still temped to go with the 640 and save $50. There's another 1TB WD green for $105 with 16MB cache. Or does the 32MB cache make the difference?

My enclose has USB2 and firewire 800 but my PC just has usb2 and fw400.
.

To answer this thought, I will say that there's always a "sweet spot" for hard drive purchases. Any drive smaller than the sweet spot will tend to be more expensive, and any drive larger than the sweet spot will also be more expensive since these are newer models.

Right now, the sweet spot is at the 1TB mark where prices are approximately 9cents/GB. A 250GB HDD for $50, by comparison, is more than twice as expensive per GB.

I wouldn't buy anything less than a 1TB drive right now, anything less is a waste of your money unless you are getting a spectacular deal.

As others have said, get a WD Green Power drive if your enclosure is USB, if your enclosure is eSATA then you should at least consider faster drives, although I'd still recommend the GP.
 
The extra cache doesn't make much of a difference, especially on the GP's.
 
Back
Top